From: Whitlock, Stan [stan.whitlock@intel.com] Sent: Sunday, August 10, 2003 8:42 AM To: x3j3 Subject: (j3.2003-640) J3 meeting #164 minutes - 03-190.txt To: J3 J3/03-190 From: Stan Whitlock Page 1 of 22 Date: 10-Aug-2003 Subject: J3 meeting #164 minutes Minutes of INCITS/J3 Committee Meeting #164 March 30 - April 4, 2003 Las Vegas, Nevada 0. List of papers passed at meeting #164 Here is a list of the paper numbers that passed at meeting #164, including F95 interpretations. The reference is to the latest revision on the ftp server after the meeting, not to the actual revision that was voted upon. The motions below reference the actual revision voted upon. 03-101r2 03-118r3 03-138r1 03-156r1 03-173 03-103r3 03-119r1 03-139r2 03-157r1 03-174r1 03-104r2 03-120r1 03-140r1 03-158r3 03-175r1 03-105r3 03-121r1 03-142r1 03-159r2 03-176 03-108r3 03-122r1 03-144r2 03-162r2 03-177 03-109r1 03-124r1 03-145r1 03-164r1 03-178 03-110r2 03-125r2 03-146 03-165 03-179 03-111r2 03-126 03-147r1 03-166 03-180 03-112r2 03-127r2 03-152r2 03-167r2 03-183 03-113r3 03-130r2 03-153 03-170r1 03-184 03-114r1 03-131r1 03-154r2 03-171r2 03-186 03-115r1 03-134r2 03-155r1 03-172r1 03-188r1 03-116r2 03-135r3 No Fortran F95 interpretations were passed at this J3 meeting. The last recorded interp is #000101 in 02-006Ar1 of 2-Nov-2002. 1. Sunday, March 30, 2003 1.1 WG5 session - see the minutes in WG5/N1518 This is a concurrent WG5 and J3 meeting. WG5 will decide content for the Draft F2K Standard. J3 will implement changes WG5 and J3 feel are necessary to complete the technical content of F2K. 2. Monday, March 31, 2003 2.2 Opening business - D. Nagle The meeting was called to order at 8:00 am, Monday, March 31, 2003, at the Las Vegas Marriott Residence Inn Hughes Center by the chair, Dan Nagle. 2.2.1 Remarks from the chair - D. Nagle This J3 meeting is co-located with the WG5 meeting. J3 counted votes will be J3 members only. All present may vote in straw votes and participate in debates. 10-Aug-2003 Page 2 of 22 03-190 2.2.2 Adoption of agenda - D. Nagle ** motion: adopt the agenda for meeting #164 as amended (moved by Whitlock/seconded by Hendrickson) - passed by unanimous consent (uc) There will be a US TAG meeting Thursday. The final agenda is in Appendix A. 2.2.3 Approval of Meeting 163 minutes - D. Nagle ** motion: approve meeting #163 minutes == paper 02-334 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - uc 2.2.4 INCITS/OMC report - D. Nagle There were 2 votes to INCITS on TAG business and 1 vote by J3. NB: A public comment stays on the public record until the submitter informs INCITS that due process was followed. The was no annual report because of this joint meeting so Dan will do the regular report in January. 2.2.5 ISO/WG5 report - Van Snyder, IR The ballot was submitted on the F2K draft. 2.2.6 H2 Liaison report - C. Dedo Craig sent mail to H2 but received no answer. SQL 2003 is coming. 2.2.7 IEEE 754 report - M. Ingrassia for L. Meadows There is a draft of IEEE 754. 2.2.8 Treasurer's report - M. North As of now -- $2718.54 is the balance. There are no outstanding bills. There is no meeting fee for this meeting. 2.2.9 Beginning membership report - K. Hirchert Total membership at the beginning of this meeting is 13, with 11 present or represented. ** motion: excuse R. Bleikamp's absence from this meeting (Hirchert/North) - uc See Appendix E for details. 2.2.10 Local arrangements - M. North - no discussion recorded 10-Aug-2003 Page 3 of 22 03-190 2.2.11 Comments from members These are co-located meetings of WG5 and J3 so the host has to do no extra work. 2.1 WG5 session - out of agenda order J3/03-168 summarizes the status of public comments in WG5/N1512. N1511 is the start of the draft response to public comment. 2.3 Subgroup organization and initial paper assignments - D. Nagle The three subgroups formed in the WG5 meeting will meet during J3: /JOR: Whitlock (head), Dedo, Hendrickson, Nagle, Takata /interop: Long (head), Moene /data: Cohen (head), Hirchert, Ingrassia, James, Martin, Brainerd, Donev, Maine, Morgan, Muxworthy, Schonfelder /edit: Maine (head) Papers were distributed to subgroups as follows: /JOR: 115, 124, 125, 136, 146, 150, 151, 152, 155, 156, 163 129, 146, 121 /interop: 104, 105, 109 /data: 101, 141, 142, 147, 148, 153, 157, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 164 /edit: 127, 149 No interpretations of F95 will be processed at this meeting. /data: ** motion: paper 03-165 reorganize 006 section 4.5 and 03-166 the reorganized text as amended (Hirchert/Dedo) - uc all edits for section 4.5 this week will be against 03-166 {no post meeting 03-166r1} 2.