InterNational Committee for Information Technology Standards (INCITS)
Secretariat: Information Technology Industry Council (ITI)
700 K Street NW, Suite 600, Washington, DC 20001
www.incits.org

INCITS/Fortran Meeting #241 Draft Minutes
INCITS/Fortran Live agenda reference 26-227.pdf

October 20, 22, 26, 28, 2026:
  6:00 PM - 9:00 PM U.S. Eastern Time (UTC-4)

Meeting #241 is a virtual meeting.

Teleconference details are provided for members at:
https://j3-fortran.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=180

I. Tuesday, October 20, 2026 -- 6:00PM - 9:00PM EDT (UTC-4)
--------------------------------------------------------------
   1. Opening Business - R. Budiardja
      a. INCITS Code of Conduct
         http://www.incits.org/standards-information/policies
      b. INCITS Patent Policy and Antitrust
         http://www.incits.org/standards-information/legal-info
      c. Beginning membership report - L. Menard
         1. 26-214.txt
      d. Beginning Treasurer's report -  J. Steidel
         1. 26-199.txt
      e. Approval of draft agenda - R. Budiardja
         1. Reference document:  Fortran-2026-00091-m241-draft-agenda.txt
            Steidel/Klimowiz
            UC
      f. Approval of Meeting #240 minutes - R. Budiardja
         1. Reference document:  Fortran-2026-00089-m240-minutes.txt
            Menard/Steidel
            UC
 
   2. National Items
      1. Liaison reports
         1. INCITS report (if any) - R. Budiardja
            1. None
         2. MPI Liaison report (if any)
            1. Nothing
         3. OpenMP Liaison report (if any) - B. Long
            1. None
         4. flang Liaison report (if any) - M. LeAir
            1. 26-212r2.txt
         5. OpenACC Liaison report (if any) - J. Larkin
            1. None; looking for new liason
         6. fortran-lang/LFortran (if any) - O. Certik
            1. 26-213.txt
 
   3. International Items - S. Lionel
       Comments back and uploaded at 26-195, responses are started.
       Steve will put into a document and send back to ISO, WG5
       Malcolm will have a DIS that will go back to the countries
          for a vote, which takes several months.
       Any comments would be incorporated into a FDIS
 
   4. Other Business - R. Budiardja
      1. Comments from members
      2. Tutorials (if needed)
      3. Subgroup Organization

   5. Plenary - subgroup heads

/Edit
**Motion 26-193 "Typo in CO_SUM_PREFIX_EXCLUSIVE" [Bonachea](Cohen/Raghu)
  UC

--Withdrawn 26-194 "Edit: Relocate constraint C1703" [Bonachea](Cohen/Bonachea)
 
--Discuss 26-205 "Editorial improvement suggestion"

--Discuss 25-204 "Responses to editorial comments JP-1 to JP-14"

/Interp
**Motion 26-200 "Interp F23/021 on pointers in COMMON and SIMPLE procedures"
                [Cohen](Cohen/K. Rasmussen)
  UC
 
--Withdrawn 26-201 "Interp F23/022 on simple procedures and ISO_FORTRAN_ENV"
               [Cohen](Cohen/Bonachea)

--Withdrawn 26-202 "Interp F23/023 on simple functions and the IEEE modules"

**Motion 26-203 "Interp F23/024 on coindexing and SIMPLE procedures" 
               [Cohen](Cohen/Richardson)

/Generic
--Discussion 26-196 "Matching Deferred Procedure Interfaces"

--Discussion 26-197 "Fixing Deferred Kind and Rank Equivalence"

   6. Subgroup reports:

Meeting recessed 8:30PM


II. Thursday, October 22, 2026 -- 6:00PM - 9:00PM EDT (UTC-4)
--------------------------------------------------------------
   1. Tutorials (if needed)
   2. Open Discussion
   3. Plenary - subgroup heads

/JoR
--Withdrawn 26-198 "US-012/013: Edits for OPERATION argument to REDUCE"
                   [Bonachea]

/HPC
--Withdrawn 26-207 "US-016: Mathematical Properties of CO_REDUCE*(OPERATION)"
                  [Bonachea,HPC](Bonachea/Johnson)

--Withdrawn 26-208r1 "US-017: Edits to replace the CO_REDUCE example"
                  [Bonachea,Rouson,HPC](Bonachea/Lionel)
 Straw poll results:
8-> 1. Change current example to something else 
       (and possibly add something to the Annex)  
7-> 2. Change current example to example option A 
       and add nothing to the Annex
4->  3. Leave current example unchanged, with possible prose changes 
       and add Example A in Annex C 
1->  4. Undecided
       

--Withdrawn 26-206 "US-011/014/015: Edits for team queries of invariant state"
                   [Bonachea,Rouson,HPC](Bonachea/Menard)
 
/Edit
**Motion 26-204 "Responses to editorial comments JP-1 to JP-14" 
                [Cohen](Cohen/Clune)
  UC

**Motion 26-201r1 "Editorial paper on simple procedures and ISO_FORTRAN_ENV"
                 [Cohen] (Cohen/Bonachea)
  As amended (to include MAX_RANK, PROCEDURE_NAME, SOURCE_FILE, SOURCE_LINE)
  UC

Meeting recessed 9:00

III. Monday, October 26, 2026 -- 6:00PM - 9:00PM EDT (UTC-4)
--------------------------------------------------------------
   1. Tutorials (if needed)
   2. Open Discussion
   3. Plenary - subgroup heads

