To: J3 J3/10-107r1 From: Stan Whitlock Subject: Comment GB-3 Delete arithmetic IF Date: 2010 February 15 References: WG5/N1802, WG5/N1803, J3/09-007r3, J3/10-107 DISCUSSION FCD comment GB-3 requested that the arithmetic IF statement be deleted from F2008. WG5 agreed that it should not be deleted but should be prohibited. 10-107 pointed out that these edits should also be made: 8.2.4: Define the meaning as that of the equivalent IF construct. 1.7.1: Correct the words that refer to vertical format control. [4:39] "arithmetic IF statement," should be in tiny font. EDITS [4:39] In 1.3.18, set "arithmetic IF statement," in tiny font. [25:1] In 1.7.1p1, change "five" to "six" . [187:4+] Append the following sentence to 8.2.4p1: "The value of the numeric expression shall not be a NaN." .