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm 2.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm /J3: The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Tuesday. 3. Tuesday, April 1, 2003 3.1 WG5 session - no business 10-Aug-2003 Page 4 of 22 03-190 3.2 F2002 Plenary - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am /JOR: ** motion: paper 03-146 MTC8 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - uc ** motion: paper 03-121r1 MTC3-5, not MTC6 (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc ** motion: paper 03-143r2 US1.12 (Whitlock/Nagle) - uc {NB editor: use line numbers in PDF 007} ** motion: paper 03-126 MTC9 (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc ** motion: paper 03-108r3 2.13 (whitlock/Nagle) - uc ** motion: paper 03-103r1 2.9 (Whitlock/Dedo as amended: straw vote: allow multiple values for EOF? yes-no-undecided: 5-9-5 compromise: keep single value and add intrinsics 2.9 now "un-rejected" by WG5 => back to JOR paper withdrawn ** motion: paper 03-135r2 2.14 (Whitlock/Hendrickson): straw vote: satisfy 2.14 by allowing intrinsic and non-intrinsic modules with the same name in the same program? yes-no-undecided: 16-2-1 straw vote: satisfy 2.14 by allowing intrinsic and non-intrinsic modules with the same name in the same scope? yes-no-undecided: 1-13-3 paper withdrawn ** motion: paper 03-167 MTC6 (Whitlock/Dedo) - withdrawn ** motion: paper 03-131 MTC10 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) as amended - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-124 as amended (Whitlock/Nagle) - passed 9-0 {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-152r2 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - passed 9-2 paper 03-150 will have no further processing paper 03-130 straw votes in section 5: Q1) a-b-undecided: 16-1-0 Q2) {input case insensitive} a-b-c-d-e-undecid: 2-0-3-0-13-0 Q4) yes-no-undecided: 13-2-3 Q5) a-b-c-undecided: 4-11-0-2 Q6) a-b-c-undecided: 11-0-6-1 /data: ** motion: paper 03-116r1 TC3 (Hirchert/Martin) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-122r1 TC2 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc 10-Aug-2003 Page 5 of 22 03-190 /interop: ** motion: paper 03-142 2.5 (Long/Whitlock) - section III only, as amended - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-120 MTC11 (Long/Whitlock) as amended - withdrawn ** motion: paper 03-170 parts of MTC14 as amended (Long/Whitlock) - uc {post meeting r1} /edit: ** motion: paper 03-171r1 contains parts of 03-142 and edits (Maine/Nagle) as amended - 03-134r2 overrides this - withdrawn there will be no action taken on 03-149 since 2.4 of 03-107r1 is in 03-171r1 editor accepted edits in Japan's comment, in Australia's comment, and in UK's comment {expect E1, E8, and E22 which are in J3 papers; E4 withdrawn} 3.3 Tutorials - none given 3.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm 2.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm /data: ** motion: paper 03-110r1 (Snyder/Ingrassia) as amended - passed 9-1 {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-144r1 as amended (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc {post meeting r2} /edit: ** motion: paper 03-171r2 (Maine/Nagle) - uc /J3: /data graciously accepted sections 4 and 5 of 03-142 from /JOR The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Wednesday. 4. Wednesday, April 2, 2003 4.1 WG5 session - nothing recorded 10-Aug-2003 Page 6 of 22 03-190 4.2 F2002 Plenary - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am /JOR: ** motion: paper 03-135r3 2.14 (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc ** motion: paper 03-103r2 2.9 as amended (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc {post meeting r3} ** motion: paper 03-167r1 MTC6 as amended (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-174 Japan response as amended (Whitlock /Dedo) - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-136 pi (Whitlock/Long) - failed 2-9 paper 03-151 will have no further processing /data: ** motion: paper 03-139r1 examples only (Hirchert/Snyder) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-145r1 TC7 (Hirchert/Snyder) - passes 7-3 ** motion: paper 03-138r1 TC4 (Hirchert/Martin) - uc /interop: ** motion: paper 03-172 TC14 (Long/Moene) as amended - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-133r2 1.14 (Long/Moene) - straw vote: keep WCHAR? yes-no-undecided: 1-8-7 paper withdrawn ** motion: paper 03-104r1 example (Long/Moene) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-109 (Long/Moene) as amended - uc {post meeting r1} /edit: ** motion: paper 03-173 Japan (Maine/Nagle) - uc ** motion: paper 03-175 Australian response (Maine/Dedo) - withdrawn ** motion: paper 03-114 MTC1 (Maine/Dedo) as amended - uc {post meeting r1} 4.3 Tutorials - none given 4.