To: J3 J3/01-347 From: Stan Whitlock Page 1 of 26 Date: 17-Sep-2001 Subject: J3 meeting #158 minutes Minutes of NCITS/J3 Committee Meeting #158 August 20 - 24, 2001 Las Vegas, Nevada 0. List of papers passed at meeting #158 Here is a list of the paper numbers that passed at meeting #158, including F95 interpretations. The reference is to the latest revision on the ftp server after the meeting, not to the actual revision that was voted upon. The motions below reference the actual revision voted upon. 01-264r2 01-284r1 01-295r1 01-307 01-321 01-334 01-265r1 01-285r1 01-296r1 01-308 01-322 01-335r1 01-266r2 01-286r2 01-297 01-309r1 01-323r1 01-336r2 01-267r2 01-287 01-298r1 01-310r1 01-325r2 01-338r1 01-268r1 01-288 01-299r2 01-312r2 01-326 01-339r1 01-269r1 01-289 01-300 01-313 01-327 01-341r1 01-270r2 01-290r1 01-302 01-314r1 01-328r1 01-343 01-273r2 01-291r1 01-303r1 01-315r2 01-329 01-344 01-279r2 01-292 01-304 01-318r1 01-331r1 01-345 01-282r2 01-293r1 01-305r1 01-319 01-332r1 01-283r2 01-294r1 01-306r1 01-320r1 01-333r2 F95 interp letter ballot #5 passed 6 of 7 interps: 01-274 gives the balloted text {#31 failed} 01-275 lists the following interps as passed J3 letter ballot and ready for WG5: 94, F90/190, F90/191, F90/196, F90/204, F90/205 The following Fortran 95 interpretations were passed at this J3 meeting: interp #000006 = 01-305r1 interp #000097 = 01-345 interp #000007 = 01-287 interp #F90/164 = 01-3121r2 interp #000009 = 01-288 interp #F90/207 = 01-292 interp #000026 = 01-306r1 interp #F90/209 = 01-293r1 interp #000027 = 01-289 interp #F90/211 = 01-294r1 interp #000066 = 01-295r1 interp #F90/212 = 01-307 interp #000067 = 01-290r1 interp #JP-04 = 01-308 interp #000068 = 01-296r1 interp #JP-05 = 01-303r1 interp #000071 = 01-291r1 interp #JP-08 = 01-309r1 interp #000086 = 01-297 interp #JP-16 = 01-310r1 interp #000091 = 01-302 interp #JP-17 = 01-300 interp #000095 = 01-285r1 interp #JP-31 = 01-304 17-Sep-2001 Page 2 of 26 01-347 1. Monday, August 20, 2001 1.1 Opening business The meeting was called to order at 8:30 am, Monday, August 20, 2001, at the Las Vegas AmeriSuites Hotel by Dan Nagle. 1.1.1 Remarks from the chair WG5 has given J3 new work items: 01-286, 01-298, 01-299. 1.1.2 Adoption of agenda ** motion: adopt the agenda for meeting #158 as amended (moved by Whitlock/seconded by Hendrickson) - passed by unanimous consent (u.c.) The final agenda is in Appendix A. 1.1.3 Approval of Meeting 157 minutes ** motion: adopt the minutes (01-254) of meeting #157 (Hendrickson/Maine) - u.c. 1.1.4 NCITS/OMC report by D. Nagle Dan gave the J3 yearly report to NCITS: they asked if J3 was on shecdule; Dan said yes. Dan acquired electronic copies of many NCITS standards for the use of the committee. Craig Dedo volunteered to be the J3 liaison with H2, the NCITS Database Committee. 1.1.5 ISO/WG5 report by V. Snyder The WG5 London meeting was productive - see the London resolutions in WG5/N1443 and related papers. 1.1.6 Treasurer's report by M. North As of now, all bills are paid and the balance is $2961.69. There is no meeting fee for this meeting. 17-Sep-2001 Page 3 of 26 01-347 1.1.7 Beginning membership report by K. Hirchert Members present or represented: Rich Bleikamp, Malcolm Cohen, Richard Maine (alternate for Malcolm Cohen), Craig Dedo, Dick Hendrickson, Kurt Hirchert, Bill Long, Jeanne Martin, Larry Meadows, Dan Nagle, Mallory North, Van Snyder, Toon Moene (Alternate for Matthijs van Waveren), Stan Whitlock. Jeanne Martin now represents herself. Stan Whitlock replaces Mike Ross as Intel's representative. Compaq has not named a new representative. Andy Vaught from FSF was a visitor. Members absent: Compaq, Brian Smith Total membership at the beginning of the meeting is 15. There are 15 attendees, 13 members present or represented. A majority is 8 and quorum is 5. 1.1.8 Local arrangements by M. North - described but not recorded. 1.1.9 Comments from members - not recorded. 