To: J3 J3/01-404 From: Stan Whitlock Page 1 of 39 Date: 29-Dec-2001 Subject: J3 meeting #159 minutes Minutes of NCITS/J3 Committee Meeting #159 December 3 - 7, 2001 Las Vegas, Nevada 0. List of papers passed at meeting #159 Here is a list of the paper numbers that passed at meeting #159, including F95 interpretations. The reference is to the latest revision on the ftp server after the meeting, not to the actual revision that was voted upon. The motions below reference the actual revision voted upon. 01-350r1 01-361r2 01-365r1 01-376r3 01-389r1 01-394r1 01-355r3 01-362r2 01-367r1 01-384r1 01-390r1 01-399 01-356r2 01-363r2 01-373r2 01-385r1 01-391 01-401 01-359 01-364r1 01-374r1 01-388r1 01-392 F95 interp letter ballot #6 passed 21 of 24 interps: 01-379 gives the balloted text {#6, F90/207, JP-17 failed} 01-380 lists the interps that passed {JP-17 reconsidered} 21 of the 24 interps went forward to WG5, see N1470 N1471 is the results; JP 17 failed N1472 is corrigendum 2 N1473 is the defect report N1474 is 006 equivalent, about 26 interps left The following Fortran 95 interpretations were passed at this J3 meeting: none - but see 01-398 reopening interp JP-17 1. Monday, December 3, 2001 Morning minutes kindness of Dick Hendrickson. 1.1 Opening business The meeting was called to order at 8:00 am, Monday, December 3, 2001, at the Las Vegas Marriott Residnece Inn by Dan Nagle. 1.1.1 Remarks from the chair - none recorded. 29-Dec-2001 Page 2 of 39 01-404 1.1.2 Adoption of agenda ** motion: adopt the agenda for meeting #159 as amended (moved by Nagle/seconded by Hendrickson) - passed by unanimous consent (u.c.) The final agenda is in Appendix A. 1.1.3 Approval of Meeting 158 minutes ** motion: adopt the minutes (01-347) of meeting #158 (Nagle/Hendrickson) - u.c. 1.1.4 NCITS/OMC report by D. Nagle We need a formal vote to officially approve work on SC22 proposal for the enhanced module TR. ** motion: J3 officially approves the proposed work item for a type 2 TR on enhanced module facilities (Dedo/Synder) - u.c. No other NCITS report. 1.1.5 ISO/WG5 report by V. Snyder - nothing to report. 1.1.6 H2 liaison report by C. Dedo Craig sent e-mail to his contacts, but got no reply until Saturday. They needed links to our web pages, etc. which Craig supplied. 1.1.7 Treasurer's report by M. North As of last meeting after all expenses, $2751.47 balance. Meeting fee for this meeting is $50.00. At end of this meeting we need to decide on whether to stay here or go back to Amerisuites. JTC1 tag administrator has given us official approval to host the scheduled joint meetings with WG5. 1.1.8 Beginning membership report by K. Hirchert Members present or represented: Craig Dedo, Dick Hendrickson, Kurt Hirchert, Bill Long, Jeanne Martin, Larry Meadows, Dan Nagle, Mallory North, Walt Brainerd (alternate for Brian Smith), Van Snyder, Stan Whitlock. 29-Dec-2001 Page 3 of 39 01-404 Members absent: Rich Bleikamp, Malcolm Cohen, Compaq, Rich Maine (alternate for Malcom Cohen) Total membership at the beginning of the meeting is 15. There are 11 attendees, 11 members present or represented. A majority is 8 and quorum is 5. Walt Brainard is now Brian Smith's alternate. The chair ruled he is eligible to vote at this meeting. There will be 11 members present. Bleikamp and the Compaq representative will both be in jeopardy for missing two out of last three meetings. See appendix E for details. Brian Smith missed two out of the last three between meetings letter ballots. We expect Compaq will not appoint a new member and will send a warning letter to Bleikamp. 1.1.8 Local arrangements by M. North - described but not recorded. 1.1.9 Comments from members Jeanne Adams had a bad fall, in the hospital intensive care unit for a while. Old timers should send her an e-mail message; old NCAR address still works 1.2 Subgroup organization Technical subgroups will meet and dispatch their work as early in the week as posisble: /interop: Larry Meadows (head), Walt Brainerd, Bill Long Work on the "allocate in C, use in Fortran" issue from last WG5 meeting. Brief discussion and references in 01-381 and N1442, etc. At least need to get a paper passed which lays out a framework or says why we can't do it. It seems to be "the one hole in interoperability" according to John Reid. Paper 381 We will continue to follow the work plan laid out in 01-199: Group A is /JOR: chapters 8 through 12 Stan Whitlock(head), Craig Dedo, Dick Hendrickson, Dan Nagle Papers to consider this week: 357, 358, 359, 360, 384, 385, 386 29-Dec-2001 Page 4 of 39 01-404 Group B is /data: chapter 13 through end Kurt Hirchert(head), Jeanne Martin, Van Snyder Papers to consider this week: 361, 362, 363, 364, 365, 366, 367, 368, 378 Group C is /interop: Beginning through chapter 7 Larry Meadows(head), Walt Brainerd, Bill Long /C will initially work as /interop on the WG5 issue Papers to consider this week: 350, 353, 354, 355, 356, 373, 374, 375, 376, 377 1.3 F95 interpretation organization /interp: Stan Whitlock (head) Papers to consider this week: none Defer until this afternoon. 1.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 1.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. /interp - postponed fromm the morning Letter ballot 6 is in paper 379; results in 380. 21 of the 24 interps went forward to WG5, see N1470 N1471 is the results; JP-17 failed N1472 is corrigendum 2 N1473 is the defect report for corrigendum 2 N1474 is 006a equivalent, about 26 interps left Group B: Paper 01-366 will be sent directly to the editor. Group C: Paper 01-354 has already been put into 01-007R4. Paper 01-387 will be sent directly to the editor. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Brief discussion and straw votes on 01-363 by Group B: The last sentence of 15.1 says the ISO C BINDING module shall not provide any other entities. What does this mean? How can we prohibit extensions? Environment module allows extensions, 13.8. IEEE module is silent on the issue. Defer until tomorrow. 29-Dec-2001 Page 5 of 39 01-404 Also some questions about definition of main program, executable program, etc., now that it can be a C program with Fortran subroutines. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Tuesday. 2. Tuesday, December 4, 2001 2.1 F2000 Plenary - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am. Group A: ** motion: paper 01-359 (Hendrickson/Snyder) - u.c. Group C on extensions to intrinsic modules {15.1 vs 13.8}: straw vote: should all intrinsic modules be consistent with respect to extensions? {yes-no-undecided} 9-2-0 straw vote: consistently allow extensions in intrinsic modules - always disallow - undecided? 11-0-0 2.2 F95 interpretation processing - nothing to do. 2.3 Tutorials Van Snyder on the Enhanced Modules TR - see papers 01-371 and 01-372. Larry Meadows on Cptr_to_Fptr - see paper 01-381. Larry Meadows will pursue the question of typeless constants vs BOZ in F90 semantics + allowing INT(boz) and REAL(boz) vs full F2K semantics. 2.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 2.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. Group C: ** motion: paper 01-350r1 (Meadows/Long) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-374r1 (Meadows/Long) - passed 9-1 ** motion: paper 01-376r1 (Meadows/Brainerd) - withdrawn 29-Dec-2001 Page 6 of 39 01-404 J3: The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Wednesday. 