<html xmlns:o="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:office"
xmlns:x="urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:excel"
xmlns="http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-html40">
<head>
<meta http-equiv=Content-Type content="text/html; charset=windows-1252">
<meta name=ProgId content=Excel.Sheet>
<meta name=Generator content="Microsoft Excel 11">
<link rel=File-List href="combined_files/filelist.xml">
<link rel=Edit-Time-Data href="combined_files/editdata.mso">
<link rel=OLE-Object-Data href="combined_files/oledata.mso">
<!--[if gte mso 9]><xml>
<o:DocumentProperties>
<o:Author>David Muxworthy</o:Author>
<o:LastAuthor>David Muxworthy</o:LastAuthor>
<o:LastPrinted>2010-01-15T15:54:46Z</o:LastPrinted>
<o:Created>2010-01-15T14:46:46Z</o:Created>
<o:LastSaved>2010-01-18T12:09:47Z</o:LastSaved>
<o:Company>University of Edinburgh</o:Company>
<o:Version>11.6568</o:Version>
</o:DocumentProperties>
</xml><![endif]-->
<style>
<!--table
{mso-displayed-decimal-separator:"\.";
mso-displayed-thousand-separator:"\,";}
@page
{margin:.39in .35in .59in .35in;
mso-header-margin:.39in;
mso-footer-margin:.51in;
mso-page-orientation:landscape;}
.font9
{color:windowtext;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-weight:400;
font-style:normal;
text-decoration:none;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;}
.font10
{color:windowtext;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-weight:700;
font-style:italic;
text-decoration:none;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;}
tr
{mso-height-source:auto;}
col
{mso-width-source:auto;}
br
{mso-data-placement:same-cell;}
.style0
{mso-number-format:General;
text-align:general;
vertical-align:bottom;
white-space:nowrap;
mso-rotate:0;
mso-background-source:auto;
mso-pattern:auto;
color:windowtext;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-weight:400;
font-style:normal;
text-decoration:none;
font-family:Arial;
mso-generic-font-family:auto;
mso-font-charset:0;
border:none;
mso-protection:locked visible;
mso-style-name:Normal;
mso-style-id:0;}
td
{mso-style-parent:style0;
padding-top:1px;
padding-right:1px;
padding-left:1px;
mso-ignore:padding;
color:windowtext;
font-size:10.0pt;
font-weight:400;
font-style:normal;
text-decoration:none;
font-family:Arial;
mso-generic-font-family:auto;
mso-font-charset:0;
mso-number-format:General;
text-align:general;
vertical-align:bottom;
border:none;
mso-background-source:auto;
mso-pattern:auto;
mso-protection:locked visible;
white-space:nowrap;
mso-rotate:0;}
.xl24
{mso-style-parent:style0;
vertical-align:top;}
.xl25
{mso-style-parent:style0;
text-align:left;
vertical-align:top;}
.xl26
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-weight:700;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
text-align:center;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
.xl27
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-weight:700;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
text-align:center;
vertical-align:top;}
.xl28
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-size:9.0pt;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
mso-number-format:"\@";
text-align:left;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
.xl29
{mso-style-parent:style0;
color:black;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
mso-number-format:"\@";
text-align:left;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
.xl30
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
text-align:left;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
.xl31
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
text-align:left;
vertical-align:top;}
.xl32
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-weight:700;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
.xl33
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
.xl34
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
vertical-align:top;}
.xl35
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-weight:700;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
white-space:normal;}
.xl36
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
white-space:normal;}
.xl37
{mso-style-parent:style0;
font-family:Arial, sans-serif;
mso-font-charset:0;
mso-number-format:"\@";
text-align:left;
vertical-align:top;
white-space:normal;}
-->
</style>
<!--[if gte mso 9]><xml>
<x:ExcelWorkbook>
<x:ExcelWorksheets>
<x:ExcelWorksheet>
<x:Name>combined</x:Name>
<x:WorksheetOptions>
<x:FitToPage/>
<x:FitToPage/>
<x:Print>
<x:FitHeight>3</x:FitHeight>
<x:ValidPrinterInfo/>
<x:PaperSizeIndex>9</x:PaperSizeIndex>
<x:Scale>92</x:Scale>
<x:HorizontalResolution>300</x:HorizontalResolution>
<x:VerticalResolution>300</x:VerticalResolution>
<x:Gridlines/>
</x:Print>
<x:Selected/>
<x:Panes>
<x:Pane>
<x:Number>3</x:Number>
<x:ActiveRow>58</x:ActiveRow>
<x:ActiveCol>1</x:ActiveCol>
</x:Pane>
</x:Panes>
<x:ProtectContents>False</x:ProtectContents>
<x:ProtectObjects>False</x:ProtectObjects>
<x:ProtectScenarios>False</x:ProtectScenarios>
</x:WorksheetOptions>
<x:Sorting>
<x:Sort>Clause No Subclause No. Annex</x:Sort>
<x:Sort>Paragraph/ Figure Table/ Note</x:Sort>
</x:Sorting>
</x:ExcelWorksheet>
</x:ExcelWorksheets>
<x:WindowHeight>4365</x:WindowHeight>
<x:WindowWidth>17115</x:WindowWidth>
<x:WindowTopX>240</x:WindowTopX>
<x:WindowTopY>60</x:WindowTopY>
<x:ProtectStructure>False</x:ProtectStructure>
<x:ProtectWindows>False</x:ProtectWindows>
</x:ExcelWorkbook>
<x:ExcelName>
<x:Name>OLE_LINK1</x:Name>
<x:SheetIndex>1</x:SheetIndex>
<x:Formula>=combined!$E$2</x:Formula>
</x:ExcelName>
<x:ExcelName>
<x:Name>Print_Titles</x:Name>
