Minutes of Meeting 135

X3J3 ANSI Fortran Standards Committee

November 13 - 17, 1995

San Diego, California

X3J3 / 95-314r1

Table of Contents

1	Monday, November 13, 1995	1

1.1	Opening Announcement	1

1.2	Meeting 135 Objectives and Chair's Report	1

1.3	Adoption of the Agenda	1

1.4	Approval of the Meeting 134 Minutes	2

1.5	Meeting 134 Action Items	2

1.6	Treasurer's Report	3

1.7	Membership Report	3

1.8	X3/OMC Report	4

1.10	ISO/WG5 Report	4

1.11	Local Arrangements	4

1.12	Subgroup Assignments	5

1.13	Comments from Members	5

2	Tuesday, November 14, 1995	5

2.1	Subgroup Reports and Processing	5

Edit	5

Interpretations	5

Parallel	5

JOR	5

2.2	Tutorial on Floating Point Exception Handling	6

2.3	Letter Ballot Voting Record Discussion	6

3	Wednesday, November 15, 1995	7

3.1	Subgroup Reports and Processing	7

JOR	7

Conditional Compilation (CoCo)	7

Parameterized Derived Types	7

Interoperability	7

Other JOR Items	7

Interpretations	8

Edit	8

Floating Point Exception Handling	8

3.2	Liaison Reports	8

3.3	Review of Upcoming Papers	9

4	Thursday, November 16, 1995	9

4.1	Subgroup Reports and Processing	9

JOR	9

Parallel	9

Interpretations	9

Edit	10

4.2	Liaison Reports	10

4.3	Subgroup Reports and Processing	10

5	Friday, November 17, 1995	11

5.1	Approve Comment Response Letters	11

5.2	Subgroup Reports and Processing	11

Interpretations	11

5.3	Approve WG5 Resolution Responses	11

5.4	Approve Liaison Reports	11

5.5	Future Meetings	12

5.6	Review of Meeting 135 Action Items	13

5.7	Membership Report	13

5.8	Treasurer's Report	14

5.10	Meeting 136 Agenda	14

5.11	Comments from Members	14

Appendix A
Agenda for X3J3 Meeting 135	15

Appendix B
X3J3 Register of Documents for 1995	17

Appendix C
Future Meetings and Distribution Assignments	22

Appendix D
Committee Organization	23

Appendix E
Membership Summary	24

Appendix F
X3J3 Membership	25

Meeting 135 Minutes

by Craig T. Dedo

November 28, 1995

1	Monday, November 13, 1995

A regular meeting was held at 8:30 a.m. on Monday, November 13, 1995 in the Lisbon Conference Room at the Ramada Inn San Diego North, 5550 N. Kearny Mesa Road, San Diego, CA 92111. Jerrold Wagener was in the chair and Craig Dedo took the minutes.

1.1	Opening Announcement

Larry Rolison is a brand new graduate of the ANSI school of rules and procedures. He learned a lot about the expectations that ANSI has of officers of ANSI sponsored standards efforts. Larry Rolison asked that we take a vote to declare the meeting to be duly called in the event we had unknowingly violated any ANSI, X3, or other governing body rules regarding meeting validity. We expect to take this action at the beginning of each meeting.

Motion:	X3J3 declares this meeting to be a duly called meeting.

Moved:	Larry Rolison	Second:	Craig Dedo

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

1.2	Meeting 135 Objectives and Chair's Report

Discussion Leader:	Jerrold Wagener

There are 7 major objectives.

1.	Produce the Fortran 95 Draft International Standard (DIS). WG5 the previous week (November 6-10, 1995) sent Fortran 95 out with a few holes for us to fill. Each subgroup will get an assignment. There will be no formal votes on the Fortran 95 DIS unless members ask for some.

2.	Produce response letters to the public review comments and vote on the final language. Each letter needs to pass by a 2/3 vote.

3.	Assist John Reid, the Project Editor, in completing the Technical Report (TR) on Floating Point Exception Handling. John Reid would like X3J3 to be closely involved with the development work. WG5 changed the rules for developing a TR. [Reference: 95-273, p. 2]

4.	Review the initial list of Fortran 2000 requirements and present them with a report and analysis.

5.	Produce 6 liaison / response reports on:

•	Floating Point Exception Handling

•	Interoperability with C

•	Allocatable Components, Allocatable Dummy Arguments, and Allocatable Function Results

•	Parameterized Derived Types

•	Conditional Compilation

•	Fortran 2000 Requirements

6.	Decide whether we accept the invitations from WG5 on two subjects:

•	Do we want to be the maintenance body for Fortran 95?

•	Do we want to be the primary development body for Fortran 2000?

7.	Develop responses to the WG5 resolutions.

1.3	Adoption of the Agenda

Discussion Leader:	Jerrold Wagener

Presented as mailed with changes proposed by Jerrold Wagener (see Appendix A).

Motion:	Adopt the agenda with the changes as proposed by Jerrold Wagener.

Moved:	Craig Dedo	Second:	Stan Whitlock

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

1.4	Approval of the Meeting 134 Minutes

Discussion Leader:	Jerrold Wagener

Reference:	95-249, Meeting 134 Minutes

Extensive discussion on the content and format of the minutes. Following are the major points covered in the discussion. Specific amendments to the content are not included.

•	We need to be aware of and responsive to political sensitivities. Including a lot of detail and background information may aggravate political sensitivities.

•	In many organizations, people often get punished for saying anything that their superiors do not like. This is why many bureaucrats will say little or nothing of substance on the record; they fear that whatever they may say will come back later to haunt them.

•	It is important to reflect the essence of the technical argument. However, we need to work in an informal, cooperative spirit. Recording a lot of detail may intimidate people.

•	We generally have a scribe for long discussions. The Secretary should not try to be a discussion scribe.

•	There were a number of errors.

•	Accuracy is far more important than including background information.

•	Local arrangements should not be in the minutes.

•	The post-meeting distribution did not arrive until two months after the meetings.

•	Normally, the minutes includes a list of all of the papers. This is required by the SD-2.

•	Is there a scorecard for what happened to the papers?

•	Some members would like pure ASCII text, rather than PostScript or word processing documents.

•	It is possible to put the minutes on the X3J3 server.

Members presented numerous amendments. All were approved by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve the minutes as amended.

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Stan Whitlock

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

Action Item:	Craig Dedo should prepare a revised copy of the minutes incorporating all of the amendments and issue a paper 95-249r1.

1.5	Meeting 134 Action Items

Discussion Leader:	Craig Dedo

1.	Kurt Hirchert	Check out whether the auto-unzip feature on the X3J3 server works yet.

He checked but it is still not working. Kurt will keep encouraging the staff of the server to make it work.

Status: Continuing.

2.	Craig Dedo	Send a copy of X3J3 and US TAG minutes to Jerrold Wagener for his review prior to sending them to the X3J3 Mailing List or to Kurt Hirchert for inclusion in the post-meeting mailing.

Jerrold Wagener was unavailable when the minutes were prepared so Craig Dedo sent them to Larry Rolison.

Status: Closed.

3.	Larry Rolison	Did the interpretations at the Tokyo WG5 meeting pass the WG5 ballot?

No. However, WG5 approved them at the recently concluded meeting.

Status: Closed.

4.	Craig Dedo	Check with Ivor Philips to see whether he still has the list of publications that he sent information and press releases to.

Ivor Philips does not have any part of the list, either paper or electronic.

Status: Closed.

Action Item:	Jeanne Martin will check to see if she has a copy of the list in her office.

Action Item:	Craig Dedo should prepare a copy of the August 1995 US TAG meeting minutes as soon as possible after this meeting concludes.

1.6	Treasurer's Report

Discussion Leader:	Mallory North

Reference:	95-248, Treasurer's Report for Meeting 135

All bills are paid. There is no meeting fee for this meeting. The regular meeting fee of $100.00 will be reinstated starting with meeting 136.

1.7	Membership Report

Discussion Leader:	Larry Rolison

Reference:	95-262, Record of X3J3 Letter Ballot Votes, 1/94 through 10/95

•	Bruce Bush is replacing Bill Lassaline as the representative for Lahey Computer Systems.

•	Jim Himer, Exxon, cannot make it to this meeting.

•	Linda O'Gara of Microsoft has not resigned. If Microsoft does not send anyone to this meeting, its membership will lapse.

•	In the next membership summary, Larry Rolison will delete identification of institutional members.

•	What happens to memberships if people switch organizational affiliations? For example, Jerrold Wagener recently retired from Amoco. Will he have to attend a meeting as a non-voting applicant? Is there a way of immediately terminating an institution after the former employee separates from the employer but still serves on X3J3?

•	Hewlett -Packard (HP) is buying out Convex. The acquisition will be finalized on December 20. Richard Bleikamp will still have a separate vote on the upcoming interpretations ballot. He will not officially represent or be an alternate for HP until the start of the next meeting.

•	The membership rules apply to both meeting attendance and letter ballot voting. A member will be dropped from membership if he or she meets either of the following criteria:

Meeting attendance	Miss 3 out of the last 4 meetings

Letter ballots	Miss 3 consecutive letter ballots

These criteria do not apply to TAG votes.

Current Membership:	22

Quorum:	8

One over half:	12

Members in Danger of Losing Membership:

James Himer	(Exxon)

David Levine	( Hewlett -Packard)

Linda O'Gara	(Microsoft)

Brian Smith	(University of New Mexico)	He may name Jeanne Martin as his alternate.

Non-voting Alternates:

Jeanne Adams	(National Center for Atmospheric Research)

Tom Lahey	(Lahey Computer Systems)

Henry Zongaro	(IBM)

Visitors:

John Reid	(Rutherford Appleton Laboratory)

1.8	X3/OMC Report

Discussion Leader:	Jerrold Wagener

Reference:	95-266, X3 Subgroup Annual Report

Jerrold Wagener appeared at the meeting on December 13 and gave the annual report.

The call for the International Representative closes this week. Right now, we have one applicant. If there is more than one applicant, X3 will conduct a ballot among the X3J3 membership.

Recess.

1.9	Location of Meeting 136

Meeting 136 is currently scheduled to be held February 12-16, 1996. Walt Brainerd has offered to host the meeting in or around Albuquerque, NM.