3. Wednesday, December 4, 2001 - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am. 3.1 F2000 Plenary Group A: Paper 01-383 will be sent directly to the editor. ** motion: paper 01-384r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-388 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended, answers 01-358r1 - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-389 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended, answers 01-357r1 - withdrawn ** motion: paper 01-390 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended, answers 01-360r1 - withdrawn Group B: ** motion: paper 01-363r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-365r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) - u.c. Paper 01-378: Tighten up definition of RANDOM_NUMBER etc straw vote #1: work on this? (yes-no-undecided} 1-7-3 => no more work on this 3.2 F95 interpretation processing - nothing to do. 3.3 Tutorials - none given. 3.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 3.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. Group B: straw vote: want index of notes in F2K by page number? {yes-no-undecided} 2-5-3 29-Dec-2001 Page 7 of 39 01-404 It was noted that a page index for J3 notes would be useful. Chair: ** motion: paper 01-392 (Hirchert/Hndrickson) - u.c. Group C: ** motion: paper 01-373r1 (Meadows/Brainerd) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} J3: Walt described the SuperComputing 2001 panel discussion on High Performance Computing: Software: Have we succeeded because of or in spite of it? The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Plenary recessed until 8:00 am Thursday. 4. Thursday, December 5, 2001 - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am. 4.1 F2000 Plenary Group A: ** motion: paper 01-389r1 (Whitlock/Dedo) answers 01-357r1 (not section 2) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-390r1 (Whitlock/Dedo) answers 01-360r1 - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-385r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - u.c. Group B: ** motion: paper 01-364r1 (Hirchert/Martin) parts 1 & 2 - u.c. Group A: discuss paper 01-393 (the F2K resulting text from applying the edits in section 2 of 01-357r1) - amended => post-meeting 01-393r1 discuss paper 01-386 - no action will be taken; Dick will follow-up with Malcolm 29-Dec-2001 Page 8 of 39 01-404 Group C: discussion of paper 01-396 - not scribed 4.2 F95 interpretation processing - nothing to do. 4.3 Tutorials Kurt discussed paper 01-397. 4.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:00 pm. 4.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:00 pm. Group A: ** motion: paper 01-399 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - u.c. {no post-meeting 01-357r2} Group B: ** motion: paper 01-361r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) sections 1 & 2 as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-361r1 (Snyder/Dedo) section 3.4 - passed 9-1 {will be in post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-362r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) sections 1, 2, & 3 as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-362r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) section 4, item 2 as amended - u.c. {will be in post-meeting r2} Group C: ** motion: paper 01-391 (Meadows/Long) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-394 (Meadows/Long) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} /interp: Paper 01-398 on reopening interp JP-17 on whether or not duplicate names are allowed in a NAMELIST - the current interp answer disallows them: straw vote: allow duplicates - disallow - undecided: 7-2-2 => JP-17 will be reopened for J3 consideration 29-Dec-2001 Page 9 of 39 01-404 J3: The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. 4.6 Early closing business /J3 closing business preponed from Friday {5.3.1} Review of action items - none so far {5.3.2} Future meetings Meeting #160: 25-Feb-1-Mar-2002 at Las Vegas Marriott Residence Inn; we must leave on Friday Meeting #161: 13-17-May-2002 Meeting #162: 1-16-Aug-2002 joint with WG5 Remaining dates are in Appendix C of these minutes. {5.3.3} Treasurer's report - paper 01-403 Opening balance: $2754.30 Meeting income: + 550.00 Meeting expenses: - 213.71 Final balance: $3090.59 {5.3.4} Closing membership report 11 of 15 members here or represented. Total attendance is 11. Rich Bleikamp and Compaq are in jeopardy. Brian Smith/Walt Brainerd are in jeopardy since they missed 2 of the last 3 leter ballots. {5.3.5} Comments from members Mallory needs electronic copies of all papers and revisions. Plenary recessed until 8:00am Friday. 5. Friday, December 7, 2001 - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am. Minutes kindness of Bill Long. 29-Dec-2001 Page 10 of 39 01-404 5.1 F2000 Plenary Group B: ** motion: paper 01-367r1 (Hirchert/Snyder) - u.c. Group C: ** motion: paper 01-355r2 (Meadows/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r3} ** motion: paper 01-356r2 (Meadows/Long) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-376r2 (Meadows/Long) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r3} ** motion: paper 01-401 (Meadows/Brainerd) as amended - u.c. {The edit was made directly by Mallory on his copy; no r1 necessary} Unfinished Papers: 01-377 not addressed and 01-375 only partially addressed. 5.2 F95 interpretation processing - nothing to do. 5.3 Closing business 5.3.1 Review of action items - see 4.6 {5.3.1} above Two action items for future J3 meeting(s): (1) Interop/Group C will continue work on a paper to allow C_PTR's to be converted to Fortran pointers in such a way as to not foul up Fortran's ability to do optimizations. (2) Bill will develop a paper on a TYPELESS data type for Fortran, with the goal of having it ready for presentation at the joint meeting with WG5 in August, 2002. 5.3.2 Future meetings - see 4.6 {5.3.2} above 5.3.3 Treasurer's report - paper 01-403 - see 4.6 {5.3.3} above 5.3.4 Closing membership report - see 4.6 {5.3.4} above 29-Dec-2001 Page 11 of 39 01-404 5.3.5 Comments from members Round of applause for Mallory for his usual excellent work as host and the seamless transition to a new facility. Minutes for meeting will be paper 01-404. Mallory needs electronic copies of all papers and revisions. For next meeting, the chapter assignments for each group are Group A: chapter 13 through end Group B: beginning through chapter 7 Group C: chapters 8 through 12 5.3.6 Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 8:25am, December 7, 2001. 29-Dec-2001 Page 12 of 39 01-404 Appendix A: Final Agenda for J3 Meeting 159 =============================== 1. Monday, December 3, 2001 8:00 am ------------------------------------ 1.1 Opening business D. Nagle Remarks from the chair D. Nagle Adoption of agenda D. Nagle Approval of Meeting 158 minutes D. Nagle NCITS/OMC report D. Nagle ISO/WG5 report V. Snyder H2 Liaison Report C. Dedo Treasurer's report M. North Beginning membership report K. Hirchert Local arrangements M. North Comments from members 1.2 Subgroup organization D. Nagle 1.3 F95 interpretation organization S. Whitlock 1.4 Subgroup meetings 1.