<x:SheetIndex>1</x:SheetIndex>
<x:Formula>=combined!$1:$1</x:Formula>
</x:ExcelName>
</xml><![endif]-->
</head>
<body link=blue vlink=purple>
<table x:str border="1" cellpadding=0 cellspacing=0 width=1078 style='border-collapse:
collapse;table-layout:fixed;width:810pt'>
<col class=xl25 width=64 style='width:48pt'>
<col class=xl25 width=100 style='mso-width-source:userset;mso-width-alt:3657;
width:75pt'>
<col class=xl25 width=80 style='mso-width-source:userset;mso-width-alt:2925;
width:60pt'>
<col class=xl25 width=50 style='mso-width-source:userset;mso-width-alt:1828;
width:38pt'>
<col class=xl24 width=438 style='mso-width-source:userset;mso-width-alt:16018;
width:329pt'>
<col class=xl24 width=218 style='mso-width-source:userset;mso-width-alt:7972;
width:164pt'>
<col class=xl24 width=128 style='mso-width-source:userset;mso-width-alt:4681;
width:96pt'>
<tr height=68 style='height:51.0pt'>
<td height=68 class=xl27 width=64 style='height:51.0pt;width:48pt'>MB</td>
<td class=xl26 width=100 style='width:75pt'>Clause No<br>
Subclause No.<br>
Annex</td>
<td class=xl26 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Paragraph/<br>
Figure Table/ Note</td>
<td class=xl26 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Type of com-<br>ment</td>
<td class=xl27 width=438 style='width:329pt'
x:str="Comment (justification for change by the MB) ">Comment (justification
for change by the MB)<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span></td>
<td class=xl27 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Proposed change by the MB</td>
<td class=xl26 width=128 style='width:96pt'>Secretariat Observations<font
class="font9"><br>
on each comment submitted</font></td>
</tr>
<tr height=306 style='height:229.5pt'>
<td height=306 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:229.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-1</td>
<td class=xl31>general</td>
<td class=xl31></td>
<td class=xl31>ge</td>
<td class=xl32 width=438 style='width:329pt'><a name="OLE_LINK1">Proposed
subset<font class="font9"><br>
In its vote on the Fortran 2008 CD the UK noted that, for well known
reasons, the current standard had not been fully implemented four years after
publication and five years after technical stabilization. Since then it has
become apparent that some major suppliers are unlikely to implement all of
Fortran 2003 but are planning to incorporate some of the new features from
Fortran 2008 according to their customers' requirements.<span
style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>Thus each provider will in effect be
defining its own subset of Fortran 2008.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'>
</span>This negates the principal objective of the standard, viz 'to promote
portability, reliability, maintainability, and efficient execution of Fortran
programs for use on a variety of computing systems'.<br>
<br>
Since full Fortran 2008 compilers are unlikely to be widely available for
the foreseeable future while there is certainly user demand for some of the
new features, the UK proposes that a subset of Fortran 2008 be defined and
standardized.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>This standard should
define the common subset of what is reliably portable in order to provide a
basis for the production of portable programs.<span
style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>Further, it should exclude some or all of
the obsolescent features listed in Annex B.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'>
</span>Where the process of defining it identifies features and restrictions
that are historical, unnecessary and impair portability, they should be
identified and either proposed as changes for a future revision of the
Fortran standard or described in a Technical Report.</font></a></td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>There should be a new project to
define a compatible subset of the language.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=357 style='height:267.75pt'>
<td height=357 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:267.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-2</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>general</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ge</td>
<td class=xl32 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Disposition of coarrays in the
standard<font class="font9"><br>
</font><font class="font10">The comments in this section reflect the
majority, but not the unanimous, opinion of the BSI Fortran panel.</font><font
class="font9"><br>
We have no objections to the coarray proposals themselves although it
appears, given the on-going technical discussions, that they are not yet
sufficiently mature to be standardized.
<br>
<br>
We are however concerned that the coarray model is not sufficiently general
for standardization and it is not obvious that it is the best model for
Fortran to adopt for the longer term.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'>
</span>We would prefer a more architecture-neutral model so as to allow for
future architectural developments. <br>
<br>
Moreover it is far from clear that the Fortran programmer who has need of
parallel computation facilities would prefer coarrays to more established
alternative systems such as MPI.<br>
<br>
These points lead to the conclusion that coarrays should be not be in the
base language but should be developed separately as an optional feature,
either as a Technical Report or as an optional part of the standard.</font></td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Coarrays should be developed