1.2 Subgroup organization Technical subgroups will meet and dispatch their work as early in the week as posisble: /JOR: Stan Whitlock (head), Rich Bleikamp, Craig Dedo, Dick Hendrickson, Dan Nagle Papers to consider this week: 299, 316, 317 {ruled out of order, to be looked at by JOR} /data: Malcolm Cohen (head), Kirt Hirchert, Jeanne Martin, Van Snyder Papers to consider this week: 286 /interop: Larry Meadows (head), Bill Long, Rich Maine, Toon Moene Papers to consider this week: 298, 311, 315 /edit: Richard Maine (head) Papers to consider this week: 313 17-Sep-2001 Page 4 of 26 01-347 We will continue to follow the work plan laid out in 01-199: Group A is /JOR: beginning through chapter 7 Papers to consider this week: 258-262, 271, 276-284, 313, 314, 317, 320 Group B is /data: chapter 8 through chapter 12 Papers to consider this week: 264-268, 270, 272, 273 Group C is /interop: chapter 13 through end Papers to consider this week: 263, 269 1.3 F95 interpretation organization /interp: Stan Whitlock (head), Rich Bleikamp, Malcolm Cohen Papers to consider this week: 274, 275, 285, 287-297, 300-310, 312 1.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:30 pm. 1.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:30 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. /JOR Paper 01-317 was ruled as out of order: it will not be processed further. /edit and Group A Paper 01-313 is accepted as purely editorial. Group C Paper 01-263 requires no edits {see 01-007r2 [page 315:lines 15-17]} so no further action will be taken. Paper 01-269: the editor agress to make these changes as amended {there will be a post-meeting revision numbered r1}. /J3 Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Tuesday. 17-Sep-2001 Page 5 of 26 01-347 2. Tuesday, August 21, 2001 2.1 F2000 Plenary - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. /JOR ** motion: paper 01-316r1 (Whitlock/Dedo) answers WG5 question in 01-299 about removing named scratch files from F2K: Straw vote: 1) delete named scratch files 2) add note about behavior if the file already exists 3) undecided Straw vote: 6 - 5 - 3 Straw vote: opposed to deleting named scratch files? Yes - No - Undecided: 2 - 12 - 0 Paper withdrawn. /data ** motion: paper 01-286r1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} /interop ** motion: paper 01-298 (Meadows/Bleikamp) to delete BINDNAME but no edits - u.c. discuss paper 01-315 to not restrict VALUE attribute: Straw vote: agree with WG5? Yes - No - Undecided: 14 - 0 - 0 Paper withdrawn for edits. ** motion: paper 01-311r1 (Meadows/Martin) - failed 5 - 7 Group A: ** motion: paper 01-284r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-318 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-319 (Whitlock/Dedo) - passed 7 - 5 ** motion: paper 01-321 (Whitlock/Dedo) - u.c. Group A to investigate the use of the term "program unit". 17-Sep-2001 Page 6 of 26 01-347 Group C: Paper 01-263 will have no further processing since 01-007r2 has already been amended [315:15-17]. John Reid agrees that IEEE_SUPPORT_FLAG should not be elemental. 2.2 F95 interpretation processing /interp Paper 01-285 is a new F95 interp #000095. 2.3 Tutorials - none given. 2.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:00 pm. 2.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:00 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. /J3 Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Wednesday. 3. Wednesday, August 22, 2001 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. 3.1 F2000 Plenary /JOR ** motion: paper 01-299r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} Group A: ** motion: paper 01-261 (Whitlock/Snyder) - withdrawn ** motion: paper 01-323 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-314r1 (Whitlock/Bleikamp) - u.c ** motion: paper 01-320 (Whitlock/Snyder) as amended - u.c {post-meeting r1} 17-Sep-2001 Page 7 of 26 01-347 Group B: ** motion: paper 01-326 (Cohen/Snyder) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-327 (Cohen/Snyder) - u.c. Paper 01-322 is accepted by the editor. ** motion: paper 01-267r1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-270r1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} Group C: ** motion: paper 01-298r1 (Meadows/Maine) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-315r1 (Meadows/Long) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-328 (Meadows/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-329 (Meadows/Maine) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-325 (Meadows/Long) - withdrawn Paper 01-324 about making BOZ constants in F2K like F95: Straw vote: 1) fix BOZ 2) leave BOZ alone 3) undecided Straw vote: 13 - 0 - 1 Straw vote: 1) specify where BOZ are allowed 2) specify where BOZ are not allowed 3) undecided Straw vote: 3 - 7 - 4 3.2 F95 interpretation processing /interp ** motion: paper 01-287 interp #7 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-288 interp #9 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-289 interp #27 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. 