Straw Vote:	Where should we hold meeting 136?

9	Albuquerque

5	Santa Fe

2	Angel Fire Ski Resort

0	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Where in Albuquerque should we have the meeting?

4	Downtown

5	Suburban

6	Undecided

1.10	ISO/WG5 Report

Discussion Leader:	Jerrold Wagener

Reference:	95-273, Draft Revision of ISO/IEC JTC1 /SC22/WG5 - N1046 , Strategic Plan for Fortran Standardization

95-274, WG5 Procedures for the Future Development of Urgent New Features in Fortran by Means of Type 2 Technical Reports

95-275, Resolutions of the WG5 Meeting on 6 to 10 November 1995 in San Diego, CA

Here is a summary of the major decisions of the WG5 meeting recently concluded.

•	There is a revised strategic plan for Fortran 2000. This includes the revisions to the TR process that X3J3 requested.

•	WG5 issued a Fortran 95 Draft International Standard.

•	WG5 is asking X3J3 to be the primary development body for Fortran 95.

•	WG5 developed a preliminary list of requirements for the Fortran 2000 revision. This will need to be refined later.

•	The TR on Interoperability with C is moving ahead. Michael Hennecke was just appointed to be the project editor.

•	The TR effort on Data Type Enhancements has been split. The part on Parameterized Derived Types (PDT) was removed from it into a separate collateral development effort. Dr. J. Steve Morgan will lead the development work on PDT. WG5 may make PDT a fourth TR at its meeting in July 1996.

•	There is interest in developing a facility to support interval arithmetic. WG5 is asking persons to bring proposals for technical development work to the next WG5 meeting.

1.11	Local Arrangements

Discussion Leader: Ted Terpstra

1.12	Subgroup Assignments

Discussion Leader: Jerrold Wagener

Reference: 95-276, Assignments for X3J3 Meeting 135

1.13	Comments from Members

There were no comments from members.

Recess for subgroups at 11:25 a.m.

2	Tuesday, November 14, 1995

Call to order at 8:30 a.m.

2.1	Subgroup Reports and Processing

Edit

Discussion Leader: Richard Maine

Reference: 95-278, Responses to Fortran 95 CD Ballot

The Edit Subgroup has reviewed the F95 DIS through Chapter 5. So far, 17 editorial items have been fixed. There are three places which may prove difficult:

•	37:39+	This is waiting for X3J3 action on the definition of a direct component.

•	62:17	BOZ constants. Are there consistency and redundancy problems?

•	55:12+	Here we made technical changes that are incompatible with Fortran 90 but are compatible with all existing implementations. We removed the restriction that objects with the POINTER attribute cannot be implicitly typed.

Interpretations

Discussion Leader: Janice Shepherd

Reference:	95-261, 95-006 Status

95-263, F95 CD Edits Delegated to X3J3

The Interpretations Subgroup has started looking through the interpretations that passed recently to see that they are incorporated into the F95 CD. Then, Interpretations will start looking through corrigendum 3 in order to make sure that all of the items in it are included.

Parallel

Discussion Leader: Dick Hendrickson

The Parallel Subgroup met with Janice Shepherd and talked about the IBM comments. It would like some time in plenary so that John Reid could present his tutorial on the Exception Handling TR and take some straw votes.

JOR

Discussion Leader: Kurt Hirchert

Reference:	95-253, Response to IBM Comment on Fortran 95

95-264, Fortran 2000 Requirements

95-265, Fortran 2000 Requirements Processing at X3J3 Meeting 135

JOR is working to refine the draft response letters. It will draft a shorter version of the IBM response letter. Later, JOR will tackle the items in the preliminary list of requirements. In the initial review, the members of JOR will attempt to evaluate each feature in three areas:

•	The cost of standardizing the feature

•	The cost of implementing the feature

•	The benefit of the feature to users of Fortran

2.2	Tutorial on Floating Point Exception Handling

Discussion Leader: John Reid

Reference:	95-277, Floating Point Exceptions

The subgroup discussion proposed several changes. Following is a brief summary of the subgroup's thinking.

1.	There should be two modules.

USE IEEE_SUBSET	! Provides minimal support, runs fast.

USE IEEE_ARITHMETIC	! As proposed in the original version of 95-277.

2.	Should some capabilities be functions or subroutines?

The proposed functions, IEEE_GET_FSR and IEEE_GET_ROUNDING_MODE, are not pure; they will become subroutines. IEEE_GET_FLAG is also not pure but is awkward as a subroutine.

Straw Vote:	IEEE_GET_FLAG - Are you very uncomfortable if it is a subroutine?

5	Yes	11	No	2	Undecided

Straw Vote:	IEEE_GET_FLAG - Are you very uncomfortable if it is a function?

5	Yes	8	No	3	Undecided

Straw vote:	Which is the preferred form for IEEE_GET_FLAG?

10	Subroutine	7	Function	2	Undecided

3.	All of the IEEE_SUPPORT functions need an argument X, to see if the inquired about functionality is available for the same kind as X. Is there a way to inquire about support for all KINDs with one function call?

4.	The proposal will make more use of arrays of the exception flags as arguments.

5.	More specific functions will be merged to become functions that are generic over the defined exception flags.

6.	What kind of IEEE floating point support would the IEEE_SELECT_REAL_KIND return?

7.	Should there be special syntax for intrinsic modules? For example,

USE, INTRINSIC :: IEEE_ARITHMETIC

Straw Vote:	Do you like this idea or something like it?

10	Yes	3	No	5	Undecided

8.	We would add a rule that these procedures cannot be used as actual arguments in procedure calls.

2.3	Letter Ballot Voting Record Discussion

Discussion Leader: Larry Rolison

Reference:	95-262, Record of X3J3 Letter Ballot Votes, 1/94 Through 10/95

Some members are in danger of losing their membership due to frequent missed letter ballots. According to ANSI rules, any member who misses 3 out of the last 4 letter ballots loses their membership due to inactivity. Members should carefully review the paper to see if they are in danger.

Recess for subgroups at 10:15 a.m.

3	Wednesday, November 15, 1995

Call to order at 8:30 a.m.

3.1	Subgroup Reports and Processing

JOR

Reference:	95-257, Conditional Compilation: the FCC Approach

95-264, Fortran 2000 Requirements

95-265, Fortran 2000 Requirements Processing at X3J3 Meeting 135

Conditional Compilation (CoCo)

Discussion Leader: David Epstein

Reference:	95-279, Specifications and Requirements for CoCo

95-280, Recognizing the Fortran INCLUDE for CoCo

There are two evolving definitions for a CoCo facility. Both need quite a lot of work.

1.	Existing practice, generally assumed to be some derivative of cpp, the C language preprocessor.

2.	A Fortran-like pre-processor.

What do we want to do about INCLUDE? Would modules be preferable to INCLUDE?

Straw Vote:	Do we want to recognize the Fortran 95 INCLUDE facility in CoCo?

14	Yes	0	No	0	Undecided

Additional issues that members mentioned include:

•	Is there any interaction between INCLUDE and USE?

•	CoCo variables should behave just like regular Fortran variables. We should not introduce more irregularities.

•	File dependencies are a bad idea. Although INCLUDE introduces some file dependencies, we should work hard to minimize additional dependencies. The meaning and execution of a Fortran program should not change solely due to what file or files the source code is compiled from.

•	What is the scope control for meta-variables? If there are conflicting declarations when files are concatenated, we will have file scoping.

•	Are we going to have meta-variable assignment statements beyond meta-variable declarations?

Parameterized Derived Types

Discussion Leader: Richard Maine

Reference:	95-288, X3J3 Liaison Report on Parameterized Derived Types

The biggest area of difficulty is with the inquiry functions.

Interoperability

Discussion Leader: Henry Zongaro

Reference:	95-293, X3J3 Liaison Report on Interoperability

95-294, Draft Interoperability TR

95-295, HPF Calling C Interoperability Proposal, Version 1.2

There will be a meeting after dinner to discuss ideas on interoperability. Anyone who is interested is welcome to attend and should contact Henry Zongaro.

Other JOR Items

•	There will be a paper later with all of the draft responses to the public review comments.

•	There will be at least 3 related papers listing administrative side actions which X3J3 must accomplish in order to make the responses true.

•	The JOR Subgroup expects to get into the evaluation of the items on the B list for Fortran 2000 later in the day.

Action Item: Jerrold Wagener should contact Miles Ellis and verify that 95-265 item B1 is actually the top priority for Fortran 2000.

Interpretations

Discussion Leader: Janice Shepherd

Reference:	95-281, 95 -006r4 Status Changes per WG5 Meeting

95-263, Fortran 95 CD Edits Delegated to X3J3

There is a new WG5 policy on interpretation processing. Any item which is approved by X3J3 and WG5 will appear in the Technical Corrigendum 3. Any item which was approved by WG5 but sent back to X3J3 will be subject to an X3J3 letter ballot. There is no longer any chance of answering any interpretation requiring edits. Such items will become Fortran 95 interpretations. However, interpretations which do not require edits can still be answered as part of the Fortran 90 maintenance effort.

Paper 95-289, Definition for Direct Component, will go back to subgroup.

Motion:	Approve 95-287, Deferred Items 213:11-12, 18+, 27, 30

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed on a counted vote by show of hands. Vote:	Yes - 10	No - 2

Parliamentary Inquiry by Janice Shepherd: Does this motion require an ANSI-style 2/3 vote?

Answer by Jerrold Wagener: No, it does not.

There are two possible answers for Interpretation 155:

95-290, F95 Edits for Defect Item 000155

95-282, F95 Edits for Defect Item 000155, Alternative Response

Straw Vote:	Which approach do you prefer?

8	Paper 95-282

1	Paper 95-290

9	Undecided

Motion:	Approve 95-282, F95 Edits for Defect Item 000155, Alternative Response

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

Edit

Discussion Leader: Richard Maine

The Edit Subgroup has reviewed the Fortran 95 CD up to and including the Annex A edits. So far, there have been 41 editorial changes. Once the Edit Subgroup is finished with Annex C, it will put all of the editorial changes into a paper. With several items, the Edit Subgroup still has to wait for X3J3 action.

Floating Point Exception Handling

Discussion Leader: John Reid

Reference:	95-277r1, Floating Point Exception Handling - Draft for Second Part of TR

Straw Vote:	Should we use a subroutine or function for IEEE_TEST_FLAG?