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 2. Tuesday, December 4, 2001 8:00 am ------------------------------------- 2.1 F2001 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads 2.2 F95 interpretation processing (00-006) S. Whitlock 2.3 Tutorials (if needed) 2.4 Subgroup meetings 2.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 3. Wednesday, December 5, 2001 8:00 am --------------------------------------- 3.1 F2001 Plenary Subgroup Heads 3.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 3.3 Tutorials (if needed) 3.4 Subgroup meetings 3.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 4. Thursday, December 6, 2001 8:00 am -------------------------------------- 4.1 F2001 Plenary Subgroup Heads 4.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 4.3 Tutorials (if needed) 4.4 Subgroup meetings 4.5 Subgroup reports (4:00 pm) 4.6 Early closing business 5. Friday, December 7, 2001 8:00 am ------------------------------------ 5.1 F2001 Plenary Subgroup heads 5.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 5.3 Closing business Review of action items (if any) Future meetings M. North Treasurer's report M. North Closing membership report K. Hirchert Comments from members Adjournment 29-Dec-2001 Page 13 of 39 01-404 Appendix B: J3 REGISTER OF DOCUMENTS FOR 2001 J3/01-000 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3 REGISTER OF DOCUMENTS FOR 2001 01-000.TXT Revised December 19, 2001 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ftp site: ftp://ftp.j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/year/01 J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.j3-fortran.org ---------------------------------------------------------------------- I. Standing Documents Paper Number Title ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/01-000 Register of Documents J3/01-001 Membership List J3/01-002 Unassigned J3/01-003 J3 Member References J3/01-004 Journal of Requirements J3/01-005 J3 Resolutions and Responses to WG5 Resolutions J3/01-006 Defect Report J3/01-007 Draft Revision to Fortran 2000 J3/01-008 Editorial Considerations for F2000 Draft Review J3/01-009 Technical Proposals for Future Revisions J3/01-010 J3 Work Plan J3/01-011 Editor's List of Unresolved Issues J3/01-012 - J3/01-100 are unassigned ---------------------------------------------------------------------- II. 2001 Papers ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 156 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, MARCH 19 - 23, 2001 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/01-007 001221 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/01-011 001221 Maine Editor's List of Unresolved Issues txt J3/01-101 001221 Maine Edits Incorporated in 01-007 txt J3/01-102 001221 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-103 001221 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps,pdf J3/01-103r1 010319 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps J3/01-103r2 010321 Snyder Miscellaneous items ps 29-Dec-2001 Page 14 of 39 01-404 J3/01-104 001221 Snyder Several small things ps,pdf J3/01-104r1 010306 Snyder Several small things ps J3/01-105 001221 Snyder Issue 313 ps,pdf J3/01-105r1 010319 Snyder Issue 313, part of issue 290 ps J3/01-106 001222 Maine Open unresolved issues txt J3/01-107 010101 Martin Adjusted Work Plan for Meeting 156 txt J3/01-108 010103 Dedo Issue 305 - Connection Properties in txt,ps,wpd Annex C J3/01-108r1 010103 Dedo Issue 305 - Connection Properties in txt,ps,wpd Annex C J3/01-108r2 010319 Dedo Issue 305 - Connection Properties in txt,ps,wpd Annex C J3/01-108r3 010321 Dedo Issue 305 - Connection Properties in txt,ps,wpd Annex C J3/01-109 010104 Dedo Issue 306 - Initial Modes for Child txt,ps,wpd Data Transfer Statements J3/01-109r1 010104 Dedo Issue 306 - Initial Modes for Child txt,ps,wpd Data Transfer Statements J3/01-109r2 010319 Dedo Issue 306 - Initial Modes for Child txt,ps,wpd Data Transfer Statements J3/01-109r3 010320 Dedo Issue 306 - Initial Modes for Child txt,ps,wpd Data Transfer Statements J3/01-110 010104 Dedo Issue 307 - What Does INQUIRE Really txt,ps,wpd Return? J3/01-110r1 010319 Dedo Issue 307 - What Does INQUIRE Really txt,ps,wpd Return? J3/01-110r2 010320 Dedo Issue 307 - What Does INQUIRE Really txt,ps,wpd Return? J3/01-111 010104 Dedo Issue 308 - Oddities for PAD= in txt,ps,wpd INQUIRE J3/01-111r1 010104 Dedo Issue 308 - Oddities for PAD= in txt,ps,wpd INQUIRE J3/01-111r2 010319 Dedo Issue 308 - Oddities for PAD= in txt,ps,wpd INQUIRE J3/01-111r3 010320 Dedo Issue 308 - Oddities for PAD= in txt,ps,wpd INQUIRE J3/01-112 010105 Dedo Issue 310 - Default-int-variable txt,ps,wpd unused J3/01-113 010105 Dedo Issue 312 - Additional KIND Arguments txt,ps,wpd J3/01-113r1 010105 Dedo Issue 312 - Additional KIND Arguments txt,ps,wpd J3/01-113r2 010319 Dedo Issue 312 - Additional KIND Arguments txt,ps,wpd 29-Dec-2001 Page 15 of 39 01-404 J3/01-114 010108 Snyder More comments on Section 13 ps,pdf J3/01-114r1 010322 Snyder More comments on Section 13 ps J3/01-114r2 010323 Snyder More comments on Section 13 ps J3/01-115 010108 Snyder Issues 287, 288, 296, and part of ps,pdf 290: Type-bound operators, assignment and generic procedures J3/01-115r1 010321 Snyder Issues 287, 288, 296, and part of ps 290: Type-bound operators, assignment and generic procedures J3/01-116 010108 Dedo Issue 311 - Annex B is obsolete txt,ps,wpd J3/01-116r1 010320 Dedo Issue 311 - Annex B is obsolete txt,ps,wpd J3/01-116r2 010321 Dedo Issue 311 - Annex B is obsolete txt,ps,wpd J3/01-116r3 010322 Dedo Issue 311 - Annex B is obsolete txt,ps,wpd J3/01-117 010108 Dedo Add ASA Carriage Control to Annex B txt,ps,wpd J3/01-118 010111 Dedo Issue 30 - Edit Descriptors and DTIO txt,ps,wpd J3/01-119 010111 Dedo Design Considerations for Stream I/O txt,ps,wpd J3/01-120 010112 Reid Edit to 01-007 txt J3/01-120r1 010319 Cohen TARGET attribute clarification ps J3/01-120r2 010320 Cohen TARGET attribute clarification ps J3/01-121 010117 Snyder Suggested minor change to the PRESENT ps,pdf intrinsic J3/01-122 010119 Snyder Issue 309 ps,pdf J3/01-122r1 010319 Snyder Issue 309 ps J3/01-123 010119 Snyder Issue 304 ps,pdf J3/01-123r1 010320 Snyder Issue 304 ps J3/01-123r2 010321 Snyder Issue 304 ps J3/01-124 010122 Snyder Issue 119 ps,pdf J3/01-124r1 010319 Snyder Issue 119 ps J3/01-125 010122 Snyder Issue 259 ps,pdf 29-Dec-2001 Page 16 of 39 01-404 J3/01-125r1 010321 Snyder Issue 259 ps J3/01-126 010122 Snyder Issue 283 ps,pdf J3/01-126r1 010321 Snyder Issue 283 ps J3/01-127 010122 Snyder Issue 61 ps,pdf J3/01-128 010206 Snyder Regularize type specification ps,pdf J3/01-129 010209 Snyder One more thing for ALLOCATABLE dummy ps,pdf arguments J3/01-130 010210 Clodius Issue 212 - the content and place- txt ment of note 15.6 J3/01-130r1 010412 Whitlock Issue 212 - the content and place- txt ment of note 15.6 J3/01-131 010210 Clodius Ambiguity in the title of section 15 txt J3/01-132 010212 Snyder Comments on Annex A, issue 283 ps,pdf J3/01-132r1 010322 Snyder Comments on Annex A, issue 283 ps J3/01-132r2 010323 Snyder Comments on Annex A, issue 283 ps J3/01-133 010212 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps,pdf J3/01-134 010212 Snyder Minor defect in definition of txt "present" J3/01-134r1 010319 Cohen Minor defect in definition of txt "present" J3/01-135 010212 Snyder Another constant for ISO_FORTRAN_ENV ps,pdf J3/01-136 010213 Snyder Interp 88 - INTRINSIC statement and txt attribute