17-Sep-2001 Page 8 of 26 01-347 ** motion: paper 01-290 interp #77 (Whitlock/Cohen) - failed 6 - 6 Fix interp as an oversight: don't fix F95 via an interp; fix F2K ** motion: paper 01-291 interp #71 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-292 interp #F90/207 (Whitlock/Cohen) - passed 11 - 1 ** motion: paper 01-293 interp #F90/209 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-294 interp #F90/211 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-295r1 interp #66 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-296 interp #68 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-297 interp #86 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-300 interp #JP-17 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. 3.3 Tutorials - none given. 3.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:00 pm. 3.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:00 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. /J3 Paper WG5/N1460 and slides in paper 01-330 presented by Dan Nagle as some thoughts on the standard after F2K. Plenary recessed until 8:30 am Thursday. 4. Thursday, August 23, 2001 - Plenary reconvened at 8:30 am. 4.1 F2000 Plenary Group A: ** motion: paper 01-332 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} 17-Sep-2001 Page 9 of 26 01-347 ** motion: paper 01-333 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - withdrawn ** motion: paper 01-334 (Whitlock/Dedo) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-335 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-336 (Whitlock/Bleikamp) as amended - withdrawn Paper 01-276 has been examined and no further action will be taken. 4.2 F95 interpretation processing /interp ** motion: paper 01-285r1 interp #95 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-290r1 interp #67 (Whitlock/Bleikamp) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-302 interp #91 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-303 interp #JP-05 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-304 interp #JP-31 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-305 interp #6 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-306 interp #26 (Whitlock/Bleikamp) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-307 interp #F90/212 (Whitlock/Dedo) - passed 10-2 ** motion: paper 01-308 interp #JP-04 (Whitlock/Cohen) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-309 interp #JP-08 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-310 interp #JP-16 (Whitlock/Cohen) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-312r1 interp #F90/164 (Whitlock/Bleikamp) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} 4.3 Tutorials - none given. 17-Sep-2001 Page 10 of 26 01-347 4.4 Subgroup meetings - Plenary recessed until 4:00 pm. 4.5 Subgroup reports - Plenary reconvened at 4:00 pm. The list of papers for voting, discussion, or action later in the week was reviewed. Group C: Paper 01-338 to fix IEEE_SUPPORT_FLAG: Straw vote: 1) edits in 01-338 2) change the example (no array argument) 3) undecided Straw vote: 10 - 2 - 2 ** motion: paper 01-338 (Meadows/Dedo) as amended - withdrawn /edit Paper 01-343 (from Maine) accepted by the editor (Maine) /interp Paper 01-340 is new F95 interp #000096. Paper 01-345 is new F95 interp #000097. 4.6 Early closing business /J3 closing business preponed from Friday {5.3.1} Review of action items ACTION ITEMS: 1) D. Nagle will respond to John Reid and WG5 about the London resolutions. 