To: J3 J3/00-228

From: Stan Whitlock Page 1 of 20

Date: 23-June-2000

Subject: J3 meeting #153 minutes

Minutes of NCITS/J3 Committee Meeting #153

May 29 - June 2, 2000

Las Vegas, Nevada

0. List of papers passed at meeting #153

Here is a list of the paper numbers that passed at meeting

#153. The reference is to the latest revision on the ftp

server after the meeting, not to the actual revision that

was voted upon. The motions below reference the actual

revision voted upon.

00-158 == interp #1 00-178r3 00-212

00-159 == interp #2 00-182r1 00-213 == interp #66

00-160r2 == interp #4 00-183r2 00-214 == interp #12

00-161 == interp #5 00-184r2 00-215

00-169r2 00-187r1 00-216

00-171r2 00-195r2 00-218r1

00-172r2 00-196 @#152 00-219

00-173r1 00-198r1 00-220

00-174r1 00-199r1 00-222 edit

00-175r1 00-200r3 00-224

00-176r2 00-207 00-225r1

00-177 00-211

1. Monday, May 29, 2000

1.1 Opening business

The meeting was called to order at 8:30 am, Monday, May 29,

2000, at the Las Vegas AmerSuites Hotel.

1.1.1 Remarks from the chair - none recorded.

1.1.2 Adoption of agenda

** motion: adopt the agenda as amended (moved by Dick

Hendrickson/seconded by Dan Nagle) - passed by

unanimous consent (u.c.)

1.1.3 Approval of Meeting 152 minutes

** motion: adopt the minutes (00-157) of meeting #152

(DickH/Dan) - u.c.

1.1.4 NCITS/OMC report - no report was given.

1.1.5 ISO/WG5 report

The next WG5 meeting is in Oulu, Finland, August 14-18, 2000.

An official notice has gone out seeking a replacement for

Keith Bierman as International Representative; no response

as yet.

J3/00-228

Page 2 of 20

1.1.6 Treasurer's report

As of 30-April-2000, all bills were paid; the balance was

$3762.80. There is no meeting fee for this meeting.

1.1.7 Beginning membership report

Members present or represented: Keith Bierman, Richard

Bleikamp, Richard Maine (alternate for Malcolm Cohen), Craig

Dedo, Dick Hendrickson, Kurt Hirchert, Dan Nagle, Mallory

North, Mike Ross, Jeanne Martin (alternate for Brian Smith),

Van Snyder, Jon Steidel, Matthijs van Waveren, Tony Warnock,

Stan Whitlock

Members absent: Henry Zongaro

Keith Bierman will resign at the end of this meeting; Larry

Meadows is attending this meeting and will become Sun's

principal representative.

Jon Steidel's new alternate is Bill Long.

There are 16 members of J3. 15 were present or represented.

1.1.8 Local arrangements - described but not recorded.

1.1.9 Comments from members

Jeanne Martin asked that a list of the papers that passed be

included in the front of the minutes.

Dan Nagel said he had an implementation of CoCo on his web

site.

1.2 Subgroup organization

/JOR will act as /interp for this meeting: Stan Whitlock

(head), Rich Bleikamp, Dick Hendrickson, Craig Dedo, Dan

Nagle, Jon Steidel (if needed)

Papers to consider this week: 00-158, 00-159, 00-160,

00-161, 00-165, 00-202, 00-203, 00-204

/interop: Jon Steidel (head), Keith Bierman, Richard Maine,

Matthijs van Waveren, Larry Meadows

Papers to consider this week: 00-168, 00-170, part of

00-192, 00-196, 00-198, 00-199, 00-200, 00-201

/data: Kurt Hirchert (head), Van Snyder, Jeanne Martin, Mike

Ross

Papers to consider this week: 00-167 (really JOR), 00-169

(JOR), 00-170 (JOR), 00-171, 00-172 (JOR), 00-174, 00-175,

00-176, 00-177, 00-178, 00-179 (JOR), 00-180, 00-181

(JOR), 00-182, 00-185, 00-186, 00-187, 00-190, 00-191,

00-192, 00-193, 00-194, 00-195, 0-197

J3/00-228

Page 3 of 20

1.3 F95 interpretation organization - /JOR will meet as /interp all

week.