separately as an optional feature.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=289 style='height:216.75pt'>
<td height=289 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:216.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-3</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>general</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>te</td>
<td class=xl35 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Delete arithmetic IF<br>
<font class="font9">The arithmetic IF should be deleted in order to help
reduce redundancy in the language.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>It
was classed as obsolescent in Fortran 90 and in subsequent standards.<span
style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>The words in 8.2.4,<br>
<br>
<dir> Execution of an arithmetic IF statement causes evaluation of the numeric
expression followed by a branch. The branch target statement identified by
the first label, the second label, or the third label is executed next
depending on whether the value of the numeric expression is less than zero,
equal to zero, or greater than zero, respectively. <br>
</dir> <br>
are incorrect when the expression has a NaN value since this is not less
than zero, not equal to zero and not greater than zero. <br>
<br>
If required in a standard-conforming program, the statement can trivially
be replaced with an IF-construct, using a preprocessor.</font></td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Delete the arithmetic IF
statement</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=68 style='height:51.0pt'>
<td height=68 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:51.0pt;width:48pt'>GB-4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>general</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>It is confusing that STOP
initiates normal termination but the quite similar ALL STOP initiates error
termination.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>We suggest replacing ALL
STOP by a different, stronger, term namely ABORT ALL.<span
style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>The term ALL STOP occurs in 12 places in
the document in total.</td>
<td class=xl34>Rename the ALL STOP statement.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt;mso-yfti-irow:1'>
<td height=17 class=xl28 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>US-2</td>
<td class=xl28 width=100 style='width:75pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Ed</td>
<td class=xl29 width=438 style='width:329pt'><span lang=EN-US>Wordsmithing</span></td>
<td class=xl28 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Details in attached file
09-290r2.txt</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt;mso-yfti-irow:3'>
<td height=17 class=xl28 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>US-4</td>
<td class=xl28 width=100 style='width:75pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Ed</td>
<td class=xl29 width=438 style='width:329pt'><span lang=EN-US>Wordsmithing</span></td>
<td class=xl28 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Details in attached file
09-300r1.txt</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt;mso-yfti-irow:4'>
<td height=17 class=xl28 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>US-5</td>
<td class=xl28 width=100 style='width:75pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl29 width=438 style='width:329pt'><span lang=EN-US>General scoping
fixes</span></td>
<td class=xl28 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Details in attached file
09-302r1.txt</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt;mso-yfti-irow:5;mso-yfti-lastrow:yes'>
<td height=17 class=xl28 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>US-6</td>
<td class=xl28 width=100 style='width:75pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Several</td>
<td class=xl28 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl29 width=438 style='width:329pt'><span lang=EN-US>Scoping unit
fixes for BLOCK construct</span></td>
<td class=xl28 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Details in attached file
09-303r2.txt</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-5</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>1.3.143.2</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>There is a duplicate ‘the’ in
the text.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘the the’ to ‘the’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl28 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>US-1</td>
<td class=xl28 width=100 style='width:75pt'>2.3.5</td>
<td class=xl28 width=80 style='width:60pt'>2-3</td>
<td class=xl28 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl29 width=438 style='width:329pt'><span lang=EN-US>Contradictions
concerning branching and transfer of control</span></td>
<td class=xl28 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Details in attached file
09-289r1.txt</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-6</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>2.3.5</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt'>4,7</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>te</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The current wording
overspecifies error termination in paragraph 4 of 2.3.5 (Execution sequence).</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>See section 1 of accompanying UK