J3/01-136r1 010412 Whitlock Interp 88 - INTRINSIC statement and txt attribute J3/01-137 010213 Snyder Interp 89 - Rules allowing duplicate txt names J3/01-137r1 010412 Whitlock Interp 89 - Rules allowing duplicate txt names J3/01-138 010213 Snyder Interp 90 - What do "prior specifica- txt tion" and "defined previously" mean? J3/01-138r1 010322 Bleikamp Interp 90 txt J3/01-139 010215 Dedo Issue 127 - End-of-File in Formatted txt,ps,wpd Stream Files J3/01-139r1 010322 Dedo Issue 127 - End-of-File in Formatted txt,ps,wpd Stream Files J3/01-140 010215 Dedo Issue 128 - Empty Incomplete Record txt,ps,wpd 29-Dec-2001 Page 17 of 39 01-404 J3/01-141 010215 Dedo Inclusions and Exclusions txt,ps,wpd J3/01-142 010215 Dedo Additional Normative References txt,ps,wpd J3/01-142r1 010320 Dedo Additional Normative References txt,ps,wpd J3/01-143 010215 Dedo Alphabetize I/O Keywords & Data txt,ps,wpd Attributes J3/01-143r1 010320 Dedo Alphabetize I/O Keywords & Data txt,ps,wpd Attributes J3/01-144 010216 Snyder Proposed change to MERGE (or maybe to ps,pdf PRESENT) J3/01-145 010226 Snyder Type parameter inquiries for disas- ps,pdf sociated pointers and unallocated allocatables J3/01-146 010228 Snyder Type aliases have too many unreason- ps,pdf able restrictions J3/01-147 010301 Cohen MTE 16: Defined assignment fixup txt (data abstraction) J3/01-147r1 010322 Cohen MTE 16: Defined assignment fixup txt (data abstraction) J3/01-148 010301 Cohen Revised Interp 000018 txt J3/01-148r1 010321 Cohen Revised Interp 000018 txt J3/01-149 010301 Cohen Revised Interp 000028 txt J3/01-150 010302 Hendrickson Minor editorial change to character txt intrinsic description J3/01-150r1 010412 Whitlock Minor editorial change to character txt intrinsic description J3/01-151 010303 Reid Interpretations 2, 11, 23, JP-06 txt J3/01-151r1 010412 Whitlock Interpretations 2, 11, 23, JP-06 txt J3/01-152 010303 Reid Interpretation 10 (meaning of embed- txt ded blanks in namelist input name) J3/01-152r1 010322 Bleikamp Interpretation 10 (meaning of embed- txt ded blanks in namelist input name) J3/01-153 010303 Reid Interpretation 12 (Evaluation of txt Intrinsic Procedures) J3/01-154 010303 Reid Interpretation 19 (Result of NULL txt intrinsic associated with CHARACTER(*) dummy argument) J3/01-154r1 010412 Whitlock Interpretation 19 (Result of NULL txt intrinsic associated with CHARACTER(*) dummy argument) J3/01-155 010303 Reid Interpretation 20 (Execution of a txt WHERE statement within a WHERE construct) 29-Dec-2001 Page 18 of 39 01-404 J3/01-156 010303 Reid Interpretation 21 (Restrictions on txt on END INTERFACE) J3/01-157 010303 Reid Interpretation 22 (Use of NULL() as txt initialization) J3/01-158 010303 Reid Interpretation 24 (Termination of a txt partial record by a CLOSE, BACKSPACE, ENDFILE, or REWIND statement) J3/01-158r1 010412 Whitlock Interpretation 24 (Termination of a txt partial record by a CLOSE, BACKSPACE, ENDFILE, or REWIND statement) J3/01-159 010303 Reid Interpretation 25 (List-directed txt input: types of variables correspond- ing to repeated values) J3/01-159r1 010321 Bleikamp Interpretation 25 (List-directed txt input: types of variables correspond- ing to repeated values) J3/01-160 010305 Cohen Revised Interp 000085 txt J3/01-161 010305 Hirchert MOVE_ALLOC txt J3/01-162 010309 Cohen Unresolved Issues 5 and 6 txt J3/01-162r1 010319 Cohen Unresolved Issues 5 and 6 ps J3/01-162r2 010322 Cohen Unresolved Issues 5 and 6 ps J3/01-163 010309 Cohen The term "local variable and other txt issues J3/01-163r1 010320 Cohen The term "local variable and other ps issues J3/01-164 010315 Cohen Unresolved Issues 260 and 267 txt J3/01-165 010315 Cohen Revised Interp 00081 txt J3/01-165r1 010321 Cohen Revised Interp 00081 txt J3/01-166 010315 Reid Interpretation 31 (Association of txt pointer function result with INTENT(OUT) dummy argument) J3/01-167 010321 Moene Unresolved issues 144, 240, 248, 254, txt 264 J3/01-167r1 010322 Moene Unresolved issues 144, 240, 248, 254, txt 264 J3/01-167r2 010323 Moene Unresolved issues 144, 240, 248, 254, txt 264 J3/01-168 010319 Meadows Unresolved issues 204, 160, 239, txt typos J3/01-168r1 010320 Meadows Unresolved issues 204, 160, 239, txt typos 29-Dec-2001 Page 19 of 39 01-404 J3/01-169 010320 Meadows VALUE and INTENT(IN), unresolved txt issue 161 J3/01-169r1 010321 Meadows VALUE and INTENT(IN), unresolved txt issue 161 J3/01-169r2 010322 Meadows VALUE and INTENT(IN), unresolved txt issue 161 J3/01-170 010320 Meadows Unneeded TYPEALIAS constraint txt J3/01-170r1 010322 Meadows Unneeded TYPEALIAS constraint ps J3/01-171 010319 Maine I/O Modes (Issues 306 and 305) txt J3/01-171r1 010321 Maine I/O Modes (Issues 306 and 305) txt J3/01-172 010321 Dedo Interpretation 92-Values of the PAD= txt,ps,wpd specifier in the INQUIRE statement J3/01-173 010320 Bleikamp Derived Type I/O Fixup txt J3/01-173r1 010321 Bleikamp Derived Type I/O Fixup txt J3/01-174 010320 Meadows Unresolved issue 250 txt J3/01-175 010319 Cohen Issue 262 ps J3/01-176 010320 Snyder Work on Accessibility ps J3/01-176r1 010322 Snyder Work on Accessibility ps J3/01-177 010321 Hirchert Inquiry function inconsistencies txt J3/01-177r1 010322 Hirchert Inquiry function inconsistencies txt J3/01-178 010321 Cohen Type parameter names and object names ps J3/01-178r1 010321 Cohen Type parameter names and object names ps J3/01-179 010321 Snyder Adding an access-spec to USE ps J3/01-180 010321 Snyder Problems with named constants ps J3/01-181 010321 Meadows Unresolved issues 144, 177, 168 txt J3/01-182 010321 Meadows Unresolved issue 243 txt J3/01-182r1 010322 Meadows Unresolved issue 243 txt J3/01-182r2 010322 Meadows Unresolved issue 243 txt J3/01-183 010321 Steidel Unresolved issues 217, 245 txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 20 of 39 01-404 J3/01-183r1 010322 Steidel Unresolved issues 217, 245 txt J3/01-184 010322 Cohen Interpretation request on allocatable ps arrays J3/01-185 010322 Hirchert Issue 276 (Identifier) txt J3/01-185r1 010323 Hirchert Issue 276 (Identifier) txt J3/01-186 010322 Steidel Unresolved issue 253 txt J3/01-186r1 010322 Steidel Unresolved issue 253 txt J3/01-187 010323 North Meeting 156 Treasurer's Report txt J3/01-188 010323 Whitlock Meeting 156 Minutes txt ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 157 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, JUNE 4 - 8, 2001 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/01-001r1 010625 Hirchert Membership list txt,htm J3/01-006a 010519 Whitlock Outstanding Fortran 95 Interpreta- txt tions J3/01-006b 010519 Whitlock Completed Fortran 95 Interpretations txt J3/01-007r1 010425 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/01-011r1 010425 Maine Editor's List of Unresolved Issues txt J3/01-189 010326 Steidel Minor Interop Edits txt J3/01-189r1 010604 Steidel Minor Interop Edits txt J3/01-190 010425 Maine Edits incorporated in 01-007r1 txt J3/01-191 010425 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-192 010425 Maine Open unresolved issues txt J3/01-193 010507 Snyder Miscellaneous remarks ps J3/01-193r1 010604 Snyder Miscellaneous remarks ps J3/01-194 010507 Snyder Comments on section 1 ps J3/01-194r1 010605 Snyder Comments on section 1 ps 29-Dec-2001 Page 21 of 39 01-404 J3/01-195 010507 Snyder Comments on section 2 ps J3/01-195r1 010608 Snyder Comments on section 2 ps