1.4 Presentation: TR on Module Splitting

Van gave a talk on splitting modules into specifications and

code at J3 meeting #144 in Lafayette, LA. He would like to

propose paper 00-197 to WG5 as a TR - would J3 oppose that?

More discussion Wednesday.

1.5 Subgroup meetings - plenary recessed until 4:30 pm.

1.6 Subgroup reports - plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm.

/interop reported that paper 00-196 was passed at J3 meeting

#152.

The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later

in the week was reviewed by /data, /interop, and /interp.

Dan will interoduce a paper on "Eliminating printing (aka

Carriage Control" 00-220 for action later this week.

Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Tuesday.

2. Tuesday, May 30, 2000

2.1 F2000 Plenary - plenary reconvened at 8:30 am.

/data

** motion: paper 00-195r1 (Van/Kurt)

straw vote: Should SOURCE= require a polymorphic <source-

variable>? yes-no-undecided: 0-9-5

paper 00-195r1 as amended - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-178r1 (Van/Kurt) - withdrawn

** motion: paper 00-182r1 (Van/Kurt) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-183r1 (Van/Stan)

straw vote: 3 choices: 1) require NEAREST to be as

defined by IEEE even if the implementation

does not support IEEE; 2) require NEAREST

to choose one of the nearest values but not

specify which one; 3) delete paragraph 1 of

Issue 237; or undecided? 0-7-5-1 therefore

use alternate edits

paper 00-183r1 as amended - passed 6-4

J3/00-228

Page 4 of 20

/interop

** motion: paper 00-198r1 (Jon/Matthijs) - u.c

** motion: paper 00-199r1 (Jon/Matthijs) - u.c.

/interp - status given but no papers

2.2 F95 interpretation processing - see 2.1 above

2.3 Tutorials (if needed) - none given.

2.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm.

2.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm.

/interp acting as /JOR reported that 00-162 contained no JOR

work.

/interp reported on the final disposition of the first F95

interp letter ballot (00-202, 00-203, 00-209, 00-208, 00-210):

13 of 14 interps passed: 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 76, 77, 79,

80, 82, 83, 84; interp 66 will be resubmitted to J3 in paper

00-213.

The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later

in the week was reviewed by /interp, /data, and /interop.

Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Tuesday.

3. Wednesday, May 31, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am.

3.1 F2000 Plenary

/interop

** motion: paper 00-207 (Jon/Matthijs) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-211 (Jon/RichM) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-212 (Jon/Matthijs) - passed 12-1

/data

** motion: paper 00-178r2 (Van/MikeR) as amended - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-169r1 (Van/Jeanne) as amended - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-171r1 (Van/MikeR) as amended - withdrawn

** motion: paper 00-172r1 (Van/Craig) as amended - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-187r1 (Van/Craig) - passed 7-4

** motion: paper 00-173 (Van/Craig) as amended - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-174 (Van/Craig) as amended - u.c.

J3/00-228

Page 5 of 20

/interp

** motion: paper 00-158 (Stan/DickH) interp #1 - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-159 (Stan/Craig) interp #3 - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-161 (Stan/DickH) interp #5 as amended - u.c.

/interp acting as /JOR

** motion: paper 00-205 (Dan/Van) as amended

straw vote: Should section 9.5.5 about printing be deleted?

yes-no-undecided: 8-3-4

paper 00-205 - withdrawn

3.2 F95 interpretation processing - see 3.1 above

3.3 Presentation: TR on Module Splitting

straw vote: Does J3 oppose making 00-197 a TR?

oppose-acquiesce-undecided: 4-9-3

straw vote: Does J3 oppose making 00-197 a TR this year?

oppose-acquiesce-undecided: 13-1-2

3.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm.

3.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 3:30 pm.

The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later

in the week was reviewed by /data, /interp, and /interop.

Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Tuesday.

