MINUTES OF MEETING 125 X3J3 FORTRAN May 10-14, 1993 Urbana, IL X3J3/Meeting 125 Table Of Contents 1 Agenda 1 2 Opening Business 2 2.1 Meeting Objectives & Chair's Report 2 2.2 Adoption of the Final Agenda 2 2.3 X3/OMC (SPARC) Report 2 2.4 ISO Report 2 2.5 Membership/Attendance Report 2 2.6 Approval of Meeting 124 Minutes 2 2.7 Review of the Action Items from Meeting 124 3 2.8 Comments from the Membership 3 3 Committee Action Items 4 3.1 Discussion of Implementation Subgroup 4 3.2 Interpretations 4 3.3 Object Oriented Presentation 4 3.4 X3H5 Fortran 90 Binding Discussion 4 3.5 Interpretations Processing -- May 12 6 3.5.1 PROC 6 3.5.2 CIO 6 3.5.3 DATA 6 3.5.4 GEN 7 3.6 Interpretations Processing -- May 13 7 3.6.1 GEN 7 3.6.2 CIO 7 3.6.3 GEN -- session 2 8 3.6.4 DATA 8 3.7 Discussion of Implementation Subgroup 8 3.8 Parallel Subgroup Report 8 3.9 JOR Subgroup Report 8 3.10 Treasurer's Report 11 3.11 Edit Subgroup Report 11 3.12 JOR Subgroup Report -- session 2 11 3.13 OOF Subgroup Report 12 3.14 Edit Subgroup 12 3.15 Interpretations Processing -- May 14 12 3.15.1 PROC 12 3.15.2 DATA 12 3.15.3 CIO 13 3.15.4 Wrapup 13 3.16 JOR Subgroup 13 3.17 Parallel Subgroup 13 3.18 Edit Subgroup 13 4 Closing Business 13 4.0 Interpretations Summary 13 4.1 Membership Report 14 4.2 Future Meetings 14 4.3 Agenda of Meeting 126 14 4.4 Treasurer's Report 14 4.5 Action Items Review 14 4.6 Comments from Members 14 4.7 Adjournment 14 5 Document Lists 14 5.1 Current Standing Documents 14 5.2 1993 Document Register 14 5.3 1993 Documents By Meeting 18 5.3.1 Meeting 124 Documents 18 5.3.2 Meeting 125 Documents 18 6 Committee Organization 19 6.1 Officers 19 6.2 Subgroups 19 7 Future Meetings and Distribution Assignments 19 8 Membership 21 8.1 Meeting Attendance 21 8.2 X3J3 Membership 22 1 Agenda Agenda for X3J3 Meeting 125 Monday, May 10, 1993 8:30 Opening Business J. Wagener Meeting objectives and Chair's report Adopting agenda X3/SPARC report (93-012,93-109) ISO report J.Martin, I. Philips Membership report/Introductions M. Hoffert Approving Meeting 124 minutes (93-125) R. Kelble Review Meeting 124 Action items R. Kelble Comments from members Discussion of Implementation Subgroup (92-241,93-063) Action on Interpretations in Pre-Meeting (93-006r, 93- 111 to 93-114, 93-117) 1:30 Subgroup Meetings Tuesday, May 11, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Meetings 1:30 Object Oriented Presentation T. Lahey 3:30 X3H5 F90 Binding Discussion B. Leasure, J. Steidel 4:30 US Tag Organization Meeting I. Philips Wednesday, May 12, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Processing Subgroup heads 10:00 Technical Subgroup Meetings (/parallel and /OOF) 1:30 Subgroup Meetings Thursday, May 13, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Meetings 1:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing X3J3/Parallel Report J. Steidel JOR Report X3J3/Object Oriented Fortran Report T. Lahey Subgroup Meetings Friday, May 14, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Processing Subgroup heads 10:00 Closing Business M. Hoffert Membership Report Future Meetings Treasurer's Report M. North Next Meeting Agenda Action Items Reviewed Comments from Members Action Items Reviewed 11:00 US Tag Session I. Philips 3:00 Adjournment 2 Opening Business 2.1 Meeting Objectives & Chair's Report 1. Process remaining interpretations 2. Provide X3H5 input on the draft Fortran 90 binding 3. Prepare requirements for WG5 2.2 Adoption of the Final Agenda Discussion Leader: Jerry Wagener Motion: (Lauson/Whitlock) Adopt the agenda as modified. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 2.3 X3/OMC (SPARC) Report Discussion Leader: Jerry Wagener References: 93-012, 93-109, 93-110, 93-128 Note: The liaison for the BSI and the BCS should be Miles Ellis. Wagener: [Reviewed 93-128 from the annual report to the OMC presentation. Jerry had recommended that the ISO processing be done first and that ANSI adopt the resulting ISO document and the OMC agreed. One member suggested that the interpretations be contained in an annex and that all 006 items should contain an edit which in the case of an interpretation would enter the interpretation into that annex.] Weaver: We should propose a format for the ISO document to WG5 at the July meeting. Martin: John Reid has already sent the 006 to Geneva in order to get their reading on the format. Hirchert: I have a fax from John Reid containing his response from ISO. I will have it copied and put on the table. Rolison: Would it be possible to have an updated copy of the standard containing all of the edits passed thus far. Wagener: I have already asked /Edit to look into this to see if a document could be produced for the July meetings. Weaver: The ISO document should contain change pages to the standard. 2.4 ISO Report Discussion Leader: Jeanne Martin There will be papers on the table regarding defect processing and the SC22 procedures for handling defect reports. The N865 ballot closed on March 12. Two items failed the country vote. If we want them published with this batch, we should be prepare to convince WG5 to do so at the July meeting. The Informal WG5 Ballot on ISO Varying String Issues closes on May 17. The ad hoc committee on character handling met and a report of that meeting will be included in a future WG5 distribution. The Guidelines for Writing Bindings to Fortran 90 document being prepared by the UK will be included in the next WG5 distribution. 2.5 Membership/Attendance Report Discussion Leader: Maureen Hoffert There are currently 30 members, 24 of whom are present or represented. Four additional members will be in jeopardy of losing their membership if they don't attend this meeting. 2.6 Approval of Meeting 124 Minutes Discussion Leader: Rich Kelble Reference: 93-125 Motion: (Kelble/Whitlock) Approve the minutes of meeting 124 as modified by 93-125. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 2.7 Review of the Action Items from Meeting 124 Reference: Minutes if meeting 124 1. Andrew Tait: Make rules about the use of page and line numbers in 006. At meeting 124, a straw vote on whether they should appear was (21-0-3), so the rules should include the form and location of page and line numbers in 006. Status: Pending -- Andrew has ruled that the use of page and line numbers is acceptable. However, no rules have been established on the form and location of page and line numbers. 2. Andrew Tait: Determine a method of identifying new items in 006 #0000 for subsequent ballots. Status: Closed -- The edits will be batched into a new item on a meeting by meeting basis. 3. Jerry Wagener discuss with Walt Brainerd: When we get the 006 items back from the WG5 ballot, the edits contained in the items which passed should be put in document order to help ensure that there are no collisions between them. Status: Closed -- Both Jerry and Richard Maine did this individually and /edit will be reviewing this during their subgroup time. 4. Jerry Wagener discuss with Andrew Tait: A subgroup field should be added to the 006 items. Status: Pending -- Jerry had recommended to Andrew that this not be done, but no ruling has been made. 5. Andrew Tait: Provide a ruling on the format of titles in the 006 items. Status: Closed -- The initial letter in the first word in each title will be capitalized. 2.8 Comments from the Membership Wagener: HPFF has requested Ken Kennedy to write us a letter asking for user defined elementals. Their next meeting is scheduled for January or February next year. Weaver: The chair of the POSIX Fortran 90 binding is currently recommending that the POSIX Fortran 90 binding project be canceled. Whitlock: [Stan started a discussion regarding the appropriateness of some of the recent entries in f90-interp. This discussion lead to the suggestion that we invite the users who seem to have something to say and who local to our meeting locations to our meetings. For our November meeting this would imply 3 speakers.] straw: Are three speakers too many for one meeting? (6-10-6) several members: It was recommended that the users be invited but that the session be held in the evening. Ellis: The BSI has published the Fortran standard. Maine: I gave a talk on Fortran 90 at the SHARE meeting. Philips: What document processing utility will be used for the next standard? answer: Frame with SGML compatibility. 3 Committee Action Items 3.1 Discussion of Implementation Subgroup Discussion Leader: Maureen Hoffert References: 92-241, 93-063 Hoffert: Membership in this subgroup will be open to all. It is an implementation not implementors subgroup. It will consider implementation issues as they relate to: (1) future additions to Fortran 90, (2) integration of Fortran 90 and Fortran 77 extensions, and (3) proposal of new features to Fortran 90. Motion: (Shepherd/Lahey) Adopt 93-241. Hendrickson: How will this group find time to operate? Shepherd: If a number of people wish to participate in both this group and one of the other subgroups, the meetings could be held in the evenings or over lunch. straw: Are you in favor of this motion? (12-5-8) Move to table: (Leonard/Ellis) Action: Tabled till Thursday by a vote of (18-1) 3.2 Interpretations Discussion Leader: Jerry Wagener Wagener: There are 19 interpretations left over from the last meeting, 8 to reconsider from our ballot, 5 to reconsider from the WG5 ballot, and 93-116,118,121,123. straw: We should not automatically pick up interpretations requests from f90-interp? (17- 0-2) [Note that this is reaffirming 93-013.] 