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm 10-Aug-2003 Page 7 of 22 03-190 4.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm /edit: ** motion: paper 03-175r1 (Maine/Dedo) - uc /J3: The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Thursday. 5. Thursday, April 3, 2003 5.1 WG5 session - nothing recorded 5.2 F2002 Plenary - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am /JOR: ** motion: paper 03-130r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-154r1 {Whitlock/Dedo) - uc ** motion: paper 03-115 as amended {Whitlock/Nagle} - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-156 as amended {Whitlock/Nagle} - uc {post meeting r1} paper 03-163 will have no further processing ** motion: paper 03-155r1 {Whitlock/Dedo} - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-125r1 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-178 (Whitlock/Dedo) - passes 8-2 ** motion: paper 03-159r1 as amended (Whitlock/Nagle) - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-184 (Whitlock/Deo) - uc /data: ** motion: paper 03-111r1 as amended (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-112r2 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc ** motion: paper 03-113r2 as amended (Hirchert/Snyder) - deferred {see below} ** motion: paper 03-118r2 (Snyder/Martin) as amended - passes 8-2 {post meeting r3} 10-Aug-2003 Page 8 of 22 03-190 ** motion: paper 03-119r1 remove TYPEALIAS (Hirchert/Snyder) - failed 4-5 {see WG5 sidebar below} ** motion: paper 03-140 as amended (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-142 W8 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc ** motion: paper 03-147 as amended (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-162r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-164r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc ** motion: paper 03-176 (Ingrassia/Martin) - uc paper 03-177 affected by 03-119r1 failure - see below ** motion: paper 03-179 (Hircheret/Snyder) - uc ** motion: paper 03-180 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc paper 03-148 will have no further processing /interop: ** motion: paper 03-120r1 (Long/Moene) - uc ** motion: paper 03-105r2 (Long/Moene) as amended - uc {post meeting r3} paper 03-128 MTC12 is addressed in 03-120r1 since 03-119r1 failed {see below} MTC14 is complete in /interop by 03-170 and 03-172 MTC15 was rejected by WG5 => no further processing /edit: ** motion: paper 03-127r2 (Maine/Nagle) - uc ** motion: paper 03-183 (Maine/Whitlock) - uc ** motion: paper 03-153 (Maine/Dedo) - uc /WG5 sidebar: 03-168r2 MTC13 is rejected by WG5 03-119r1 TC8 remove TYPEALIAS 03-141 is a fallback position on TYPEALIAS straw vote: stongly object to removing TYPEALIAS - strongly object to keeping - undecided: 4-5-8 10-Aug-2003 Page 9 of 22 03-190 straw vote: remove TYPE ALIAS? yes-no-undecided: 12-4-2 country vote: 3-1 {US opposed} /J3: ** move to reconsider 03-119r1 (Dedo/Maine) - uc ** vote: paper 03-119r1 - uc /data: ** motion: paper 03-177 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc 5.3 Tutorials - none given 5.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm There will be a US TAG meeting this afternoon. 5.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm /WG5 business: 03-185r1 resolutions will go into WG5/N1517 03-169 ballot responses will go into N1520 N1519 is CoCo interpretations 03-168r3 is the analysis of the letter ballot /data: ** motion: paper 03-113r2 {undefer} as amended (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc {Post meeting r3} ** motion: give editor license to improve the character set examples 007 [39: note 4.14] along themlines of F90 (Hirchert/Snyder) - uc Start Closing Business early: 6.6 Closing membership report All by 2 members attended or were represented; Bleikamp was excused; James was absent. See Appendix E for details. /J3: ** motion: the meeting minutes appendix B should list the documents for the meeting, not the entire year (Martin/Nagle) - uc The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Friday. 