3.6 US TAG meeting - convened at 4:00 pm

4. Thursday, June 1, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am.

4.1 F2000 Plenary

/interop

** motion: paper 00-215 (Jon/Matthijs) as ammedned - u.c.

/interp

** motion: paper 00-160r1 (Stan/RichB) interp #4 as amended -

passed 7-5

** motion: paper 00-213 (Stan/RichB) interp #66 - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-214 (Stan/RichB) interp #12 - u.c.

Paper 00-165 (interp #191) was discussed: J3 agrees with the

direction but the answer needs more work.

J3/00-228

Page 6 of 20

/interp acting as /JOR

** motion: paper 220 (Stan/Dan) - passed 9-3

Paper 00-205r1 will not be acted upon.

/data

** motion: paper 00-216 (RichM/Kurt) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-175r1 (Kurt/RichM) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-177 (Kurt/MikeR) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-171r2 (Kurt/MikeR) edit 6 dropped - u.c.

4.2 F95 interpretation processing - see 4.1 above

4.3 Tutorials (if needed) - none given.

4.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm.

4.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm.

/interp

The second F95 interp letter ballot will be issued after this

meeting and will contain interps #1, 3, 4, 5, 12, and 66 that

have passed at this meeting plus an F95 interpretation for F2K

MTE M16 that passed long ago in paper 97-197.

/interp acting as /JOR

/JOR has considered paper 00-179, likes the general approach

to derived type i/o routines specified as type-bound

procedures, but desires one addition:

An explicit interface, as described in 9.5.4.4.3, should

override any type-bound DTIO procedure.

/JOR encourages Van to add the necessary edits and submit a

revised paper for the next J3 meeting.

/data

** motion: paper 00-176r1 (Kurt/MikeR) as amended by paper

00-225 - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-184r1 (Kurt/Craig) as amended by paper

00-225 - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-171r2 item 6 (Kurt/Craig) as amended by

paper 00-225 - u.c.

J3/00-228

Page 7 of 20

** motion: paper 00-225 item 4 (Kurt/DickH): this adds an

unresolved issue promised in paper 00-222; paper

00-192r2 will not be processed at this meeting -

u.c.

** motion: paper 00-222 edit at the bottom (DickH/Kurt) -

withdrawn

/interop

** motion: paper 00-218r1 (Jon/Craig) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-219 (Jon/Craig) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-200r2 (Jon/Matthijs) as amended - u.c.

Paper 00-217 will not be acted upon at this meeting.

Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Tuesday.

5. Friday, June 2, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am.

5.1 F2000 Plenary

/JOR

** motion: paper 00-224 (RichB/Jon) - u.c.

** motion: paper 00-223 (RichB/Craig) - withdrawn: general

direction seems correct; it will be submitted for

the next J3 meeting

/interop

Paper 00-217 was not acted upon.

/data

** motion: paper 00-222 edit at the bottom (Kurt/Jeanne) - u.c.

5.2 F95 interpretation processing - none

5.3 Closing business

5.3.1 Review of action items

Tony will send status reports 00-010r4 and 00-221r1 to WG5.

Tony will bring the following to WG5's attention: 00-007r2

(or r1 if r2 not ready), 00-194, 00-226.

Tony or RichM will bring the following to WG5's attention:

the list of passed edits not incorporated into 00-007r2 and

00-011 (if ready).

J3/00-228

Page 8 of 20

Stan will bring the following to WG5's attention: 00-006 (if

ready).

5.3.2 Future meetings

Meeting #154: Sep 18-22, 2000: Las Vegas Amerisuites, rooms

available from Sep 15; reservation deadline

Aug 16.

Meeting #155: Dec 11-15, 2000: Las Vegas, Amerisuites, rooms

available from Dec 8-15; reservation

deadline, Nov 8.

2001 dates are tentative: $59 rate for 2000, 2001 rate

unknown, for Amerisuites.

5.3.3 Treasurer's report

Meeting expenses: $162.91

Balance: $3599.89

No change in meeting fees for now.