3.3 Object Oriented Presentation Presenter: Ralph E. Johnson Reference: 93-141 3.4 X3H5 Fortran 90 Binding Discussion Discussion Leader: Rich Bleikamp Presenter: Bruce Leasure References: X3H5/93-SDA revision 1, Parallel Extensions for Fortran (April 2). Scribe: David Phillimore. Leasure: X3H5 took 4 parts of parallel model and produced 3 forms of block structured constructs with implicit synchronization. a) Parallel construct. (fork/join and data allocation) b) Grouping construct. (synchronized work) c) Worksharing construct. (shared work among members of team) (then explanation of example code.) Shorthand forms exist. Explicit synchronization can be done by (a) critical sections (b) synchronization statements (overloaded on type of lock) X3H5 will be useful because something similar, (different spellings) already on most (all?) shared memory machines. 3rd party vendors would benefit from standard, would probably be first to use it. APR & Kuck: ship both X3H5-like and HPFF processors. Data distribution of HPFF goes with control flow parallelism of X3H5. Small amount of overlap. Modules and Common: Start of a parallel construct often requires some private data (own variables?). In complex program, e.g., parallel libraries need own variable with respect to point of parallel execution. May want a single copy sometimes. Need attribute for programmer to describe that a process should get its own storage area for Common/Module data, i.e., relocatable Common. Somewhat similar to Task Common on Cray. Binding: is being rewritten from thick F77- flavor binding to thin F90 binding. Comments from Parallel subgroup on mark. 1st shot at thin binding may be ready be X3J3 Belgium meeting. November is target for completion. Directive binding is like F77 Appendix (not part of standard, but advice) Bleikamp: Please elaborate on X3H5 v HPFF. Leasure: (references to earlier remarks). HPFF (colon notation plus forall) to express parallelism doesn't meet all cases (e.g., some SPEC benchmarks). where larger granularity required. Data parallel and Control flow parallelism are compatible. Leonard: Please elaborate on X3H5 v Posix Threads. Leasure: Another implementation of fork/join/synchronization. A C binding exists. Good implementation layer - have ported X3H5 like system on top of Posix threads, existence was convenient. It provides shareable data & uniform address space. Probably too low level for most programmers. Leonard: Are there conflicts? Leasure: No. Would encourage customers to provide Posix threads, - makes port easier. Hoffert: ISO recommends F90 bindings via modules. Leasure: X3H5 binding activated by USE X3H5. Would like to create new statements though. Hoffert: Is there much overhead on a serial machine? Leasure: No, can be done. May allocate extra storage. Weaver: F90 intrinsics RANDOM, RANDOM SEED have side effects, what happens in parallel. Would like repeatable programs. Leasure: RANDOM just one example. SUM is same - may sum elements in different (local) order. Parallel DO does not specify the order of iterations. Roundoff error may affect result. Implementations often have two modes - one with sequence iterator which runs slower, but guarantees order. Similarly for random number generators. Leonard: May want same seed in each processor. Is that possible? Can user control whether a side- effect is shared or private? Leasure: No, can't do. Parallel/Shared/Private is attribute of data at parallel sequence point. Need primitive which is 'independent in parallel code'. Hoffert: HPFF has pure functions - free of side- effects. Useful? Leasure: X3H5 doesn't worry about side-effects. There are basic rules, e.g., two process can't modify same thing at same time which programmers have to follow. Side effects not special. Wagener: Advantage of Group construct is synchronization may be avoided by NOWAIT. But last processor still has to finish. Is this sufficient (and only) reason for the construct? Leasure: Yes, only advantage is to reduce overhead. Assumption is that synchronization is expensive. Whitlock: Does synchronization occur only at end of Worksharing construct? Leasure: Three places. End of Parallel construct, end of Worksharing construct, end of Group construct. Weaver: Is each statement in a Worksharing construct independent? Leasure: No, they are independent groups of statements, e.g., distinct Parallel Dos can't use arbitrary globals. Weaver: Does Parallel Section still exist? Leasure: Yes, like Parallel case. Just not in example. Mattoon/Leasure: Discussion of details in example... Levine: It seems Group could be done, with Parallel loops and nested parallel sections. Leasure: Will discuss afterwards. Bleikamp: 3 Straw votes. straw: Should X3H5 avoid all examples which could be done more simply in Fortran 90? (5-12-8) straw: Are you in favor of parallel scoping along the lines that X3H5 has introduced? (9-7-9) straw: Are you in favor of different instantiations of modules and common? (3-10-12) 3.5 Interpretations Processing -- May 12 Wagener: Are there any objections to continuing the practice started at the last meeting of using a majority vote to move an interpretation to the letter ballot? Hearing none, the practice will stand. 3.5.1 PROC 93-146 (93-006.000124): Motion: (Shepherd/Hirchert) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 93-147 (93-006.000126): Motion: (Shepherd/Hirchert) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 93-148 (93-006.000127): Motion: (Shepherd/Hirchert) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Withdrawn for revision. straw: Is an edit needed here? (10-9-2) straw: If there is an edit, would you vote against this edit? (1-18-2) 93-149 (93-006.000128): Motion: (Shepherd/Hirchert) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed as amended by a vote of (17-1). 93-006.000090: Motion: (Shepherd/Hirchert) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 93-152 (93-006.000049): straw: Is this an appropriate new edit for item 49? (6-6-11) 3.5.2 CIO 93-118r1 (93-006.000131): Motion: (Bleikamp/Leonard) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed as amended by unanimous consent. 3.5.3 DATA 93-112 (93-006.000076): Motion: (Martin/Rolison) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed as amended by a vote of (15-6). 93-113 (93-006.000077): Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by a vote of (18-1). 93-138 (93-006.000100): straw: Would you prefer that the edit read rank, shape, rank and shape, or undecided? (1-3-11-4) Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed by a vote of (11-8). 93-135 (93-006.000027): Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed by a vote of (15-3). 93-136 (93-006.000087): Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as proposed. straw: do you think that the redundant text in edit 3 should be deleted instead of fixing it? (12-5-5) straw: Should the constraint be deleted instead of modified? (7-10-5) Action: Passed as amended by a vote of (18-2) 93-137 (93-006.000091): Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Withdrawn. 93-139 (93-006.000125): Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed as amended by a vote of (17-1). 93-153 (93-006.000111): Motion: (Martin/Rolison) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 93-150 (93-006.various): Motion: (Martin/Lindhorst) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 3.5.4 GEN 93-132 (93-006.000001): Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Withdrawn. 3.6 Interpretations Processing -- May 13 3.6.1 GEN 93-132r1 (93-006.000001): Motion: (Weaver/Hendrickson) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by a vote of (18-4). 93-134 (93-006.000028): Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed as amended by unanimous consent. 93-144 (93-006.000096): Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed as amended by unanimous consent. 93-145 (93-006.000101):\ Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Withdrawn. 93-151 (93-006.000047): Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed as amended by unanimous consent. 3.6.2 CIO 93-165 (93-006.000098): Motion: (Bleikamp/Leonard) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Withdrawn. 3.6.3 GEN -- session 2 93-145r1 (93-006.000101): Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed as amended by a vote of (14-1). 93-179 (93-006.000140): Motion: (Hendrickson/Terpstra) Adopt this item as proposed. Shepherd: I would like to invoke the two-week rule as this paper was just distributed less than 3 hours ago. Wagener: I rule that the two-week rule does not apply in this instance as this paper is based on the discussion of 93-134 from earlier today. Action: Withdrawn. 3.6.4 DATA 93-137r (93-006.000091): Motion: (Martin/Rolison) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Passed by a vote of (13-4). 3.7 Discussion of Implementation Subgroup Discussion Leader: Maureen Hoffert References: 92-241r1, 93-063 Note: This is a continuation of the discussion of the motion to adopt 92-241, which has been replaced by 92-241r1, that was tabled on Monday. Bierman: I call the question. [Note that this was after some discussion.] Action: Question called by a vote of (15-0). Action: Passed by a vote of (14-6). 