7	Subroutine	6	Function	3	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Should the names of the procedures and values have IEEE_ in front?

10	IEEE_ in front of almost everything

6	IEEE_ in front gone almost always

0	Undecided

3.2	Liaison Reports

No reports or action at this time.

Recess for subgroups.

3.3	Review of Upcoming Papers

Each subgroup reported the list of papers that it will have ready for action on Thursday.

Recess at 4:50 p.m.

4	Thursday, November 16, 1995

Call to order at 8:30 a.m.

Jerrold Wagener announced that he had received an e-mail message from Walt Brainerd. Walt said that he would not be able to host the February 1996 meeting as originally planned since he will be going to an ACM symposium class that week.

4.1	Subgroup Reports and Processing

JOR

Discussion Leader: Kurt Hirchert

Motion:	Approve 95-292, Default Real and Double Precision DO Variables in I/O

Moved:	Kurt Hirchert	Second:	Jeanne Martin

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Paper 95-298 will put three items in document 95-008.

Paper 95-299 is a Request for Information on the subroutine MVBITS. What does "same variable" mean?

Paper 95-297, Proposed Responses to the Public Comments, is for discussion only. There will be a revision.

There is a new field in the JOR Register.

Parallel

Discussion Leader: Dick Hendrickson

There are a number of papers coming out: 95-277r2, 95-307, 95-308, and 95-288.

Interpretations

Discussion Leader: Janice Shepherd

Motion:	Approve 95-289r1, Definition for Direct Component

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Straw Vote:	Should we strike "another" and "other" in the second edit?

9	Strike the words

3	Don't strike the words

2	Undecided

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-291, F95 CD Edit [WG5-S51, S28] Delegated to X3J3

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-301, Supplement to Edits in 95-287

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-302, BOZ Literal Constants and N1135 Comments

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Maine

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

Paper 95-303, Interp 145 Edits Translated to Fortran 95 Draft, needs further work.

Edit

Discussion Leader: Richard Maine

All of the edits up through chapter 7 have been entered.

4.2	Liaison Reports

Discussion Leader:	Henry Zongaro

References:	95-288, X3J3 Liaison Report on Parameterized Derived Types

95-293, X3J3 Liaison Report on Interoperability

95-307, X3J3 Liaison Report on Floating Point Exception Handling TR

95-308, X3J3 Liaison Report on Allocatable Components TR

There are no more comments on 95-307 or 95-308.

An informal group met Wednesday night to discuss the TR on Interoperability with C. From the discussion, it is obvious that we do not even have a proper problem definition yet. There also is a problem with the scope and size of the project. Those who met made a very rough guess as to the amount of work required. They believe that a complete, high quality TR will require much more effort (i.e., labor hours) than is currently available.

There was discussion on paper 95-288. There will be revisions to the paper and it will come back later.

Recess.

Discussion Leader: David Epstein

Reference:	95-266, X3 Subgroup Annual Report

95-283, Draft X3J3 Responses to the WG5 San Diego Resolutions

95-296, X3J3 Liaison Report on Conditional Compilation (CoCo)

Do we really need this liaison report? It is important to record our decisions and make sure that they are copied to WG5 and other X3J3 members. We are not yet sure which of the two approaches to CoCo we will take. A revised paper will be available this evening.

There was some discussion on papers 95-283 and 95-266.

Action Item: Jerrold Wagener should go back to the SD-10 and check to see whether all of the information listed in Section III.c is required to be in the annual report.

Action Item: Walt Brainerd should contact William B. Clodius and get clarification of his intentions in paper 95-300, PFR on Flexible Accessibility.

Recess for subgroups.

4.3	Subgroup Reports and Processing

Jerrold Wagener reported that he got an answer from Miles on whether we are authorized to make minor technical changes to the Fortran 95 CD. The answer is yes.

Interpretations will have these papers ready for Friday: 95-304, 95-305, 95-306, 95-310, 95-311.

JOR will have these papers ready for Friday: 95-297r1, 95-312.

Parallel will have these papers ready for Friday: 95-283r1, 95-288r1, 95-296r1, 95-307, 95-308.

Paper 95-293 will also be ready for consideration on Friday.

Recess at 4:35 p.m.

5	Friday, November 17, 1995

Call to order at 8:30 a.m.

Jerrold Wagener announced that Walt Brainerd cannot host the February meeting until two weeks after the originally scheduled date.

5.1	Approve Comment Response Letters

Motion:	Approve 95-297r1, Proposed Responses to the Public Comments

Moved:	Kurt Hirchert	Second:	Jeanne Martin

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

5.2	Subgroup Reports and Processing

Interpretations

Motion:	Approve 95-304, Defect Item 179, DO variable with POINTER Attribute.

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-305, Defect Item 194, Statements Between SELECT CASE and CASE

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Larry Rolison

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-306, Defect Item 100, ASSOCIATED Intrinsic and Zero-Sized Objects

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-310, Defect Item 185, What is the Allocation Status of an Array After an Allocation Failure?

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Bleikamp

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-311, Note on Elemental Actual Argument Restriction

Moved:	Janice Shepherd	Second:	Richard Maine

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

5.3	Approve WG5 Resolution Responses

Motion:	Approve 95-283r1, X3J3 Responses to the WG5 San Diego Resolutions

Moved:	Keith Bierman	Second:	Kurt Hirchert

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

5.4	Approve Liaison Reports

Motion:	Approve 95-307, X3J3 Liaison Report on Floating Point Exception Handling TR

Moved:	Dick Hendrickson	Second:	Keith Bierman

Action:	Passed by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-308r1, X3J3 Liaison Report on Allocatable Components TR

Moved:	Dick Hendrickson	Second:	Keith Bierman

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-293, X3J3 Liaison Report on Interoperability

Moved:	Henry Zongaro	Second:	Craig Dedo

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-288r1, X3J3 Liaison Report on Parameterized Derived Types

Moved:	Craig Dedo	Second:	Janice Shepherd

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Motion:	Approve 95-296r1, Proposed Responses to the Public Comments

Moved:	David Epstein	Second:	Craig Dedo

Action:	Passed, as amended, by unanimous consent.

Recess.

Discussion Leader:	Jeanne Martin

Reference:	95-312, Liaison Report on Requirements for Fortran 2000

Straw Vote:	Move Asynchronous I/O to the Executive Summary list.

6	Yes	4	No	2	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Delete item D2, Compiler Directives, from the list.

7	Delete	2	Keep	4	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Delete Category E.

6	Delete	4	Keep	4	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Remove "Specifying Default Precision" from the Executive Summary

1	Remove	6	Keep	7	Undecided

Straw Vote:	A major activity at the next meeting should be to specify or sharpen the requirments for OOF.

12	Yes	1	No	2	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Add the following to Section C: Additional intrinsic data types such as Varying String, BIT, and UNSIGNED INTEGER.

7	Yes	3	No	3	Undecided

Jeanne Martin will prepare a version 95-312r1 and put it in the post-meeting.

5.5	Future Meetings

See also Appendix C.

Walt Brainerd cannot host the February meeting unless we postpone it for 2 weeks. Should we hold all meetings next year in Las Vegas, NV? This is close enough to NASA Dryden so that Richard Maine can drive and provide computer support. We would need someone to make the arrangements. If we did this, we would need to book the hotel at least 3 weeks in advance.

The next WG5 meeting is the last week of July in Dresden, Germany. Do we want the August meeting to be in Boston, which is on the way back from Germany?

Straw Vote:	Do we want the 1996 meetings to be in one city or move the meetings around the country, like we have been doing?

8	One city	2	Move meetings around the country	4	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Do we want to have our 1996 meetings in Las Vegas or some other place?

8	Las Vegas	0	Some other place	5	Undecided

Straw Vote:	Would holding the February meeting the week of February 26 be OK as a backup date?

8	Yes	0	No	5	Undecided

Larry Rolison took the chair.

5.6	Review of Meeting 135 Action Items

Discussion Leader:	Craig Dedo

1.	Kurt Hirchert	Motivate the system operators at the NCSA to get the auto-unzip feature on the X3J3 server to work.

Status: Continuing

2.	Craig Dedo	Prepare a revised copy of the Meeting 134 minutes and send out to the members.

Status: New

3.	Craig Dedo	Prepare printed copy of the US TAG minutes as soon as possible.

Status: New

4.	Jeanne Martin	Check to see if she has a copy of the list of publications that Ivor Philips used to send press releases to.

Status: New

5.	Jerrold Wagener	Contact Miles Ellis and verify that item B1 in paper 95-265 really is the top priority for Fortran 2000. Answer: Yes.

Status: Closed

6.	Jerrold Wagener	Check the SD-10 to see whether all of the information listed in Section III.c. of the X3J3 Annual Report to X3 is actually required.

Status: New

7.	Walt Brainerd	Communicate with William Clodius and clarify his intent in paper 95-300.

Status: New

8.	Craig Dedo	Send a copy of the X3J3 Meeting 135 Minutes to those persons who want to review them before sending them to the X3J3 Mailing List or including them in the post-meeting mailing.

Status: New

5.7	Membership Report

Discussion Leader:	Larry Rolison

Memberships Lost:

James Himer	(Exxon)

Jose Oglesby	(Microsoft)

Members in Danger of Losing Membership:

David Levine	(Hewlett-Packard)

Brian Smith	(University of New Mexico)

Current Membership:	20

One Over Half:	11

Quorum:	7

5.8	Treasurer's Report

Discussion Leader:	Mallory North

Reference:	95-248, Meeting 134 Treasurer's Report

95-313r1, Meeting 135 Treasurer's Report

5.10	Meeting 136 Agenda

Discussion Leader:	Larry Rolison

The Vice Chair solicited ideas for the agenda for the next meeting. Following are ideas that were mentioned.

•	Select new JOR items to send to WG5.

•	Look at the way we organize ourselves and divide up work assignments.

•	Discuss and possibly finish the development work on Conditional Compilation (CoCo). We should have a thorough discussion of CoCo on Monday.

•	Strategic planning for Fortran 2000 and setting of priorities on various items.

•	Status reports from the various liaison groups.

•	Forward the DIS to the ISO for review and written ballot.