J3/01-196 010507 Snyder Comments on section 3 ps J3/01-196r1 010608 Snyder Comments on section 3 ps J3/01-197 010507 Snyder Comments on section 4 ps J3/01-197r1 010607 Snyder Comments on section 4 ps J3/01-197r2 010608 Snyder Comments on section 4 ps J3/01-198 010511 Snyder Comments on section 5 ps J3/01-198r1 010606 Snyder Comments on section 5 ps J3/01-199 010513 Martin Proposed Work Plan for Meeting 157 txt J3/01-200 010514 Reid Interpretation 31 (association of txt pointer function result with INTENT(OUT) dummy argument) J3/01-201 010514 Reid Interpretation F90/000190 (subobjects txt of constants in a DATA statement) J3/01-202 010514 Reid Interpretation F90/205 (restrictions txt on EXTERNAL) J3/01-203 010514 Snyder Comments on section 6 ps J3/01-203r1 010606 Snyder Comments on section 6 ps J3/01-204 010514 Snyder Comments on section 7 ps J3/01-204r1 010608 Snyder Comments on section 7 ps J3/01-205 010521 Cohen Unresolved issues 320 and 330 txt J3/01-206 010514 Snyder Unresolved issue 329 ps J3/01-207 010519 Whitlock F95 Interp letter ballot # 4 - due txt 18-May-2001 J3/01-207r1 010614 Whitlock F95 Interp letter ballot # 4 - txt interps ready for WG5 J3/01-208 010520 Dedo Design considerations for stream I/O txt,ps,wpd J3/01-209 010520 Dedo Issue 127 - End-of-file in formatted txt,ps,wpd stream file J3/01-210 010520 Dedo Issue 128 - Empty incomplete record txt,ps,wpd 29-Dec-2001 Page 22 of 39 01-404 J3/01-211 010521 Cohen Interp request on the NULL intrinsic txt J3/01-211r1 010617 Whitlock Interp request on the NULL intrinsic txt (Interp # 94) J3/01-212 010521 Cohen Unresolved issue 317 txt J3/01-213 010521 Cohen Unresolved issues 321 and 322 txt J3/01-213r1 010606 Cohen Unresolved issues 321 and 322 ps J3/01-213r2 010606 Cohen Unresolved issues 321 and 322 ps J3/01-214 010521 Cohen Further "name" infelicities txt J3/01-214r1 010607 Cohen Further "name" infelicities txt J3/01-215 010521 Cohen Unresolved issues 127 and 128 txt J3/01-215r1 010607 Cohen Unresolved issues 127 and 128 txt J3/01-216 010521 Cohen Unresolved issue 323 txt J3/01-217 010521 Cohen Unresolved issue 318 txt J3/01-217r1 010605 Cohen Unresolved issue 318 txt J3/01-218 010521 Cohen Unresolved issue 332 txt J3/01-218r1 010606 Cohen Unresolved issue 332 ps J3/01-218r2 010608 Cohen Unresolved issue 332 ps J3/01-219 010521 Reid Interpretation F90/000191 txt (Interaction of SEQUENCE derived types and rename) J3/01-220 010521 Reid Interpretation F90/000204 txt (Meaning of "same variable" description of MVBITS) J3/01-220r1 010617 Whitlock Interpretation F90/000204 txt (Meaning of "same variable" description of MVBITS) J3/01-221 010521 Reid Interpretation F90/000196 txt (Inaccessibility of intrinsic procedures) J3/01-221r1 010617 Whitlock Interpretation F90/000196 txt (Inaccessibility of intrinsic procedures) J3/01-222 010521 Meadows BOZ Constants txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 23 of 39 01-404 J3/01-223 010521 Nagle Issues 127, 314 & cetera txt J3/01-223r1 010605 Nagle Issues 295, 314, 124, & NOT_A_UNIT & txt Miscellany J3/01-223r2 010608 Nagle Issues 295, 314, 124, 262, & txt Miscellany J3/01-224 010529 Whitlock Results of the F95 interp letter txt ballot # 4 J3/01-224r1 010614 Whitlock Results of the F95 interp letter txt ballot # 4 J3/01-225 010530 Cohen Unresolved issue 327 txt J3/01-225r1 010604 Cohen Unresolved issue 327 ps J3/01-225r2 010604 Cohen Unresolved issue 327 ps J3/01-226 010530 Cohen Unresolved issue 331 txt J3/01-226r1 010605 Cohen Unresolved issue 331 txt J3/01-227 010530 Cohen Unresolved issue 324 txt J3/01-227r1 010605 Cohen Unresolved issue 324 ps J3/01-228 010530 Cohen Unresolved issue 315 txt J3/01-229 010531 Cohen Pointer assignment is a mess txt J3/01-230 010531 Snyder Section 14 doesn't account for type- ps bound procedures J3/01-230r1 010607 Snyder Section 14 doesn't account for type- ps bound procedures J3/01-231 010531 Snyder Remarks on Section 10 ps J3/01-232 010601 Donev The need for C-like array pointers in txt,wpd Fortran J3/01-233 010602 Snyder Comments on terminology for input/ ps output rounding J3/01-233r1 010606 Snyder Comments on terminology for input/ ps output rounding J3/01-234 010604 van Waveren Unresolved issue 246 txt J3/01-234r1 010604 van Waveren Unresolved issue 246 txt J3/01-235 010604 van Waveren Unresolved issue 213 txt J3/01-235r1 010606 van Waveren Unresolved issue 213 txt J3/01-236 010604 Long Normal Program Termination (Issue txt 241) 29-Dec-2001 Page 24 of 39 01-404 J3/01-237 010604 Dedo Issue 308 - PAD= Specifier in the txt,ps,wpd INQUIRE Statement J3/01-237r1 010604 Dedo Issue 308 - PAD= Specifier in the txt,ps,wpd INQUIRE Statement J3/01-238 010604 Meadows Unresolved issue 171 txt J3/01-239 010607 Snyder Problems with section 12 - mostly ps with the procedure declaration statement J3/01-240 010605 Dedo Representation of EOR in Formatted txt,ps,wpd Stream I/O J3/01-241 010605 Cohen Problems with type parameters ps J3/01-242 010606 Dedo Issue 311 - Additional References to txt,ps,wpd Fortran 95 J3/01-243 010606 Dedo Issue 325 - Keyword Used as Parameter txt,ps,wpd Name J3/01-243r1 010608 Dedo Issue 325 - Keyword Used as Parameter txt,ps,wpd Name J3/01-244 010606 Nagle Constrain INPUT_UNIT, OUTPUT_UNIT, & txt ERROR_UNIT J3/01-245 010606 Hirchert Clarify "Keyword" txt J3/01-245r1 010606 Hirchert Clarify "Keyword" txt J3/01-245r2 010608 Hirchert Clarify "Keyword" txt J3/01-246 010606 Nagle Issues 326, 237 txt J3/01-246r1 010608 Nagle Issue 237 txt J3/01-247 010606 Cohen An attribute is specified when a ps keyword appears J3/01-248 010606 VOID. Number issued in error. J3/01-249 010605 Cohen Pointers are a mess ps J3/01-249r1 010605 Cohen Pointers are a mess ps J3/01-250 010607 Hirchert Issue 316 txt J3/01-251 010607 Cohen Unresolved issue 328 ps J3/01-252 010607 Nagle Unresolved issue 326 txt J3/01-252r1 010608 Nagle Unresolved issue 326 txt J3/01-253 010608 North Meeting 157 Treasurer's Report txt J3/01-254 010608 Whitlock Meeting 157 Minutes txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 25 of 39 01-404 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 158 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, AUGUST 20 - 24, 2001 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/01-007r2 010622 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/01-011r2 010627 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-255 010622 Maine Edits incorporated in 01-007r2 txt J3/01-256 010622 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-257 010627 Maine Open unresolved issues txt J3/01-258 010629 Snyder Comments on section 2 ps J3/01-259 010629 Snyder Comments on section 4 ps J3/01-260 010629 Snyder Comments on section 5 ps J3/01-261 010706 Snyder Issue 337 ps J3/01-262 010709 Snyder Comments on section 7 ps J3/01-263 010709 Snyder Comments on section 13 ps J3/01-264 010711 Snyder Comments on section 8 ps,pdf J3/01-264r1 010822 Snyder Comments on section 8 ps J3/01-264r2 010824 Snyder Comments on section 8 ps J3/01-265 010713 Snyder Comments on section 9 ps,pdf J3/01-265r1 010822 Snyder Comments on section 9 ps J3/01-266 010715 Snyder Comments on section 10 ps,pdf J3/01-266r1 010823 Snyder Comments on section 10 ps J3/01-266r2 010824 Snyder Comments on section 10 ps J3/01-267 010717 Snyder Comments on section 11 ps,pdf J3/01-267r1 010821 Snyder Comments on section 11 ps