3.8 Parallel Subgroup Report Discussion Leader: Rich Bleikamp Bleikamp: While meeting with /Parallel earlier this week, Bruce Leasure agreed with and accepted the recommendations of the subgroup. Leonard: X3J3 should submit a comment on the X3H5 model document during their public comment. straw: Do you support X3J3 submitting such a comment? (6-1-15) Action: Keith Bierman and Bill Leonard will prepare the comment. 3.9 JOR Subgroup Report Discussion Leader: Stan Whitlock References: 93-004r,142,161-164,166-173 Scribe: Ivor Philips Stan Whitlock gave an overview of the procedures with respect to X3J3/004r. It was emphasized that all new items should be sent to Len Moss by May 20, 1993 if they were to be included in the version of 004 that will be sent to WG5 for the July meeting. It will not be done by the JOR subcommittee. Item 1 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.001 to status 6 (archival). Action: Passed by unanimous consent. Item 2 No motion. Item 3 straw: Do you wish to move 93-004r.003 to status 3 (forward to WG5), change it to status 6 (archival), or are you undecided? (8-4-12) No motion Item 4 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.004 to status 3a (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 95). Tom Lahey noted that existing implementations of HPF give an excellent justification. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. Item 5 straw: Do you wish to move 93-004r.005 to status 3 (forward to WG5), change it to status 6 (archival 6), or are you undecided? (2-19-2) Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.005 to status 6 (archival). Hendrickson: It was taken out for a good reason, vendors can put it in. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. Items 6-9 straw: Are you in favor of moving 93- 004r.006,007,008,009 to status 6 (archival)? (18-3-3) Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.006 to status 6 (archival). Action: Passed by a vote of (23-1). Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.007 to status 6 (archival). Action: Passed by unanimous consent. Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.008 to status 6 (archival). Action: Passed by a vote of (23-1). Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.009 to status 6 (archival). Action: Passed by unanimous consent. Item 10 straw: Do you wish to move 93-004r.010 to status 3 (forward to WG5), change it to status 6 (archival), or are you undecided? (13-3-8) Motion: (Whitlock/Ellis) Move 93-004r.010 to status 3b (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 2000). Lahey: There are no Fortran compilers for this. There is no user demand. Shepherd: I have used a language that has this feature. I don't use it often but when I do its very convenient. Hirchert: It is most valuable in conjunction with item 11. With respect to editorial issues, it would be easy to do for 95. I would accept doing it for 2000. Action: Failed by a vote of (15-6). Item 11 straw: Do you wish to move 93-004r.011 to status 3 (forward to WG5), change it to status 6 (archival), or are you undecided? (4-12-6) Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.011 to status 6 (archival). Hirchert: Used for mathematical software. Partially bound arguments. Action: Passed by a vote of (19-5). Item 12 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.012 to status 3b (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 2000). Katz: Would change some Air Force opposition to Fortran 90. Ellis: Important to do this in 1995. straw: Do you wish to move 93-004r.012 to a status of 3a (Fortran 95 requirement), 3b (Fortran 2000 requirement), or are you undecided? (9-13-1) Leonard: The C++ committee has been working for 2 years on this issue --- it is not yet finished. We can't do better. If attempted, we will be unable to complete in 1995 and waste effort. Better to do it in 2000. Shepherd: Not in favor of this generality. Would like exception handling restricted to call site, as it will help optimization. Ellis: Prefer recommending to WG5 that it be considered for Fortran 95 and if it can't be done defer it to 2000. Hirchert: There is no way it can be done right by 1995. It would be silly for X3J3 to recommend it to WG5 and then reported later that it can't do it. Action: Passed by a vote of (20-2). Item 13 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.013 to status 3a (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 95). Lahey: Came up in OOF. OOF will be able to initialize entities. Make sure there is no conflict downstream. Leonard: Favors problem being fixed that it attempts to fix, but prefers a constructor/destructor method. Mistake to do both. Add to object oriented requirement. Otherwise may be a conflict. Bierman: Users can take optional action when instantiating an object. Can implement just part of object oriented. Don't propose a specific solution. Ellis: It will certainly be brought up by several WG5 members. Bierman: Having a compiler always initializing a pointer is expensive. straw: Do you wish to forward 93-004r.013 to WG5 (status 3), change it to status archival (status 6), or are you undecided? (7-8-10) Action: Withdrawn. Item 14 straw: Do you wish to move 93-004r.014 to status 3 (forward to WG5), change it to status 6 (archival), or are you undecided? (9-3-8) Action: None -- it keeps the current status. Item 15 Bierman: Very convenient. ANSI C put it into language. Should be a separate standard. Lahey: Implemented but not used. Bierman: C version heavily used for Fortran. Martin: HPF would like this. Allows directives for different processes Leonard: HPF would be satisfied by a separate standard. Shepherd: Important to have. Urgent, because otherwise there will be more and more use of CPP, which is not addressed to Fortran. Kelble: WG5 could do it as a separate standard. Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.015 to status 3b (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 2000). Action: Failed by a vote of (12-11). Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.015 to status 3a (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 95). Action: Passed by a vote of (18-6). Item 16 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.016 to status 3b (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 2000). Bierman: Is it not in POSIX and done well? Lahey: I would like to see it in 95 Leonard: Don't want to add something that would conflict with POSIX. Requirement should state that interoperability with POSIX is necessary. Mattoon: Will refer it to POSIX. Action: Failed by a vote of (11-12). Shepherd: Fix AIX reference. Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.015 to status 3a (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 95). Action: Passed by a vote of (21-1). Item 17 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.017 to status 3b (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 2000). Katz: Number one on DOD list Shepherd: Contradictory justification. Move status to 2 to refine. Warnock: One of the two things needed in Fortran 90. Action: Passed by a vote of (22-2). Item 18 Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.018 to status 3a (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 95). Action: Failed by a vote of (14-8). Motion: (Whitlock/Philips) Move 93-004r.018 to status 3b (forward to WG5 as a requirement for Fortran 2000). Action: Passed by a vote of (17-4). 3.10 Treasurer's Report Discussion Leader: Mallory North Motion: (North/Katz) Exempt Jim Himer and Ted Terpstra from the meeting fee. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 3.11 Edit Subgroup Report Discussion Leader: Richard Maine An updated 008 (Editorial Considerations for 9x Draft Revision) will be available on Friday. 93-178 is the current sorted list of approved edits. A version of the standard containing the approved edits will be available on the FTP server hopefully within the next few weeks. 3.12 JOR Subgroup Report -- session 2 Discussion Leader: Stan Whitlock Scribe: Ivor Philips Whitlock asked that the following papers proposed for inclusion in the JOR be briefly introduced by the proposer. X3J3/93-167 Nested Where Desired by HPF. Useful since their parallelism only from arrays, not from loops. X3J3/93-168 "User Defined Intrinsic Functions" Title in quotes because it may be modified. Most user functions can be the ordinary external functions. However, some functions must be known to the compiler such as a function the compiler calls to get the number of processors to define an array dimension. X3J3/93-169 Pure User Functions and Subroutines. Useful in FORALL since it is specified by the user that the function or subroutine has no side-effects. This addresses the same issues (but in a different way) as paper 163 - User defined elementals. X3J3/93-170 Packaging implementor specific intrinsics in MODULEs Provides a way to control name space pollution while still making available intrinsics from vendors or other standard bodies. Would provide an answer to interpretation 122 X3J3/93-171 Directives No explanation needed. X3J3/93-120 Object Oriented Fortran OOF Kurt has provided an email group for those interested in OOF. This topic was discussed in more detail in the OOF report. X3J3/93-164 Variant Derived Types (non-tag version) Suggest keyword be spelled UNION since many vendors already have identical or similar UNION construct. Non-tag version would have less overhead. In many useful situations, tag may not be known at compile time. In fact, the tag may not be a part of the data, but merely implied by which routine processes the data. While some believe that OOF and classes with inheritance could solve this problem, it is not clear that this entirely replaces UNION functionality. Can you union more than two objects--example shows only two? Only one equivalence is shown because there is currently no nesting of derived types. But you can get same effect by creating a derived type for the data you wish equivalenced. I/O for these variant derived types could be "messy." Perhaps I/O for those fields would be prohibited. Some feeling is that this is reintroducing the idea of equivalence that people want to get away from. Garbage collection may be impossible with this proposal if pointers are being equivalenced. But garbage collection is difficult in Fortran in general. 