5.11	Comments from Members

There were no comments from members.

The meeting adjourned at 11:55 a.m.

Appendix A

Agenda for X3J3 Meeting 135

(as Originally Proposed)

Monday, November 13, 1995

8:30	Opening Business	J. Wagener

Meeting objectives and Chair's report	J. Wagener

Membership Report / Introductions	L. Rolison

Adopting Agenda	J. Wagener

Approving Meeting 134 Minutes	C. Dedo

Review Meeting 134 Action Items	C. Dedo

Treasurer's Report	M. North

X3/OMC report	J. Wagener

ISO/WG5 report	K. Hirchert

Comments from members

Local Arrangements	T. Terpstra

Subgroup Head reports / goals for meeting	Subgroup heads

Organizing subgroups to handle public comments	J. Wagener

12:00	Lunch

1:30	Subgroup meetings

Tuesday, November 14, 1995

8:30	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

10:00	Miscellaneous Items (time permitting)

12:00	Lunch

1:30	Subgroup Meetings

Wednesday, November 15, 1995

8:30	Interpretations subgroup report and processing	J. Shepherd

Subgroup Meetings

12:00	Lunch

1:30	Subgroup Meetings

Thursday, November 16, 1995

8:30	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

Subgroup Meetings

12:00	Lunch

1:30	Subgroup Meetings

4:00	U.S. TAG

Friday, November 17, 1995

8:30	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

12:00	Lunch

1:30	Subgroup Reports and Processing	Subgroup heads

3:30	Closing Business	J. Wagener

Membership Report	L. Rolison

Future Meetings	L. Rolison

Treasurer's Report	M. North

Next Meeting Agenda	L. Rolison

Review of Action Items	C. Dedo

Comments from Members

5:00	Adjournment

Agenda for X3J3 Meeting 135

(as Adopted)

9.	Monday, November 13, 1995

1.1	Opening Business	J. Wagener

1.2	Meeting Objectives and Chair's report	J. Wagener

1.3	Adopting Agenda	J. Wagener

1.4	Approving Meeting 134 Minutes	C. Dedo

1.5	Review Meeting 134 Action Items	C. Dedo

1.6	Treasurer's Report	M. North

1.7	Beginning Membership Report / Introductions	L. Rolison

1.8	X3/OMC report	J. Wagener

1.9	Location of Meeting 136	W. Brainerd

1.10	ISO/WG5 report	K. Hirchert

1.11	Local Arrangements	T. Terpstra

1.12	Subgroup Assignments	J. Wagener

1.13	Comments from members

Lunch (12:00)

Subgroup meetings (1:30)

10.	Tuesday, November 14, 1995

2.1	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

2.2	Tutorial on floating point exception handling	J. Reid

2.3	Letter ballot voting record discussion (95-262)	L. Rolison

Lunch (12:00)

Subgroup meetings (1:30)

11.	Wednesday, November 15, 1995

3.1	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

3.2	Liaison reports	Liaisons

Subgroup meetings

Lunch (12:00)

Subgroup Meetings (1:30)

3.3	Subgroup reports (review of upcoming items) (4:30)	Subgroup heads

12.	Thursday, November 16, 1995

4.1	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

4.2	Liaison reports	Liaisons

Subgroup meetings

Lunch (12:00)

Subgroup Meetings

4.3	Subgroup reports (review of upcoming items) (4:30)	Subgroup heads

13.	Friday, November 17, 1995

5.1	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

5.2	Approve comment response letters

5.3	Subgroup reports and processing	Subgroup heads

5.4	Approve liaison reports

5.5	Approve WG5 resolution responses	Subgroup heads

5.6	Future Meetings	L. Rolison

5.7	Review of Meeting 135 Action Items	C. Dedo

5.8	Membership Report	L. Rolison

5.9	Treasurer's Report	M. North

5.10	Next Meeting Agenda	L. Rolison

5.11	Comments from Members

Adjournment

Appendix B

X3J3 Register of Documents for 1995

Standing Documents

Paper Number Title

X3J3/95-000 Register of Documents

X3J3/95-001 Membership List

X3J3/95-002 (Unused)

X3J3/95-003 X3J3 Member References

X3J3/95-004 Journal of Development

X3J3/95 -005r1 X3J3 Resolutions and Responses to WG5 Resolutions

X3J3/95-006 Defect Report

X3J3/95-007 Draft Revision to Fortran 95

X3J3/95-008 Editorial Considerations for 9X Draft Revision

X3J3/95-009 Technical Proposals for Future Revisions

X3J3/95-010 (Unused)

1995 Papers

Paper Number Submitter Date Title

X3J3/95-011 O'Gara Meeting 131 Minutes

X3J3/95-012 North 950116 Meeting 131 Treasurer's Report

X3J3/95-013 Shepherd 941121 006 Post Meeting 131 Letter Ballot

X3J3/95-014 Shepherd 941121 Request for Interpretation of

INQUIRE Statement

(Interpretation 000195)

X3J3/95 -015r1 Maine 941129 Revised Answer for Interpretation 000091

X3J3/95-016 Bleikamp 941208 Interpretation 000186, 1st Answer

X3J3/95 -017r1 Bleikamp 941208 Interpretation 000186, Alternative Answer

X3J3/95-018 Bleikamp 941208 Interpretation 000195

X3J3/95-019 Bleikamp 941208 Interpretation 000193

X3J3/95-020 Maine 941209 Guidelines for F95 Edit References

X3J3/95-021 Maine 941209 Edits Incorporated in 94 -007r4

X3J3/95-022 Maine 941209 Work Needed on 94 -007r4

X3J3/95 -023r2 Bleikamp 941209 Interpretation 000173

X3J3/95-024 Martin 941209 Proposed Reordering of Sec. 4.4.1

X3J3/95-025 Wagener 941212 X3 Response to X3J3/94-315

X3J3/95 -026r1 Wagener 941212 Floating Point Subset of ENABLE

X3J3/95-027 Moss 941214 Subset ENABLE Proposal

X3J3/95-028 Moss 941216 Permit BOZ Constants in Transfer Function

X3J3/95 -029r3 Levine 941216 Default Initialization

X3J3/95-030 Rolison 941216 Interpretation Request 000197

X3J3/95 -031r1 Shepherd 941219 RFI 000196 on TARGET Dummy Arguments and Elemental Sequence Calls

X3J3/95-032 Phillimore 941217 Mildly Substantive Edits

X3J3/95-033 Rolison 941219 Revised Response to Interp 000140

X3J3/95 -034r1 Shepherd 941219 006 Ballot Summary

X3J3/95 -035r1 Shepherd 941219 Edits to Note 6.9 in 007r4

X3J3/95-036 Shepherd 941219 Minor Non-Technical Changes to X3J3/94 -007r4

X3J3/95-037 Shepherd 941219 006 Ballot Comments for Ballot Ending 12/17/94

X3J3/95-038 Lauson 950104 Edits to X3J3/94 -007r4

X3J3/95 -039r1 Bleikamp 950104 Interpretation 000185

X3J3/95-040 Martin 950106 Review of 94-007

X3J3/95-041 Shepherd 950108 X3J3 Balloted Defect Items Effect on 94 -007r4

X3J3/95-042 Shepherd 950108 RFI 000198 on Dummy Procedure Characteristics

X3J3/95-043 Shepherd 950109 Defect Item 000081

X3J3/95-044 Martin 950118 Results of the Informal Ballot on Responses to Defect Items in WG5- N1070

X3J3/95 -045r1 Martin 950119 Pointer Initialization in DATA Statements

X3J3/95-046 Shepherd 950119 Rationale Text in 94 /007r4

X3J3/95-047 Wagener 950123 Revision of the 94 -007r4 Foreword

X3J3/95-048 Wagener 950123 Withdrawal of ANSI X3.9:1977 FORTRAN 77

X3J3/95-049 Kelble 950123 Record of X3J3 Letter Ballot Votes, 1/93 through 12/94

X3J3/95-050 Dedo 950123 Minutes of Meeting 132, Houston, Texas

X3J3/95 -051r2 Warnock 950123 Edits from / Interp for Chapters 4,5,6

X3J3/95 -052r1 Dedo 950123 Rationales for New Features in Fortran 95

X3J3/95-053 Wagener 950124 Transparencies supporting X3J3/95 -026r1

X3J3/95 -054r1 / Interp 950124 Interp. 192: Ambiguity of Dummy Procedures

X3J3/95 -055r1 /Parallel 950124 Proposed Changes to Annex C Regarding Chapters 4 - 6

X3J3/95-056 Wagener 950124	X3J3 Responses to the Public Review Comments on FORTRAN 77 Withdrawal

X3J3/95 -057r2 /Parallel 950124 Miscellaneous Edits to Chapters 4-6

X3J3/95 -058r2 /Parallel 950124 Array Status after Allocation Failure

X3J3/95 -059r2 /Parallel 950124 Subobjects of Constants in a DATA Statement

X3J3/95-060 /Interp 950125 Edits Against X3J3/95 -007r4 for Ch. 9

X3J3/95 -061r1 /JOR 950125 Edits for Chapters 11,12,14

X3J3/95-062 /Interp 950125 Non-Technical Changes to Chapter 2

X3J3/95 -063r1 /Interp 950125 Technical Changes to Chapter 2

X3J3/95 -064r2 /OOF 950125 Proposed Revision of FORALL Description

X3J3/95-065 /Parallel 950125 Restoration of Text Regarding Unsigned Literal Constant

X3J3/95 -066r2 /Parallel 950125 Proposed Note Regarding Negative Zero

X3J3/95-067 /Interp 950125 Alternate Response to Defect Item 000198

X3J3/95 -068r1 /Interp 950125 Miscellaneous Edits to Section 1, Plus Some Others

X3J3/95 -069r1 /Interp 950125 Edits against 007r4 for Chapter 10

X3J3/95 -070r1 /OOF 950125 Disposition of FORALL within WHERE

X3J3/95 -071r1 /OOF 950125 Semantics for Mask on ELSEWHERE

X3J3/95 -072r1 /OOF 950125 CMPLX Intrinsic and Optional Arguments

X3J3/95 -073r1 Rolison 950125 Review of 95 -007r4 Section 3

X3J3/95-074 /OOF 950125 Section 12.7 Constraint

X3J3/95 -075r1 /Interp 950125 Miscellaneous Edits from Interps Passed at this Meeting (132)