J3/01-267r2 010822 Snyder Comments on section 11 ps 29-Dec-2001 Page 26 of 39 01-404 J3/01-268 010721 Snyder Comments on section 12 ps,pdf J3/01-268r1 010823 Snyder Comments on section 12 ps J3/01-269 010714 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps,pdf J3/01-269r1 010823 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps J3/01-270 010714 Snyder Issue 339 ps,pdf J3/01-270r1 010821 Snyder Issue 339 ps J3/01-270r2 010822 Snyder Issue 339 ps J3/01-271 010721 Snyder Further comments on Section 5 ps,pdf J3/01-272 010721 Snyder Issue 338 ps,pdf J3/01-273 010721 Snyder Issue 333 ps,pdf J3/01-273r1 010822 Snyder Issue 333 ps J3/01-273r2 010824 Snyder Issue 333 ps J3/01-274 010726 Whitlock F95 interp letter ballot # 5 - due txt 20-Jul-2001 J3/01-275 010726 Whitlock Results of the F95 interp letter bal- txt lot # 5 J3/01-276 010803 Hendrickson General questions about 007 txt J3/01-277 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 1 and Intro comments txt J3/01-278 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 2 comments txt J3/01-279 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments txt J3/01-279r1 010823 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments txt J3/01-279r2 010824 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments txt J3/01-280 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 4 comments txt J3/01-281 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 5 comments txt J3/01-282 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments txt J3/01-282r1 010823 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments txt J3/01-282r2 010824 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 27 of 39 01-404 J3/01-283 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments txt J3/01-283r1 010823 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments txt J3/01-283r2 010824 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments txt J3/01-284 010804 Hendrickson Typos and Nits txt J3/01-284r1 010819 Hendrickson Typos and Nits txt J3/01-285 010806 Cohen Interpretation request on ENTRY txt points J3/01-285r1 010822 Cohen Interpretation request on ENTRY txt points J3/01-286 010806 Cohen The PROTECTED attribute txt J3/01-286r1 010820 Cohen The PROTECTED attribute ps J3/01-286r2 010820 Cohen The PROTECTED attribute ps J3/01-287 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp 7 txt J3/01-288 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp 9 txt J3/01-289 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp 27 txt J3/01-290 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 67 txt J3/01-290r1 010822 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 67 txt J3/01-291 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 71 txt J3/01-291r1 010821 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 71 txt J3/01-292 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp F90/207 txt J3/01-293 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/209 txt J3/01-293r1 010821 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/209 txt J3/01-294 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/211 txt J3/01-294r1 010821 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/211 txt J3/01-295 010806 Cohen WG5 recommendation on Interp 66 txt J3/01-295r1 010821 Cohen WG5 recommendation on Interp 66 txt J3/01-296 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 68 txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 28 of 39 01-404 J3/01-296r1 010821 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 68 txt J3/01-297 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 86 txt J3/01-298 010806 Nagle Sj Response to a WG5 comment txt (bindname) J3/01-298r1 010821 Maine Remove bindname txt J3/01-299 010806 Nagle Sj Response to a WG5 comment txt (named scratch files) J3/01-299r1 010821 Nagle Response to a WG5 comment (named txt scratch files) J3/01-299r2 010907 Nagle Response to a WG5 comment (named txt scratch files) J3/01-300 010806 Reid Interpretation JP-17 (Multiple occur- txt rence of namelist group object in namelist group) J3/01-301 010806 Reid Interps ready for corrigendum 2 txt J3/01-302 010806 van Waveren Interp 91 (Definition of "present" is txt defective) J3/01-303 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-05 (Construction of array txt values) J3/01-303r1 010903 Whitlock Interp JP-05 (Construction of array txt values) - revised J3/01-304 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-31 (Signs of literal txt constants) J3/01-305 010806 van Waveren Interp 6 (Character length specifi- txt cation of a function result) J3/01-305r1 010903 Whitlock Interp 6 (Character length specifi- txt cation of a function result)-revised J3/01-306 010806 van Waveren Interp 26 (List-directed input: types txt of variables corresponding to repeat- ed values) J3/01-306r1 010903 Whitlock Interp 26 (List-directed input: types txt of variables corresponding to repeat- ed values) - revised J3/01-307 010806 van Waveren Interp F90/000212 (EQUIVALENCE of txt Data Objects of Different Types or Kinds) J3/01-308 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-04 (Construction of derived txt type values) J3/01-309 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-08 (Type declaration state- txt ments) J3/01-309r1 010903 Whitlock Interp JP-08 (Type declaration state- txt ments) - revised J3/01-310 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-16 (Multiple occurrence of txt namelist-group-name in NAMELIST statement) 29-Dec-2001 Page 29 of 39 01-404 J3/01-310r1 010903 Whitlock Interp JP-16 (Multiple occurrence of txt namelist-group-name in NAMELIST statement) - revised J3/01-311 010806 Meadows Square brackets for array construct- txt ors J3/01-311r1 010820 Meadows Square brackets for array construct- txt ors J3/01-312 010810 Reid Interpretation F90/000164: draft txt response J3/01-312r1 010822 Bleikamp Interpretation F90/000164: draft txt response J3/01-312r2 010822 Bleikamp Interpretation F90/000164: draft txt response J3/01-313 010811 Whitlock Editorial Comments on 01-007r2 txt J3/01-314 010811 Whitlock Comments/Questions on chapters 1 - 7 txt of 01-007r2 J3/01-314r1 010821 Whitlock Comments/Questions on chapters 1 - 7 txt,ps,wpd of 01-007r2 J3/01-315 010814 Nagle Response to a WG5 comment (value txt attribute) J3/01-315r1 010821 Maine Response to a WG5 comment (value txt attribute) J3/01-315r2 010822 Maine Response to a WG5 comment (value txt attribute) J3/01-316 010814 Dedo Named Scratch Files - Proposed txt,ps,wpd Response to WG5 J3/01-316r1 010820 Dedo Named Scratch Files - Proposed txt,ps,wpd Response to WG5 J3/01-317 010814 Dedo What is an Input/Output Error? txt,ps,wpd J3/01-318 010820 Dedo JOR response to 01-259 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-318r1 010821 Dedo JOR response to 01-259 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-319 010820 Dedo JOR response to 01-271 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-320 010818 Snyder Comments concerning 01-007r2 arising ps from or after the WG5 meeting J3/01-320r1 010822 Snyder Comments concerning 01-007r2 arising ps from or after the WG5 meeting J3/01-321 010820 Dedo JOR response to 01-258 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-322 010821 Snyder Purely editorial issues from /B ps J3/01-323 010821 Dedo Response to Chapter 1 and