To: J3 J3/00-300 From: Stan Whitlock Page 1 of 24 Date: 16-Nov-2000 Subject: J3 meeting #154 minutes Minutes of NCITS/J3 Committee Meeting #154 September 18 - 22, 2000 Las Vegas, Nevada 0. List of papers passed at meeting #154 Here is a list of the paper numbers that passed at meeting #154. The reference is to the latest revision on the ftp server after the meeting, not to the actual revision that was voted upon. The motions below reference the actual revision voted upon. 00-233r2 00-246r1 00-266 00-281 00-290 00-236r1 00-248r1 00-267r1 00-282 00-291 00-237r1 00-250r2 00-270 00-283 00-293 00-238 00-252r1 00-275 00-284 00-294r1 00-239r1 00-256r1 00-276r1 00-285r1 00-296r1 00-241r1 00-258 00-277r2 00-286 00-297 00-242 00-263r1 00-278 00-287r1 00-298 00-243 00-265r2 00-280 00-288r1 00-260: interpretations 14, 15, 24, 31, 32, 73, 74, 75, 85, F90/197, /205, /206, /207, /208, /210, JP-4, -5, -8, -12, -16, -17, -31 00-292: interpretation 86 1. Monday, September 18, 2000 1.1 Opening business The meeting was called to order at 8:30 am, Monday, September 18, 2000, at the Las Vegas AmerSuites Hotel. 1.1.1 Remarks from the chair Tony Warnock is absent; he asked Jeanne Martin to chair this meeting. 1.1.2 Adoption of agenda ** motion: adopt the agenda as amended (moved by Stan Whitlock/seconded by Rich Maine) - passed by unanimous consent (u.c.) 1.1.3 Approval of Meeting 153 minutes ** motion: adopt the minutes (00-228) of meeting #153 as amended (StanW/RichB) - u.c. 1.1.4 NCITS/OMC report - no report was given. 16-Nov-2000 Page 2 of 24 00-300 1.1.5 ISO/WG5 report KeithB's report of the Oulu WG5 meeting is paper 00-262. Jeanne, Van, Larry, and Malcolm attended the meeting. WG5 forwarded papers to J3: 00-260, 00-261, 00-268, 00-269, 00-270, 00-271. The WG5 Oulu resolutions in WG5/N1412 require no response from J3. Jeanne will e-mail J3's status of the forwarded WG5 papers after this meeting. An official notice has gone out seeking a replacement for Keith Bierman as International Representative; no response as yet. 1.1.6 Treasurer's report There was a $70 fee for registering our web name. As of August 31, 2000, all bills were paid; the balance was $3545.31. There is no meeting fee for this meeting. 1.1.7 Beginning membership report Members present or represented: Richard Bleikamp, Malcolm Cohen, Richard Maine (alternate for Malcolm Cohen), Craig Dedo, Kurt Hirchert, Larry Meadows, Dan Nagle, Mallory North, David Moore (alternate for Mike Ross), Jeanne Martin (alternate for Brian Smith), Van Snyder, Jon Steidel, Stan Whitlock Members absent: Dick Hendrickson, Matthijs van Waveren, Tony Warnock, Henry Zongaro There are 16 members of J3. 12 were present or represented. No member is at jeopardy at the start of this meeting. David Moore is the alternate for Intel, representing Mike Ross. KurtH is now with the Univeristy of Illinois Department of Atmospheric Sciences: Jeanne ruled that Kurt could vote at this meeting. Andrew Vaught from the Free Software Foundation was an observer starting Wednesday. 1.1.8 Local arrangements - described but not recorded. 1.1.9 Comments from members The NASA ftp server should mirror j3-fortran.org. The JPL ftp server will be phased out. Papers for the ftp server should be sent to Mallory, not the webmaster. 16-Nov-2000 Page 3 of 24 00-300 1.2 Subgroup organization /data: Malcolm Cohen (head), Kurt Hirchert, Jeanne Martin, Van Snyder Papers to consider this week: 234, 236-239, 241, 245, 247, 250-252, 255, 270, 271, 272, 275, 276, 277, {274 will be withdrawn in favor of 255}; items from 240, 244 /editor: Rich Maine Papers to consider this week: 261; items from 240, 244 /interop: Jon Steidel (head), Larry Meadows, David Moore Papers to consider this week: 235, 256-258, 263-265, 267, 269; items from 240, 244 /JOR: Stan Whitlock (head), Rich Bleikamp, Craig Dedo, Dan Nagle Papers to consider this week: 232, 242, 243, 248, 266; items from 240, 244 1.3 F95 interpretation organization /interp: Stan Whitlock (head), Rich Bleikamp, Malcolm Cohen, Jon Steidel Papers to consider this week: 229, 246, 249, 260, 268, 273; items from 006 1.4 Subgroup meetings - plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 1.5 Subgroup reports - plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed by /JOR, /interp, /data, /interop, and /editor. ** motion: paper 00-238 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-270 == WG5/N1407 (Malcolm/Van) for specs/ syntax/edits - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-258 (Jon/Stan) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-265 (Jon/Craig) as amended - withdrawn Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Tuesday. 2. Tuesday, September 19, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. 