10-Aug-2003 Page 10 of 22 03-190 6. Friday, April 4, 2003 6.1 WG5 session All 8 resolutions in N1517 passes uc. WG5/J3 accomplished setting the technical content of F2K. 6.1+ F2002 Plenary - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am ** motion: paper 03-142 W9 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) as amended - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-187 as amended (Whitlock/Dedo) - failed 1-8 ** motion: paper 03-188 as amended (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc {post meeting r1} ** motion: paper 03-154r2 as amended (Whitlock/Dedo) - uc {post meeting r3} /data: ** motion: paper 03-186 (Ingrassia/Snyder) - uc ** motion: paper 03-101r1 (Snyder/Ingrassia) as amended - uc {post meeting r2} ** motion: paper 03-157r1 (Ingrassia/Snyder) - uc ** motion: paper 03-158r2 (Ingrassia/Snyder) as amended - uc {post meeting r3} paper 03-160 did not get processed by /data - WG5 in Dresden will have to look at it /interop: ** motion: paper 03-142 T6 as amended (Long/Moene) - uc {post meeting r1} 6.2 Closing business Minutes will be paper 03-190. The editor will try to have the updated draft 03-007 available in 2 weeks. 6.3 Review of action items (if any) - none. 6.4 Future meetings - M. North J3 meeting #165, at this hotel in Las Vegas Monday August 18 - Friday August 22, 2003 10-Aug-2003 Page 11 of 22 03-190 J3 discussed holding 2 of 4 meetings per year in Las Vegas {in the "cold" months} and 2 in Indiana so Mallory could continue to act as host. After 2003 Mallory will not longer be able to come to Las Vegas. The host does lots of stuff so someone would have to do gthat work for Las Vegas meetings. No resolution was reached. Details of following meetings in Appendix C. 6.5 Treasurer's report - M. North The hotel food cost $628 - we agreed not to have hotel food for all breaks. The Treasurer's report will be paper 03-189. ** motion: Meeting fee will be $50.00 for future meetings (North/Whitlock) - uc 6.6 Closing membership report - K. Hirchert See 6.6 in 5.5 above and Appendix E for details. 6.7 Comments from members - none. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 9:25 am, April 4, 2003. 10-Aug-2003 Page 12 of 22 03-190 Appendix A: Final Agenda for J3 Meeting 164 =============================== 1. Sunday, March 30, 2003 9:00 am ------------------------------------- 1.1 WG5 Session J. Reid, Convenor 2. Monday, March 31, 2003 8:00 am ------------------------------------- 2.1 WG5 Session J. Reid, Convenor 2.2 Opening business D. Nagle Remarks from the chair D. Nagle Adoption of agenda D. Nagle Approval of Meeting 163 minutes D. Nagle NCITS/OMC report (if any) D. Nagle ISO/WG5 report Van Snyder, IR H2 Liaison report (if any) C. Dedo IEEE 754 report (if any) L. Meadows Treasurer's report M. North Beginning membership report K. Hirchert Local arrangements M. North Comments from members 2.3 Subgroup organization D. Nagle 2.4 Subgroup meetings 2.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 3. Tuesday, April 1, 2003 8:00 am -------------------------------------- 3.1 WG5 Session J. Reid, Convenor 3.2 F2000 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads 3.3 Tutorials (if needed) 3.4 Subgroup meetings 3.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 4. Wednesday, April 2, 2003 8:00 am ---------------------------------------- 4.1 WG5 Session J. Reid, Convenor 4.2 F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads 4.3 Tutorials (if needed) 4.4 Subgroup meetings 4.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 5. Thursday, April 3, 2003 8:00 am --------------------------------------- 5.1 WG5 Session J. Reid, Convenor 5.2 F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads 5.3 Tutorials (if needed) 5.4 Subgroup meetings 5.5 Subgroup reports (4:00 pm) 5.6 TAG meeting (5:00 pm) Van Snyder, IR 6. Friday, April 4, 2003 8:00 am -------------------------------------- 6.1 WG5 Session J. Reid, Convenor 6.1+ F2000 Plenary Subgroup Heads 6.2 Closing business 6.3 Review of action items (if any) 6.4 Future meetings M. North 6.5 Treasurer's report M. North 6.6 Closing membership report K. Hirchert 6.7 Comments from members Adjournment 10-Aug-2003 Page 13 of 22 03-190 Appendix B: J3 REGISTER OF DOCUMENTS FOR 2003 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 164 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, MARCH 30 - APRIL 4, 2003 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/03-101 021114 Snyder Editorial Comments ps,tex J3/03-101r1 030403 Snyder Editorial Comments ps,tex J3/03-101r2 030404 Snyder Editorial Comments ps,tex J3/03-102 021207 Snyder Treatment of BOZ is inconsistent, ps,tex incomplete, and maybe unreasonable J3/03-103 021207 Snyder Replace IOSTAT_END and IOSTAT_EOR by ps,tex functions J3/03-103r1 030331 Dedo Replace IOSTAT_END and IOSTAT_EOR txt,ps,pdf,wpd with Functions J3/03-103r2 030401 Dedo Replace IOSTAT_END and IOSTAT_EOR txt,ps,pdf,wpd with Functions J3/03-103r3 030402 Dedo Replace IOSTAT_END and IOSTAT_EOR txt,ps,pdf,wpd with Functions J3/03-104 021216 Donev Corrections to 10.2.3-4 