3.13 OOF Subgroup Report Discussion Leader: Tom Lahey References: 93-120, 174. An updated version of 93-120 will be distributed to the email mailing list after the meeting. 3.14 Edit Subgroup Discussion Leader: Richard Maine Philips: We should remember the 008 in planning the 1995 revision. straw: Are you in favor of moving Annex C to footnotes? (23-0-2) 3.15 Interpretations Processing -- May 14 3.15.1 PROC 93-180 (93-006.000083): Motion: (Shepherd/Ellis) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed by a vote of (19-1). 3.15.2 DATA 93-174 (93-006.000081): Motion: (Martin/Rolison) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Withdrawn. 93-181 (93-006.000140): straw: Should this be an 006 item? (13-2-3) straw: Should this include an edit to make it clearer? (8-7-5) Motion: (Martin/Hendrickson) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Withdrawn. 93-183 (93-006.000139): Motion: (Martin/Phillimore) Adopt this item as proposed. Action: Withdrawn. 3.15.3 CIO 93-118r2 (93-006.000131): Motion: (Bleikamp/Leonard) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 93-165 (93-006.000098): Motion: (Bleikamp/Leonard) Adopt this item as modified. Action: Passed as amended by unanimous consent. 3.15.4 Wrapup Motion: (Lahey/Ellis) Remove item 91 (93-137r) from the ballot. Action: Passed by a vote of (13-7). 3.16 JOR Subgroup Motion: (Whitlock/Leonard) Forward the revised 004 to WG5 as X3J3's input on the proposed requirements of the next Fortran standards. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 3.17 Parallel Subgroup Motion: (Leonard/Lauson) That the chair be directed to send the letter contained in 93-184 to Bob Follett. Leonard: I recommend that a sentence be added to apologize for not having brought this issue up earlier. Wagener: I will add text to indicate that it will be difficult to carry out our liaison duties unless we review the model and the bindings together. Action: Passed by unanimous consent. 3.18 Edit Subgroup straw: Should the examples be made informative rather than normative (they will remain integrated in the document)? (6-8-7) 4 Closing Business 4.0 Interpretations Summary 93-006 Item reference mover/seconder disposition 1 93-132r1 Weaver/Hendrickson 18-4, passed 27 93-135 Martin/Lindhorst 15-3, passed 28 93-134 Hendrickson/Terpstra unanimous consent 47 93-151 Hendrickson/Terpstra unanimous consent 76 93-112 Martin/Rolison 15-6, passed 77 93-113 Martin/Lindhorst 18-1, passed 81 93-174 Martin/Rolison withdrawn 83 93-180 Shepherd/Ellis 19-1, passed 87 93-136 Martin/Lindhorst 18-2, passed 90 93-006.000090 Shepherd/Hirchert unanimous consent 91 93-137 Martin/Lindhorst withdrawn 96 93-144 Hendrickson/Terpstra unanimous consent 98 93-165 Bleikamp/Leonard unanimous consent 100 93-138 Martin/Lindhorst) 11-8, passed 101 93-145r1 Hendrickson/Terpstra 14-1, passed 111 93-153 Martin/Rolison unanimous consent 124 93-146 Shepherd/Hirchert unanimous consent 125 93-139 Martin/Lindhorst 17-1, passed 126 93-147 Shepherd/Hirchert unanimous consent 127 93-148 Shepherd/Hirchert withdrawn 128 93-149 Shepherd/Hirchert 17-1, passed 131 93-118r2 Bleikamp/Leonard unanimous consent 139 93-183 Martin/Philimore withdrawn 140 93-181 Martin/Hendrickson withdrawn 4.1 Membership Report Discussion Leader: Maureen Hoffert At this meeting 24 of our 30 members were either present of represented. Six members are in jeopardy of losing their membership (Walt Brainerd, Alex Marusak, Geoff Millard, Linda O'Gara, Ivor Philips, and Andrew Tait). 4.2 Future Meetings See section 7 of these minutes. 4.3 Agenda of Meeting 126 Discussion: An initial discussion of the agenda was held. All further suggestions should be sent to Maureen. 4.4 Treasurer's Report The treasurer's report will be available at the next meeting. 4.5 Action Items Review 1. Andrew Tait: Make rules about the use of page and line numbers in 006. At meeting 124, a straw vote on whether they should appear was (21-0-3), so the rules should include the form and location of page and line numbers in 006. Status: Pending -- Andrew has ruled that the use of page and line numbers is acceptable. However, no rules have been established on the form and location of page and line numbers. 2. Jerry Wagener discuss with Andrew Tait: A subgroup field should be added to the 006 items. Status: Pending -- Jerry had recommended to Andrew that this not be done, but no ruling has been made. 3. Andrew Tait:: Make a ruling on the format of standard citations in the 006. Currently, some are enclosed in quotation marks and some are indented. Status: New 4.6 Comments from Members Wagener: We need a volunteer to take the position of secretary. If you are interested, please contact me. Wagener: I would like to give my thanks to Kurt for hosting this meeting. 4.7 Adjournment 5 Document Lists 5.1 Current Standing Documents The current standing documents of this committee are 93- 000 through 93-010. 5.2 1993 Document Register Item Number Submitter/Title X3J3/93-000 Register of Documents X3J3/93-001 X3J3/93-002 X3J3/93-003 X3J3 Processes and Procedures X3J3/93-004r1 Moss/Journal of Development X3J3/93-005 X3J3 Resolutions and Responses to WG5 Resolutions X3J3/93-006 Tait/Defect Report X3J3/93-007 Draft Revision to Fortran 90 X3J3/93-008r3ED/Editorial Considerations for 9X Draft Revision X3J3/93-009 X3J3/93-010 X3J3/93-011 Shepherd/RFI: PARAMETER and SAVE statements X3J3/93-012 Wagener/Index to X3 Documents X3J3/93-013 Wagener/Interpretation Procedures X3J3/93-014 Wagener/X3J3 Organization X3J3/93-015r1 Wagener/S20 (93-006) Status Summary X3J3/93-015 Wagener/S20 (93-006) Status Summary X3J3/93-016 Wagener/Letter Ballot on S20.123 Items X3J3/93-017 Wagener/Results of S20.123 Letter Ballot X3J3/93-018 Reid/Comments on S20.123 X3J3/93-019 Moss/Report on JOD Meeting X3J3/93-020r1 Wagener/X3J3 Letter Ballot Record X3J3/93-020 Wagener/X3J3 Letter Ballot Record X3J3/93-021 Wagener/Approval of Project 966-I X3J3/93-022 Wagener/X3T2 Reply to X3J3 Review of CLID X3J3/93-023 O'Gara/How to Number Documents X3J3/93-024 O'Gara/Response to RFI #91 X3J3/93-025 Moss/RFI: Intrinsic Procedures in Modules X3J3/93-026r1 Moss/Fortran Requirements Procedures X3J3/93-026 Moss/Fortran Requirements Procedures X3J3/93-027 Shepherd/RFI: Initialization Procedures X3J3/93-028 Shepherd/RFI: Multiple USE of Modules X3J3/93-029 Shepherd/RFI: Multiple Accessible Defined Assign't X3J3/93-030r1 Shepherd/RFI: USE and Host Association X3J3/93-030 Shepherd/RFI: USE and Host Association X3J3/93-031 Hoffert/Fortran Requirements Collection Process X3J3/93-032r1 Martin/Proposed response to S20.89 X3J3/93-032 Martin/Proposed response to S20.89 X3J3/93-033 Martin/Response to Cross-Language Questionnaire X3J3/93-034 Steidel/Draft Response to S20.92 X3J3/93-035 Steidel/Draft Response to S20.100 X3J3/93-036 Tait/JIS Defects X3J3/93-037 Rolison/RFI: Is a module a global entity X3J3/93-038 Rolison/RFI: Statement execution order and expr.eval X3J3/93-050 Hirchert/X3J3/Fortran 90 Interp. Email Aliases X3J3/93-051 Wagener/Defect Management X3J3/93-052 Wagener/Letter from X3T2 re. LIA X3J3/93-053 Wagener/Note from Bruce Martin re. Paul Libassi X3J3/93-054 Wagener/Comment from Bruce martin on POSIX revision X3J3/93-055 Wagener/X3 call for candidates for X3J3 vice chair X3J3/93-056 Wagener/Letter from John Ber re. CS1 special issue on Fortran X3J3/93-057 Wagener/From Van Snyder re. suggestions for 9X X3J3/93-058 Shepherd/RFI: Generic Names X3J3/93-059 Shepherd/RFI: END Statements X3J3/93-060 Martin/Letter from Jeanne Martin on Cont. to Cross Lang. X3J3/93-061 Martin/International Activity Report to 124th Meeting X3J3/93-062 Lahey/Letter to Tom Lahey from Gary Leavens X3J3/93-063 Lahey/Fortran Implementors and the Std. Committee X3J3/93-064 Lahey/Scribe notes from Meeting 123 on X3J3 Organ. X3J3/93-065 Lahey/Article by P. Wegner on Concepts and Paradigms in OOP X3J3/93-066 Lahey/Article by G. Leavens on Intro. to Literature on OOD X3J3/93-067 Bierman/LIA: a report for X3J3 X3J3/93-068 Nebesh/Viewgraphs from OO presentation X3J3/93-069 Philips/Requirements for Future Evolution of Fortran X3J3/93-070 Steidel/RFI: Change array constructor constraint to prose X3J3/93-071 Bleikamp/CIO Ballot Item Response X3J3/93-072 Moss/Appendix