÷Ą; č TeX output 2000.07.31:1455 ’’’’ ©K
ż>ģķī¹ļhtml:ļ html:óKń`y
ó3
cmr10¹3¦fJuly2000 P²!age1ofļhtml:5ļ html:óņ"V
ó3
cmbx10ŗJ3/00-234 £nķī¹ żuģļ4html:ļhtml:ļ html: ¤
¹Sub »ject:Seman²!tics¦foftheselectkindconstructarenotdescribMŽed,anditappearstobea”:VÖmess¦ftouse”F’erom:,`Van¦fSn²!yder”References:ŻŻ98-179,¦fļ%html:00-179ļ html:,ļ%html:00-186ļ html:,ļ%html:00-194ļ html:,ļ%html:00-233ļ html: [śļhtml:ļ html:ėóĀÖN ff cmbx12¼1LĖInĢtros3ductionq¹The9selectkindconstruct,/®apparen²!tlyintendedtobMŽeusedwithinaderivedtypMŽedenitionto”selectdieren²!tspMŽecicprocedurestoin²!vokeusinganob »jectofderiv²!edtypMŽe, śdependingonthe”kind¦äparameters,§isnotdescribMŽedfurtherthanpro²!vidingitssyntax.ßXInparticular,§therelation”bMŽet²!ween¦fselectkind,inheritance,andprocedureo²!verriding¦fisnotdescribed.©F’eurthermore,“·if~§I~ounderstanditcorrectly,“·itisquitecum²!bMŽersometouse.f Supposeonehasa”t²!ypMŽe7;withthreekindparameters,Mwandoneanticipatesthreev’dDaluesforeachofthoseparameters.”IfąoneproMŽcedureisneededforeac²!hcombinationofkindtypMŽeparameterv’dDalues,ļ&thisresultsin”a|requiremen²!ttobind27proMŽcedurestothetypMŽe.`?Itappearstorequire92statemen²!tstodo”so,ĶSusingÅtheselectkindconstruct:%Threenestedselectkindconstructsareneeded.;ITheinner”onesneeds8statemen²!tseach{theSELECTnCASEandENDSELECTstatements,;V3CASE”statemen²!ts,öNandęS3proMŽceduredeclarationstatements.¤Eachmiddleoneenclosesthreeofthese,”and0¢addsv²!emorestatements,S1foratotalof29statementspMŽermiddlelevelcase.|Theouter”one:łhasthreemiddleones,`andaddsv²!emorestatements,`foratotalof92statements.The”propMŽosal|’herew²!ouldallowtouseonestatement{albMŽeitperhapsusingmorethanoneline,
Fbut”not¦f92lines.¦AsÕIunderstandit,»thisisav²!eryclumsyexplicitreplacementfortheautomaticgenericresolution”mec²!hanism.Óm(Actually’e,YtheintentistospMŽecifyhowtogeneratedispatchtables,Ybutthegeneric”mec²!hanism¦fcoulddothatmoreclearly’e.)¦I¤*propMŽoseinthispapertoreplacetheselectkindconstructwiththealready-dev²!elopedgeneric”resolution¦fmec²!hanism.¦This°Żstrategyhasasimpleextensiontot²!ypMŽe-bound°Żdenedassignment,ó{typMŽe-bound°Żdened”opMŽerators,št²!ype-boundĆderived-typeĆinput/outputproMŽcedures(seeļ%html:00-233ļ html:),šandtypMŽe-boundĆnal”proMŽcedures¦f(seeļ%html:00-194ļ html:).Ķļhtml:ļ html:C4¼2LĖSps3ecicationsq¹Sev²!eralųāspMŽecicproceduresma²!ybeboundtoat²!ypeb²!yusingonebindingname.ÕRThespe-”cic×DproMŽceduresboundto(notinheritedin²!to)asingletypMŽe-bound×Dprocedurenameshallbe”distinguishable¦faccordingtotherulesforunam²!biguousgenericproMŽcedurereference(14.1.2.3).