Intro txt,ps,wpd Comments J3/01-323r1 010822 Dedo Response to Chapter 1 and Intro txt,ps,wpd Comments 29-Dec-2001 Page 30 of 39 01-404 J3/01-324 010821 Meadows BOZ constants txt J3/01-325 010821 Meadows Section 15.2.6 Edits txt J3/01-325r1 010821 Subgroup C Section 15.2.6 Edits txt J3/01-325r2 010831 Subgroup C Section 15.2.6 Edits txt J3/01-326 010821 Cohen Unresolved Issue 338 ps J3/01-327 010821 Cohen Improving present terminological ps consistency J3/01-328 010821 Maine Reorg of c13 txt J3/01-328r1 010822 Maine Reorg of c13 txt J3/01-329 010821 Maine MINLOC/MAXLOC txt J3/01-330 010822 Nagle F2k+1 slides ps J3/01-331 010822 Snyder Repair use of undefined terms in ps Sections 9 and 10 J3/01-331r1 010824 Snyder Repair use of undefined terms in ps Sections 9 and 10 J3/01-332 010822 Dedo Response to Issue 337 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-332r1 010823 Dedo Response to Issue 337 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-333 010822 Nagle Flesh Out Intro txt J3/01-333r1 010823 Nagle Flesh Out Intro txt J3/01-333r2 010823 Nagle Flesh Out Intro txt J3/01-334 010822 Nagle Database Liaison Charge txt J3/01-335 010822 Dedo Response to Chapter 5 Comments txt,ps,wpd J3/01-335r1 010823 Dedo Response to Chapter 5 Comments txt,ps,wpd J3/01-336 010822 Bleikamp Program terminology cleanup txt J3/01-336r1 010823 Bleikamp Program terminology cleanup txt J3/01-336r2 01-08-23 Bleikamp Program terminology cleanup txt J3/01-337 010822 Moene Improving present terminology txt consistency II J3/01-338 010822 Subgroup C IEEE_SUPPORT_FLAG txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 31 of 39 01-404 J3/01-338r1 010823 Subgroup C IEEE_SUPPORT_FLAG txt J3/01-339 010823 Bleikamp Writing zero in list directed and txt namelist I/O J3/01-339r1 010823 Bleikamp Writing zero in list directed and txt namelist I/O J3/01-340 010823 Snyder Request for interpretation on txt end-of-record and PAD= J3/01-341 010822 Long Command line and environment txt intrinsics J3/01-341r1 010831 Subgroup C Command line and environment txt intrinsics J3/01-342 010823 Moene Apply answer to interp F95/000005 to txt IEEE_SELECTED_REAL_KIND J3/01-343 010823 Maine Edits from editor txt J3/01-344 010823 Cohen /DATA responses to 01-260 and 01-320 ps J3/01-345 010823 Maine Interp request on OPEN txt J3/01-346 010824 North Meeting 158 Treasurer's Report txt J3/01-347 010824 Whitlock Meeting 158 Minutes txt ---------------------------------------------------------------------- PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 159 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, DECEMBER 3 - 7, 2001 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title ---------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/01-000 011219 North J3 Register of Documents txt J3/01-001r3 011219 Hirchert J3 Membership List txt,htm J3/01-007r3 011001 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/01-007r4 011031 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,pdf,tex J3/01-011r3 010822 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-348 011001 Maine Edits incorporated in 01-007r3 txt J3/01-349 011001 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-350 011017 Nagle Fix up Intro (again) txt J3/01-350r1 011204 Meadows Fix up Intro (again) txt J3/01-351 011022 Maine Open Unresolved Issues txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 32 of 39 01-404 J3/01-352 011102 Maine Annex E txt,ps,pdf J3/01-353 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 2 ps,pdf J3/01-354 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 4 ps,pdf J3/01-355 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 5 ps,pdf J3/01-355r1 011202 Snyder Comments on Section 5 ps,tex J3/01-355r2 011206 Subgroup C Reply to paper 01-355r1 txt J3/01-355r3 011207 Subgroup C Reply to paper 01-355r1 txt J3/01-356 011102 Snyder Comments on Section 7 ps,pdf J3/01-356r1 011202 Snyder Comments on Section 7 txt J3/01-356r2 011207 Subgroup C Reply to paper 01-356 txt J3/01-357 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 9 ps,pdf J3/01-357r1 011202 Snyder Comments on Section 9 ps,tex J3/01-358 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 10 ps,pdf J3/01-358r1 011202 Snyder Comments on Section 10 ps,tex J3/01-359 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 11 ps,pdf J3/01-360 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 12 ps,pdf J3/01-360r1 011202 Snyder Comments on Section 12 ps,tex J3/01-361 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 13 ps,pdf J3/01-361r1 011205 Snyder Comments on Section 13 ps,tex J3/01-361r2 011205 Snyder Comments on Section 13 ps,tex J3/01-362 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 14 ps,pdf J3/01-362r1 011205 Snyder Comments on Section 14 ps,tex J3/01-362r2 011205 Snyder Comments on Section 14 ps,tex J3/01-363 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 15 ps,pdf J3/01-363r1 011204 Snyder Comments on Section 15 ps,tex 29-Dec-2001 Page 33 of 39 01-404 J3/01-363r2 011205 Snyder Comments on Section 15 ps,tex J3/01-364 011105 Snyder Comments on Section 16, Issues 319 ps,pdf and 336 J3/01-364r1 011204 Snyder Comments on Section 16, Issues 319 ps,tex and 336 J3/01-365 011105 Snyder Comments on Annex A ps,pdf J3/01-365r1 011204 Snyder Comments on Annex A ps,tex J3/01-366 011105 Snyder Comments on Annex B ps,pdf J3/01-367 011105 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps,pdf J3/01-367r1 011206 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps,tex J3/01-368 011105 Snyder Unresolved issue 344 and nearby stuff ps,pdf J3/01-369 011105 Snyder Defects in the conversion to LaTeX ps,pdf J3/01-369r1 011204 Snyder Defects in the conversion to LaTeX ps,tex J3/01-370 011109 Snyder LaTeX style macros for J3 work ps,pdf J3/01-371 011112 Snyder Technical issues in the submodules TR ps,pdf J3/01-372 011113 Snyder Slides to accompany 01-371 ps,pdf J3/01-373 011116 Hendrickson Chapter 2 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-373r1 011204 Brainerd Chapter 2 comments txt J3/01-373r2 011204 Brainerd Chapter 2 comments txt J3/01-374 011116 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-374r1 011204 Meadows Response to 01-374 from Dick txt Hendrickson J3/01-375 011116 Hendrickson Chapter 4 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-376 011116 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-376r1 011204 Meadows Chapter 6 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-376r2 011206 Meadows Chapter 6 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-376r3 011207 Meadows Chapter 6 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 J3/01-377 011116 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments, updated from txt meeting 158 29-Dec-2001 Page 34 of 39 01-404 J3/01-378 011119 Hirchert RANDOM expectations txt J3/01-379 011124 Whitlock F95 interp letter ballot #6 - txt due 19-Oct-2001 J3/01-380 011124 Whitlock Results of the F95 interp letter txt ballot #6 J3/01-381 011124 Nagle Pointers & C Interop txt J3/01-382 011127 Maine Editor's comments on mtg159 papers txt J3/01-383 011129 Hendrickson Typos in the PDF version of 007r4 txt J3/01-384 011129 Hendrickson Wording clarifications for Chapter 8 txt J3/01-384r1 011204 Hendrickson Wording clarifications for Chapter 8 txt,doc J3/01-385 011129 Hendrickson Technical issues in Chapter 