2.1 F2000 Plenary /JOR ** motion: paper 00-248r1 (Stan/Dan) as amended - u.c. 16-Nov-2000 Page 4 of 24 00-300 ** motion: paper 00-242 (Stan/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-243 (Stan/Van) as amended - u.c. Jeanne ruled that we would discuss paper 00-266 on command line argument changes for no more than 45 minutes, ending with a vote on how to proceed. The discussion was not recorded. ** motion: 00-266 (RichM/Larry) - needs 007r2 line numbers straw vote: keep the existing PROGRAM statement args facility? yes-no-undecided: 1-10-1 straw vote: 3 choices: 1) intrinsics; 2) routines accessible from module; 3) undecided: 5-4-3 paper 00-266 to be amended - passed 11-0 2.2 F95 interpretation processing - none. 2.3 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 2.4 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed by /JOR, /data, /interop, /editor, and /interp. Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Wednesday. 3. Wednesday, September 20, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. 3.1 F2000 Plenary Kurt noted paper 00-295 contains an analysis/cross-reference of the F2K BNF. /JOR ** motion: paper 00-246r1 (Stan/Van) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-290 (Stan/RichB) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-291 (Stan/RichB) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-294 (Stan/Dan) as amended - withdrawn ** motion: paper 00-287 (Stan/Dan) as amended - withdrawn ** motion: paper 00-288 (Stan/Dan) as amended - withdrawn /data ** motion: paper 00-275 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-276r1 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-241r1 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. 16-Nov-2000 Page 5 of 24 00-300 ** motion: paper 00-239r1 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-250r1 (Malcolm/Van) sectioons 2 & 3 == specs/syntax - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-280 (Malcolm/Van) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-281 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-252r1 (Malcolm/Van) - u.c. /interop ** motion: paper 00-256r1 (Jon/Larry) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-263r1 (Jon/Larry) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-256r1 (Jon/Craig) as amended - withdrawn ** motion: paper 00-267r1 (Jon/Craig) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-278 (Jon/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-283 (Jon/Stan) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-284 (Jon/Stan) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-285 (Jon/Larry) - withdrawn /editor ** motion: paper 00-293 (RichM/Jon) - u.c. 3.2 F95 interpretation processing /interp ** motion: paper 00-260 (Stan/Jon) interpretations 14, 24, 31, 32, 73, F90/197 - passed as amended 10-0 3.3 Presentation: Malcolm on papers 00-271 and 00-277r1 3.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 3.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 3:30 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed by /JOR, /data, /interop, and /interp. /data ** motion: papers 00-271 and 00-277r1 (Malcolm/Van) as specs/ syntax as amended - u.c. paper 00-233 straw vote: is it illegal for type bound dtio procedures to conflict with interface blocks? yes-no-undecided: 8-0-4 Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Thursday. 16-Nov-2000 Page 6 of 24 00-300 4. Thursday, September 21, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. 4.1 F2000 Plenary /JOR ** motion: paper 00-287r1 (Stan/Dan) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-288r1 (Stan/Dan) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-294r1 (Stan/Dan) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-279 (Stan/Craig) as amended - withdrawn: J3 wants specs/syntax before passing edits /data ** motion: paper 00-236r1 (Malcolm/Van) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-237r1 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. paper 00-255 straw vote: should we do this? yes-no-undecided: 4-4-5 => will not be done /interop ** motion: paper 00-265r2 (Jon/Stan) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-285r1 (Jon/Larry) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-286 (Jon/Stan) as amended - u.c. 4.2 F95 interpretation processing /interp ** motion: paper 00-260 (Stan/Malcolm) interpretations 15, 74, 75, 85, F90/205, /206, /207, /208, /210, JP-4, -5, -8, -12, -16, -17, -31 - passed as amended 9-0 ** motion: paper 00-292 (Stan/Malcolm) interpretation 86 - passed 11-0 4.3 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 4.4 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed by /JOR and /data. Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Friday. 5. Friday, September 22, 2000 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. 