5.3.4 Closing membership report

IBM not represented at meeting 153; membership not in danger

yet.

MikeR excused from first F95 interp letter ballot, since he

didn't receive it.

5.3.5 Comments from members

Kurt: Do we need to assemble the minutes into 1 physical

document? Tony said NO.

Kurt: drop appendix F from the minutes, and insert a pointer

(full web addresses) to the 001 standing document.

Kurt will still prepare appendix E for the minutes.

Mallory: Rose Hulman has a web person willing to do all of

J3's stuff (email, web pages, archive), we will

move all that to Rose Hulman. Will investigate

getting fortran.org or j3.fortran.com, so future

moves will be less painful. Spam removal will be

investigated.

Matthijs: Wants a list of papers to send to Mr. Kruyt: JOR

sent email, data prepared 00-222.

5.3.6 Adjournment

The meeting was adjourned at 9:22 am.

J3/00-228

Page 9 of 20

Appendix A: Meeting Agenda

Final Agenda for J3 Meeting 153

===============================

1. Monday, May 29, 2000 8:30 am

--------------------------------

1.1 Opening business T. Warnock

Remarks from the chair T. Warnock

Adoption of agenda T. Warnock

Approval of Meeting 152 minutes T. Warnock

NCITS/OMC report (if any) T. Warnock

ISO/WG5 report K. Bierman

Treasurer's report M. North

Beginning membership report T. Warnock

Local arrangements M. North

Comments from members

1.2 Subgroup organization T. Warnock

1.3 F95 interpretation organization S. Whitlock

1.4 Presentation: TR on Module Splitting V. Snyder

1.5 Subgroup meetings

1.6 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)

2. Tuesday, May 30, 2000 8:30 am

---------------------------------

2.1 F2000 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads

2.2 F95 interpretation processing (00-006) S. Whitlock

2.3 Tutorials (if needed)

2.4 Subgroup meetings

2.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm)

3. Wednesday, May 31, 2000 8:30 am

-----------------------------------

3.1 F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads

3.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock

3.3 Presentation: TR on Module Splitting V. Snyder

3.4 Subgroup meetings

3.5 Subgroup reports (3:30 pm)

3.6 US TAG meeting (4:00 pm) K. Bierman

4. Thursday, June 1, 2000 8:30 am

----------------------------------

4.1 F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads

4.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock

4.3 Tutorials (if needed)

4.4 Subgroup meetings

4.5 Subgroup reports (3:30 pm if TAG)

4.6 TAG meeting (4:00) (if needed) K. Bierman

J3/00-228

Page 10 of 20

5. Friday, June 2, 2000 8:30 am

--------------------------------

5.1 F2000 Plenary Subgroup heads

5.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock

5.3 Closing business

Review of action items (if any)

Future meetings M. North

Treasurer's report M. North

Closing membership report T. Warnock

Comments from members

Adjournment

J3/00-228

Page 11 of 20

Appendix B J3/00-000

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

J3 REGISTER OF DOCUMENTS FOR 2000

00-000.TXT

Revised June 6, 2000

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

ftp site: ftp://math.jpl.nasa.gov/x3j3/doc/year/00

ftp mirror site: ftp://ftp.drfc.nasa.gov/pub/x3j3/jpl

J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.ionet.net/~jwagener/J3

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

I. Standing Documents

Paper Number Title

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

J3/00-000 Register of Documents

J3/00-001 Membership List

J3/00-002 Unassigned

J3/00-003 J3 Member References

J3/00-004 Journal of Requirements

J3/00-005 J3 Resolutions and Responses to WG5 Resolutions

J3/00-006 Defect Report

J3/00-007r1 Draft Revision to Fortran 2000

J3/00-008 Editorial Considerations for F2000 Draft Review

J3/00-009 Technical Proposals for Future Revisions

J3/00-010r4 J3 Work Plan

J3/00-011r1 Editor's List of Unresolved Issues

J3/00-012 - J3/00-100 are unassigned

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

II. 2000 Papers

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 152

LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, FEBRUARY 28 - MARCH 3, 2000

