To: J3 Members J3/16-273 From: Van Snyder Subject: Comments on 15.5.2 References: 16-007r2 Date: 2016 September 30 1. Introduction --------------- 15.5.2.5p3 specifies requirements on the relationship the rank and type parameters of actual and dummy arguments. Some of those requirements are then repeated in 15.5.2.7p3. 15.5.2.6p4 and 15.5.2.7p3 then both say that the values of assumed type parameters are assumed from corresponding type parameters of the effective argument. Since the effect is the same for both allocatable and pointer dummy arguments, it would be better to say it just once in 15.5.2.5p3. 2. Edits -------- [320:3 15.5.2.5p3] Move [320:11-12 15.5.2.6p4] to the end of 15.5.2.5p3 at [320:3] (thereby deleting 15.5.2.6p4). [320:35-38 15.5.2.7p3] Delete 15.5.2.7p3 because it's now covered by 15.5.2.5p3.