5.1 F2000 Plenary /JOR ** motion: paper 00-282 (RichB/Craig) as amended - u.c. 16-Nov-2000 Page 7 of 24 00-300 ** motion: "give Richard Maine permission to resolve issue 225 by removing italics in Annex A as appropriate" (RichB/Jon) - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-297 (RichB/Craig) straw vote: should we delete the 2nd sentence of the edit in 00-297? yes-no-undecided: 10-1-0 straw vote: should we make the Edits a NOTE? yes-no-undecided: 6-2-3 paper 00-297 as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-298 (RichB/Craig) as amended - u.c. /data ** motion: paper 00-233r2 (Malcolm/Van) edits - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-250r2 (Malcolm/Van) as amended - u.c. ** motion: paper 00-277r2 (Van/Kurt) edits - passed 8-1 ** motion: paper 00-296r1 (Malcolm/Kurt) edits - u.c. paper 00-244 was called to the editor's attention There was no action on paper 00-240r3 ** motion: paper 00-289 (Craig/Van) straw vote: 1) 00-289 as is: 1 2) 00-289 with fewer restrictions: 8 3) leave as is: 2 4) undecided: 0 paper 00-289 withdrawn straw vote: Should dummy procedures continue to be prohibited in specification expressions? yes-no-undecided: 4-2-3 5.2 F95 interpretation processing - none 5.3 Closing business 5.3.1 Review of action items comments from Chair: Passed 35 papers, processed 23 interps for letter ballot. There is only one more corrigenda scheduled for F95. Resolved 26 issues, added 2 new issues, 57 issues remaining. We're ready to start integration. ACTION ITEM: Jeanne Martin to formulate a plan for document integration 16-Nov-2000 Page 8 of 24 00-300 5.3.2 Future meetings Meeting #155: Dec 11-15, 2000: Las Vegas, Amerisuites, rooms available from Dec 8-15; reservation deadline, Nov 8. No meeting fee for the December meeting. 5.3.3 Treasurer's report - paper 00-299 Meeting expenses: $110.39 Balance: $3545.31 before paying outstanding debts No change in meeting fees for now. 5.3.4 Closing membership report Henry Zongarro (IBM) in danger, new member Larry Meadows (Sun) attended, Andrew Vaught (FSF) observer, Kurt Hirchert has moved (U. of K. resigned, U of I rejoined) 5.3.5 Comments from members Richard Maine: 39 papers with edits passed, 31 have already been entered into the 007. Resolved 23 issues, 55 left unresolved. 007 should be available soon. Mallory: needs electrons for papers as always Jon Steidel thanked Jeanne Martin for serving as chairperson (spontaneous applause) 5.3.6 Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 9:52 am. 16-Nov-2000 Page 9 of 24 00-300 Appendix A: Meeting Agenda Final Agenda for J3 Meeting 154 =============================== 1. Monday, September 18, 2000 8:30 am -------------------------------- 1.1 Opening business J. Martin Remarks from the chair J. Martin Adoption of agenda J. Martin Approval of Meeting 154 minutes J. Martin NCITS/OMC report (if any) J. Martin ISO/WG5 report (if any) New IR Treasurer's report M. North Beginning membership report K. Hirchert Local arrangements M. North Comments from members 1.2 Subgroup organization J. Martin 1.3 F95 interpretation organization S. Whitlock 1.4 Subgroup meetings 1.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 2. Tuesday, September 19, 2000 8:30 am --------------------------------- 2.1 F2000 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads 2.2 F95 interpretation processing (00-006) S. Whitlock 2.3 Subgroup meetings 2.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 3. Wednesday, September 20, 2000 8:30 am ----------------------------------- 3.1 F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads 3.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 3.3 Tutorials M. Cohen 3.4 Subgroup meetings 3.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 4. Thursday, September 21, 2000 8:30 am ---------------------------------- 4.1 F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads 4.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 4.3 Subgroup meetings 4.4 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 5. Friday, September 22, 2000 8:30 am -------------------------------- 5.1 F2000 Plenary Subgroup heads 5.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 5.3 Closing business Review of action items (if any) Future meetings M. North Treasurer's report M. North Closing membership report J. Martin Comments from members Adjournment =============================== 16-Nov-2000 Page 10 of 24 00-300 Appendix B: J3 Register of Documents J3/00-000 -------------------------------------------------------------------------- J3 REGISTER OF DOCUMENTS FOR 2000 00-000.TXT Revised November 13, 2000 -------------------------------------------------------------------------- ftp site: ftp://ftp.j3-fortran.org/x3j3/doc/year/00 ftp mirror site: ftp://ftp.drfc.nasa.gov/pub/x3j3/jpl J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.j3-fortran~.org -------------------------------------------------------------------------- I. Standing Documents Paper Number Title -------------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/00-000 