txt J3/03-104r1 030116 Donev Corrections to 10.2.3-4 txt,ps J3/03-104r2 030402 Moene Corrections to 10.2.3-4 txt J3/03-105 021216 Reid Edits for C_LOC and C_F_POINTER txt J3/03-105r1 021218 Reid Edits for C_LOC and C_F_POINTER txt J3/03-105r2 030402 Moene Edits for C_LOC and C_F_POINTER txt J3/03-105r3 030403 Moene Edits for C_LOC and C_F_POINTER txt J3/03-106 030102 Nagle J3's Response to the Public Review on htm ISO/IEC CD 1539-1 J3/03-107 021218 Snyder Comments on Committee Draft for ps,tex 1539-1 J3/03-107r1 030208 Snyder Comments on Committee Draft for ps,tex 1539-1 J3/03-108 030112 Nagle Response to Comment txt J3/03-108r1 030116 Nagle Response to Comment txt J3/03-108r2 030211 Nagle Response to Comment txt J3/03-108r3 030331 Nagle Response to Comment txt J3/03-109 030128 James/Reid Genericity of ISO_C_BINDING module txt procedures J3/03-109r1 030402 Moene Genericity of ISO_C_BINDING module txt procedures J3/03-110 030209 Donev Pointer assignment deficiency ps J3/03-110r1 030331 Reid Edits for polymorphic association txt 10-Aug-2003 Page 14 of 22 03-190 J3/03-110r2 030402 Reid Edits for polymorphic association txt J3/03-111 030212 Donev "Value of" for Derived Types txt J3/03-111r1 030402 Donev "Value" for Derived Types txt J3/03-111r2 030403 Donev "Value" for Derived Types txt J3/03-112 030212 Donev Cloning via SOURCE txt J3/03-112r1 030313 Donev Cloning via SOURCE txt,ps J3/03-112r2 030402 Donev Cloning via SOURCE txt J3/03-113 030214 Donev Reinstating Deferred Bindings via txt Abstract Types J3/03-113r1 030312 Donev Reinstating Deferred Bindings via txt,ps Abstract Types J3/03-113r2 030401 Donev Reinstating Deferred Bindings via txt Abstract Types J3/03-113r3 030401 Donev Reinstating Deferred Bindings via txt Abstract Types J3/03-114 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC1 (reword txt "NONKIND" J3/03-114r1 030402 Maine Edits for UK comment MTC1 (reword txt "NONKIND" J3/03-115 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment E8 (Description txt of DT i/o) J3/03-115r1 030402 Hendrickson Edits for UK comment E8 (Description txt of DT i/o) J3/03-116 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC3 (Default txt DT parameter initialization) J3/03-116r1 030331 Schonfelder Edits for UK comment TC3 (Default txt DT parameter initialization) J3/03-116r2 030401 Schonfelder Edits for UK comment TC3 (Default txt DT parameter initialization) J3/03-117 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC9 (Remove txt ENUM) J3/03-118 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC10 txt (Allocatable array assignment) J3/03-118r1 030226 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC10 txt (Allocatable array assignment) J3/03-118r2 030402 Schonfelder Edits for UK comment TC10 txt (Allocatable array assignment) J3/03-118r3 030403 Schonfelder Edits for UK comment TC10 txt (Allocatable array assignment) J3/03-119 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC8 (Remove txt TYPEALIAS) J3/03-119r1 030401 Snyder Edits for UK comment TC8 (Remove txt TYPEALIAS) J3/03-120 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC11 (Separate txt C data & procedure pointers) J3/03-120r1 030402 Moene Edits for UK comment MTC11 (Separate txt C data & procedure pointers) J3/03-121 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comments MTC3 to MTC6 txt (various i/o fixes) J3/03-121r1 030331 Dedo Edits for UK comments MTC3 to MTC6 txt,ps,pdf,wpd (various i/o fixes) J3/03-122 030211 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC2 txt (Respecification at type extension) 10-Aug-2003 Page 15 of 22 03-190 J3/03-122r1 030331 Schonfelder Edits for UK comment TC2 txt (Respecification at type extension) J3/03-123 030212 Snyder Working Draft ISO IEC TECHNICAL ps,tex REPORT 19767: Enhanced Module Facilities in Fortran J3/03-124 030215 Nagle Control Characters in Formatted txt Streams? J3/03-124r1 030331 Nagle Control Characters in Formatted txt Streams? J3/03-125 030304 Cohen/Morgan ASYNCHRONOUS and VOLATILE are poorly txt described J3/03-125r1 030402 Hendrickson ASYNCHRONOUS and VOLATILE are poorly txt described J3/03-125r2 030403 Hendrickson ASYNCHRONOUS and VOLATILE are poorly txt described J3/03-126 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC9 (IEEE txt extended format) J3/03-127 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment E22 (Indexing txt asterisk) J3/03-127r1 030401 Maine Edits for UK comment E22 (Indexing txt asterisk) J3/03-127r2 030402 Maine Edits for UK comment E22 (Indexing txt asterisk) J3/03-128 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comments MTC12-MTC15 txt (C interoperability) J3/03-129 