X3J3/95 -076r1 /Parallel 950126 Miscellaneous Edits for Chapters 4,5,6 from 94-007r4.5

X3J3/95-077r1 /Interp 950126 Further Edits to Sec. 1,2,3,9,10

X3J3/95-078r1 /OOF 950126 Non-technical Edits to Chapter 7

X3J3/95-079 /OOF 950126 Technical Edits to Chapter 7

X3J3/95-080r1 /OOF 950126 PURE and ELEMENTAL Constraints

X3J3/95-081r1 /JOR 950126 Miscellaneous Edits to Ch. 11,12,14

X3J3/95-082r1 Rolison 950126 Glossary Review

X3J3/95-083 /Edit 950126 Namelist

X3J3/95-084 /Edit 950126 Implementation of 94-008r5 Item 64

X3J3/95-085 /Interp 950126 How to Update F90 for Defect Item 184

X3J3/95-086 /Interp 950126 Non-Technical Changes to Defect Item 161

X3J3/95-087r1 /OOF 950126 Technical Changes to (7.5.3) "Masked Array Assignment - WHERE"

X3J3/95-088r1 /OOF 950126 Chapter 13 Edits

X3J3/95-089 /OOF 950126 Additional Chapter 13 Edits; also Ch. 7

X3J3/95-090 /OOF 950126 PURE and ELEMENTAL Edits (Ch. 12)

X3J3/95-091 /OOF 950126 Suggested Reorg. of Chapter 13 Sec.

X3J3/95-092 /Interp 950127 Revised Response to Interp 140

X3J3/95-093 /OOF 950127 Miscellaneous Edits to Chapter 8

X3J3/95-094 /Interp 950130 Summary of Approved Edits for Sections 1, 2, 9, 10

X3J3/95-095 Adams 950201 Book Introducing Fortran 90 in China

X3J3/95-096 Bleikamp 950201 X3J3 Letter Ballot for 006 Items

X3J3/95-097 Shepherd 950217 RFI 000193 - Pointer Actual Arg's. with the OPTIONAL Attibute

X3J3/95-098 Wagener 950228 Floating Point Subset of ENABLE

X3J3/95-099 Wagener 950228 Extrinsic C Interfaces

X3J3/95-100 Maine 950302 Edits Incorporated in X3J3/95-007r0

X3J3/95-101 Bleikamp 950306 Results of the Post Meeting 132 006 Letter Ballot

X3J3/95-102 Rolison 950306 Correcting the Response to Interp 125

X3J3/95-103 /Edit 950306 Work Needed on X3J3/95-007r0

X3J3/95-104 Brainerd 950222 Namelist and List-Directed I/O

X3J3/95-105 Dedo 950307 Rationales for New Features in Fortran 95

X3J3/95-106 /OOF (Dedo) 950307 PURE and ELEMENTAL Edits (Ch. 12)

X3J3/95-107 North 950317 Meeting 132 Treasurer's Report

X3J3/95-108 Billen 950317 Inclusion of Conditional Compilation in F90

X3J3/95-109 Wagener 950320 Letter to the X3 Secretariat

X3J3/95-110 Wagener 950320 F90 Compilers and the NIST FORTRAN 77 Validation Suite

X3J3/95-111 Levine 950330 CEILING and FLOOR need KIND

X3J3/95-112 Bierman 950412 A Fortran Preprocessor

X3J3/95-113 Levine 950413 Derived types, Default Initialization and COMMON

X3J3/95-114 O'Gara 950424 Interoperability

X3J3/95-115 Wagener 950424 Results of the TAG Ballot on 95-007

X3J3/95-116 Wagener 950424 Tokyo Papers

X3J3/95-117 Adams 950424 Beaver Run Resort

X3J3/95-118 Ellis 950424 The use of Type 2 Technical Reports to Accelerate Standardization

X3J3/95-119 Wagener 950424 Preamble for Object Initialization Fixes

X3J3/95-120 Wagener 950424 Pointer Initialization Fix

X3J3/95-121 Wagener 950424 Value Initialization Fix: Ch. 14 Only

X3J3/95-122 Wagener 950424 Default Initialization Semantics: Ch. 4

X3J3/95-123r2 Himer 950425 /Parallel Edits to PURE

X3J3/95-124 Himer 950425 /Parallel Responses to 95-103

X3J3/95-125 Rolison 950425 /Interp - Open Interpretation Summary

X3J3/95-126r1 Epstein 950425 /OOF Report on Assignments

X3J3/95-127 Epstein 950425 /OOF PURE and ELEMENTAL Keyword Implementation

X3J3/95-128r1 Whitlock 950425 /JOR - X3J3 Response to Tokyo WG5 Resolution 7

X3J3/95-129 Barber 950425 /Interp Edits from N1112, 5/N1105

X3J3/95-130r1 Barber 950425 /Interp Edits from N1112, 5/N1106

X3J3/95-131r1 Maine 950425 /Edit Responses to 95-103, Batch 1

X3J3/95-132r1 Terpstra 950425 /Parallel - Definition and Undefinition of FORALL Index-names

X3J3/95-133r1 Rolison 950425 /Interp - Update to Defect Item 125, edit in N1112

X3J3/95-134r2 Zongaro 950425 /Parallel - Misc. Edits, N1112, 1.7

X3J3/95-135 Zongaro 950425 /Parallel - WHERE nested in FORALL clarification

X3J3/95-136 Zongaro 950425 /Parallel - ENTRY and PURE

X3J3/95-137r1 Zongaro 950425 /Parallel - Fortran 90 and HPF com- patibility (MAXLOC, MINLOC, et al.)

X3J3/95-138r2 Bierman 950426 /Parallel - Chap. 13 Special Bracket Rule

X3J3/95-139 Rolison 950426 /Interp - Revised Response to Defect Item 127

X3J3/95-140 Hirchert 950426 /Edit - Responses to 95-103, Batch 2

X3J3/95-141 Barber 950426 /Interp - Revised Response to Defect Item 158

X3J3/95-142r1 Barber 950426 /Interp - Revised Response to Defect Item 148

X3J3/95-143 Barber 950426 /Interp - Edit from 95-103 (52)

X3J3/95-144 Barber 950426 /Interp - Revised Response to Defect Item 173

X3J3/95-145r2 Wagener 950426 Public Review of the Fortran 95 Draft Standard

X3J3/95-146r2 Himer 950426 /Parallel Edits to Sec 12.7.3 Elemental Subroutine Arguments

X3J3/95-147 Rolison 950426 /Interp - Disposition of Defect Item 0000e

X3J3/95-148r1 Hirchert 950426 /Edit - Additional Action in Response to 95-103, Item 51

X3J3/95-149r1 Epstein 950426 /OOF - Edits Resulting from 95-103

X3J3/95-150r1 Maine 950426 /Edit - Responses to N1099

X3J3/95-151 O'Gara 950427 Meeting 133 Minutes

X3J3/95-152r1 Maine 950427 /Edit Responses to 95-103, Batch 3

X3J3/95-153r1 Whitlock 950427 /JOR Maintenance of the JOR (95-004)

X3J3/95-154 Barber 950427 /Interp Response to 95-103, Item 41

X3J3/95-155 Barber 950427 /Interp Revised Response to Defect Item 176

X3J3/95-156 Barber 950427 /Interp Response to N1112, 1.4 (Namelist, 95-104)

X3J3/95-157 North 950427 Meeting 133 Treasurer's Report

X3J3/95-158 Barber 950427 /Interp Bleikamp Comment from N1106

X3J3/95-159r1 Bierman 950427 /Parallel Miscellaneous Edits II

X3J3/95-160 Barber 950427 /Interp Revised Response to Defect Item 186

X3J3/95-161 Rolison 950427 /Interp Fortran 95 Edit from N1112, 1.2

X3J3/95-162 Rolison 950427 /Interp Revised Response to Defect Item 101

X3J3/95-163 Barber 950427 /Interp Revised Response to Defect Item 179

X3J3/95-164r1 Epstein 950427 /OOF Edits for X3J3/95-119 to X3J3/95-122 and X3J3/95-103, Item 44

X3J3/95-165 Epstein 950427 /OOF Edits Resulting from 95-103, (Completion of Items 2 and 47)

X3J3/95-166 Epstein 950427 /OOF Possible OO Direction

X3J3/95-167 Epstein 950427 /OOF CCF is not a Preprocessor

X3J3/95-168 O'Gara 950427	/JOR Preliminary Recommendation for Objectives and Approach for Fortran 2000

X3J3/95-169r1 Martin 950428 /00F Edit for X3J3/95-113

X3J3/95-170 Bierman 950428 Communication from Dick Hendrickson

X3J3/95-171 Dedo 950428 Constraint on DO-variable Index as a Pointer

X3J3/95-172 Martin 950428 /00F Replacement of First Two Edits of X3J3/95-164r1

X3J3/95-173 Dedo 950518 Scribe Notes - Possible Object-Oriented Direction

X3J3/95-174 Shepherd 950613 95-006 Post-Meeting 133 Letter Ballot

X3J3/95-175 Rolison 950622 Interpretation Request SELECTED_REAL_KIND (Defect Item 201)

X3J3/95-176 Shepherd 950629 Defect Item 0000e and Paper 95-147

X3J3/95-177 Shepherd 950711 Defect Item 125 - Arguments with the TARGET attribute

X3J3/95-178 Epstein 950711 CCF Proposed Technical Report Type 2

X3J3/95-179 Levine 950714 Comments on the CCF Proposal

X3J3/95-180 Shepherd 950716 Clarification of Defect Item 155

X3J3/95-181 Shepherd 950717 RFI on Kind Type Parameters and DELIM=

X3J3/95-182 Shepherd 950717 RFI on Evaluation of NINT

X3J3/95-183 Shepherd 950717 Results of the Post Meeting 133 95-006 Letter Ballot

X3J3/95-184 Shepherd 950718 Status of 95-006

X3J3/95-185 Martin 950718 Uninitialized Variables a Requirement for F2000?