¦The3P’eASS Ø/ ff Hųń'OBJÕdeclarationappliestothebindingname,o„andthereb²!ytoallofthespMŽecic”proMŽcedures¬ŗboundtothet²!ype,īOandallofitsextensions,b²!ythatname,sow²!edon'tneedto”w²!orryS¹abMŽoutthecasethatabindingnamehasP’eASS Ø/ ff Hųń'OBJSintheparenttypMŽebutnotinthe”t²!ypMŽe¦fbeingdeclared,orvice-v²!ersa.¦Therulesforo²!verridingarenotm²!uchmoredicultthaninthecaseofnongenerict²!ypMŽe-bound”proMŽcedures.ÕČW’ee&don'tha²!ve&anexplanationfortheseman²!ticsoftheselectkindconstruct, butI”don'tthinkitw²!ouldbMŽesimplerthanthis:©Ifaspecicproceduretobeboundtoat²!ypeb²!ya”particularmbindingnameisnotdistinguishablefromonebMŽoundtotheparen²!tbythesamename,”butwiththet²!ypMŽeofthepassed-ob »jectdummyargumentreplacedbythepresenttypMŽe,8byusing * ©K
ż>ģķī¹ļhtml:ļ html:¹3¦fJuly2000 P²!age2ofļhtml:5ļ html:ŗJ3/00-234 £n żģķī¹¹the¬rulesinsection14.1.2.3,Žito²!verrides¬theoneinheritedfromtheparen²!t.Otherwise,itextends¤
ķī¹the_¶setofproMŽceduresaccessibleb²!yapplyingthegenericprocedureresolutionmec²!hanismtothe”ķī¹binding¦fname.©ķī¹No²!wlĶconsiderproMŽcedureinvoMŽcation.
1DeneatypMŽe-boundlĶgenericinterfaceforatypMŽeand”ķī¹binding nametobMŽethesetofproceduresinheritedforthatbindingnamefromtheparen²!tof”ķī¹the ÷t²!ypMŽe,)@minustheoverriddenones,)@plustheonesdeclaredinthetypMŽe.©øEachproMŽcedureinsuch”ķī¹aŲægenericin²!terfacehasacorrespMŽondingoneineachgenericinterfaceforeachextensiontypMŽe{”ķī¹eitherO«thesameproMŽcedureoronethato²!verridesO«it.Ł¬First,yüoneprocedureisselectedfromthe”ķī¹t²!ypMŽe-boundÖgenericinterfaceforthedeclaredtypMŽeoftheinvokingob »jectandspMŽeciedbinding”ķī¹name,`accordingWūtothegenericresolutionrules.ņThenthecorrespMŽondingprocedurefromthe”ķī¹t²!ypMŽe-boundU¾genericinterfaceforthedynamictypMŽeoftheinvokingob »jectandthesamebinding”ķī¹nameDbisin²!voked.·ŃF’eromDbanimplemen²!torspMŽointofview,kįthereisaseparatedispatchtablefor”ķī¹eac²!h¦fdistinctgenericresolutionofabindingname.ķī¹”Rļhtml:ļ html:Žļ¼3LĖSynĢtaxq¹The]`propMŽosedsyn²!taxtospecifygenerict²!ype-boundproceduresistospecifynon-genericpro-”cedure8%bindingsb²!yusingthePROCEDURE8 statement,\andgenericbindingsbyusinganew”GENERIC|ęstatemen²!t.bThis}hasthedisadv’dDantageofrequiringanewstatement,²Ėandthead-”v’dDan²!tageethattheproMŽcessorcandetectonecaseinwhichonemistakenlyextendsthegenericset”instead¦fofo²!verriding¦fanon-genericbinding{thecasewhenthenameisalreadynon-generic.¦The¦fPR²!OCEDUREstatementisunchanged,andtheóż ':