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Paper Number Date Submitter Title

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

J3/00-101 000114 Maine Edits incorporated in 00-007

txt

J3/00-102r1 000114 Maine Changes to the list of unresolved

txt issues

J3/00-103r1 000131 Snyder Miscellaneous remarks concerning

ps 00-007

J3/00-104r1 000206 Snyder Comments on SELECT TYPE

J3/00-105r3 000206 Snyder Thoughts stimulated by issue 216

J3/00-106 000206 Snyder Comments on INTENT

J3/00-107 000206 Snyder Another reason for a READONLY

ps attribute

J3/00-108r1 000207 Snyder Oversights in adding IOSTAT_END and

ps IOSTAT_EOR

J3/00-109r2 000209 Snyder Issue 64 (again)

J3/00-110 000209 Snyder Section headings in 9.5.1

J3/00-228

Page 12 of 20

J3/00-111r2 000209 Snyder Issue 79 (again)

J3/00-112r3 000210 Snyder Exposition of command-line access

J3/00-113 000210 Snyder Issue 14

J3/00-114r1 000211 Cohen Issue 141 and a related problem

txt

J3/00-115 000211 Cohen Issues 222 and 224

txt

J3/00-116 000214 Cohen Issues 233, 234, and 235

txt

J3/00-117 000214 Cohen Procedure Interface Body

txt

J3/00-118 000216 Cohen Issues with NAME= and BINDNAME=

txt

J3/00-119 000217 Takata Review of the J3 responses to interp-

txt retation requests from Japan

J3/00-120r1 000222 Zongaro Miscellaneous Interop Fixes (Issues

txt 218 and 229)

J3/00-121 000223 Mitchell f90gl and C Interoperability

ps,pdf

J3/00-122r2 000223 Zongaro Edits for Issues 149 and 120

txt

J3/00-123 000224 Cohen Interpretation request on ELEMENTAL

txt procedures (revised)

J3/00-124r1 000224 Cohen Interpretation request: Scope of

txt ac-implied-DO variable

J3/00-125 000224 Cohen VOLATILE questions

txt

J3/00-126 000224 Whitlock F95 Interpretations Index

txt

J3/00-127 000224 Zongaro Edits for Issues 89, 148, 162, 230

txt and 231 (Interop.)

J3/00-128r1 000228 Cohen Unresolved issue 132

txt

J3/00-129 000228 Cohen Asynchronous questions

txt

J3/00-130 000228 Cohen Abstract interface blocks

txt

J3/00-131 000228 Cohen Miscellaneous infelicities

txt

J3/00-132r1 000228 Dedo Edits - VOLATILE fixups

txt,ps,wpd

J3/00-133 000228 Cohen Interpretation 70: revised

txt

J3/00-134 000229 Cohen Issue 215

txt

J3/00-135 000229 Cohen Interpretation 81: revised

txt

J3/00-136r1 000229 Snyder Imprecision in pointer disassociation

ps and undefinition

J3/00-137r2 000229 Nagle Issue 3

txt

J3/00-138 000229 Snyder Starting to rebuild finalization

J3/00-228

Page 13 of 20

J3/00-139 000301 Maine Command argument simplification

txt

J3/00-140r1 000301 Bleikamp Async volatile fixups

txt,doc

J3/00-141 000301 Cohen Issue 13 and Interpretation 84

txt

J3/00-142 000301 Whitlock Rules for voting on Fortran 95

txt interpretations

J3/00-143r2 000301 Dedo JOR responses to proposed edits in

txt,ps,wpd J3/00-103r1 - Chapters 1, 2, 3

J3/00-144r1 000301 Snyder Data issues from J3/00-103r1

J3/00-145 000302 Snyder Specification functions in the

ps Glossary

J3/00-146r1 000302 Snyder Remove identical syntax rule

J3/00-147 000302 Snyder Issue 82

J3/00-148 000302 Cohen Issues 17 - 19 and 211

txt

J3/00-149r1 000302 Zongaro Revision of ENUM syntax and un-

txt resolved issue 231

J3/00-150 000302 Steidel New /Interop unresolved issues

txt

J3/00-151r1 000302 Dedo JOR responses to proposed edits in

txt,ps,wpd J3/00-103r1 - Chapters 7, 8, 9

J3/00-152 000302 Snyder Define "component order" term

J3/00-153 000302 Maine Corrections to J3/00-007

txt

J3/00-154 000302 Cohen Issues 223

txt

J3/00-155r1 000302 Cohen ALLOCATE(MOULD=)