X3J3/95-186 Shepherd 950725 Proposed Answer for Defect Item 175

X3J3/95-187 Shepherd 950728 Revision of Defect Item 198

X3J3/95-188r1 /Parallel 950824 Responses to 95-205 (41, 46, and 48) and 95-203 (8, 9, 14, 3)

X3J3/95-189 Shepherd 950810 Proposed JOR Item on New Annex

X3J3/95-190 Hirchert 950817 Public Draft Comments

X3J3/95-191 Martin 950817 Review of Fortran 95/Requirements for Future Fortran Standards

X3J3/95-192 Reid 950818 Enable Technical Report

X3J3/95-193 HPFF 950818 Comments on Proposed Fortran Standard, F95

X3J3/95-194 Zosel 950818 HPFF Detail Comments on Proposed Fortran Standard

X3J3/95-195r2 Smith 950823 Comments on Fortran 95

X3J3/95-196 Shepherd 950821 Revision of Defect Item 083

X3J3/95-197 /Edit 950821 Edits Incorporated in 95-007r1

X3J3/95-198 /Edit 950821 Work to do on 95-007r1

X3J3/95-199 Meltzer 950821 Interlanguage Calling Proposal

X3J3/95-200 Martin 950821 Interlanguage Communication on the NERSC CRAYs

X3J3/95-201 Epstein 950821 Comments on 95-007r1

X3J3/95-202 Epstein 950821 Conditional Compilation Presentation

X3J3/95-203 Zongaro 950821 Concerns about 95-007r1

X3J3/95-204 Whitlock 950821 Three Official US Fortran 95 Comments

X3J3/95-205 Whitlock 950821 IBM Official US Fortran 95 Comments

X3J3/95-206 /Interp 950821 Edits Based on Meissner's E-mail Public Review Comments

X3J3/95-207 Levine 950822 Ideas for Interoperability

X3J3/95-208 Bierman 950822 Standardize Module Processing (Proposed JOR Item)

X3J3/95-209 Bierman 950822 Intrinsic Floating Point Support

X3J3/95-210 /Edit 950822 Editorial Changes to 95-007r1 from Hank Lauson

X3J3/95-211 /Edit 950822 Normative Reference Changes to 95-007r1

X3J3/95-212r1 Hendrickson 950822 ENABLE Discussion

X3J3/95-213 /Interp 950822 Responses to Walt's Public Review Comments

X3J3/95-214r1 /JOR 950823 Preliminary Recommendations for Fortran 2000 Requirements

X3J3/95-215 /OOF 950822 IBM FORALL Comments (#53, #55, #59) - Proposed Technical Edits

X3J3/95-216r1 Hirchert 950822 Public Review Comment Edits #1

X3J3/95-217 Hirchert 950822 Public Review Comments Edits #2

X3J3/95-218r1 /Interp 950823 Analysis of Brian Smith's Public Review Comments

X3J3/95-219 Levine 950823 Interoperability Architecture

X3J3/95-220 Wagener 950823 (X3J3.1995-325) Official Comment on X3J3/95-007r1

X3J3/95-221 Levine 950823 (X3J3.1995-319) Re:Initialization and Static . . .

X3J3/95-222 Meissner 950823 (X3J3.1995-352) Public Draft Comments

X3J3/95-223r1 /Edit 950823 Editorial Changes from Brian Smith Comments, Part 1

X3J3/95-224 US TAG 950823 US TAG Recommendations for Fortran 2000 Requirements

X3J3/95-225r1 /Edit 950823 Responses to IBM Comment #1

X3J3/95-226r1 /Edit 950823 ENTRY vs. PURE and ELEMENTAL

X3J3/95-227r1 /Parallel 950823 Misc. Responses to Public Comments

X3J3/95-228r1 /Parallel 950823 Responses to 95-203

X3J3/95-229r1 /Edit 950823 Misc. Edits Proposed by BTS

X3J3/95-230r1 /Edit 950823 Misc. Editorial Changes

X3J3/95-231r1 /Interp 950823 More Replies to Comments from Brian Smith

X3J3/95-232 /Interp 950823 Brian Smith's Public Review Comments, Round 2 of ?

X3J3/95-233r2 /OOF 950823 Responses to IBM Comments, Part 1 (#1 thru #50)

X3J3/95-234r1 /OOF 950823 IBM Comments #51 to #75(OOF Response)

X3J3/95-235 Bierman 950823 Asynchronous I/O

X3J3/95-236 Bierman 950823 PRIVATE and SHARED Variables for TASK Parallelism

X3J3/95-237r1 Wagener 950823 Improving the TR Process in the Context of the Strategic Plan

X3J3/95-238r1 Hirchert 950824 USE Clarification

X3J3/95-239 Hirchert 950824 Alternative Response to Defect Item 155

X3J3/95-240r1 /OOF 950824 Response to IBM Comments #76 to #156

X3J3/95-241 Dedo,Warnock 950824 /JOR Item on Asynchronous I/O

X3J3/95-242 /Interp 950824 Response to IBM Comments 26,27,36,38

X3J3/95-243r1 /Interp 950824 Brian Smith's Public Review Comments, Rest of Round 2

X3J3/95-244 /Interp 950824 Revision of Defect Item 81

X3J3/95-245r1 /Edit 950824 More Items from Smith Comments

X3J3/95-246 Hirchert 950824 Revised Response to Defect Item 179

X3J3/95-247r1 Bierman 950824 RFI on Evaluation of Functions

X3J3/95-248 North 950830 Meeting 134 Treasurer's Report

X3J3/95-249r1 Dedo Meeting 134 Minutes

X3J3/95-250 Shepherd 950905 006 Post-Meeting 134 Letter Ballot

X3J3/95-251 Purnell 950908 Deficiencies in Fortran 90

X3J3/95-252 Shepherd 950921 RFI from Micheal Hennecke on Intrinsic Procedures

X3J3/95-253 Shepherd 951002 Response to IBM Comment on Fortran 95

X3J3/95-254 Shepherd 951004 RFI from Micheal Hennecke on Scope of Operators and Assignment

X3J3/95-255 Hendrickson 951005 Proposed Responses to HPFF Comments (193, 194)

X3J3/95-256 Shepherd 951009 Results of the Post Meeting 134 006 Letter Ballot

X3J3/95-257 Epstein 951026 Conditional Compilation: The Fcc Approach

X3J3/95-258 Wagener 951027 Draft Response to Marshall Comment Letter

X3J3/95-259 Wagener 951027 Draft Response to Helmers Comment Letter

X3J3/95-260 Dedo 951028 Evaluation of Intrinsic Procedures, Interpretation 202

X3J3/95-261 Shepherd 951030 95-006 Status

X3J3/95-262 Rolison 951103 Letter Ballot Voting Record

X3J3/95-263 Wagener 951113 F95 CD Edits Delegated to X3J3

X3J3/95-264 Wagener 951113 Fortran 2000 Requirements

X3J3/95-265 Wagener 951113 Fortran 2000 Requirements Processing at X3J3 Meeting 135

X3J3/95-266 Wagener 951113 X3 Subgroup Annual Report

X3J3/95-267 Wagener 951113 Fortran 95 Draft Comments

X3J3/95-268 Wagener 951113 Helmers Public Comment

X3J3/95-269 Wagener 951113 US National Activity Report

X3J3/95-270 Wagener 951113 X3J3 Responses to WG5 Tokyo Resolutions

X3J3/95-271 Wagener 951113 Asynch I/O Proposal

X3J3/95-272 Wagener 951113 ISO Data Type Enhancements in Fortran

X3J3/95-273 Wagener 951113 Strategic Plan for Fortran Standardization

X3J3/95-274 Wagener 951113	WG5 Procedures for the Future Development of Urgent New Features in Fortran by Means of Type 2 Technical Reports

X3J3/95-275 Wagener 951113 WG5 San Diego Resolutions (S45a)

X3J3/95-276 Wagener 951113 Assignments for X3J3 Meeting 135

X3J3/95-277r2 Reid 951113 Floating Point Exceptions

X3J3/95-278 Maine 951113 WG5 N1153 - Responses to Fortran 95 CD Ballot

X3J3/95-279 Epstein 951113 Specifications and Requirements for CoCo

X3J3/95-280 Epstein 951113 Recognizing the Fortran INCLUDE for CoCo

X3J3/95-281 Shepherd 951113 95-006r4 Status Changes per the WG5 Meeting

X3J3/95-282 /Interp 951113 F95 Edits for Defect Item 000155, Alternative Response

X3J3/95-283r1 Wagener 951113 X3J3 Responses to the WG5 San Diego Resolutions

X3J3/95-284 /Interp 951114 Edits to Fortran 95 for Defect Item 81

X3J3/95-285 /Interp 951114 Edits to Fortran 95 for Defect Item 125

X3J3/95-286r1 /Interp 951114 Some of the Edits for F95 from Pending Defect Items

X3J3/95-287 /Interp 951114 Deferred Items 213:11-12, 18+, 27, 30

X3J3/95-288r1 Wagener 951114 Liaison Report on Parameterized Derived Types

X3J3/95-289r2 /Interp 951114 Definition for Direct Component

X3J3/95-290 /Interp 951114 F95 Edits for Defect Item 000155

X3J3/95-291r1 /Interp 951114 F95 CD Edit [WG5-S51,S28] Delegated to X3J3

X3J3/95-292r1 /JOR 951115 Default Real and Double Precision DO Variables in I/O

X3J3/95-293r1 /Interop 951115 X3J3 Liaison Report on Interoperability

X3J3/95-294 Zongaro 951115 Draft Interoperability TR (S6)

X3J3/95-295 Zongaro 951115 HPF Calling C Interoperability Proposal

X3J3/95-296r2 Epstein 951115 X3J3 Liaison Report on Conditional Compilation

X3J3/95-297r2 /JOR 951115 Proposed Responses to the Public Comments

X3J3/95-298 /JOR 951115 Items for Inclusion in X3J3/95-008

X3J3/95-299 /JOR 951115 Request for Interpretation

X3J3/95-300 Clodius 951115 PFR on Flexible Accessibility

X3J3/95-301r1 /Interp 951115 Supplement to Edits in 92-287

X3J3/95-302 /Interp 951115 BOZ Literal Constants and N1135 Comments

X3J3/95-303r1 /Interp 951115 Interp 145 Edits Translated to Fortran 95 Draft

X3J3/95-304r1 /Interp 951115 Response to Defect Item 179

X3J3/95-305r1 /Interp 951115 New Answer for Defect Item 000194

X3J3/95-306r1 /Interp 951115 Replacement for Defect Item 000100

X3J3/95-307r1 /Parallel 951115 X3J3 Liaison Report on Floating Point Exception Handling TR