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC2 (Remove txt ambiguities re VOLATILE) J3/03-130 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC7 (Output of txt IEEE exceptional values) J3/03-130r1 030402 Hendrickson Edits for UK comment MTC7 (Output of txt IEEE exceptional values) J3/03-130r2 030403 Hendrickson Edits for UK comment MTC7 (Output of txt IEEE exceptional values) J3/03-131 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC10 (Control- txt ling IEEE underflow) J3/03-131r1 030401 Hendrickson Edits for UK comment MTC10 (Control- txt ling IEEE underflow) J3/03-132 030310 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC5 (Change to txt type extension) J3/03-133 030310 Nagle Cater for more C types txt J3/03-133r1 030312 Nagle Cater for more C types txt J3/03-133r2 030401 Moene Cater for more C types txt J3/03-134 030310 Nagle Add kind= to iachar txt J3/03-134r1 030331 Nagle Add kind= to iachar txt J3/03-134r2 030331 Nagle Add kind= to iachar txt J3/03-135 030310 Nagle Intrinsic and Non-intrinsic modules txt J3/03-135r1 030312 Nagle Intrinsic and Non-intrinsic modules? txt J3/03-135r2 030331 Nagle Edits for US 2.14 intrinsic and non- txt intrinsic modules J3/03-135r3 030401 Nagle Edits for US 2.14 intrinsic and non- txt intrinsic modules 10-Aug-2003 Page 16 of 22 03-190 J3/03-136 030310 Long The meaning of pi txt J3/03-137 030311 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC11 txt (Reallocate arrays) J3/03-138 030311 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC4 txt (Type-bound generics) J3/03-138r1 030401 Reid Edits for UK comment TC4 txt (Type-bound generics) J3/03-139 030310 Hirchert US Item 2.1 txt J3/03-139r1 030401 Hirchert Corrections to C.9.6 txt J3/03-139r2 030402 Hirchert Corrections to C.9.6 txt J3/03-140 030310 Hirchert US Item 2.7 txt J3/03-140r1 030402 Hirchert US Item 2.7 txt J3/03-141 030312 Muxworthy TYPEALIAS description txt J3/03-142 030312 Maine Edits for 2.5, 2.6, 2.11, and txt 2.12(T6) of US comments J3/03-142r1 030404 Moene Edits for 2.5, 2.6, 2.11, and txt 2.12(T6) of US comments J3/03-143 030313 Schonfelder Comments on draft TR on Module txt Enhancements J3/03-123 J3/03-143r1 030330 Schonfelder Comments on draft TR on Module ps,pdf Enhancements J3/03-123 J3/03-144 030313 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC6 txt (Restrictions on CLASS(*) pointers) J3/03-144r1 030331 Cohen Edits for UK comment TC6 txt (Restrictions on CLASS(*) pointers) J3/03-144r2 030401 Cohen Edits for UK comment TC6 txt (Restrictions on CLASS(*) pointers) J3/03-145 030313 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC7 txt (Extending any non-SEQUENCE type) J3/03-145r1 030401 Schonfelder Edits for UK comment TC7 txt (Extending any non-SEQUENCE type) J3/03-146 030313 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment MTC8 txt (IEEE_CLASS_TYPE extension) J3/03-147 030313 Cohen Problem with defined assignment txt J3/03-147r1 030403 Cohen Problem with defined assignment txt J3/03-148 030313 Donev Edits for parent components txt J3/03-149 030313 Donev Correction to Note 4.50 txt J3/03-150 030313 Maclaren Recursive I/O txt J3/03-151 030313 Maclaren Problem with evaluation of functions txt J3/03-152 030313 Maclaren Trailing comments txt J3/03-152r1 030316 Nagle Trailing comments txt J3/03-152r2 030331 Nagle Trailing comments txt J3/03-153 030314 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment E1 (Generic txt bindings and abstract interfaces) 10-Aug-2003 Page 17 of 22 03-190 J3/03-154 030314 Muxworthy Edits for UK comment TC1 txt (More support for ISO 10646) J3/03-154r1 030402 Nagle Edits for UK comment TC1 txt (More support for ISO 10646) J3/03-154r2 030403 Nagle Edits for UK comment TC1 txt (More support for ISO 10646) J3/03-154r3 030404 Nagle Edits for UK comment TC1 txt (More support for ISO 10646) J3/03-155 030314 Reid Treatment of signed zeros by ATAN2, txt LOG, and SQRT J3/03-155r1 030331 Reid Treatment of signed zeros by ATAN2, txt LOG, and SQRT J3/03-156 030314 Reid I/O edits txt J3/03-156r1 030402 Nagle I/O edits txt J3/03-157 030314 Reid Data edits txt J3/03-157r1 030403 Snyder Data edits txt J3/03-158 030314 Snyder Some more loose ends txt J3/03-158r1 030331 Snyder Some more loose ends txt J3/03-158r2 030403 Snyder Some more loose ends ps,tex J3/03-158r3 030404 Snyder Some more loose ends ps,tex J3/03-159 030314 Ingrassia Edits in Response to Public Comment txt # 20 J3/03-159r1 030402 Nagle Edits in Response to Public Comment txt # 20 J3/03-159r2 030403 Nagle Edits in Response to Public Comment txt # 20 J3/03-160 030314 Maine Local/global entities txt J3/03-161 030312 Hirchert UK Item TC11 txt J3/03-162 