2) M. North will put C. Dedo's liaisonship with NCITS/H2 on the J3 web page. 3) M. North will act as US host for the WG5 meetings scheduled for the US in November, 2002, and March, 2003. {5.3.2} Future meetings Meeting #159: December 3-7, 2001: Las Vegas, Residence Inn. Remaining dates are in Appendix C of these minutes. 17-Sep-2001 Page 11 of 26 01-347 {5.3.3} Treasurer's report - paper 01-346 Opening balance: $2961.69 Meeting expenses: $199.33 Final balance: $2762.36 ** motion: Set the meeting fee for future meetings at $50.00 (Dedo/Hirchert) - passed 10 - 0 {5.3.4} Closing membership report 13 of 15 members here or represented. Total attendance is 15. Brian Smith is in jeopardy. {5.3.5} Comments from members Mallory needs electronic copies of all papers and revisions. Plenary recessed until 8:00am Friday. 5. Friday, August 24, 2001 - Plenary reconvened at 8:00 am. 5.1 F2000 Plenary Group C: ** motion: paper 01-341 (Meadows/Dedo) as amended - passed 11 - 2 {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-342 (Meadows/Dedo) as amended - withdrawn ** motion: paper 01-338r1 (Meadows/Long) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-325r1 (Meadows/Long) as amended - passed 11 - 0 {post-meeting r2} Group A: ** motion: paper 01-279r1 (Whitlock/Meadows) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-282r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-283r1 (Whitlock/Hendrickson) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-333r1 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} 17-Sep-2001 Page 12 of 26 01-347 ** motion: paper 01-336r1 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-339 (Whitlock/Dedo) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} Paper 01-262 was reviewed; no further action will be taken. Group B: ** motion: paper 01-331 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r1} ** motion: paper 01-264r1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-273r1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-265r1 section 1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - motion to table failed with no second passed 9 - 0 {no post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-266r1 section 1 (Cohen/Snyder) as amended - u.c. {post-meeting r2} ** motion: paper 01-344 (Cohen/Snyder) - u.c. ** motion: paper 01-268r1 section 1 (Cohen/Snyder) - passed 9 - 0 5.2 F95 interpretation processing /interp ** motion: paper 01-345 interp #97 (Whitlock/Maine) - passed 8 - 1 There was a question about which "midnight" did an interp letter ballot close on: the midnight that ends the day or the midnight at begins the day. The chair of interp ruled that interp letter ballots will close at 11:59:59pm, ie, at the end of the day, to avoid astronomical confusion. 5.3 Closing business 5.3.1 Review of action items - see 4.6 {5.3.1} above 5.3.2 Future meetings - see 4.6 {5.3.2} above 17-Sep-2001 Page 13 of 26 01-347 5.3.3 Treasurer's report - paper 01-346 - see 4.6 {5.3.3} above 5.3.4 Closing membership report - see 4.6 {5.3.4} above 5.3.5 Comments from members None. Minutes for meeting will be paper 01-347. Mallory needs electronic copies of all papers and revisions. For next meeting, the chapter assignments for each group are Group A: chapters 8 through 12 Group B: chapter 13 through end Group C: beginning through chapter 7 5.3.6 Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 10:45am, August 24, 2001. 17-Sep-2001 Page 14 of 26 01-347 Appendix A: Final Agenda for J3 Meeting 158 =============================== 1. Monday, August 20, 2001 8:30 am -------------------------------- 1.1 Opening business D. Nagle Remarks from the chair D. Nagle Adoption of agenda D. Nagle Approval of Meeting 157 minutes D. Nagle NCITS/OMC report D. Nagle ISO/WG5 report V. Snyder Treasurer's report M. North Beginning membership report K. Hirchert Local arrangements M. North Comments from members 1.2 Subgroup organization D. Nagle 1.3 F95 interpretation organization S. Whitlock 1.4 Subgroup meetings 1.5 Subgroup reports (4:30 pm) 2. Tuesday, August 21, 2001 8:30 am --------------------------------- 2.1 F2001 Plenary (00-010) Subgroup Heads 2.2 F95 interpretation processing (00-006) S. Whitlock 2.3 Tutorials (if needed) 2.4 Subgroup meetings 2.5 Subgroup reports (4:00 pm) 3. Wednesday, August 22, 2001 8:30 am ----------------------------------- 3.1 F2001 Plenary Subgroup Heads 3.