X3J3/95-308r1 /Parallel 951115 X3J3 Liaison Report on Allocatable Components TR

X3J3/95-309 Maine 951116 Proposed 95-007r2 Contents

X3J3/95-310r1 /Interp 951116 Revised Defect Item 185 (To Match F95 Edits)

X3J3/95-311r1 /Interp 951116 Note on Elemental Actual Argument Restriction

X3J3/95-312r1 /JOR 951116 Liaison Report on Requirements for Fortran 2000

X3J3/95-313 North 951117 Meeting 135 Treasurer's Report

X3J3/95-314 Dedo 951117 Meeting 135 Minutes

X3J3/95-315 Rolison 951127 Meeting 135 Agenda

X3J3/95-316 Shepherd 951126 006 Items with Status "WG5 Approved; Ready for X3J3"

Appendix C

Future Meetings and Distribution Assignments

Meeting conventions:

- 4 meetings per year

- attempt to schedule second full week of month

- attempt to schedule meetings back to back with WG5 meetings

At meeting 135, the committee considered meeting primarily in Las Vegas, NV for 3 out of the 4 meetings next year. However, no hotel arrangements had been made with any Las Vegas venue by the close of the meeting so the tentative hosts are still listed below for the 1996 meetings. If the February, May, and November meetings are held in Las Vegas, they tentatively will be held the same weeks as the meeting dates shown below. David Levine has not yet been contacted about hosting the July/August meeting, but since he has offered several times in the recent past to host a meeting, he is the current tentative host for that meeting, subject to his approval and ability/willingness to host. Also, if the May meeting takes place in Champaign-Urbana, Kurt has notified the committee that the date may need to be changed so as not to conflict with graduation at the university.

136 February 12-16, 1996 - Albuquerque, NM (Brainerd, tentative host)

Pre-meeting distribution deadline:

Pre-meeting distribution: Rolison, Cray Research

Post-meeting distribution: Shepherd, IBM

137 May 13-17, 1996 - Champaign-Urbana, IL (Hirchert, tentative host)

Pre-meeting distribution deadline:

Pre-meeting distribution: Smith, UNM

Post-meeting distribution: Terpstra, Princeton

138 August 12-16, 1996 -

Pre-meeting distribution deadline:

Pre-meeting distribution: Wagener, self

Post-meeting distribution: Warnock, LANL

Barber: European Based

Excused: Brainerd, Dedo, Epstein, Hendrickson, Martin

List for Distribution Recipients:

Agenda and meeting notice sent to:

Principals

Alternates

Observers, consultants, liaisons

WG5/ISO members

Interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or email

REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 Weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3)

Pre and post meeting distribution sent to:

Principals

FEW additional others:

Alternates that wish to receive the material

Active participants, such as former members, that specifically ask to receive the material

REQUIREMENT: Distribution of Pre-Meeting 2 Weeks before meeting

(documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1)

Minutes sent to (required by X3):

Principals

Alternates

Observers, consultants, liaisons

REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 Weeks Following Meeting Adjournment (SD-2 4.2.5, 4.3.6)

Appendix D

Committee Organization

D.1	Officers

Chair	J. Wagener

Vice Chair	L. Rolison

International Rep	Open

Secretary	C. Dedo (acting)

Treasurer	M. North

Librarian	M. North

Editor	R. Maine

Maintenance	J. Shepherd

Vocabulary Rep.	K. Hirchert

D.2	Subgroups

X3J3/Interp:	F90 defect management, responsible for document 006

R. Bleikamp, G. Barber, L. Rolison, J. Shepherd (head)

X3J3/JOR:	Journal of Requirements for 1995, responsible for document 004

J. Adams, W. Brainerd, C. Dedo, S. Whitlock (head)

X3J3/Edit:	prepare the draft standard, responsible for documents 007 and 008

K. Hirchert, R. Maine (head), M. North

X3J3/Parallel:	parallel computing, responsible for coordinating with X3H5 and HPFF;

Exception Handling Technical Report

K. Bierman, R. Hendrickson (head), T. Terpstra

X3J3/OOF:	Object-Oriented Fortran - Data Enhancements Technical Report

D. Epstein, D. Levine (head), J. Martin

X3J3/Interop	Interoperability with other languages - Interop Technical Report

H. Zongaro

The subgroups were temporarily rearranged at this meeting to consider public review comments, exception handling, interoperability, etc.

Appendix E

Membership Summary

Meeting #	22	23	24	25	26	27	28	29	30	31	32	33	34	35

Location	WA	CT	FL	IL	BE	NM	CA	NV	ED	MA	TX	HI	CO	CA

Date	08	11	02	05	07	11	02	05	08	11	01	04	08	11

92	92	93	93	93	93	94	94	94	94	95	95	95	95

Name	Affiliation

Barber, Graham	Edinburgh	R	R	A	A**	R**	R	A	R	R	V	A	V	A**	V

Bierman, Keith	Sun	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V

Bleikamp, Rich	CONVEX	V	V	V	V	A	V	A**	V	A**	V	V	A	V	V

Brainerd, Walt	Unicomp	V	V	A	A**	R**	V	R	V	R	A	V	R	V	V

Bush, Bruce	Lahey	R	R	R	R	R	R	R	R	A	R	A**	V	/a**	V

Dedo, Craig	P	V	V	A	V	V	V	V	V

Epstein, David	P	V	V	V

Hendrickson, Dick	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	A	V	A**	V	V

Himer, Jim	Esso Canada	A	V	A**	V	A**	V	A**	V	A**	V	A**	V	A**	Q

Hirchert, Kurt	Univ. Illinois	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V

Levine, David	HP	R	R	R	R	R	V	V	V	A	V	V	A	V	A**

Martin, Jeanne	Livermore	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V

Maine, Richard	NASA	V	V	A	V	V	A	V	V	A	V	V	V	V	V

North, Mallory	Rose-Hulman Inst	V	V	V	V	A	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V

Oglesby, Jose	Microsoft	R	A	R	R	A	V	V	A	V	V	A	V	A**	A***

Rolison, Larry	Cray Research	R	R	R	V	V	V	V	V	R	V	V	V	V	V

Shepherd, Janice	IBM	R	R	R	R	R	R	V	V	V	V	V	R	V	V

Smith, Brian	UNM	R	R	A	R	A**	R	R	R	A	R	R	V	A	A**

Terpstra, Ted	Princeton	I	V	V	V	A	V	V	V	A	V	E	V	V	V

Wagener, Jerry	Amoco	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V

Warnock, Tony	LANL	P	V	A	V	V

Whitlock, Stan	DEC	A	V	V	V	A	V	V	V	A	V	V	V	V	V

V present and voting

R absent but represented

A absent and not represented

P present but not voting

E excused

Q resigned

** missed 2 of last 3 meetings

*** LOST membership

Total Membership at end of Meeting: 20

Total Members Attended or Represented: 18

Total Attendees: 22

Changes since Meeting 134

Lost Members:

Jose Oglesby (Microsoft)

James Himer (Exxon)

New Members:

(none)

Alternates Representing principals at meeting:

(none)

Nonvoting Alternates present:

Jeanne Adams (alternate to Walt Brainerd)

Tom Lahey (alternate to Bruce Bush)

Henry Zongaro (alternate to Janice Shepherd)

Visitors at Meeting:

John Reid

Prospective Members (Observer Meeting)

(None)

Appendix F

X3J3 Membership

-------------------------

PRINCIPALS

-------------------------

Graham Barber

Edinburgh Portable Compilers, Ltd.

17 Alva Street

Edinburgh EH2 4PH

SCOTLAND

Email: gra@epc.ed.ac.uk

Phone: 44 31 225 6262

Fax: 44 31 225 6644

Alternate: G. E. Millard

-------------------------

Keith H. Bierman

Sun Microsystems, Inc.

SunSoft Developer Products

2550 Garcia

UMPK16-304

Mountain View CA 94043

Email: keith.bierman@sun.com

Phone: (415) 786-9296

Fax: (415) 336-7473

Alternate: Michael Ingrassia

-------------------------

Richard Bleikamp

CONVEX Computer Corporation

3000 Waterview Parkway

P. O. Box 833851

Richardson TX 75083-3851

Email: bleikamp@convex.com

Phone: (214) 497-4133

Fax: (214) 497-4500

Alternate: Presley Smith

-------------------------

Walter S. Brainerd

Unicomp Inc.

1874 San Bernardino Ave NE

Albuquerque NM 87122

Email: walt@fortran.com

Phone: (505) 275-0800

Fax: (505) 856-1501

Alternate: Jeanne Adams, Charles Ritz

-------------------------

Bruce Bush

Lahey Computer Systems Inc.

865 Tahoe Blvd

Suite 204

P. O. Box 6091

Incline Village NV 89450-6091

Email: fortran@lahey.com

Phone: (702) 831-2500

Fax: (702) 831-8123

Alternate: Tom Lahey

-------------------------

Craig T. Dedo

17130 W. Burleigh Place

Brookfield WI 53005

Email: Craig.Dedo@mixcom.com

Phone: (414) 783-5869

-------------------------

David Epstein

Imagine1

P.O. Box 250

Sweet Home OR 97386

Email: david@imagine1.com

Phone: (503) 383-4846

-------------------------

Richard A. Hendrickson

50 Melbourne Ave SE

Minneapolis MN 55414

Email: rah@vz.cis.umn.edu

Phone: (612) 378-9694

-------------------------

Kurt W. Hirchert

University of Illinois

152 Computing Applications Bldg.

605 East Springfield Avenue

Champaign IL 61820

Email: hirchert@ncsa.uiuc.edu

Phone: (217) 333-8093

Fax: (217) 244-2909

Alternate: Murray Freeman

-------------------------

David R. Levine

Hewlett-Packard Company

MS CHR-02-DC

Massachusetts Language Lab.