document.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-7</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>2.4.7</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>3</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The use of ‘rectangular pattern’
is unclear; a clarification is proposed.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>See section 2 of accompanying UK
document.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-1</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>2.5.7</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Note 2.16</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"6.5.5.3 of ISO/IEC
9899:1999" should be "6.7.5.3 of ISO/IEC 9899:1999".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-8</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>4.5.3.2</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>2</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The variable names T1, K1, K2,
K3 in the commentary should be in lower case as in the example.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change upper case to lower case.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-9</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>4.5.4.6</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>8</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Example years appear to be out
of date.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘1994’ to ‘2008’ and
‘1995’ to ‘2009’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=68 style='height:51.0pt'>
<td height=68 class=xl31 style='height:51.0pt'>JP-2</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>5.2.1</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>C506</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"<obsolescent>a
statement function,</obsolescent>" should be inserted before
"or an automatic object".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt;mso-yfti-irow:2'>
<td height=17 class=xl28 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>US-3</td>
<td class=xl28 width=100 style='width:75pt'>6.2, 7.2.2.2</td>
<td class=xl28></td>
<td class=xl28 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl29 width=438 style='width:329pt'><span lang=EN-US>Syntax
ambiguity concerning data pointers</span></td>
<td class=xl28 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Details in attached file
09-294.txt</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-3</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>7.1.6.1</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.1</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference of generic
interface, "(4.5.2, 12.4.3.4)", should be "(4.5.5,
12.4.3.4)".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl31 style='height:25.5pt'>JP-4</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>7.1.6.1</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.2, (2), (b)</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference of generic
binding, "(4.5.2)", should be "(4.5.5)".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl31 style='height:25.5pt'>JP-5</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>7.1.6.1</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.5, (2), (b)</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference of generic
binding, "(4.5.2)", should be "(4.5.5)".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-6</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>7.2.1.4</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.1</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference of generic
interface, "4.5.2, 12.4.3.4.3", should be "4.5.5,
12.4.3.4.3".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl31 style='height:25.5pt'>JP-7</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>7.2.1.4</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.2, (2), (b)</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference of generic
binding, "(4.5.2)", should be "(4.5.5)".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-10</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>7.2.2.4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>1</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>There is a duplicate ‘the’ in
the text.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘the the’ to ‘the’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=119 style='height:89.25pt'>
<td height=119 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:89.25pt;width:48pt'>CA-01</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>8.1.4</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'
x:str="there seems no requirement for WAIT statements before the corresponding END BLOCK statement for asynchronous data transfers to complete. ">there
seems no requirement for WAIT statements before the corresponding END BLOCK
statement for asynchronous data transfers to complete.<span
style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span></td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Either disallow the ASYNC
attribute on data in block constructs, or amend the requirement on the wait
statement so that it is required before the block ends when asynchronous data
transfer has been initiated.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-11</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>8.5.4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>te</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The note on SYNC IMAGES is
incorrect.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>See section 3 of accompanying UK
document.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-12</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>8.5.4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The difference between SYNC