F Bit Requirement X3J3/93-073 Martin/Proposed combination of 93-006, items 12 & 23 X3J3/93-074 Martin/Revised response to 93-006, item 114 X3J3/93-075 Martin/Proposed response to 93-006, item 93 X3J3/93-076 Martin/Proposed response to 93-006, item 108 X3J3/93-077 PROC/Proposed response to JIS (93-036, item 3) X3J3/93-078 PROC/Additional edit for 93-006, item 0, from JIS,93-036,1 X3J3/93-079r1 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 105 X3J3/93-079 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 105 X3J3/93-080 Martin/Revised response to 93-006, item 113 X3J3/93-081 Kelble/Additional Edits for 006.000 X3J3/93-082 PROC/Proposed change to X3J3/93-006, item 33 X3J3/93-083 EDIT/Common Block names and local names X3J3/93-084 Steidel/Response to X3J3/93-070 X3J3/93-085 Steidel/Response to X3J3/93-006, item 81 X3J3/93-086 GEN/revisions of 93-006, item 97 X3J3/93-087 PROC/response to John Reid's comment on 006, item 71 X3J3/93-088 GEN/Draft Response to X3J3/93-27, RFI: Init. expr. X3J3/93-089 LIA/Letter to X3T2 Regarding LIA X3J3/93-090 EDIT/Revision of 93-006, item 73 X3J3/93-091 PROC/Proposed 93-006, item 106 X3J3/93-092 PROC/Proposed 93-006, item 126 X3J3/93-093 O'Gara/Response to X3J3/93-006, item 111 X3J3/93-094 GEN/Response to 93-059, redefinition of 'program unit' X3J3/93-095 Steidel/Defect 006, item 125, Copy-in, copy- out of target args X3J3/93-096 Shepherd/Proposed response to 006, item 124 X3J3/93-097 Hoffert/Proposed response to 93-037, Is a module a global? X3J3/93-098 PROC/Response to 93-058, RFI Generic names, 006, item 128 X3J3/93-099 DATA/Revised response for X3J3/93-006, item 27 X3J3/93-100 DATA/Response combining 006,30 with response to X3J3/93-070 X3J3/93-101 Steidel/Revised response to X3J3/93-006, item 41 X3J3/93-102 Steidel/Revised response to X3J3/93-006, item 70 X3J3/93-103 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 90 X3J3/93-104 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 82 X3J3/93-105 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 49 X3J3/93-106 Lauson/Modifications to X3J3/93-005, suggestions for hosts X3J3/93-107 PROC/Revised 93-006, item 90 X3J3/93-108 Moss/Slide on Status of Fortran Requirements (old JOD) X3J3/93-109 Wagener/Index to Selected X3 Documents X3J3/93-110 Wagener/X3J3 Annual Report: April 1992 - April 1993 X3J3/93-111 Wagener/Letter Ballot on X3J3/93-006r Items X3J3/93-112 Martin/Proposed response to X3J3/93-006, item 76 X3J3/93-113 Martin/Proposed response to X3J3/93-006, item 77 X3J3/93-114 Wagener/X3J3 Letter Ballot Record X3J3/93-115 Wagener/Status of X3J3/93-006 Items X3J3/93-116 Shepherd/Formatted Input and Kind Type Parameters (See also X3J3/93-118) X3J3/93-117 Martin/Reconsideration of 006 items based on WG5 ballot comments X3J3/93-118 Leonard/Formatted Input and Kind Type Parameters (Proposed answers to X3J3/93-116) X3J3/93-119 Lahey/BIT Data Type email(X3J3.1993-93) X3J3/93-120 Lahey/Object Oriented Fortran, OOF; Requirements with Discussion X3J3/93-121 Wagener/Proposed ANSWER section for item 000122 of X3J3/93-006r X3J3/93-122 MJHanna-Wagener/Termination of POSIX-Fortran 90 Project AKA DRAFT Final Report of the ANS/IEEE 1003.9 (Fortran Bindings) Working Group Emailed as (X3J3.1993-114) X3J3/93-123 Shepherd/Issues to reconsider about 93-006 #79 -- Emailed as (X3J3.1993-118) X3J3/93-124 Martin/Results on the WG5 Letter Ballot on 006 items approved by X3J3 X3J3/93-125 Kelble/Approval of the Minutes of Meeting 124 X3J3/93-126 Ellis /IT STANDARDIZATION have we got it wrong? X3J3/93-127 Reid-Brannon/Technical Corrigendum X3J3/93-128 Wagener/Use subsets of 006 for the four defect management dispositions X3J3/93-129 Hoffert/Implementation Subgroup X3J3/93-130 Synder-Lahey/SYSTEM_CLOCK Intrinsic X3J3/93-131 Lahey/Definition of TOKEN as used in section 3.3.1 X3J3/93-132 Weaver/Revision of Interpretation number 1 X3J3/93-133 Moss/How to Submit a Fortran Requirement X3J3/93-134 Weaver/Revision of Interpretation number 28 X3J3/93-135 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 27 X3J3/93-136 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 87 X3J3/93-137 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 91 X3J3/93-138 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 100 X3J3/93-139 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 125 X3J3/93-140 J. Martin-Reid/Message for X3J3 re ISO Technical Corrigendum X3J3/93-141 Terpstra - Johnson/OOF - Making your favorite language object-oriented X3J3/93-142 Whitlock/JOR Processing X3J3/93-143 Weaver/Revision of interpretation 97 X3J3/93-144 Weaver/Revision of interpretation 96 X3J3/93-145 Weaver/Revision of interpretation 101 X3J3/93-146 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 124 X3J3/93-147 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 126 X3J3/93-148 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 127 X3J3/93-149 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 128 X3J3/93-150 J. Martin/Edits of 006 Items X3J3/93-151 Weaver/Automatic data objects in initialization expression interpretation 47 X3J3/93-152 Shepherd/New Edits for Interpretation 49 X3J3/93-153 Rolison/Revised response for item 111 X3J3/93-154 Lahey/Copyright permission to distribute "Concepts and Paradigms of Object-Oriented Programming" X3J3/93-155 Weaver/Parameter, Namelist, and Implicit Typing Interpretation 114 X3J3/93-156 Weaver/Intent (IN) conformance X3J3/93-157 Weaver/Scalar-structure-component of data- implied-do X3J3/93-158 Weaver/Array element in data-implied-do X3J3/93-159 Weaver/private accessibility of a module procedure X3J3/93-159r1 X3J3/93-160 Weaver/Intrinsic, External attribute questions X3J3/93-161 Maine/Obsolescence of Fixed Source Form X3J3/93-162 Phillips/IEEE 754 binding to Fortran X3J3/93-163 Lindhorst/User defined elementals X3J3/93-164 Lindhorst/Variant derived types X3J3/93-165 Kelble/New answer for 006 item 98 X3J3/93-166 Phillips/Intrinsic STRING data type X3J3/93-167 Bleikamp/Consider nested WHERE statement X3J3/93-168 Bleikamp/User defined intrinsic functions X3J3/93-169 Bleikamp/Pure User Functions and Subroutines X3J3/93-170 Bleikamp/Packaging implementor specific intrinsics in Modules X3J3/93-171 Bleikamp/Directives X3J3/93-172 Lahey/Object Oriented Features for 1995 X3J3/93-173 Shepherd/Varying String Requirement X3J3/93-174 J. Martin/Revised Response for item 81 X3J3/93-175 Lindhorst/Precedence of Host Association X3J3/93-176 Wagener/Letter to John Hill on Defect Management X3J3/93-177 Weaver/Private in a second module specifying a type definition X3J3/93-178 Maine/Sorted list of approved edits X3J3/93-179 Weaver/Precedence of Host Association X3J3/93-180 Hoffert/Extend generic intrinsic procedures X3J3/93-181 J. Martin/Response to New 006 item from email of May 7 (Yukimasa Yoshida) X3J3/93-182 Himer/Interpretation of paper 93-130 SYSTEM_CLOCK X3J3/93-183 Phillimore/Intrinsic, External attribute questions X3J3/93-184 Wagener/X3H5 Model Document and Fortran 90 Binding X3J3/93-185 Hirchert/PROC subgroup report X3J3/93-186 Shepherd/Tutorial on Host Association Edits Other Papers Distributed: WG5/N871 WG5 DRAFT of the repository of requirements (WG5 SD-5) WG5/N870 Martin/Proposed Form for the Repository of Requirements X3J11.1/92-065 Extending 'C' for Numerical Computing X3J3/92-252 Reproduced copy of John Reid's remarks on S20.029 X3H5/SD-2 Leasure/Revision I Model Document - Parallel Processing Model for High Level Programming Languages 5.3 1993 Documents By Meeting 5.3.1 Meeting 124 Documents The documents for meeting 124 are X3J3/93-000 through X3J3/93-108, WG5/N870, WG5/N871, X3J11.1/92-065, and X3J3/92-252. 5.3.2 Meeting 125 Documents The documents for meeting 125 are X3J3/93-004r, X3J3/93- 008r3, X3J3/93-109 through X3J3/93-186, and X3H5/SD-2. 6 Committee Organization 6.1 Officers Chair J. Wagener Vice Chair M. Hoffert International Rep I. Philips Secretary R. Kelble Librarian D. Mattoon Editor W. Brainerd Maintenance A. Tait Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert 6.2 Subgroups X3J3/F90maint -- F90 defect management, responsible for document 006 A. Tait -- coordinator and editor of document 006 GEN (chap 1-3,7,17) DATA (chap 4-6) CIO (chap 8-10) PROC (chap 11-13) R. Hendrickson (head) H. Katz R. Bleikamp (head) K. Bierman T. Lahey J. Martin R. Kelble M. Ellis A. Marusak L. O'Gara (head) W. Leonard J. Himer T. Terpstra L. Rolison (Steidel) J. Oglesby K. Hirchert (head) R. Weaver G. Steele (Phillimore) M. Hoffert J. Shepherd X3J3/JOR -- Journal of Requirements for 1995, responsible for document 004 D. Mattoon, G. Millard, L. Moss(head), I. Philips, S. Whitlock X3J3/editorial -- prepare the draft standard, responsible for documents 007 and 008 W. Brainerd(head), R. Maine, H. Lauson, M. North X3J3/parallel - parallel computing, responsible for coordinating with X3H5 and HPFF K. Bierman, J. Himer, L. O'Gara, G. Steele(D. Phillimore), J. Steidel(head) X3J3/posix -- Posix coordination, especially on the Fortran 90 Posix binding J. Brixius, B. Martin, R. Weaver(head) X3J3/OOF -- Object-Oriented Fortran M. Ellis, M. Hoffert, H. Katz, R. Kelble, T. Lahey(head), B. Leonard, J. Martin, R. Weaver 7 Future Meetings and Distribution Assignments Four Meeting Schedule for 1993: Meeting conventions: - 4 meetings per year - attempt to schedule second full week of month - attempt to schedule meetings back to