txt

J3/00-156 000303 North Meeting 152 Treasurer's Report

txt

J3/00-157 000303 Zongaro Meeting 152 Minutes

txt,ps,htm

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 153

LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, MAY 29 - JUNE 2, 2000

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Paper Number Date Submitter Title

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

J3/00-007r1 000502 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000

txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif

J3/00-010r4 000505 Warnock J3 Work Plan

doc,txt

J3/00-011r1 000505 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues

txt

J3/00-158 000417 Reid Interpretation 001

txt

J3/00-159 000417 Reid Interpretation 003

txt

J3/00-160r2 000417 Reid Interpretation 004

txt,ps,wpd

J3/00-228

Page 14 of 20

J3/00-161 000417 Reid Interpretation 005

txt

J3/00-162 000503 Maine Edits incorporated in 00-007r1

txt

J3/00-163 000503 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues

txt

J3/00-164 000503 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues,

txt Part A

J3/00-165 000504 Reid Interpretation 191

txt

J3/00-166 000505 Maine Editors list of unresolved issues,

txt Part B

J3/00-167 000505 Maine F90 interp and the f2k IMPORT

txt

J3/00-168 000508 Mitchell Fortran pointer from C pointer

txt

J3/00-169r2 000508 Snyder Minor things ? left over from

ps,pdf 00-144r1, and a few more

J3/00-170 000508 Snyder Syntax and symantics of VALUE attrib-

ps,pdf ute, issue 214, part of issue 90

J3/00-171r2 000508 Snyder One more little problem with pro-

ps,pdf cedure pointers

J3/00-172r2 000508 Snyder Issue 263

ps,pdf

J3/00-173r1 000508 Snyder Issue 262

ps,pdf

J3/00-174r1 000508 Snyder Issue 236

ps,pdf

J3/00-175r1 000508 Snyder Issue 268

ps,pdf

J3/00-176r2 000508 Snyder Issue 269

ps,pdf

J3/00-177 000508 Snyder Issue 7

ps,pdf

J3/00-178r3 000508 Snyder More work on SELECT TYPE and

ps,pdf ASSOCIATE

J3/00-179 000508 Snyder Derived-type input/output and its

ps,pdf relation to type-bound procedures

J3/00-180r2 000508 Snyder Define "component order" term,

ps,pdf issues 17 - 19 and 211, more work on

constructors

J3/00-181 000508 Snyder A problem I had in converting FORTRAN

ps,pdf 77 to Fortran 95

J3/00-182r1 000508 Snyder Issue 266

ps,pdf

J3/00-183r2 000508 Snyder Part of issue 237

ps,pdf

J3/00-184r2 000508 Snyder Issue 258

ps,pdf

J3/00-185 000508 Snyder More work on extensible derived-type

ps,pdf definitions

J3/00-186r1 000508 Snyder Semantics of the select kind con-

ps,pdf struct are not described, and it

appears to be a mess to use

J3/00-187r1 000508 Snyder The discussion of INTRINSIC is scat-

ps,pdf tered, contradictory, and repetitive

J3/00-228

Page 15 of 20

J3/00-188 000511 Kruyt Blanks in ELSEWHERE

txt

J3/00-189 000511 Kruyt Usage of DELIM= in control-info-list

txt of transfer statement

J3/00-190 000511 Kruyt Name of derived-type definition

txt

J3/00-191 000511 Kruyt Usage of name, identifier, local

txt name, local identifier

J3/00-192r2 000511 Snyder Miscellaneous items

ps,pdf

J3/00-193 000512 Snyder One more try at READONLY attribute

ps,pdf

J3/00-194r1 000512 Snyder FINAL procedures as type-bound