8 txt J3/01-385r1 011205 Hendrickson Technical issues in Chapter 8 txt,doc J3/01-386 011129 Hendrickson Questions about associated names and txt variables in CH 8 J3/01-387 011203 Meadows Types and LaTeX conversion bugs, txt Sections 0 - 4 J3/01-388 011203 Dedo JOR Response to 01-358r1 - Comments txt,ps,wpd on Section 10 J3/01-388r1 011205 Dedo JOR Response to 01-358r1 - Comments txt,ps,wpd on Section 10 J3/01-389 011204 Dedo JOR Response to 01-357r1 - Comments txt,ps,wpd on Section 9 J3/01-389r1 011204 Dedo JOR Response to 01-357r1 - Comments txt,ps,wpd on Section 9 J3/01-390 011204 Dedo JOR Response to 01-360r1 - Comments txt,ps,wpd on Section 12 J3/01-390r1 011204 Dedo JOR Response to 01-360r1 - Comments txt,ps,wpd on Section 12 J3/01-391 011205 Meadows Various issues in Sections 1 - 4 txt J3/01-392 011205 Nagle J3 Supports Editor's LaTeX Experiment txt J3/01-393 011205 Hendrickson Proposed rewrite of Section 9.9 txt,doc J3/01-393r1 011206 Hendrickson Proposed rewrite of Section 9.9 txt,doc J3/01-394 011205 Meadows BOZ Constants txt J3/01-394r1 011205 Meadows BOZ Constants txt J3/01-395 011205 Meadows Enhanced C Interoperability txt 29-Dec-2001 Page 35 of 39 01-404 J3/01-396 011205 Brainerd Program Concepts txt J3/01-397 011206 Hirchert Interface Block / Host Association txt Proposal J3/01-398 011206 Long Namelist lists and interp JP 17 txt J3/01-399 011206 Hendrickson Response to 01-357r1, Part 2 txt,doc Rewrite of 9.9 J3/01-400 011206 Hirchert CONTEXT Tutorial Examples ps,doc J3/01-401 011206 Brainerd Responses to J3/01-375 txt J3/01-402 011206 Dedo Declarations of Derived-Type txt,ps,wpd Parameters J3/01-403 011207 North Meeting 159 Treasurer's Report txt J3/01-404 011207 Whitlock Meeting 159 Minutes txt ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 29-Dec-2001 Page 36 of 39 01-404 Appendix C: Future Meetings and Distribution Meeting Conventions: - Four meetings per year - Attempt to schedule second full week of the month - Attempt to schedule meeting contiguous with WG5 annual meeting Future meeting schedule: 160 February 25 - March 1, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: February 11, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 161 May 13 - 17, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: April 29, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 162 August 11 - 16, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: July 29, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Note: Joint meeting with WG5 163 November 11 - 15, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: October 28, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Committee materials availability: Agenda and meeting notice available at the J3 web site and from the J3 ftp server. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3) Pre- and post-meeting distribution available at the J3 ftp and web sites. 29-Dec-2001 Page 37 of 39 01-404 Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution of premeeting 2 weeks prior to meeting. (documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1) Meeting minutes are available at the J3 web and ftp sites. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ftp site: ftp://ftp.j3-fortran.org/j3 J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.j3-fortran.org ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ********************************************************************** Appendix D: Committee Organization D.1 Officers and Management Chair D. Nagle International Rep. V. Snyder Secretary S. Whitlock Treasurer M. North Librarian M. North Editor R. Maine (WG5 appointment) Maintenance S. Whitlock Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert Future Meetings M. North Membership List K. Hirchert H2 Liaison C. Dedo D.2 Subgroups JOR: Responsible for the maintenance of the Journal of Development (standing document 004) and managing the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R.1, R.2, R.8, and all MTE and B items. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, C. Dedo, D. Hendrickson, D. Nagle DATA: Responsible for language design topics related to data and data structures; manages the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R3, R5, R6, and R7. M. Cohen (head), K. Hirchert, R. Maine, J. Martin, V. Snyder INTEROP: Responsible for R9 (interoperability with C) L. Meadows (head), W. Brainerd, B. Long, R. Maine, M. van Waveren {Toon Moene} INTERP: Responsible for evaluating interpretation requests, providing responses to such requests, and maintaining standing document 006. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, M. Cohen 29-Dec-2001 Page 38 of 39 01-404 Appendix E: Membership summary J3 Meeting Attendance (Principal Members) Meeting # 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 Location (state) NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV Date (month year) 08 11 02 05 09 12 03 06 08 12 99 99 00 00 00 00 01 01 01 01 Name Affiliation Bleikamp, R HP V A** V V V A V A** V A** Cohen, M NAG V V V R V V V V V A (Compaq rep) Compaq RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP A A** Dedo, C self V** V V V V V V V V V Hendrickson, D self V V V V A V A** V V V Hirchert, K U of IL A** Q V V V V V V Hirchert, K U of KY V V Q Long, W Cray RP RP RP RP RP RP RP V V V Martin, J self V V Meadows, L Sun RP RP RP V V V V V V V Nagle, D self P V V V V V V V V V North, M Rose-Hulman V V V V V V V V V V Smith, B U of NM R A** R R R R A R A** R** Snyder, V JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V V V V van Waveren, M Fujitsu A** V R V A A** R** V R A Whitlock, S Intel P A RP R RP R A V V J3 Letter Ballot Participation (Principal Members) Meeting # 152a 153a 154a 155a 156a 157a 158a Date (month year) 05 07 11 03 05 07 10 00 00 00 01 01 01 01 Name Affiliation Bleikamp, R HP V V V V V V V Cohen, M NAG V V V R V V V (Compaq rep) Compaq RP RP RP RP RP RP A Dedo, C self V V V V V V V Hendrickson, D self V V V V V V V Hirchert, K U of IL V V V V V Hirchert, K U of KY V V Long, W Cray RP RP RP RP V V V Martin, J self A Meadows, L Sun RP V V V V V V Martin, J self A Nagle, D self V V V V V V V North, M Rose-Hulman V V V V V V V Smith, B U of NM R R R R A R A** Snyder, V JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V van Waveren, M Fujitsu V V R V V V V Whitlock, S Intel E RP RP RP RP RP V 29-Dec-2001 Page 39 of 39 01-404 V present and voting other voting attendees: R absent but represented W Brainerd, alternate for B Smith A absent and not represented P present and not voting non-voting attendees: RP represented by previous member E Excused Q Resigned ** missed 2 of last 3 meetings *** lost membership Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 159 15 Majority 8 Quorum 5 Total Membership at end of Meeting 159 15 Total Members Attended or Represented at 159 11 Total Attendees at Meeting 159 11 membership changes since last meeting: Walt Brainerd was named the alternate for Brian Smith. A new principal member from Compaq has not yet been named. ********************************************************************** Appendix F: Membership Roster The Membership Roster is not reproduced here. The current Membership Roster may be found in ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/01-001.html and ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/01-001.txt