back with WG5 meetings 126 July 12-16, 1993 - Belgium (Hendrickson) (Following the WG5 Meeting, July 5-9 in Bavaria) pre-meeting distribution deadline: June 7, 1993 2 week deadline: June 28, 1993 pre-meeting distribution: Leonard, Harris post-meeting distribution: Steele, TM 127 Nov. 8-12, 1993 - Albuquerque, NM (Lauson, host) pre-meeting distribution deadline: October 4, 1993 pre-meeting distribution: Mattoon, Railroad post-meeting distribution: Ted Terpstra, DECUS 128 Feb. 7-11, 1994 - Palmdale, CA (Richard Maine, host) pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Philips, Boeing post-meeting distribution: Bleikamp, Convex 129 May 2-6, 1994 - Lake Tahoe (Lahey, host) pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Hirchert, UIUC post-meeting distribution: Kelble, Unisys 130 August 15-19, 1994 - Edinburgh, Scotland (EPC) pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Levine, HP post-meeting distribution: Moss, SLAC 131 Nov. 7-11, 1994 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: North, Rose-Hulman post-meeting distribution: Oglesby, Microsoft 132 Feb., 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Rolison, Cray post-meeting distribution: Weaver, IBM 133 May, 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Whitlock, DEC post-meeting distribution: Marusak, Los Alamos 134 July, 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Bierman, SUN post-meeting distribution: Maine, NASA 135 Nov., 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: post-meeting distribution: Martin: Distributes WG5 Documents Ellis, Hendrickson, Millard: European Based Excused: Himer, Lauson List for Distribution Recipients: pre and post meeting distribution sent to: principals FEW additional others: alternates who attend the meetings regularly active participants in email, such as former members REQUIREMENT: DISTRIBUTION of Pre-Meeting 2 Weeks before meeting (documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1) minutes sent to (required by X3) principals alternates observers, consultants, liaisons REQUIREMENT: DISTRIBUTION 4 Weeks Following Meeting Adjournment (SD-2 4.2.5, 4.3.6) agenda and meeting notice sent to: general mailing list consisting of: principals alternates observers, consultants, liaisons WG5/ISO members general (names of contacts, former members) REQUIREMENT: DISTRIBUTION 4 Weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3) 8 Membership 8.1 Meeting Attendance X3J3 Meeting Attendance X3J3 Principal Members Meeting # 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Location TX NV OX NM MN NH CA IN WA CT FL IL BE Date 01 04 08 12 04 08 11 05 08 11 02 05 07 90 90 90 90 91 91 91 92 92 92 93 93 93 Name Affiliation Bierman, Keith Sun I I I I I V V V V V V V Bleikamp, Rich CONVEX I V I A R R A R V V V V Brainerd, Walt Unicomp V V P V V V A A** Ellis, Miles Oxford V V V A V V V A V V A V Hendrickson, Dick ACSET V V V V V A A** V** V V V V Himer, Jim Esso Canada P V A A V** V A V A** V Hirchert, Kurt Univ. Illinois V V A A V V V V V V V V Hoffert, Maureen HP V V V V V V V V V V V V Katz, Henry DoD V V A A V V V V V V V V Kelble, Rich Unisys I I I A I V V A V A** V V Lahey, Tom Lahey V V V A V V V V V V V V Lauson, Herrick V V V V A V Leonard, Bill Harris V V A A V R A R V A V V Martin, Jeanne Livermore V V V V V V V V V V V V Marusak, Alex Los Alamos V V V V V V A V V A A** R Mattoon, David Assoc. Railroads P V A A V V A V V V V V Maine, Richard NASA P V V V A V Millard, Geoff Edinburgh R V R A A V V A V R A A** Moss, Len SLAC V V A A V V V A V V V A North, Mallory Rose-Hulman Inst V V A V A V V V V V V V O'Gara, Linda Supercomputer Sys V V V V V V V A V V A A** Oglesby, Jose Microsoft I I A A I V R R V A R R Philips, Ivor Boeing V V V V V A V V V A A** V** Rolison, Larry Cray* I I I I I I R R R R R V Steele, Guy Thinking Mach.* A A R R A A R** R R R A R Tait, Andrew Amdahl V V V V V A V V V A V A** Terpstra, Ted DECUS* I I I I I I I A I R V V Wagener, Jerry Amoco V V V V V V V V V V V V Weaver, Dick IBM* V V V V V A R V V V V V Whitlock, Stan DEC A V V V V V V V A V V V V present and voting represented R absent but * institutional represented member A absent and not ** missed 2 of last 3 represented meetings P present but not *** LOST membership voting I institution Total Membership at beginning of Meeting: 30 One over Half: 16 Total Membership at end of Meeting: 30 Total Members Attended or Represented: 25 Total Attendees: 27 Changes since Meeting 124: NONE New Members: NONE Alternates Representing principals at meeting: Greg Lindhorst, Microsoft David Phillimore, Thinking Machines Tony Warnock, Los Alamos Lab Visitors at Meeting: Janice Shepherd, Dick Weaver's alternate David Levine, Maureen Hoffert's alternate Bruce Leasure, Kuck and Associates, chair of X3H5 Ralph Johnson, speaker on Object Oriented Fortran 8.2 X3J3 Membership fax: (214) 497- 278834 4500 - - - - - - - - alternate: John - - - - - - - - alternate: D. Wilson - - - - Presley Smith BSI Fortran Panel PRINCIPAL - - - - - - - - BCS Fortran MEMBERS - - - - - - - - Specialist Gr - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Walter S. - - - - - - - - - - - - Brainerd - - - - Unicomp 235 Mt. Hamilton Richard A. Ave. Hendrickson Los Altos ACSET Keith H. Bierman CA 94022 Ave. Albert SMI Einstein 4 1532 Norman Ave. phone: (415) 949- B-1348-Louvain- San Jose 4052 la-Neuve CA 95125 email: walt@netcom.com Brussels phone: (415) 336- fax: (415) 949- BELGIUM 2648 4058 email: phone: 011 32 10 keith.bierman@en alternate: 470 833 g.sun.com Charles Ritz email: fax: (415) 968- hendrick@acset.b 6396 - - - - - - - - e - - - - - - - - fax: 011 32 10 alternate: - - - - 470 899 Michael Ingrassia T. Miles R. alternate: Karen Ellis Spackman - - - - - - - - Computing - - - - - - - - Teaching Centre - - - - - - - - - - - - Oxford - - - - - - - - University - - - - Richard Bleikamp 59 George Street CONVEX Computer Oxford James T. Himer Corporation OX1 2BH Esso Resources 3000 Waterview ENGLAND Division/Exxon Parkway 339 Woodside Bay P. O. Box 833851 phone: 011 44 S.W. Richardson 865 278800 Calgary TX 75083-3851 email: internet Alberta T2W 3K9 MEllis@vax.ox.ac CANADA phone: (214) 497- .uk 4133 email: janet phone: (403) 237- email: MEllis@uk.ac.ox. 4215 bleikamp@convex. vax email: com fax: 011 44 865 jthimer@iras.uca l Levine Suite 204 fax: (403) 237- P. O. Box 6091 2907 (room 16 - - - - - - - - Incline Village fax: (403) 232- - - - - - - - - NV 89450-6091 5730 - - - - phone: (702) 831- - - - - - - - - Henry Katz 2500 - - - - - - - - 8250 Brattle email: uucp - - - - Road uunet!lahey!tlah Baltimore e Kurt W. Hirchert MD 21208 email: University of tlahe@lahey.com Illinois phone: (410) 859- fax: (702) 831- 152 Computing 6324 8323 Applications email: bitnet Bldg. KATZ@UMBC2.UMBC. - - - - - - - - 605 East EDU - - - - - - - - Springfield fax: (410) 455- - - - - Avenue 3969 Champaign IL 61820 - - - - - - - - Herrick S. - - - - - - - - Lauson phone: (217) 333- - - - - 7711 Euclid Ave. 8093 N.E. email: Richard P. Albuquerque hirchert@ncsa.ui Kelble NM 87110-4803 uc.edu Unisys fax: (217) 244- Corporation phone: (505) 298- 2909 2476 Swedesford 2769 Road email: alternate: P. O. Box 203 lauson@unmvax.cs Murray F. Paoli .unm.edu Freeman PA 19301 alternate: Brian - - - - - - - - phone: (215) 648- Smith - - - - - - - - 4009 - - - - email: - - - - - - - - kelble%trprogb@t - - - - - - - - Maureen Hoffert renga.tredydev.u - - - - Hewlett-Packard nisys.com Company fax: (215 648- William Leonard 3404 E. Harmony 4624 Harris Computer Road Systems Division Fort Collins alternate: Allie 2101 W. Cypress CO 80525-9599 Murphy Creek Road Ft. Lauderdale phone: (303) 229- - - - - - - - - FL 33309 2774 - - - - - - - - email: - - - - phone: (305) 973- mbsh@fc.hp.com 5130 fax: (303) 229- Tom Lahey email: 6318 Lahey Computer bill@ssd.csd.har Systems Inc. ris.com alternate: David 865 Tahoe Blvd fax: (305) 977- 55 - - - - - - - - EH2 4PH - - - - - - - - SCOTLAND alternate: Doug - - - - Scofield phone: 011 44 31 Alex Marusak 225 6262 - - - - - - - - Los Alamos email: - - - - - - - - National Lab geoff@epc.ed.ac. - - - - Group IT-1 uk MS/B228 fax: 011 44 31 Richard Maine Los Alamos 225 6644 NASA Dryden NM 87545 M/S D-1021 alternate: P.O. Box 273 phone: (505) 667- Graham Barbe Edwards 6922 David T. CA 93523 email: internet Muxworthy alm@lanl.gov phone: (805) 258- - - - - - - - - 3316 alternate: Tony - - - - - - - - email: Warnock - - - - maine@altair.dfr DOE Language f.nasa.gov Working Group Leonard J. Moss fax: (805) 258- SLAC 3567 - - - - - - - - 2575 Sand Hill - - - - - - - - Rd. alternate: Bruce - - - - Menlo Park Martin CA 94025 David Mattoon - - - - - - - - Assoc. of phone: (415) 926- - - - - - - - - American 3370 - - - - Railroads email: 3140 South ljm@slacvm.slac. Jeanne T. Martin Federal Street stanford.edu Lawrence Chicago email: bitnet: Livermore Natl. IL 60616 ljm @ slacvm Lab. fax: (415) 926- 7000 East Avenue phone: (312) 808- 3329 P. O. Box 808 5868 L-300 phone: (708) 234- alternate: Livermore 2014 Sylvia Sund CA 94550 email: David_Mattoon_at - - - - - - - - phone: (510) 422- _CTC@relay.prote - - - - - - - - 3753 on.com - - - - email: fax: (312) 808- jtm@llnl.gov 5425 C. Mallory North fax: (510) 423- Rose-Hulman 6961 - - - - - - - - Institute of - - - - - - - - Tech. alternate: John - - - - 5500 Wabash Ave. T. Engle Campus Box 145 