030314 Hirchert MOVE_ALLOC / SWAP_ALLOC Edits txt J3/03-162r1 030402 Hirchert MOVE_ALLOC Edits txt J3/03-162r2 030403 Hirchert MOVE_ALLOC Edits txt J3/03-163 030315 Hirchert VOLATILE Functions txt J3/03-164 030315 Ingrassia Edits in Response to Public Comment txt # 20 point 15 J3/03-164r1 030402 Cohen Generic resolution solution txt J3/03-165 030318 Cohen Subclause 4.5.1 is unreadable txt J3/03-166 030318 Cohen 4.5 Replacement ps J3/03-167 030331 Dedo Replace ACHAR(10) with NEW_LINE txt,ps,pdf,wpd Function J3/03-167r1 030401 Dedo Replace ACHAR(10) with NEW_LINE txt,ps,pdf,wpd Function J3/03-167r2 0304 Dedo Replace ACHAR(10) with NEW_LINE txt,ps,pdf,wpd Function 10-Aug-2003 Page 18 of 22 03-190 J3/03-168 030330 Reid Convenor's analysis of the ballot txt J3/03-168r1 030331 Reid Convenor's analysis of the ballot txt J3/03-168r2 030402 Reid Convenor's analysis of the ballot txt J3/03-168r3 030403 Reid Convenor's analysis of the ballot txt J3/03-169 030330 Reid Draft response to the ballot txt J3/03-170 030331 Donev Edits for UK Comment MTC14 txt J3/03-170r1 030401 Donev Edits for UK Comment MTC14 txt J3/03-171 030331 Maine Editorial Proposals txt J3/03-171r1 030331 Maine Editorial Proposals txt J3/03-171r2 030401 Maine Editorial Proposals txt J3/03-172 030401 Moene Edits for UK Comment MCT14 Interop txt I/O Issues J3/03-172r1 030402 Moene Edits for UK Comment MCT14 Interop txt I/O Issues J3/03-173 030401 Maine Action on Japan's Comments txt J3/03-174 030401 Dedo Response to Japanese Comment for txt,ps,pdf,wpd Page 173 J3/03-174r1 030401 Dedo Response to Japanese Comment for txt,ps,pdf,wpd Page 173 J3/03-175 030401 Maine Action on Australian Comment txt J3/03-175r1 030402 Maine Action on Australian Comment txt J3/03-176 030402 Snyder Section 1.3 from 03-107r1, revised ps,tex J3/03-177 030402 Snyder Section 1.4 from 03-107r1, revised ps,tex J3/03-178 030402 Dedo Recommended Edits for Section 1.8 of txt,ps,pdf,wpd 03-107r1 J3/03-179 030402 Snyder Section 1.10 from 03-107r1, revised ps,tex J3/03-180 030402 Snyder Section 1.11 from 03-107r1, revised ps,tex J3/03-181 030402 Snyder Section 1.12 from 03-107r1, revised ps,tex J3/03-182 030402 Snyder Section 1.14 from 03-107r1, revised ps,tex J3/03-183 030402 Maine Action on UK E comments txt J3/03-184 030402 Dedo Response to UK Edit E11 txt,ps,pdf,wpd J3/03-185 030402 Muxworthy Draft WG5 Resolutions txt J3/03-185r1 030403 Muxworthy Draft WG5 Resolutions txt J3/03-186 030403 Cohen Further wording improvements within txt 4.5 and without J3/03-187 030403 Dedo US 1.19 - Replace "Unsaved" with txt,ps,pdf,wpd "Nonsaved" 10-Aug-2003 Page 19 of 22 03-190 J3/03-188 030403 Dedo Response to some items in 03-101 txt,ps,pdf,wpd J3/03-188r1 030404 Dedo Response to some items in 03-101 txt,ps,pdf,wpd J3/03-189 030410 North Meeting 164 Treasurer's Report txt J3/03-190 030404 Whitlock Meeting 164 Minutes txt ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ********************************************************************** Appendix C Future Meetings and Distribution Meeting Conventions: - Four meetings per year - Attempt to schedule second full week of the month - Attempt to schedule meeting contiguous with WG5 annual meeting Future meeting schedule: 165 August 18 - 22, 2003, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: August 4, 2003 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 166 November 10 - 14, 2003, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: October 27, 2003 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 167 March 1 - 5, 2004, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: February 16, 2004 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 168 May 2 - 7, 2004, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: April 18, 2004 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 169 August 9 - 13, 2004, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: July 26, 2004 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 170 November 8 - 12, 2004, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: October 25, 2004 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 10-Aug-2003 Page 20 of 22 03-190 Committee materials availability: Agenda and meeting notice available at the J3 web site and from the J3 ftp server. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3) Pre- and post-meeting distribution available at the J3 ftp and web sites. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution of premeeting 2 weeks prior to meeting. (documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1) Meeting minutes are available at the J3 web and ftp sites. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ftp site: ftp://ftp.j3-fortran.org/j3 J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.j3-fortran.org ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ********************************************************************** Appendix D: Committee Organization D.1 Officers and Management Chair D. Nagle International Rep. V. Snyder Secretary S. Whitlock Treasurer M. North Librarian M. North Editor R. Maine (WG5 appointment) Maintenance S. Whitlock Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert Future Meetings M. North Membership List K. Hirchert H2 Liaison C. Dedo IEEE 754R Working Group M. Ingrassia D.2 Subgroups JOR: Responsible for the maintenance of the Journal of Development (standing document 004) and managing the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R.1, R.2, R.8, and all MTE and B items. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, C. Dedo, D. Hendrickson, D. Nagle 10-Aug-2003 Page 21 of 22 03-190 DATA: Responsible for language design topics related to data and data structures; manages the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R3, R5, R6, and R7. K. Hirchert (head), A. Donev, R. Maine, J. Martin, V. Snyder INTEROP: Responsible for R9 (interoperability with C) B. Long (head), W. Brainerd, M. Ingrassia, R. James, R. Maine, M. van Waveren {Toon Moene} INTERP: Responsible for evaluating interpretation requests, providing responses to such requests, and maintaining standing document 006. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp ********************************************************************** Appendix E: Membership summary J3 Meeting Attendance (Principal Members) Meeting # 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 Location (state) NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV Date (month year) 12 03 06 08 12 02 05 08 11 04 00 01 01 01 01 02 02 02 02 03 Name Affiliation Bleikamp, R HP A V A** V A** V A** V A** E** Dedo, C self V V V V V V V V V V Hendrickson, D self V A** V V V V V V V V Hirchert, K U of IL V V V V V V V V V V Ingrassia, M Sun RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP V James, R IBM P V V V A Long, W Cray RP RP V V V V V V V V Martin, J self V V V V V V V Nagle, D self V V V V V V V V V V North, M Rose-Hulman V V V V V V V V V Q Smith, B U of NM R A R A** R R A R A** R Snyder, V JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V V V V van Waveren, M Fujitsu A** R** V R A V A** V R R Whitlock, S Intel RP R A V V V V V V V 10-Aug-2003 Page 22 of 22 03-190 J3 Letter Ballot Participation (Principal Members) Meeting # 154a 155a 156a 157a 158a 163a 163b 163c 163d Date (month year) 11 03 05 07 10 12 12 02 03 00 01 01 01 01 02 02 03 03 Name Affiliation Bleikamp, R HP V V V V V V V V V Dedo, C self V V V V V V V V V Hendrickson, D self V V V V V V V V V Hirchert, K U of IL V V V V V V V V V Ingrassia, M Sun RP RP RP RP RP A RP RP RP James, R IBM E E V V Long, W Cray RP RP V V V V V V V Martin, J self A V V V V Nagle, D self V V V V V V V V V North, M Rose-Hulman V V V V V R V V V Smith, B U of NM R R A R A** R R R R Snyder, V JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V V V van Waveren, M Fujitsu R V V V V E E R V Whitlock, S Intel RP RP RP RP V V V V V V present and voting other voting attendees: R absent but represented W. Brainerd, alternate for B. Smith A absent and not represented T. Moene, alternate for M. van Waveren P present and not voting RP represented by previous member non-voting attendees: E Excused A. Donev, alternate for D. Nagle Q Resigned R. Maine, alternate for V. Snyder ** missed 2 of last 3 meetings/votes M. North, alternate for K. Hirchert *** lost membership J. Reid, WG5 convener M. Cohen, WG5 delegate UK S. Morgan, WG5 delegate UK D. Muxworthy, WG5 delegate UK L. Schonfelder, WG5 delegate UK M. Takata, WG5 delegate Japan J. Wagener, former J3 member Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 164 13 Majority 7 Quorum 5 Total Membership at end of Meeting 164 13 Total Members Attended or Represented at 164 12 Total Attendees at Meeting 164 22 membership changes since last meeting: M. Ingrassia replaced L. Meadows as principal member from Sun. L. Meadows appointed alternate to M. Ingrassia. Rose-Hulman (M. North) membership terminated. M. North appointed alternate to K. Hirchert. ********************************************************************** Appendix F: Membership Roster The Membership Roster is not reproduced here. The current Membership Roster may be found in ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/03-001.html and ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/03-001.txt