ó3
cmti10½pr’p¹oc-bindingg¹is¦fextendedtoinclude”R440¦f½pr’p¹oc-binding “¬Ģŗis ÄZĢó b>
ó3
cmmi10Ą<¹as¦fatpresen²!tĄ>” “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹GENERIC¦f(½pr’p¹oc-interface-name Ņ”¹) ” ÄZĢ Ī2[,¦f½binding-attr-list ź¹]::½binding-namey¹=Ą>¹NULL()” “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹GENERIC¦f[,½binding-attr-list ź¹]:: ” ÄZĢ Ī2½binding-namey¹=Ą>¦f½pr’p¹ocedure-name-list¦¹A£Ē½binding-namev©¹spMŽecied¤inaPR²!OCEDUREstatement¤shallnotbMŽethesameasan²!yother”bindingxŹnamespMŽeciedwithinthesamederiv²!edtypMŽedenition,bnomatterwhetherspecied”inŠaPR²!OCEDUREĻöorGENERICstatemen²!t;äĻifitisthesameasaninheritedone,Śhthepresent”o²!verridingOrulesapply{itisnotpMŽermittedtoextendagenericsetwithaPR²!OCEDURE”binding.6|AĆébindingĆšnamespMŽeciedinaGENERICstatemen²!tmaybMŽethesameasthebinding”nameĢčspMŽeciedinanotherGENERICĢstatemen²!t,havingĢčthesameeectasifthe½pr’p¹ocedure-”name-lists~¹w²!ere¦fcombinedinasinglestatement.”Rļhtml:ļ html:Žļ¼4LĖEditsq¹Edits×_referto00-007r1.pÉP²!ageandlinenumbMŽersaredisplayedinthemargin.pÉAbsentother”instructions,$³aŲ>pageandlinen²!umbMŽerŲ>orlinen²!umberŲ>rangeimpliesalloftheindicatedtext”is*„tobMŽereplacedb²!yimmediatelyfollowingtext,KµwhileapageandlinenumbMŽerfollowedby+”indicates9.thatimmediatelyfollo²!wingtextistobMŽeinsertedaftertheindicatedline.¹uRemarksfor”the¦feditorarenotedinthemargin,orappMŽearbet²!ween¦f[and]inthetext.©#2 ffĆ°
Ŗ Öl½pr’p¹oc-bindingĶ° ¹43:16-17” Öl[¦f½pr’p¹oc-bindingg¹]...¦ ffĆ° 6f[Editor:ŻŻDelete.]Ķ° 43:19-20 ©K
ż>ģķī¹ļhtml:ļ html:¹3¦fJuly2000 P²!age3ofļhtml:5ļ html:ŗJ3/00-234 £nķī¹ żģ ffĆ° ©6f¹R440¦f½pr’p¹oc-binding “¬Ģŗis ÄZĢ¹PR²!OCEDURE(½pr’p¹oc-interface-name Ņ”¹)¦f Ķ° 43:21-24¤
ÄZĢ Ī2[,¦f½binding-attr-list ź¹]::½binding-namey¹=Ą>¹NULL()” “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹PR²!OCEDURE¦f[[,½binding-attr-list ź¹]::]ŻŻ ” ÄZĢ Ī2½binding-namey¹[=Ą>¦f½binding ų¹]” “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹GENERIC(½pr’p¹oc-interface-name Ņ”¹)¦f ” ÄZĢ Ī2[,¦f½binding-attr-list ź¹]::½binding-namey¹=Ą>¹NULL()” “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹GENERIC¦f[,½binding-attr-list ź¹]:: ” ÄZĢ Ī2½binding-namey¹=Ą>¦f½binding-list¹Constrain²!t:;gaIfH=Ą>½binding