IMAGES and SYNC ALL should be clarified.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'>
</span>New text is proposed.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>See section 4 of accompanying UK
document.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-8</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>9.3.4.4</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.6</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"the next position
after" should be inserted before "the highest-numbered
position".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-13</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>9.5.3</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>1</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>te</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Each image has a separate set of
units.<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span>Units are not associated with a
whole program.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change "a program" to
"an image".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-9</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>10.10.4</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.1, 3rd line</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"comma" of "if
the decimal edit mode is comma" should be uppercase like
"COMMA".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-10</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>10.11.3.5</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.1, 3rd item</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"comma" of "if
the decimal edit mode is comma" should be uppercase.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=85 style='height:63.75pt'>
<td height=85 class=xl31 style='height:63.75pt'>JP-11</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>11.2.2</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Note 11.8</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial clarification.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"The above two
constraints" is a little ambiguous and should be changed to <br>
"The constraints C1107 and C1108".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-12</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>12.4.3.4.3</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.1, 2nd line</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference of defined
assignment, "(7.2.1.4)", should be "(7.2.1.4, 7.2.1.5)".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-14</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt' x:num>13.5</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>2</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>te</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Execution of certain intrinsic
procedures is inadequately specified.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>See section 5 of accompanying UK
document.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=119 style='height:89.25pt'>
<td height=119 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:89.25pt;width:48pt'>CA-04</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The behaviour between two images
that execute the following intrinsics cannot be guaranteed.
COMMAND_ARGUMENT_COUNT, <br>
GET_COMMAND,<br>
GET_COMMAND_VARIABLE,<br>
CPU_TIME,<br>
DATE_AND_TIME,<br>
SYSTEM_CLOCK</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>We'd like to specify that it is
processor dependent to the values returned on multiple images using the
listed intrinsics</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-15</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7.44</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt'>3,6</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Example years to be appear out
of date.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘1990’ to ‘2008’ and
‘1985’ to ‘2008’ (three times).</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>CA-03</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7.57</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>It is not stated what the
behaviour is between 2 images that execute<span style='mso-spacerun:yes'>
</span>EXECUTE_COMMAND_LINE concurrently</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>We recommend that this be stated
to be processor dependent.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-16</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7.111</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>6</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The result in the example is
incorrect.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘the value 20’ to ‘the
value 4’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=102 style='height:76.5pt'>
<td height=102 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:76.5pt;width:48pt'>CA-02</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7.135</td>
<td class=xl30></td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>Te</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'
x:str="There is a discussion on random number generator (RANDOM_NUMBER) on multiple images, but is left unstated what the relationship is between cores ">There
is a discussion on random number generator (RANDOM_NUMBER) on multiple
images, but is left unstated what the relationship is between cores<span
style='mso-spacerun:yes'> </span></td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>We prefer that each image be