Register of Documents J3/00-001 Membership List J3/00-002 Unassigned J3/00-003 J3 Member References J3/00-004 Journal of Requirements J3/00-005 J3 Resolutions and Responses to WG5 Resolutions J3/00-006r1 Defect Report J3/00-007r2 Draft Revision to Fortran 2000 J3/00-008 Editorial Considerations for F2000 Draft Review J3/00-009 Technical Proposals for Future Revisions J3/00-010r4 J3 Work Plan J3/00-011r2 Editor's List of Unresolved Issues J3/00-012 - J3/00-100 are unassigned -------------------------------------------------------------------------- II. 2000 Papers -------------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 152 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, FEBRUARY 28 - MARCH 3, 2000 -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title -------------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/00-101 000114 Maine Edits incorporated in 00-007 txt J3/00-102r1 000114 Maine Changes to the list of unresolved txt issues J3/00-103r1 000131 Snyder Miscellaneous remarks concerning ps 00-007 J3/00-104r1 000206 Snyder Comments on SELECT TYPE ps J3/00-105r3 000206 Snyder Thoughts stimulated by issue 216 ps J3/00-106 000206 Snyder Comments on INTENT ps J3/00-107 000206 Snyder Another reason for a READONLY ps attribute J3/00-108r1 000207 Snyder Oversights in adding IOSTAT_END and ps IOSTAT_EOR J3/00-109r2 000209 Snyder Issue 64 (again) ps J3/00-110 000209 Snyder Section headings in 9.5.1 ps J3/00-111r2 000209 Snyder Issue 79 (again) ps 16-Nov-2000 Page 11 of 24 00-300 J3/00-112r3 000210 Snyder Exposition of command-line access ps J3/00-113 000210 Snyder Issue 14 ps J3/00-114r1 000211 Cohen Issue 141 and a related problem txt J3/00-115 000211 Cohen Issues 222 and 224 txt J3/00-116 000214 Cohen Issues 233, 234, and 235 txt J3/00-117 000214 Cohen Procedure Interface Body txt J3/00-118 000216 Cohen Issues with NAME= and BINDNAME= txt J3/00-119 000217 Takata Review of the J3 responses to interp- txt retation requests from Japan J3/00-120r1 000222 Zongaro Miscellaneous Interop Fixes (Issues txt 218 and 229) J3/00-121 000223 Mitchell f90gl and C Interoperability ps,pdf J3/00-122r2 000223 Zongaro Edits for Issues 149 and 120 txt J3/00-123 000224 Cohen Interpretation request on ELEMENTAL txt procedures (revised) J3/00-124r1 000224 Cohen Interpretation request: Scope of txt ac-implied-DO variable J3/00-125 000224 Cohen VOLATILE questions txt J3/00-126 000224 Whitlock F95 Interpretations Index txt J3/00-127 000224 Zongaro Edits for Issues 89, 148, 162, 230 txt and 231 (Interop.) J3/00-128r1 000228 Cohen Unresolved issue 132 txt J3/00-129 000228 Cohen Asynchronous questions txt J3/00-130 000228 Cohen Abstract interface blocks txt J3/00-131 000228 Cohen Miscellaneous infelicities txt J3/00-132r1 000228 Dedo Edits - VOLATILE fixups txt,ps,wpd J3/00-133 000228 Cohen Interpretation 70: revised txt J3/00-134 000229 Cohen Issue 215 txt J3/00-135 000229 Cohen Interpretation 81: revised txt J3/00-136r1 000229 Snyder Imprecision in pointer disassociation ps and undefinition J3/00-137r2 000229 Nagle Issue 3 txt J3/00-138 000229 Snyder Starting to rebuild finalization ps J3/00-139 000301 Maine Command argument simplification txt J3/00-140r1 000301 Bleikamp Async volatile fixups txt,doc 16-Nov-2000 Page 12 of 24 00-300 J3/00-141 000301 Cohen Issue 13 and Interpretation 84 txt J3/00-142 000301 Whitlock Rules for voting on Fortran 95 txt interpretations J3/00-143r2 000301 Dedo JOR responses to proposed edits in txt,ps,wpd J3/00-103r1 - Chapters 1, 2, 3 J3/00-144r1 000301 Snyder Data issues from J3/00-103r1 ps J3/00-145 000302 Snyder Specification functions in the ps Glossary J3/00-146r1 000302 Snyder Remove identical syntax rule ps J3/00-147 000302 Snyder Issue 82 ps J3/00-148 000302 Cohen Issues 17 - 19 and 211 txt J3/00-149r1 000302 Zongaro Revision of ENUM syntax and un- txt resolved issue 231 J3/00-150 000302 Steidel New /Interop unresolved issues txt J3/00-151r1 000302 Dedo JOR responses to proposed edits in txt,ps,wpd J3/00-103r1 - Chapters 7, 8, 9 J3/00-152 000302 Snyder Define "component order" term ps J3/00-153 000302 Maine Corrections to J3/00-007 txt J3/00-154 000302 Cohen Issues 223 txt J3/00-155r1 000302 Cohen ALLOCATE(MOULD=) txt J3/00-156 000303 North Meeting 152 Treasurer's Report txt J3/00-157 000303 Zongaro Meeting 152 Minutes txt,ps,htm -------------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 153 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, MAY 29 - JUNE 2, 2000 -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title -------------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/00-007r1 000502 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/00-010r4 000505 Warnock J3 Work Plan doc,txt J3/00-011r1 000505 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues txt J3/00-158 000417 Reid Interpretation 001 txt J3/00-159 000417 Reid Interpretation 