ps,pdf procedures

J3/00-195r2 000512 Snyder Edits to implement decisions in

ps,pdf 00-155 concerning ALLOCATABLE

J3/00-196 000512 Steidel Missed edit from meeting

txt

J3/00-197 000515 Snyder Draft proposed TR on Enhanced Module

ps,pdf Facilities in Fortran

J3/00-198r1 000515 van Waveren Issue 226

txt

J3/00-199r1 000515 van Waveren Issue 112

txt

J3/00-200r3 000515 van Waveren Issues 161 and 257

txt

J3/00-201 000520 Snyder Three problems with enumerations and

ps,pdf one with type aliases

J3/00-202 000524 Whitlock F95 Interp letter ballot # 1 (email

txt x3j3.2000-136) due 19-May-2000

J3/00-203 000524 Whitlock Results of the F95 Interp letter

txt ballot # 1

J3/00-204 000525 Whitlock Text of Interps 1, 3, 4, 5

txt

J3/00-205r1 000530 Nagle Standardize Printing (aka "carriage

txt control)

J3/00-206 000530 Steidel Response/Disposition of 00-168

txt,ps,pdf,htm,doc

J3/00-207 000530 Steidel Miscellaneous /Interop edits

txt,ps,pdf,htm

J3/00-208 000530 Dedo Interpretations 68 and 70

txt,ps,wpd

J3/00-209 000530 Bleikamp Further results of /Interp letter

txt ballot

J3/00-210 000530 Dedo Interpretation 67

txt,ps,wpd

J3/00-211 000530 Maine Terminology of "interoperates with"

txt

J3/00-212 000530 van Waveren Issue 214

txt

J3/00-213 000531 Bleikamp Interp 66

txt

J3/00-214 000531 Dedo Interp 12 - Evaluation of Intrinsic

txt,ps,wpd Procedures

J3/00-215 000531 Steidel BIND(C) Syntax fixes - resolution of

txt,ps,pdf,htm,doc Item 256

J3/00-228

Page 16 of 20

J3/00-216 000531 Maine Unresolved Issue 261

txt

J3/00-217 000601 Maine Unresolved Issue 257 (C Functions)

txt

J3/00-218r1 000531 Meadows Unresolved Issue 247

txt

J3/00-219 000531 Meadows Unresolved Issue 94

txt

J3/00-220 000531 Nagle Eliminate printing (aka "carriage

txt control")

J3/00-221r1 000601 Warnock Report to WG5

doc,txt

J3/00-222 000601 Hirchert Subgroup disposition of 00-190 and

txt 00-191

J3/00-223 000601 Dedo Regularize I/O Keywords

txt,ps,wpd

J3/00-224 000601 Nagle Allow space in ELSEWHERE

txt

J3/00-225r1 000601 Hirchert Thursday Report

txt

J3/00-226 000601 Hirchert Revised Constructor Specification and

txt Syntax

J3/00-227 000602 North Meeting 153 Treasurer's Report

txt

J3/00-228 000602 Whitlock Meeting 153 Minutes

txt

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

J3/00-228

Page 17 of 20

Appendix C

Future Meetings and Distribution/Secretarial Assignments

Meeting Conventions:

- Four meetings per year

- Attempt to schedule second full week of the month

- Attempt to schedule meeting contiguous with WG5 annual meeting

Future meeting schedule:

154 September 18 - 22, 2000, in Las Vegas, NV

Mallory North, acting host

Premeeting distribution deadline: September 4, 2000

Premeeting distribution: electronic

Post-meeting distribution: electronic

Secretary: Stan Whitlock

155 December 11 - 15, 2000, in Las Vegas, NV

Mallory North, acting host

Premeeting distribution deadline: November 27, 2000

Premeeting distribution: electronic

Post-meeting distribution: electronic

Secretary: Stan Whitlock

Committee materials availability:

Agenda and meeting notice available at the J3 web site and from the J3 ftp

server.

Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to

be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail.

REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3)

Pre- and post-meeting distribution available at the J3 ftp and web sites.

Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to

be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail.

REQUIREMENT: Distribution of premeeting 2 weeks prior to meeting.

(documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1)

Meeting minutes are available at the J3 web and ftp sites.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

ftp site: ftp://math.jpl.nasa.gov/x3j3/doc/meeting/153

ftp mirror site: ftp:://ftp.drfc.nasa.gov/pub/x3j3/jpl

J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.ionet.net/~jwagener/J3

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

J3/00-228

Page 18 of 20

Appendix D

Committee Organization

D.1 Officers and Management

Chair T. Warnock

International Rep. K. Bierman

Secretary S. Whitlock

Treasurer M. North

Librarian M. North

Editor R. Maine (WG5 appointment)

Maintenance S. Whitlock

Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert

Future Meetings M. North

Membership List K. Hirchert

D.2 Subgroups

JOR: Responsible for the maintenance of the Journal of Development

(standing document 004) and managing the following Fortran 2000

requirements: R.1, R.2, R.8, and all MTE and B items.

S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, C. Dedo, D. Hendrickson,

D. Nagle

DATA: Responsible for language design topics related to data and data

structures; manages the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R3,

R5, R6, and R7.

K. Hirchert (head), R. Maine, J. Martin, M. Ross, V. Snyder

INTERVAL: Responsible for R.4 (enabling technologies for interval

arithmetic)

T. Warnock

INTEROP: Responsible for R9 (interoperability with C)

J. Steidel (head), K. Bierman, R. Maine, M. van Waveren

INTERP: Responsible for evaluating interpretation requests, providing

responses to such requests, and maintaining standing document

006. (Subgroup membership is the same as JOR.)

J3/00-228

Page 19 of 20

Appendix E: Membership summary

J3 Meeting Attendance (Principal Members)

Meeting # 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 152a 153

Location (state) LA IN CA NV HI UK NV NV NV L.B. NV

Date (month year) 02 05 08 11 03 06 08 11 02 05 05

98 98 98 98 99 99 99 99 00 00 00

Name Affiliation

Bleikamp, Richard HP V V A V V A V A** V V V

Cohen, Malcolm NAG V V R V V V V V V V R

Dedo, Craig self V V V V A A** V** V V V V

Hendrickson, Dick self V V V V A V V V V V V

Hirchert, Kurt U of IL V V V V V A A** Q

Hirchert, Kurt U of KY V V V

Meadows, Larry Sun RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP V

Nagle, Dan self P V V V V

North, Mallory Rose-Hulman V V V V V V V V V V V

Ross, Mike Intel P A E V

Smith, Brian U of NM R A R R R A R A** R R R

Snyder, Van JPL/Caltech V A V V V V V V V V V

Steidel, Jon Cray V V A A** V** V V V V V V

van Waveren, Matthijs Fujitsu P V A V A** V R V V

Warnock, Tony LANL V V V V V V V V V V V

Whitlock, Stan Compaq V V V V V A V V V V V

Zongaro, Henry IBM V V V V V A V V V V A

V present and voting other voting attendees:

R absent but represented J Martin represented B Smith

A absent and not represented R Maine represented M Cohen

P present and not voting

RP represented by previous member non-voting attendees:

E excused K Bierman, alternate for L Meadows

Q Resigned

** missed 2 of last 3 meetings

*** lost membership

Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 152 16

Majority 9

Quorum 6

Total Membership at end of Meeting 152 16

Total Members Attended or Represented at 152 15

Total Attendees at Meeting 152 16

Membership changes since last meeting:

Larry Meadows replaced Keith Bierman as principal member from Sun.

Bill Long became the alternate from Cray.

J3/00-228

Page 20 of 20

Appendix F: Membership Roster

The Membership Roster is not reproduced here. The latest Membership

Roster may be found in

ftp://math.jpl.nasa.gov/x3j3/standing/001.html and

ftp://math.jpl.nasa.gov/x3j3/standing/001.txt