I¹appMŽears,2Nadouble-colonseparatorshallappearbefore½binding-name¹.”Constrain²!t:;gaThe©bindingnameshallnotbMŽethesameasabindingnameinherited(4.5.3.2)from”;gatheą(paren²!ttypMŽeforwhichtheNON Ø/ ff Hųń'OVERRIDABLEßöbindingattributeisspMŽecied.”Constrain²!t:;gaIfŗabindingnameisinherited(4.5.3.2)fromtheparen²!ttypMŽe,éµthenthebindingname”;gainheritedčGfromtheparen²!ttypMŽeandtheonebeingdeclaredshallbothbedeclared”;gawith¦fGENERICorbMŽothbedeclaredwithPR²!OCEDURE.ff ffĆ° ¦ “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹NULL(½pr’p¹ocedure-name Ņ”¹)Ķ° 43:37” “¬Ģŗor ÄZĢ¹NULL(½pr’p¹ocedure-pointer-name Ņ”¹)#2 ffĆ° ¦[Editor:éTReplace¬"\proMŽcedurethathas"b²!y\procedure.ļThe½pr’p¹ocedure-pointer-name~Ć¹shall¬"beĶ° 43:39”theŅnameofanaccessibleproMŽcedurepoin²!ter.b8Theprocedureorprocedurepoin²!tershallhave".”After¦fthesecond\proMŽcedure"insert\orprocedurepoin²!ter".]#2 ffĆ°
ŖConstrain²!t:;gaIf¦fNULLisspMŽeciedNON Ø/ ff Hųń'O²!VERRIDABLE¦fshallnotbespecied.Ķ° 43:46-44:8”Constrain²!t:;gaIfbbthebindingnameisthesameasoneinherited(4.5.3.2)fromtheparen²!ttypMŽe,”;gaP’eASS Ø/ ff Hųń'OBJüshallüĄbMŽespeciedifandonlyifitisspeciedforthebindingofthesame”;ganame¦fintheparen²!ttypMŽe.”Constrain²!t:;gaIfµP’eASS Ø/ ff Hųń'OBJµorNON Ø/ ff HųO²!VERRIDABLEµisµspMŽeciedforagenericbindingnamein”;gaone2ĪproMŽcedurebindingwithinthederiv²!edtypMŽedenition,Iģitshallbespeciedinall”;gaproMŽcedure¦fbindingsforthatbindingnamewithinthederiv²!edtypMŽedenition.”Constrain²!t:;gaIfńČan½ac’p¹cess-spec=¹isńČspMŽeciedforagenericbindingnameinoneprocedurebinding”;gawithinŠthederiv²!edtypMŽedenition,ūYanditspeciesanaccessibilit²!ydierentfromthe”;gadefaultaccessibilit²!y’e,½źthesame½ac’p¹cess-spec$x¹shallbMŽespeciedforev²!eryGENERIC”;gastatemen²!t£thatspMŽeciesthesamegenericbindingnamewithinthederivedtypMŽe”;gadenition.ff ffĆ° ¦[Editor:ŻŻDelete¦f\-½c’p¹onstruct ź¹".]Ķ° 48:12¤#2 ffĆ° ¦[Editor:ŻŻReplace¦f\saidtobMŽedeferred"with\aŗdeferred2proYcedurebinding¹".]Ķ° 48:26” ffĆ° ¦ma²!y¦foverride(4.5.3.2)theinherited(4.5.3.1)deferredbindingwithanotherdeferredbinding.Ķ° 48:29” ffĆ° ¦[Editor:ŻŻNote¦fthat00-233insertsasectionofthesamen²!umbMŽer.Put¦fthisonerst.]Ķ° 48:30+¤
ŗ4.5.1.5.12Genericbindings©¹F’eor āaparticulart²!ypMŽeand½binding-name¹,;abindingspeciedb²!yaGENERIC ĄstatementspMŽecies”a
t²!ypMŽe-boundgenericin²!terface.ńČThesetofbindingsspeciedforthat½binding-name¹,®³andthose”thatS*areinherited(4.5.3.1)in²!tothattypMŽeandnotoverridden(4.5.3.2),~[denesatypMŽe-bound”generic¦fin²!terface,inexactanalogytoagenericproMŽcedurename(12.3.2.1).¦[Editor:ŻŻInsert¦fthefollo²!wingunresolvedissuenoteonlyifpapMŽer00-233alsopasses.]¦ŗJ32in¦tternalnote #L ©K
ż>ģķī¹ļhtml:ļ html:¹3¦fJuly2000 P²!age4ofļhtml:5ļ html:ŗJ3/00-234 £n ż.øķī¹ōÉ ffĆÆ’,&f ,&f