convenor of G. E. Millard Terre Haute ISO/IEC E.P.C.L. IN 47803 JTC1/SC22/WG5 17 Alva Street Edinburgh phone: (812) 877- 8 phone: (206) 865- Phillimore email: bitnet 3522 institutional north @ rhit email: internet member (Thinking fax: (812) 877- philips @ Machines) 3198 atc.boeing.com fax: (206) 865- - - - - - - - - alternate: Jerry 2966 - - - - - - - - Fine - - - - alternate: Alvin - - - - - - - - C. Mong Andrew D. Tait - - - - - - - - Amdahl - - - - - - - - - - - - Corporation - - - - - - - - 1250 East Arques Linda O'Gara - - - - Ave. 514 South Q M/S 276 Street Lawrence R. PO Box 3470 Livermore Rolison Sunnyvale CA 94550 Cray Research CA 94088-3470 Inc. - - - - - - - - 655F Lone Oak phone: (408) 746- - - - - - - - - Dr. 7370 - - - - Eagan email: MN 55121 adt10@uts.amdahl Jose Oglesby .com c/o Microsoft phone: (612) 683- fax: (408) 992- One Microsoft 5807 2209 Way email: Redmond lrr@cray.com - - - - - - - - WA 98052 fax: (612) 683- - - - - - - - - 5307 - - - - phone: (206) 882- 8080 alternate: Jon Ted Terpstra email: Steidel (DECUS) uunet!microsoft! institutional Princton Plasma joseogl member (Cray Physics Lab fax: (206) 883- Research) Princeton 8101 University - - - - - - - - P. O. Box 451 alternate: Greg - - - - - - - - Princeton Lindhors - - - - NJ 08543 Lauren Feaux Guy L. Steele phone: (609) 243- - - - - - - - - Thinking 2823 - - - - - - - - Machines Corp email: - - - - 245 First Street TERPSTRA@USC.PPP Cambridge L.GOV Ivor R. Philips MA 02142 fax: (609) 243- Boeing Computer 3086 Services phone: (617) 234- P. O. Box 24346 1000 alternate: Joel MS 7L-21 email: internet Rose Seattle gls @ think.com instititutional WA 98124-3046 member (DECUS) alternate: David - - - - - - - - Stan Whitlock Lab. - - - - - - - - Digital P. O. Box 808 - - - - Equipment Corp. L-300 ZK02-3/N30 Livermore Jerrold L. 110 Spit Brook CA 94559 Wagener Rd. Amoco Production Nashua Research NH 03062 alternate: 4502 East 41st Jeanne T. Martin Street phone: (603) 881- P. O. Box 3385 2011 - - - - - - - - Tulsa email: internet - - - - - - - - OK 74102 whitlock@tle.ene - - - - t.dec.com phone: (918) 660- fax: (603) 881- Lauren Feaux 3978 0120 c/o Microsoft email: One Microsoft jwagener@trc.amo alternate: Keith Way co.com Kimball Redmond fax: (918) 660- WA 98052 4165 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fax: (206) 883- alternate: Rex - - - - 8101 L. Page X3J3 chair ALTERNATE alternate: Jose X3H3 (Graphics) Oglesby - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Graham Barber Richard Weaver E.P.C.L. Jerry Fine IBM M77/E365 17 Alva Street Rose-Hulman P.O. Box 49023 Edinburgh Institute of San Jose Tech. CA 95161 SCOTLAND Dept. of Mechanical phone: (408) 463- phone: 44 31 225 Engineering 2956/3088 6262 550 Wabash Ave. email: email: janet Terre Haute fortran@vnet.ibm gra@epc.ed.ac.uk IN 47803 .com fax: 44 31 225 fax: (408) 463- 6644 phone: (812) 877- 3114 1511 alternate: G. E. email: bitnet alternate: Millard fine @ rhit Janice Shepherd fax: (812) 877- institutional - - - - - - - - 3198 member (IBM) - - - - - - - - - - - - alternate: C. M. - - - - - - - - North - - - - - - - - John T. Engle - - - - Lawrence - - - - - - - - Livermore Natl. - - - - - - - - - fax: (603) 881- Building 911-C 0120 Brookhaven Murray F. National Freeman alternate: Stan Laborator Bell Whitlock Upton Communication NY 11973 Research - - - - - - - - RRC 4B-721 - - - - - - - - phone: (516) 282- 444 Hoes Lane - - - - 5647 Piscataway email: NJ 08854-4182 David R. Levine bam@bnl.gov Hewlett-Packard email: phone: (201) 699- Company bam@bnlux1.bnl.g 2272 MS CHD02CS ov Massachusetts alternate: Kurt Language Lab. alternate: W. Hirchert 300 Apollo Drive Richard Maine Chelmsford - - - - - - - - MA 01824 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - phone: (508) 256- - - - - 6600 Michael email: Alvin C. Mong Ingrassia drlevine@apollo. Boeing Computer SunPro hp.com Services 2550 Garcia P. O. Box 24346 UMTV 12-40 alternate: MS 7L-21 Mountain View Maureen Hoffert Seattle CA 94043 WA 98124-0346 - - - - - - - - phone: (415) 336- - - - - - - - - phone: (206) 865- 1024 - - - - 3531 email: email: michael.ingrassi Greg Lindhorst mong@espresso.bo a@eng.sun.com c/o Microsoft eing.com One Microsoft - - - - - - - - Way alternate: Ivor - - - - - - - - Redmond R. Philips - - - - WA 98052 - - - - - - - - Keith Kimball fax: (206) 883- - - - - - - - - Digital 8101 - - - - Equipment Corp. ZK02-3/N30 alternate: Jose Allie Murphy 110 Spit Brook Oglesby Unisys Road Corporation Nashua - - - - - - - - 2476 Swedesford NH 03062 - - - - - - - - Road - - - - P. O. Box 203 phone: (603) 881- Paoli .... Bruce A. Martin PA 19301 email: Relativistic kimball@tle.enet Heavy Ion phone: (215) 648- .dec.com Collider 4690 email: - - - - - - - - murp%trprogb@tre - - - - - - - - - - - - nga.tredydev.uni - - - - - - - - sys.com David Phillimore - - - - fax: (215) 648- Thinking 4624 Machines Inc. Doug Scofield 245 First Street Harris alternate: Rich Cambridge Corporation Kelble MA 02142 Computer Systems Div. - - - - - - - - phone: (617) 234- 2101 W. Cypress - - - - - - - - 1000 Creek Rd. - - - - email: internet Ft. Lauderdale dphillim @ FL 33309 David T. think.com Muxworthy phone: (305) 973- EUCS alternate: Guy 5120 University Steele email: Library doug@ssd.csd.har George Square - - - - - - - - ris.com Edinburgh - - - - - - - - EH8 9LJ - - - - alternate: SCOTLAND William Leonard Charles Ritz phone: 011 44 31 Fortran Journal - - - - - - - - 650 3305 P.O. Box 4201 - - - - - - - - email: janet Fullerton - - - - d.t.muxworthy @ CA 92634 edinburgh.ac.uk Janice Shepherd fax: 011 44 31 phone: (714) 441- IBM Canada Ltd. 662 4809 2022 31/123/844/TOR fax: (714) 441- 844 Don Mills alternate: G. E. 2022 Road Millard North York - - - - - - - - Ontario M3C1V7 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - CANADA - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - phone: (416) 448- Joel S. Rose 3101 Rex L. Page Computing Center email: Amoco Production University at janshep@torolab2 Research Buffalo .vnet.ibm.com P. O. Box 3385 Buffalo fax: (416) 448- Tulsa NY 14260 6057 OK 74102 phone: (716) 645- alternate: phone: (918) 660- 3566 Richard Weaver 3935 email: acuser@ubvms - - - - - - - - alternate: fax: (716) 645- - - - - - - - - Jerrold L. 3734 - - - - Wagener alternate: Brian T. Smith - - - - - - - - Rochelle Lauer University of New email: bitnet Computer Science Matt Snyder sunnie @ slacvm Dept. Lahey Computer 339 Farris Systems Inc. alternate: Engineering 865 Tahoe Blvd Leonard J. Moss Center Suite 204 Albuquerque P. O. Box 6091 - - - - - - - - NM 87131 Incline Village - - - - - - - - NV 89450-6091 - - - - phone: (505) 277- 5500 phone: (702) Tony Warnock phone: (505) 277- 831-2500 Los Alamos 3112 (secreta email: uucp National Lab. email: phonenet uunet!lahey!msny MS B296 smith @ d C-10 unmvax.cs.unm.ed email: P.O. Box 1663 u msnyd@lahey.com Los Alamos fax: (505) 277- fax: (702) 831- NM 87545 0813 8323 phone: (505) 667- alternate: - - - - - - - - 7158 Herrick Lauson - - - - - - - - ACM/SigNum - - - - alternate: Alex Parallel Marusak Computing Forum Jon Steidel - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Cray Research - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Inc. - - - - - - - - 655F Lone Oak Dr. John D. Wilson Presley Smith Eagan Computer Centre CONVEX Computer MN 55121 University of Corporation Leicester 3000 Waterview phone: (612) 683- Leicester Parkway 5734 LE1 7RH P. O. Box 833851 email: jls @ ENGLAND Richardson cray.com TX 75083-3851 phone: 011 44 alternate: Larry 533 522235 phone: (214) 497- Rolison email: 4545 jdw@leicester.ac email: - - - - - - - - .uk psmith@convex.co - - - - - - - - m - - - - alternate: T. fax: (214) 497- Miles R. Ellis 4500 Sylvia Sund SLAC - - - - - - - - alternate: Rich Bin 60 - - - - - - - - Bleikamp P.O. Box 4349 - - - - X3H2 (Database) Stanford CA 94309 OBSERVER - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - phone: (415) 926- - - - - - - - - - - - - 2277 - - - - - - - - - B. Banes Brian Brode Stephen Adamczyk Rolls Royce Ltd Pacific Sierra Edison Design Eng Comp Research Corp. Group P.O. Box 3 12340 Santa 4 Norman Road Filton Bristol Monica Blvd. Upper Montclair BS12 7QE Los Angeles NJ 07043 ENGLAND CA 90025 phone: (201) 744- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 2620 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - C. Bourstin Thomas W. Bucken - - - - AFNOR Kendall Square Div. Research Jeanne C. Adams Informatique- 170 Tracer Lane NCAR Secteur Waltham Scientific Tertiaire MA 02154 Computing Tour Europe - Division Cedex 07 phone: (617) 895- P.O. Box 3000 F-92080 Paris La 9490 Boulder Defense email: CO 80307 tbucken@koas.ksr FRANCE .com phone: (303) 497- fax: (617) 890- 1275 0996 email: internet AFNOR jeanne - - - - - - - - @ncar.ucar.edu - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fax: (303) 497- - - - - - - - - - - - - 1137 - - - - Thomas Gordon - - - - - - - - Joanne Brixius Butler - - - - - - - - Cray Research Texaco Inc. - - - - Inc. 4800 Fournace 655F Lone Oak Place Thomas Aird Dr. Bellaire Visual Numerics Eagan TX 77401 Inc. MN 55121 14141 Southwest - - - - - - - - Freeway phone: (612) 683- - - - - - - - - Suite 3000 5873 - - - - Sugar Land email: TX 77478-3498 jbrixius@cray.co Bor Chan m NERSC phone: (713) 279- Lawrence 1012 alternate: Larry Livermore email: Rolison National Lab. aird@imsl.com