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 3.3 Tutorials (if needed) 3.4 Subgroup meetings 3.5 Subgroup reports (4:00 pm) 4. Thursday, August 23, 2001 8:30 am ---------------------------------- 4.1 F2001 Plenary Subgroup Heads 4.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 4.3 Tutorials (if needed) 4.4 Subgroup meetings 4.5 Subgroup reports (4:00 pm) 4.6 Early closing business 5. Friday, August 23, 2001 8:00 am -------------------------------- 5.1 F2001 Plenary Subgroup heads 5.2 F95 interpretation processing S. Whitlock 5.3 Closing business Review of action items (if any) Future meetings M. North Treasurer's report M. North Closing membership report K. Hirchert Comments from members Adjournment 17-Sep-2001 Page 15 of 26 01-347 Appendix B: PAPERS SUBMITTED FOR J3 MEETING 158 LAS VEGAS, NEVADA, AUGUST 20 - 24, 2001 -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Number Date Submitter Title -------------------------------------------------------------------------- J3/01-007r2 010622 Maine Draft revision to Fortran 2000 txt,ps,frame55,pdf,mif J3/01-011r2 010627 Maine Editor's list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-255 010622 Maine Edits incorporated in 01-007r2 txt J3/01-256 010622 Maine Changes to list of unresolved issues txt J3/01-257 010627 Maine Open unresolved issues txt J3/01-258 010629 Snyder Comments on section 2 ps J3/01-259 010629 Snyder Comments on section 4 ps J3/01-260 010629 Snyder Comments on section 5 ps J3/01-261 010706 Snyder Issue 337 ps J3/01-262 010709 Snyder Comments on section 7 ps J3/01-263 010709 Snyder Comments on section 13 ps J3/01-264 010711 Snyder Comments on section 8 ps,pdf J3/01-264r1 010822 Snyder Comments on section 8 ps J3/01-264r2 010824 Snyder Comments on section 8 ps J3/01-265 010713 Snyder Comments on section 9 ps,pdf J3/01-265r1 010822 Snyder Comments on section 9 ps J3/01-266 010715 Snyder Comments on section 10 ps,pdf J3/01-266r1 010823 Snyder Comments on section 10 ps J3/01-266r2 010824 Snyder Comments on section 10 ps J3/01-267 010717 Snyder Comments on section 11 ps,pdf J3/01-267r1 010821 Snyder Comments on section 11 ps J3/01-267r2 010822 Snyder Comments on section 11 ps 17-Sep-2001 Page 16 of 26 01-347 J3/01-268 010721 Snyder Comments on section 12 ps,pdf J3/01-268r1 010823 Snyder Comments on section 12 ps J3/01-269 010714 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps,pdf J3/01-269r1 010823 Snyder Comments on Annex C ps J3/01-270 010714 Snyder Issue 339 ps,pdf J3/01-270r1 010821 Snyder Issue 339 ps J3/01-270r2 010822 Snyder Issue 339 ps J3/01-271 010721 Snyder Further comments on Section 5 ps,pdf J3/01-272 010721 Snyder Issue 338 ps,pdf J3/01-273 010721 Snyder Issue 333 ps,pdf J3/01-273r1 010822 Snyder Issue 333 ps J3/01-273r2 010824 Snyder Issue 333 ps J3/01-274 010726 Whitlock F95 interp letter ballot # 5 - due txt 20-Jul-2001 J3/01-275 010726 Whitlock Results of the F95 interp letter bal- txt lot # 5 J3/01-276 010803 Hendrickson General questions about 007 txt J3/01-277 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 1 and Intro comments txt J3/01-278 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 2 comments txt J3/01-279 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments txt J3/01-279r1 010823 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments txt J3/01-279r2 010824 Hendrickson Chapter 3 comments txt J3/01-280 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 4 comments txt J3/01-281 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 5 comments txt J3/01-282 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments txt J3/01-282r1 010823 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments txt J3/01-282r2 010824 Hendrickson Chapter 6 comments txt 17-Sep-2001 Page 17 of 26 01-347 J3/01-283 010804 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments txt J3/01-283r1 010823 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments txt J3/01-283r2 010824 Hendrickson Chapter 7 comments txt J3/01-284 010804 Hendrickson Typos and Nits txt J3/01-284r1 010819 Hendrickson Typos and Nits txt J3/01-285 010806 Cohen Interpretation request on ENTRY