003 txt J3/00-160r2 000417 Reid Interpretation 004 txt,ps,wpd J3/00-161 000417 Reid Interpretation 005 txt J3/00-162 000503 Maine Edits incorporated in 00-007r1 txt J3/00-163 000503 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt 16-Nov-2000 Page 13 of 24 00-300 J3/00-164 000503 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues, txt Part A J3/00-165 000504 Reid Interpretation 191 txt J3/00-166 000505 Maine Editors list of unresolved issues, txt Part B J3/00-167 000505 Maine F90 interp and the f2k IMPORT txt J3/00-168 000508 Mitchell Fortran pointer from C pointer txt J3/00-169r2 000508 Snyder Minor things ? left over from ps,pdf 00-144r1, and a few more J3/00-170 000508 Snyder Syntax and symantics of VALUE attrib- ps,pdf ute, issue 214, part of issue 90 J3/00-171r2 000508 Snyder One more little problem with pro- ps,pdf cedure pointers J3/00-172r2 000508 Snyder Issue 263 ps,pdf J3/00-173r1 000508 Snyder Issue 262 ps,pdf J3/00-174r1 000508 Snyder Issue 236 ps,pdf J3/00-175r1 000508 Snyder Issue 268 ps,pdf J3/00-176r2 000508 Snyder Issue 269 ps,pdf J3/00-177 000508 Snyder Issue 7 ps,pdf J3/00-178r3 000508 Snyder More work on SELECT TYPE and ps,pdf ASSOCIATE J3/00-179 000508 Snyder Derived-type input/output and its ps,pdf relation to type-bound procedures J3/00-180r2 000508 Snyder Define "component order" term, ps,pdf issues 17 - 19 and 211, more work on constructors J3/00-181 000508 Snyder A problem I had in converting FORTRAN ps,pdf 77 to Fortran 95 J3/00-182r1 000508 Snyder Issue 266 ps,pdf J3/00-183r2 000508 Snyder Part of issue 237 ps,pdf J3/00-184r2 000508 Snyder Issue 258 ps,pdf J3/00-185 000508 Snyder More work on extensible derived-type ps,pdf definitions J3/00-186r1 000508 Snyder Semantics of the select kind con- ps,pdf struct are not described, and it appears to be a mess to use J3/00-187r1 000508 Snyder The discussion of INTRINSIC is scat- ps,pdf tered, contradictory, and repetitive J3/00-188 000511 Kruyt Blanks in ELSEWHERE txt J3/00-189 000511 Kruyt Usage of DELIM= in control-info-list txt of transfer statement J3/00-190 000511 Kruyt Name of derived-type definition txt J3/00-191 000511 Kruyt Usage of name, identifier, local txt name, local identifier 16-Nov-2000 Page 14 of 24 00-300 J3/00-192r2 000511 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps,pdf J3/00-193 000512 Snyder One more try at READONLY attribute ps,pdf J3/00-194r1 000512 Snyder FINAL procedures as type-bound ps,pdf procedures J3/00-195r2 000512 Snyder Edits to implement decisions in ps,pdf 00-155 concerning ALLOCATABLE J3/00-196 000512 Steidel Missed edit from meeting txt J3/00-197 000515 Snyder Draft proposed TR on Enhanced Module ps,pdf Facilities in Fortran J3/00-198r1 000515 van Waveren Issue 226 txt J3/00-199r1 000515 van Waveren Issue 112 txt J3/00-200r3 000515 van Waveren Issues 161 and 257 txt J3/00-201 000520 Snyder Three problems with enumerations and ps,pdf one with type aliases J3/00-202 000524 Whitlock F95 Interp letter ballot # 1 (email txt x3j3.2000-136) due 19-May-2000 J3/00-203 000524 Whitlock Results of the F95 Interp letter txt ballot # 1 J3/00-204 000525 Whitlock Text of Interps 1, 3, 4, 5 txt J3/00-205r1 000530 Nagle Standardize Printing (aka "carriage txt control) J3/00-206 000530 Steidel Response/Disposition of 00-168 txt,ps,pdf,htm,doc J3/00-207 000530 Steidel Miscellaneous /Interop edits txt,ps,pdf,htm J3/00-208 000530 Dedo Interpretations 68 and 70 txt,ps,wpd J3/00-209 000530 Bleikamp Further results of /Interp letter txt ballot J3/00-210 000530 Dedo Interpretation 67 txt,ps,wpd J3/00-211 000530 Maine Terminology of "interoperates with" txt J3/00-212 000530 van Waveren Issue 214 txt J3/00-213 000531 Bleikamp Interp 66 txt J3/00-214 000531 Dedo Interp 12 - Evaluation of Intrinsic txt,ps,wpd Procedures J3/00-215 000531 Steidel BIND(C) Syntax fixes - resolution of txt,ps,pdf,htm,doc Item 256 J3/00-216 000531 Maine Unresolved Issue 261 txt J3/00-217 000601 Maine Unresolved Issue 257 (C Functions) txt J3/00-218r1 000531 Meadows Unresolved Issue 247 txt J3/00-219 000531 Meadows Unresolved Issue 94 txt J3/00-220 000531 Nagle Eliminate printing (aka "carriage txt control") 16-Nov-2000 Page 15 of 24 00-300 J3/00-221r1 000601 Warnock Report to WG5 doc,txt J3/00-222 000601 Hirchert Subgroup disposition of 00-190 and txt 00-191 J3/00-223 000601 Dedo Regularize I/O Keywords txt,ps,wpd J3/00-224 000601 Nagle Allow space in ELSEWHERE txt J3/00-225r1 000601 Hirchert Thursday Report txt J3/00-226 000601 Hirchert Revised Constructor Specification and txt Syntax J3/00-227 000602 North Meeting 153 Treasurer's Report txt J3/00-228r1 000602 Whitlock Meeting 153 Minutes txt -------------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 154 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, SEPTEMBER 18 - 22, 2000 -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title -------------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/00-006r1 000703 Whitlock Defect Report, F95 Interpretations txt J3/00-007r2 000612 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/00-011r2 000613 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues txt J3/00-229 000609 Snyder Request for Interpretation txt J3/00-230 000612 Maine Edits incorporated in 00-007r2 txt J3/00-231 000613 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt J3/00-232 000613 Maine Open unresolved issues txt J3/00-233 000626 Snyder Derived-type input/output and its ps,pdf,dvi relation to type-bound procedures J3/00-233r1 000920 Snyder Derived-type input/output and its ps relation to type-bound procedures J3/00-233r2 000921 Snyder Derived-type input/output and its ps relation to type-bound procedures J3/00-234 000626 Snyder Semantics of the select kind con- ps,pdf,dvi struct are not described, and it appears to be a mess to use J3/00-235 000626 Snyder Issues 270 and 271 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-236 000626 Snyder Issue 273 and other work on passed- ps,pdf,dvi object dummy arguments J3/00-236r1 000920 Snyder Issue 273 and other work on passed- ps object dummy arguments J3/00-237 000626 Snyder Work on component accessibility ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-237r1 000919 Snyder Work on component accessibility ps J3/00-238 000626 Snyder Issue 281 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-238r1 000921 Snyder Issue 281 ps 16-Nov-2000 Page 16 of 24 00-300 J3/00-239 000626 Snyder Issue 280 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-239r1 000918 Snyder Issue 280 ps J3/00-240 000626 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-240r1 000910 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps J3/00-240r2 000920 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps J3/00-240r3 000921 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps J3/00-241 000626 Snyder Issue 267 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-241r1 000918 Snyder Issue 267 ps J3/00-241r2 000919 Snyder Issue 267 ps J3/00-242 000626 Snyder Issue 237 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-242r1 000920 Snyder Issue 237 ps J3/00-243 000626 Snyder Issues 277 - 279 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-243r1 000918 Snyder Issues 277 - 279 ps J3/00-244 000626 Snyder Several small things ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-244r1 000918 Snyder Several small things ps J3/00-245 000626 Snyder A few small problems with procedure ps,pdf,dvi pointers J3/00-246 000702 Snyder Request for interpretation of rules txt allowing duplicate names J3/00-246r1 000918 Snyder Withdraw request for interpretation txt,ps of rules allowing duplicate names J3/00-247 000706 Snyder Unresolved issues 17 and 18 ps,pdf,dvi J3/00-248 000710 Nagle Note removal of 9.5.5 in Ch. 1 txt J3/00-248r1 000920 Nagle Note removal of 9.5.5 in Ch. 1 txt J3/00-248r2 000921 Nagle Note removal of 9.5.5 in Ch. 1 txt J3/00-249 000713 Snyder Request for interpretation concerning txt the INTRINSIC statement and ATTRIBUTE J3/00-250 000719 Snyder Minor spec changes - accessibility ps,pdf,dvi and default initialization of parent subobject J3/00-250r1 000918 Snyder Issue 261 and minor spec change to ps allow default initialization of parent component J3/00-250r2 000921 Snyder Issue 261 and minor spec change to ps allow default initialization of parent component J3/00-250r3 000922 Snyder Issue 61 and minor spec change to ps allow default initialization of parent component 16-Nov-2000 Page 17 of 24 00-300 J3/00-251 000719 Snyder Issues 19 and 211, more work on ps,pdf,dvi derived types and constructors J3/00-252 000719 Snyder Minor specification change - ps,pdf,dvi accessibility of constructor in the presence of private components J3/00-252r1 000919 Snyder Minor specification change - ps accessibility of constructor in the presence of private components J3/00-253 000731 Whitlock F95 interp letter ballot # 2 - due txt 28 July 2000 J3/00-254 000731 Whitlock Result of the F95 interp letter txt ballot # 2 J3/00-255 000808 Snyder Minor change in M4 to allow differ- ps,pdf,dvi ent-rank views of array objects J3/00-256 000815 Meadows Unresolved issue 251: Kind type par- ps,pdf ameters for types in and J3/00-256r1 000919 Meadows Unresolved issue 251: Kind type par- ps,pdf ameters for types in and J3/00-256r2 000921 Meadows Unresolved issue 251: Kind type par- ps,pdf ameters for types in and J3/00-257 000816 Bierman External vs. Bind ps,pdf J3/00-258 000816 Bierman Unresolved issue 83 ps,pdf J3/00-259 000816 Bierman Some remarks regarding pdf ps,pdf J3/00-260 000816 Reid Draft interpretations from WG5 txt J3/00-261 000816 Reid Draft edits to J3/00-007r2 from WG5 txt J3/00-262 000816 Bierman WG5 Report ps,pdf J3/00-263 000817 Meadows Unresolved issue 265: Kind parameter ps,pdf of enums