IEEE POSIX University of California - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - P.O. Box 5509 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - L-560 - - - - - - - - Livermore CA 94550 Communications Research - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 435 South Street - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Morristown - - - - - - - - NJ 07960 Peter Galloway Ingemar - - - - - - - - International Dahlstrand - - - - - - - - Computers Ltd. DNA/LTH - - - - Arndale House Box 118 Arndale Centre S-22100 Lund Robert Follett Manchester IBM Corp. M4 3AR SWEDEN 643/RCTR/9W ENGLAND 6705 Rockledge email: internet Drive email: ingo @ Bethesda P.Galloway@qmw.a dna.lth.se MD 20817 c.uk WG5/Sweeden phone: (301) 564 - - - - - - - - 2108 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - fax: (301) 564 - - - - - - - - - - - - 2594 - - - - L G J ter Haar - - - - - - - - Am Alten L. M. Delves - - - - - - - - Sportplatz 20 Dept. of - - - - 4194 Bedburg-Hau- Computer Science Hasselt and Statistics Lloyd Fosdick University of Dept. of Liverpool Computer Science GERMANY Liverpool University of Colorado phone: (70) ENGLAND Campus Box 430 930160 Boulder - - - - - - - - CO 80309 WG5/Netherlands - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Charles Dickman - - - - - - - - General Electric Information Sys. Michael J. John Hill 401 North Frisch Unisys Corp. Washington Computer and M/S E8-130 Street Information P.O. Box 500 Rockville Services Blue Bell MD 20850 University of PA 19424 Minnesota - - - - - - - - 100 Lauderdale phone: (215) 986- - - - - - - - - Computing 4565 - - - - Facility 2520 Broadway - - - - - - - - Stuart I. Drive - - - - - - - - Feldman Minneapolis - - - - Bell MN 55113 Paul Hurtley CA 94720 phone: (203) 432- P.G.R. Computing 3366 Dorchester House - - - - - - - - email: bitnet Station Road - - - - - - - - lauer @ yalehep Letchworth - - - - fax: (203) 432- Herts 3824 SG6 3AW Joseph King ENGLAND Genetics alternate: Joel Computer Group Rose phone: 44 462 Inc instititutional 480-648 575 Science Dr member (DECUS) Suite B - - - - - - - - Madison - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - WI 53711 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - phone: (608) 231- Kalman Janko 5200 Bruce Leasure CSENGERY 59 - 11 email: Kuck and 117 jking@gcg.com Associates Budapest fax: (608) 231- 1906 Fox Drive 1067 5202 Champaigne HUNGARY IL 61820 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - phone: (217) 356- - - - - - - - - - - - - 2288 - - - - William La - - - - - - - - E. Andrew Plante - - - - - - - - Johnson Box 2130 - - - - Open Software Arlington Foundation VA 22202 Neldon H. 11 Cambridge Marshall Center phone: (301) 763- EG&G Idaho Inc. Cambridge 3905 1580 Sawtelle MA 02142 Street - - - - - - - - M/S 2408 phone: (617) 621- - - - - - - - - P. O. Box 1625 8794 - - - - Idaho Falls email: ID 83415 andyj@osf.org Rochelle Lauer fax: (617) 225- Director phone: (208) 526- 2782 Yale University 9342 High Energy email: internet - - - - - - - - Computing nhm @ inel.gov - - - - - - - - Facility fax: (208) 526- - - - - 512 Gibbs 9591 Physics William Kahan Laboratory - - - - - - - - EE & Computer 260 Whitney - - - - - - - - Science Dept. Avenue - - - - University of P. O. Box 6666 California New Haven C. J. Mas 573 Evans CT 06511-8167 IBM France Berkeley Dept. 2729 Tour Descartes 5227 Supercomputer Cedex 50 phone: (510) 666- Research Paris La Defense 6328 (USF) University of email: Illinois FRANCE meissner@lynx.cs 305 Talbot Lab .usfca.edu Urbana IL 61801 WG5/France alternate: Bruce Martin - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - George Paul Hiroshi Matsuo IBM Research Software Works Michael Metcalf Division Hitachi Ltd. DD T.J. Watson 5030 Totsuka-cho Cern Research Center Totsuka-ku 1211 Geneva 23 P. O. Box 704 Yokohama-shi Yorktown Heights 244 NY 10598 JAPAN SWITZERLAND phone: (914) 789- phone: 011 81 45 phone: 011 41 22 7750 824-2311 767 4427 phone: (914) 769- fax: 011 81 45 phone: 011 41 22 0984 (home) 824-9092 794 4755 email: bitnet: email: bitnet GP1 @ yktvmh WG5/Japan metcalf @ email: csnet: cernvm.cern.ch GP1 @ ibm.com - - - - - - - - fax: 011 41 22 - - - - - - - - 767 7155 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Keith McConnell - - - - - - - - 106 Apple Street - - - - Aurelio Tinton Falls Pollicini NJ 07724 Meinolf CEC JRC Ispra Munchhausen I-21020 Ispra phone: (201) 758- D ST SP314 7000 Seimens Ag ITALY D-8000 Munchen - - - - - - - - 83 - - - - - - - - WG5/Italy - - - - GERMANY - - - - - - - - Loren P. - - - - - - - - Meissner EWICS - - - - University of San Francisco - - - - - - - - Richard R. Ragan 2 Kerr Avenue - - - - - - - - Control Data Kensington - - - - Corp. CA 94707 5101 Patrick David Padua Henry Dr. phone: (510) 524- Center for Santa Clara CA 95054 William C. - - - - - - - - Rinehuls - - - - - - - - phone: (408) 496- Chairman - - - - 4340 SPARC email: 8457 Rushing Lindsey Savage rrr@svl.cdc.com Creek Court University of fax: (408) 496- Springfield Manchester 4106 VA 22153 Manchester Computer Centre - - - - - - - - Oxford Road - - - - - - - - SPARC Computer - - - - Building - - - - - - - - Manchester M. Rannou - - - - - - - - M13 9PL AFNOR - - - - UNITED KINGDOM Tour Europe - CEDEX 07 Keith D. Roberts - - - - - - - - F-92080 Paris La British - - - - - - - - Defense Petroleum Res. - - - - Ctr. FRANCE Chertsey Road J. L. Sunbury-on- Schonfelder phone: (617) 895- Thames Director 9490 Middlesex Computer email: TW16 7LN Laboratory tbucken@koas.ksr ENGLAND University of .com Liverpool fax: (617) 890- - - - - - - - - P.O. Box 147 0996 - - - - - - - - Liverpool - - - - L69 3BX - - - - - - - - ENGLAND - - - - - - - - Mike Ross - - - - Metaware Inc. phone: 011 44 2161 Delaware (51) 794-3716 John K. Reid Ave. email: janet Atlas Centre Santa Cruz jls@liverpool.ac Rutherford CA 95060 .uk Appleton Laboratory - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Oxon - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - OX11 0QX - - - - - - - - ENGLAND K. H. Rotthauser Jurgen Schonhut phone: 011 44 GMD c/o FhG-AGD 235 44 6493 Schloss Wilhelminenstr.7 email: Birlinghoven D-6100 Darmstadt jkr@ib.rl.ac.uk D-5205 St. fax: 011 44 235 Augustin 1 GERMANY 44 5808 GERMANY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - WG5/Germany Ward Sly 4308 Edinbrook IBM Canada Ter. National Bureau 844 Don Mills Minneapolis of Standards Road MN 55443 Don Mills - - - - - - - - Ontario M3C 1W3 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - CANADA - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Hideo Wada WG5/Canada Madeleine R. Software Sparks Division - - - - - - - - X3H3.4 Chair Fujitsu Limited - - - - - - - - UNISYS Corp. 140 Miyamoto - - - - 4000 S. Memorial Numazu-shi Parkway Shizuoka Qing-bao Wu Huntsville 410-03 P. O. Box 619 AL 35802 JAPAN Beijing P.R.O.C. phone: (205) 880- phone: (0559) 23- CHINA 5544 2222 fax: (205) 880- email: 5680 wada@lp.nm.fujit WG5/China su.co.jp X3H3 (Graphics) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - SPARC Secretary Wolfgang Walter CBEMA Richard C. Swift Inst.f.Angewandt Suite 500 MASPAR Inc. e Mathematik 1250 Eye Street 749 North Mary Universitat NW Avenue Karlsruhe Washington Sunnyvale Kaiserstr. 12 D.C. 20005 CA 94086 D-7500 Karlsruhe 1 phone: (202) 737 phone: (408) 736- 8888 3300 GERMANY fax: (202) 638 email: 4922 argosy!swift@dec phone: 011 49 fax: (202) 628 2 wrl.dec.com 721 37 79 36 email: - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - AE38@DKAUNI2.BIT - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - NET - - - - - - - - fax: 011 49 721 608-4290 ISO/WG5 Mabel Vickers National Bureau - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - of Standards - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Building 225 - - - - - - - - Room A266 Gaithersburg Graham Warren Akio Aoyama MD 20899 Dept. Hitachi 31/123/844/TOR 549-6 Shinano- cho Dept. of - - - - Totsuka-ku Aerospace Yokohama-shi Engineering H. Sobiesiak Kanagawa-ken Universitat Kern Forschungs 244 Stuttgart Zentrum JAPAN Pfaffenwaldring Karlsruhe 27 Iak - - - - - - - - D 7000 Stuttgart Postfach 3640 - - - - - - - - 80 D 7500 Karlsruhe - - - - GERMANY GERMANY B. Buckley Computing - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Science - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Department - - - - - - - - Dalhousie University Sven Hammarling Eiji Tokunaga Halifax NAG Central c/o Information Nova Scotia B3L Office Processing 3C4 Numerical Society of Japan CANADA Algorithms Group The Kilai- Ltd. Shiukokai Bldg. - - - - - - - - Mayfield House 1-Shiba-Koen - - - - - - - - 256 Banbury Road Minato-ku - - - - Oxford Tokyo OX2 70E JAPAN Jeremy du Croz ENGLAND NAG Central - - - - - - - - Office email: janet - - - - - - - - Numerical nagsven%vax.oxfo - - - - Algorithms Group rd.ac.uk @ Ltd. nss.cs.u Rainer Zimmer Wilkinson House fax: 011 44 865 Seimens AG Jordan Hill Road 310139 K D St SP Oxford Otto-Hahn - Ring OX2 7DE - - - - - - - - 6 ENGLAND - - - - - - - - 800 Munchen 83 - - - - - - - - - - - - GERMANY - - - - - - - - Tadayoshi Kan - - - - Department of Physics Dale Ellis Faculty of DRE A Science P. O. Box 1012 Gakushuin Dartmough University N.S. B2Y 3Z7 1-5-1 CANADA Mejiro Toshima-ku - - - - - - - - Tokyo 171 - - - - - - - - JAPAN - - - - - - - - - - - - Ingolf Grieger - - - - - - - -