able to generate random numbers independently, but if this is not possible,
there should be a statement that this is processor dependent.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:38.25pt;width:48pt'>GB-17</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7.150</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>7</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The sample code is incorrect.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘SHIFTA (IBSET (0,
BIT_SIZE (0)), 2)’ to ‘SHIFTA (IBSET (0, BIT_SIZE (0) - 1), 2)’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=51 style='height:38.25pt'>
<td height=51 class=xl31 style='height:38.25pt'>JP-13</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>13.7.157</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Result Value, 2nd line</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"MIN" of the exponent
part should be lowercase.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=85 style='height:63.75pt'>
<td height=85 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:63.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-18</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt' x:num>14.7</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>1</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>It is not clear in clause 14
that each image has its own floating-point status.</td>
<td class=xl36 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Add new note before NOTE
14.6:<br>
<br>
NOTE 14.5a<br>
Each image has its own floating-point status (2.3.4)</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=68 style='height:51.0pt'>
<td height=68 class=xl31 style='height:51.0pt'>JP-14</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>14.7</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.1</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"IEEE_GET_UNDERFLOW_MODE"
and "IEEE_SET_UNDERFLOW_MODE" are missing.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl31 style='height:25.5pt'>JP-15</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>14.11.3</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>Result Value</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>"the value of X"
should be "the absolute value of X".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:25.5pt;width:48pt'>GB-19</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>14.11.24</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>6</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>A space is missing.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Add space between '1989' and
'except'.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-20</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>14.11.26</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>5</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>A space is missing.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Add space between '1989' and
'for'.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-21</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>16.3.1</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt' x:num>3</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The cross reference to 12.4.3.2
is incorrect.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ’12.4.3.2’ to ’12.4.3.4’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-22</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>16.6.5</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt'>1 item (3)</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The word ‘data’ is usually
treated as plural throughout the document.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘data is’ to ‘data are’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=34 style='height:25.5pt'>
<td height=34 class=xl31 style='height:25.5pt'>JP-16</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>16.6.6</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>(16)</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The reference
"(16.5.2.4-16.5.2.5)" should be "(16.5.2.4, 16.5.2.5)".</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=102 style='height:76.5pt'>
<td height=102 class=xl31 style='height:76.5pt'>JP-17</td>
<td class=xl37 width=100 style='width:75pt'>C.6.3</td>
<td class=xl37 width=80 style='width:60pt'>par.10, 3rd line</td>
<td class=xl31>ed</td>
<td class=xl30 width=438 style='width:329pt'>Editorial correction.</td>
<td class=xl30 width=218 style='width:164pt'>The assignment, <br>
" CH2 = '''THIS STRING HAS QUOTES.''' " should be <br>
" CH2 = '"THIS STRING HAS QUOTES."' ". <br>
(Quotation marks should be used.)</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<tr height=17 style='height:12.75pt'>
<td height=17 class=xl30 width=64 style='height:12.75pt;width:48pt'>GB-23</td>
<td class=xl30 width=100 style='width:75pt'>C.11.1</td>
<td class=xl30 width=80 style='width:60pt'>2 bullet 4</td>
<td class=xl30 width=50 style='width:38pt'>ed</td>
<td class=xl33 width=438 style='width:329pt'>The word ‘data’ is usually
treated as plural throughout the document.</td>
<td class=xl33 width=218 style='width:164pt'>Change ‘data is’ to ‘data are’.</td>
<td class=xl34></td>
</tr>
<![if supportMisalignedColumns]>
<tr height=0 style='display:none'>
<td width=64 style='width:48pt'></td>
<td width=100 style='width:75pt'></td>
<td width=80 style='width:60pt'></td>
<td width=50 style='width:38pt'></td>
<td width=438 style='width:329pt'></td>
<td width=218 style='width:164pt'></td>
<td width=128 style='width:96pt'></td>
</tr>
<![endif]>
</table>
</body>
</html>