J3/00-263r1 000919 Meadows Unresolved issue 265: Kind parameter ps,pdf of enums J3/00-264 000817 Meadows Unresolved issue 249: Rounding mode ps,pdf changes in procedures J3/00-265 000818 van Waveren C pointer comparison txt J3/00-265r1 000919 /Interop C pointer comparison J3/00-265r2 000920 /Interop C pointer comparison txt J3/00-266 000817 Meadows Unresolved issue 255 ps,pdf J3/00-266r1 000919 Meadows Unresolved issue 255 ps,pdf J3/00-267 000818 van Waveren C-Fortran I/O txt J3/00-267r1 000919 /Interop C-Fortran I/O txt J3/00-267r2 000920 /Interop C-Fortran I/O J3/00-268 000823 Reid Results of ballots on interpretations txt (N1403) 16-Nov-2000 Page 18 of 24 00-300 J3/00-269 000823 Reid Unresolved technical issues of C- txt Fortran interoperability (N1402) J3/00-270 000823 Reid Overloading structure constructors txt (N1407) J3/00-271 000823 Reid Destructors (N1417) txt J3/00-272 000904 Cohen Issues 17 - 19 and 211 txt J3/00-273 000909 Reid Interpretation 23 txt J3/00-274 000907 Snyder Minor change in M4 to allow differ- ps ent-rank views of array objects J3/00-275 000913 Cohen Ordering txt J3/00-275r1 000914 Cohen Ordering txt J3/00-276 000914 Cohen Issues 17 - 19 txt J3/00-276r1 000914 Cohen Issues 17 - 19 txt J3/00-276r2 000914 Cohen Issues 17 - 19 txt J3/00-277 000914 Cohen Edits for destructors txt J3/00-277r1 000915 Cohen Edits for destructors txt J3/00-277r2 000921 Cohen Edits for destructors txt J3/00-278 000919 Maine Issues 270 and 271 txt J3/00-279 000919 Dedo Regularize I/O keywords txt,ps,wpd J3/00-280 000919 Cohen Modifications to the edits of 00-270 txt J3/00-281 000918 Snyder Edits arising from Data subgroup ps examination of 00-261 J3/00-281r1 000920 Snyder Edits arising from Data subgroup ps examination of 00-261 J3/00-282 000918 Dedo Miscellaneous fixups txt,ps,wpd J3/00-282r1 000921 Dedo Miscellaneous fixups txt,ps,wpd J3/00-283 000919 Maine Unresolved issue 257 (C functions) txt J3/00-284 000919 Moore Issues with Bind(C) Enum Interoper- txt ability J3/00-285 000919 Meadows Unresolved issue 249 J3/00-285r1 000919 Meadows Unresolved issue 249 ps,pdf J3/00-285r2 000920 Meadows Unresolved issue 249 ps,pdf J3/00-286 000919 Steidel Interop edits J3/00-287 000918 Nagle Passing IO Mode to DTIO routines txt (Unresolved Issue # 30) J3/00-287r1 000918 Nagle Passing IO Mode to DTIO routines txt (Unresolved Issue # 30) 16-Nov-2000 Page 19 of 24 00-300 J3/00-287r2 000920 Nagle Passing IO Mode to DTIO routines txt (Unresolved Issue # 30) J3/00-288 000918 Nagle Parent & Child I/O Modes txt J3/00-288r1 000918 Nagle Parent & Child I/O Modes txt J3/00-288r2 000920 Nagle Parent & Child I/O Modes txt J3/00-289 000919 Snyder Remove prohibition against recursive ps specification functions J3/00-290 000919 Bleikamp Unresolved issue 122 txt J3/00-290r1 000919 Bleikamp Unresolved issue 122 txt J3/00-291 000919 Bleikamp Unresolved issue 124 txt J3/00-291r1 000919 Bleikamp Unresolved issue 124 txt J3/00-292 000917 Cohen Interpretation Request (F2002 txt unresolved issue 267) J3/00-293 000919 Maine Edits from WG5 txt J3/00-294 000918 Nagle Unresolved issue # 209 txt J3/00-294r1 000918 Nagle Unresolved issue # 209 txt J3/00-294r2 000920 Nagle Unresolved issue # 209 txt J3/00-295 000920 Hirchert BNF Analysis txt J3/00-295r1 001002 Hirchert BNF Analysis txt J3/00-295r1A 001002 Hirchert BNF Analysis txt J3/00-295r1B 001002 Hirchert BNF Analysis txt J3/00-295r1C 001002 Hirchert BNF Analysis txt J3/00-296 000920 Cohen Inconsistent association status txt J3/00-296r1 000920 Cohen Inconsistent association status txt J3/00-297 000921 Dedo Character Arguments in Intrinsic txt,ps,wpd Procedures J3/00-297r1 000921 Dedo Character Arguments in Intrinsic txt,ps,wpd Procedures J3/00-298 000921 Dedo Character Assignment in txt,ps,wpd GET_ENVIRONMENT_VARIABLE J3/00-298r1 000921 Dedo Character Assignment in txt,ps,wpd GET_ENVIRONMENT_VARIABLE J3/00-299 000922 North Meeting 154 Treasurer's Report txt J3/00-300 000922 Whitlock Meeting 154 Minutes -------------------------------------------------------------------------- 16-Nov-2000 Page 20 of 24 00-300 Appendix C: Future Meetings and Distribution/Secretarial Assignments Appendix C Future Meetings and Distribution/Secretarial Assignments Meeting Conventions: - Four meetings per year - Attempt to schedule second full week of the month - Attempt to schedule meeting contiguous with WG5 annual meeting Future meeting schedule: 155 December 11 - 15, 2000, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: November 27, 2000 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Secretary: Stan Whitlock 156 March 19 - 23, 2001, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: March 5, 2001 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Secretary: Stan Whitlock 157 June 4 - 8, 2001, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: May 21, 2001 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Secretary: Stan Whitlock 158 August 20 - 24, 2001, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: August 6, 2001 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Secretary: Stan Whitlock 159 December 3 - 7, 2001, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: November 19, 2001 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Secretary: Stan Whitlock Committee materials availability: Agenda and meeting notice available at the J3 web site and from the J3 ftp server. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3) 16-Nov-2000 Page 21 of 24 00-300 Pre- and post-meeting distribution available at the J3 ftp and web sites. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution of premeeting 2 weeks prior to meeting. (documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1) Meeting minutes are available at the J3 web and ftp sites. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ftp site: ftp://ftp.J3-Fortran.org/x3j3 ftp mirror site: ftp://ftp.drfc.nasa.gov/pub/x3j3 J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.J3-Fortran.org ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 16-Nov-2000 Page 22 of 24 00-300 Appendix D: Committee Organization Appendix D Committee Organization D.1 Officers and Management Chair T. Warnock International Rep. (open) Secretary S. Whitlock Treasurer M. North Librarian M. North Editor R. Maine (WG5 appointment) Maintenance S. Whitlock Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert Future Meetings M. North Membership List K. Hirchert D.2 Subgroups JOR: Responsible for the maintenance of the Journal of Development (standing document 004) and managing the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R.1, R.2, R.8, and all MTE and B items. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, C. Dedo, D. Hendrickson, D. Nagle DATA: Responsible for language design topics related to data and data structures; manages the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R3, R5, R6, and R7. K. Hirchert (head), R. Maine, J. Martin, M. Ross, V. Snyder INTERVAL: Responsible for R.4 (enabling technologies for interval arithmetic) T. Warnock INTEROP: Responsible for R9 (interoperability with C) J. Steidel (head), L. Meadows, R. Maine, M. van Waveren INTERP: Responsible for evaluating interpretation requests, providing responses to such requests, and maintaining standing document 006. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, M. Cohen, J. Steidel 16-Nov-2000 Page 23 of 24 00-300 Appendix E: Membership summary J3 Meeting Attendance (Principal Members) Meeting # 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 152a 153a Location (state) IN CA NV HI UK NV NV NV NV NV L.B. L.B. Date (month year) 05 08 11 03 06 08 11 02 05 09 05 07 98 98 98 99 99 99 99 00 00 00 00 00 Name Affiliation 98 98 98 99 99 99 99 00 00 00 00 00 Bleikamp, Richard HP V A V V A V A** V V V V V Cohen, Malcolm NAG V R V V V V V V R V V V Dedo, Craig self V V V A A** V* V V V V V V Hendrickson, Dick self V V V A V V V V V A V V Hirchert, Kurt U of IL V V V V A A** Q V Hirchert, Kurt U of KY V V Q V V Meadows, Larry Sun RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP V V RP V Nagle, Dan self P V V V V V V North, Mallory Rose-Hulman V V V V V V V V V V V V Ross, Mike Intel P A V R E V Smith, Brian U of NM A R R R A R A** R R R R R Snyder, Van JPL/Caltech A V V V V V V V V V V V Steidel, Jon Cray V A A** V** V V V V V V V V vanWaveren, Matthijs Fujitsu P V A V A** V R V A V V Warnock, Tony LANL V V V V V V V V V A V V Whitlock, Stan Compaq V V V V A V V V V V V V Zongaro, Henry IBM V V V V A V V V A A** V V V present and voting other voting attendees: R absent but represented J Martin represented B Smith A absent and not represented D Moore represented M Ross P present and not voting RP represented by previous member non-voting attendees: E excused R Maine, alternate for M Cohen Q Resigned A Vaught, observer from FSF ** missed 2 of last 3 meetings *** lost membership Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 154 16 Majority 9 Quorum 6 Total Membership at end of Meeting 154 16 Total Members Attended or Represented at 154 12 Total Attendees at Meeting 154 14 membership changes since last meeting: The University of Kentucky (Center for Computational Sciences) resigned its membership following the completion of the letter ballot, and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign (Department of Atmospheric Sciences) joined. [This reflects Kurt Hirchert changing from a job with the former department to one with the latter.] 16-Nov-2000 Page 24 of 24 00-300 Appendix F: Membership Roster The Membership Roster is not reproduced here. The latest Membership Roster may be found in ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/00-001r1.html and ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/00-001r1.txt