/Generic
**Motion 26-196r1 "Matching Deferred Procedure Interfaces" 
                   [Richardson,Generics](Clune/Cohen)
  UC

**Motion 26-197r1 "Fixing Deferred Kind and Rank Equivalence"
                  [Richardson,Generics](Clune/Menard)
  UC

/Edit
**Motion 26-194r1 "Edit: Reorganise 17.6 collective subroutines"
                  [Bonachea,Cohen](Cohen/Bonachea)
 UC

**Motion 26-205 "Editorial improvement suggestion" [Cohen](Cohen/Bonachea)
  As amended to include optional edits
  UC

**Motion 26-202r1 "Editorial improvements for simple functions in 
                    the IEEE modules" [Cohen](Cohen/Maddhipatla)
  UC

/Interp
**Motion 26-209 "Interp F23/025 on IEEE_GET_HALTING_MODE"[Cohen](Cohen/Johnson)
  UC

**Motion 26-210 "Interp F23/026 on IEEE_SCALB" [Cohen](Cohen/Clune)
  As amended to remove edits to N2258
  UC
  ==>Note: Although passed as amended this date, 26-210r2 was reintroduced on
          28-Oct 

**Motion 26-211 "Interp F23/027 on IEEE_SCALB and non-integral scaling"
                 [Cohen](Cohen/Johnson)
  As amended to remove edits to N2258
  UC

/HPC
**Motion 26-207r1 "US-016: Mathematical Properties of CO_REDUCE*(OPERATION)"
                   [Bonachea,HPC](Bonachea/Menard)
  As amended to change "can be" to "is"
  UC

**Motion 26-208r3 "US-017: Edits to replace the CO_REDUCE example"
                  [Bonachea,HPC](Bonachea/Steidel)
  UC

/JoR
**Motion 26-215r1 "Edits to repair PROCEDURE_NAME" 
                  [Bonachea,Menard](Menard/Bonachea)
  UC
  ==> Note: Although passed this date, 26-215r2 was reintroduced on 28-Oct

/Interp
**Motion 26-216 "Interp F23/022 on REDUCE OPERATION result characteristics"
                 [Bonachea,Menard](Cohen/Richardson)
  As amended to fix two typos and wrap correctly.
  UC

**Motion 26-217 "Interp F23/023 on REDUCE OPERATION associativity"
                [Bonachea,Menard](Cohen/Bonachea)
  As amended to wrap correctly
  UC

--Deferred 26-218 "Interp F23/028 on NOTIFY WAIT" [Cohen]

--Deferred 26-219 "Interp F23/028 on NOTIFY_TYPE pointers" [Cohen]

/Edit
--Deferred 26-220r1 "Correcting and improving PROCEDURE_NAME" [Cohen]

   6. Subgroup reports
/Generic
  Done for the meeting

Meeting adjourned 9:00PM EDT

IV. Wednesday, October 28, 2026 -- 6:00PM - 9:00PM EDT (UTC-4)
--------------------------------------------------------------
   1. Plenary - subgroup heads
/HPC
**Motion 26-222 "Edits to replace the NUM_IMAGES example"
                 [S.Rasmussen, HPC](S.Rasmussen/Bonachea)
  UC

**Motion 26-221 "Edits to replace the THIS_IMAGE example" 
                 [S.Rasmussen, HPC](S.Rasmussen/Bonachea)
  As amended 
  UC

**Motion 26-223 "Edits to replace the SYNC ALL example"
                 [S.Rasmussen, HPC](S.Rasmussen/Bonachea)
  As amended
  UC

/Interp
**Motion 26-224 "Interp F23/030 on conditional arguments/expressions"
                 [Cohen](Cohen/Bonachea)
  UC

**Motion 26-210r2 "Interp F23/026 on IEEE_SCALB" [Cohen](Cohen/Steidel)
  UC

**Motion 26-218 "Interp F23/028 on NOTIFY WAIT" [Cohen](Cohen/Johnson)
  As amended
  UC

**Motion 26-219 "Interp F23/028 on NOTIFY_TYPE pointers" [Cohen](Cohen/Steidel)
  As amended
  UC
/JoR

**Motion 26-215r2 "Edits to repair PROCEDURE_NAME"
                  [Bonachea,Menard,JoR](Menard/Richardson)
  UC
/Edit
**Motion 26-220r1 "Correcting and improving PROCEDURE_NAME"[Cohen](Cohen/Clune)
  As amended to include Optional; remove last edit and binding-name reference
  UC

/HPC
**Motion 26-226 "Reject US-011/014/015" [HPC] (Rouson/Lionel)
Required a roll-call vote:
   Y             AMD
   Absent        ARM
   Abstain       Dancing Bear Software
   Abstain       HPE              
   Abstain       IBM Corporation 
   Y             Intel Corporation
   Abstain       Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
   Absent        Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
   Y             Lionel 
   Y             NASA
   Abstain       National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR)
   Y            NVidia Corporation
   Y            Oak Ridge National Labs

  Result:  6 Y;  0 N; 5 Abstain; 2 Absent
  Paper passed

   2. Closing Business
      1. Future meetings - R. Budiardja
         1. m242 Feb 22-25 2027 Hybrid Hosted at Berkeley Labs
            1. Local arrangements: 26-225.pdf
         2 WG5 2027 June 14-18 2027 Bergen, Norway
      2. Ending Treasurer's report -  J. Steidel
         1. 26-199.txt
      3. Closing membership report - L. Menard
         1. 26-214r1.txt
   3. Comments from Members
   4. End of meeting #241

Meeting adjourned 8:50PM