300 Apollo Drive

Chelmsford MA 01824

Email: drlevine@apollo.hp.com

Phone: (508) 436-4015

Fax: (508) 436-5135

-------------------------

Richard Maine

NASA Dryden

M/S D-2033

P.O. Box 273

Edwards CA 93523

Email: maine@altair.dfrc.nasa.gov

Phone: (805) 258-3316

Fax: (805) 258-3567

Alternate: Bruce Martin

-------------------------

Dr. C. Mallory North, Jr.

Professor of Mechanical Engineering

Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology

5500 Wabash Ave.

Campus Box 150

Terre Haute IN 47803

Email: Charles.M.North@Rose-Hulman.Edu

Phone: (812) 877-8216

Fax: (812) 877-3198

Alternate: Jerry Fine

-------------------------

Larry Rolison

Cray Research Inc.

655F Lone Oak Dr.

Eagan MN 55121

Email: lrr@cray.com

Phone: (612) 683-5807

Fax: (612) 683-5307

Alternate: Jon Steidel

-------------------------

Janice Shepherd

IBM

P.O. Box 704

Yorktown Heights NY 10598

Email: janshep@watson.ibm.com

Phone: (914) 784-6313

Fax: (914) 784-6306

Alternate: Henry Zongaro

-------------------------

Brian T. Smith

University of New Mexico

Computer Science Dept.

339 Farris Engineering Center

Albuquerque NM 87131

Email: smith@unmvax.cs.unm.edu

Phone: (505) 277-5500

Fax: (505) 277-0813

Alternate: Jeanne T. Martin

-------------------------

Ted Terpstra

General Atomics

Building 13 / Room 514

San Diego CA 92121-1194

Email: terpstra@gav.gat.com

Phone: (619) 455-4188

-------------------------

Jerrold L. Wagener

Amoco Tulsa Technology Center

4502 East 41st Street

P. O. Box 3385

Tulsa OK 74102

Email: jwagener@ionet.net

Phone: (918) 660-3978

Alternate: Rex Page

-------------------------

Tony Warnock

Los Alamos National Lab.

MS B265

CIC-3

P.O. Box 1663

Los Alamos NM 87545

Email: ttw@lanl.gov

Phone: (505) 667-2225

-------------------------

Stan Whitlock

Digital Equipment Corp.

ZK02-3/N30

110 Spit Brook Road

Nashua NH 03062

Email: whitlock@tle.enet.dec.com

Phone: (603) 881-2011

Fax: (603) 881-0120

Alternate: Keith Kimball

-------------------------

ALTERNATES

-------------------------

Jeanne C. Adams

NCAR

Scientific Computing Division

P.O. Box 3000

Boulder CO 80307

Email: jeanne@ncar.ucar.edu

Phone: (303) 497-1275

Fax: (303) 497-1137

Alternate to: Walt Brainerd

-------------------------

Jerry Fine

Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology

Dept. of Mechanical Engineering

5500 Wabash Ave.

Campus Box 159

Terre Haute IN 47803

Email: fine@Rose-Hulman.edu

Phone: (812) 877-1511

Fax: (812) 877-3198

Alternate to: C. Mallory North

-------------------------

Murray F. Freeman

FOSI Limited

P.O. Box 184

Paupack PA 18451-0184

Email: x3t2mf@delphi.com

Phone: (717) 857-0658

Fax: (717) 857-1378

Alternate to: Kurt Hirchert

-------------------------

Michael Ingrassia

Sun Microsystems, Inc.

SunSoft Developer Products

2550 Garcia

UMPK16-304

Mountain View CA 94043

Email: michael.ingrassia@sun.com

Phone: (415) 786-8998

Fax: (415) 786-9551

Alternate to: Keith Bierman

-------------------------

Keith Kimball

Digital Equipment Corp.

ZK02-3/N30

110 Spit Brook Road

Nashua NH 03062

Email: kimball@tle.enet.dec.com

Phone: (603) 881-0120

Fax: (603) 881-0120

Alternate to: Stan Whitlock

-------------------------

Tom Lahey

Lahey Computer Systems Inc.

865 Tahoe Blvd

Suite 204

P. O. Box 6091

Incline Village NV 89450-6091

Email: tlahe@lahey.com

Phone: (702) 831-2500

Fax: (702) 831-8323

Alternate to: Bruce Bush

-------------------------

Bruce A. Martin

Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider

Build 911-C

Brookhaven National Laboratory

Upton NY 11973

Email: bam@bnl.gov

Phone: (516) 282-5647

Alternate to: Richard Maine

-------------------------

Jeanne T. Martin

Lawrence Livermore Natl. Lab.

7000 East Avenue

P. O. Box 808

L-300

Livermore CA 94550

Email: jtm@llnl.gov

Phone: (510) 422-3753

Fax: (510) 423-8704

Alternate to: Brian Smith

-------------------------

G. E. Millard

Edinburgh Portable Compilers, Ltd.

17 Alva Street

Edinburgh EH2 4PH

SCOTLAND

Email: geoff@epc.ed.ac.uk

Phone: 011 44 31 225 6262

Fax: 011 44 31 225 6644

Alternate to: Graham Barber

-------------------------

Rex L. Page

School of Computer Science

University of Oklahoma

200 Felgar Street - Room 114

Norman OK 73109

Email: rlpage@mailhost.ecn.uoknor.edu

Phone: (405) 325-4397

Fax: (405) 325-4044

Alternate to: Jerry Wagener

-------------------------

Charles Ritz

Fortran Journal

P.O. Box 4201

Fullerton CA 92634

Phone: (714) 441-2022

Alternate to: Walt Brainerd

-------------------------

Presley Smith

CONVEX Computer Corporation

3000 Waterview Parkway

P. O. Box 833851

Richardson TX 75083-3851

Email: psmith@convex.com

Phone: (214) 497-4545

Fax: (214) 497-4500

Alternate to: Richard Bleikamp

-------------------------

Jon Steidel

Cray Research Inc.

655F Lone Oak Drive

Eagan MN 55121

Email: jls@cray.com

Phone: (612) 683-5734

Fax: (612) 683-5307

Alternate to: Larry Rolison

-------------------------

Henry Zongaro

IBM Canada Ltd.

3T/123/1150/TOR

1150 Eglinton Avenue East

North York Ontario M3C 1H7

CANADA

Email: zongaro@vnet.ibm.com

Phone: (416) 448-6044

Fax: (416) 448-6057

Alternate to: Janice Shepherd

-------------------------

OBSERVERS

-------------------------

Bor Chan

NERSC

Lawrence Livermore National Lab.

University of California

P. O. Box 5509

L-560

Livermore CA 94550

Phone: (415) 422-4017

-------------------------

L. M. Delves

N.A. Software Ltd.

Roscoe House

62 Roscoe Street

Liverpool L1 9DW

ENGLAND

-------------------------

David Mattoon

1547 North Sheridan Road

Lake Forest IL 60045

Email: dmattoon@ix.netcom.com

Phone: (312) 567-4716

-------------------------

Lindsey Savage

University of Manchester

Manchester Computer Centre

Oxford Road Computer Building

Manchester M13 9PL

UNITED KINGDOM

Phone: 061 273 7121

-------------------------

Hideo Wada

Software Division

Fujitsu Limited

140 Miyamoto

Numazu-shi Shizuoka 410-03

JAPAN

Email: wada@lp.nm.fujitsu.co.jp

Phone: (0559) 23-2222

-------------------------

OMC Secretary

CBEMA

Suite 200

1250 Eye Street NW

Washington D.C. 20005

Phone: (202) 737 8888

-------------------------

LIAISONS

-------------------------

Ingemar Dahlstrand

DNA/LTH

Box 118

Lund S-22100

SWEDEN

Email: ingo@dna.lth.se

-------------------------

Jeffrey Fried

Informix, Inc.

4100 Bohannon Drive

Menlo Park CA 94025

Email: jfried@informix.com

Phone: (415) 926-6893

-------------------------

John Hill

Unisys Corporation

M/S E8-134

P.O. Box 500

Blue Bell PA 19424-0001

Email: jhill@corp.bb.unisys.com

Phone: (215) 986-4565

-------------------------

Kalman Janko

CSENGERY 59 - 11 117

Budapest 1067

HUNGARY

-------------------------

Rochelle Lauer

Director

Yale University High Energy Computing Facility

512 Gibbs Physics Laboratory

260 Whitney Avenue

P. O. Box 6666

New Haven CT 06511-8167

Email: lauer@yalehep

Phone: (203) 432-3366

-------------------------

Hiroshi Matsuo

Software Works

Hitachi Ltd.

5030 Totsuka-cho Totsuka-ku

Yokohama-shi 244

JAPAN

Phone: 011 81 45 824-2311

-------------------------

Meinolf Munchhausen

D ST SP314

Seimens AG

D-8000

Munchen 83

GERMANY

-------------------------

David T. Muxworthy

EUCS

University Library

George Square

Edinburgh EH8 9LJ

SCOTLAND

Email: d.t.muxworthy@edinburgh.ac.uk

Phone: 011 44 31 650 3305

-------------------------

K. H. Rotthauser

GMD

Schloss Birlinghoven

D-5205

St. Augustin 1

GERMANY

-------------------------

Graham Warren

Dept. 31/123/844/TOR

IBM Canada

844 Don Mills Road

Don Mills Ontario M3C 1W3

CANADA

-------------------------

UNOFFICIAL OBSERVERS

-------------------------

Joanne Brixius

Cray Research Inc.

655F Lone Oak Dr.

Eagan MN 55121

Email: jbrixius@cray.com

Phone: (612) 683-5873

-------------------------

James T. Himer

339 Woodside Bay S.W.

Calgary Alberta T2W 3K9

CANADA

Email: jthimer@iras.uc

lgary.ca

Phone: (403) 237-4215

Fax: (403) 237-2907

-------------------------

Linda O'Gara

Microsoft

One Microsoft Way

Redmond WA 98052

Email: lindaog@microsoft.com

Phone: (206) 936-6575

Fax: (206) 936-7329

Alternate to: Jose Oglesby

-------------------------

John Reid

Atlas Centre

Rutherford Appleton Laboratory

Oxon OX11 0QX

ENGLAND

Email: jkr@letterbox.rl.ac.uk

Phone: 011 44 235 44 6493

Fax: 011 44 235 44 5808

-------------------------