txt points J3/01-285r1 010822 Cohen Interpretation request on ENTRY txt points J3/01-286 010806 Cohen The PROTECTED attribute txt J3/01-286r1 010820 Cohen The PROTECTED attribute ps J3/01-286r2 010820 Cohen The PROTECTED attribute ps J3/01-287 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp 7 txt J3/01-288 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp 9 txt J3/01-289 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp 27 txt J3/01-290 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 67 txt J3/01-290r1 010822 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 67 txt J3/01-291 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 71 txt J3/01-291r1 010821 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 71 txt J3/01-292 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp F90/207 txt J3/01-293 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/209 txt J3/01-293r1 010821 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/209 txt J3/01-294 010806 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/211 txt J3/01-294r1 010821 Cohen Proposed answer for Interp F90/211 txt J3/01-295 010806 Cohen WG5 recommendation on Interp 66 txt J3/01-295r1 010821 Cohen WG5 recommendation on Interp 66 txt J3/01-296 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 68 txt 17-Sep-2001 Page 18 of 26 01-347 J3/01-296r1 010821 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 68 txt J3/01-297 010806 Cohen Revised answer for Interp 86 txt J3/01-298 010806 Nagle Sj Response to a WG5 comment txt (bindname) J3/01-298r1 010821 Maine Remove bindname txt J3/01-299 010806 Nagle Sj Response to a WG5 comment txt (named scratch files) J3/01-299r1 010821 Nagle Response to a WG5 comment (named txt scratch files) J3/01-299r2 010907 Nagle Response to a WG5 comment (named txt scratch files) J3/01-300 010806 Reid Interpretation JP-17 (Multiple occur- txt rence of namelist group object in namelist group) J3/01-301 010806 Reid Interps ready for corrigendum 2 txt J3/01-302 010806 van Waveren Interp 91 (Definition of "present" is txt defective) J3/01-303 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-05 (Construction of array txt values) J3/01-303r1 010903 Whitlock Interp JP-05 (Construction of array txt values) - revised J3/01-304 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-31 (Signs of literal txt constants) J3/01-305 010806 van Waveren Interp 6 (Character length specifi- txt cation of a function result) J3/01-305r1 010903 Whitlock Interp 6 (Character length specifi- txt cation of a function result)-revised J3/01-306 010806 van Waveren Interp 26 (List-directed input: types txt of variables corresponding to repeat- ed values) J3/01-306r1 010903 Whitlock Interp 26 (List-directed input: types txt of variables corresponding to repeat- ed values) - revised J3/01-307 010806 van Waveren Interp F90/000212 (EQUIVALENCE of txt Data Objects of Different Types or Kinds) J3/01-308 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-04 (Construction of derived txt type values) J3/01-309 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-08 (Type declaration state- txt ments) J3/01-309r1 010903 Whitlock Interp JP-08 (Type declaration state- txt ments) - revised J3/01-310 010806 van Waveren Interp JP-16 (Multiple occurrence of txt namelist-group-name in NAMELIST statement) 17-Sep-2001 Page 19 of 26 01-347 J3/01-310r1 010903 Whitlock Interp JP-16 (Multiple occurrence of txt namelist-group-name in NAMELIST statement) - revised J3/01-311 010806 Meadows Square brackets for array construct- txt ors J3/01-311r1 010820 Meadows Square brackets for array construct- txt ors J3/01-312 010810 Reid Interpretation F90/000164: draft txt response J3/01-312r1 010822 Bleikamp Interpretation F90/000164: draft txt response J3/01-312r2 010822 Bleikamp Interpretation F90/000164: draft txt response J3/01-313 010811 Whitlock Editorial Comments on 01-007r2 txt J3/01-314 010811 Whitlock Comments/Questions on chapters 1 - 7 txt of 01-007r2 J3/01-314r1 010821 Whitlock Comments/Questions on chapters 1 - 7 txt,ps,wpd of 01-007r2 J3/01-315 010814 Nagle Response to a WG5 comment (value txt attribute) J3/01-315r1 010821 Maine Response to a WG5 comment (value txt attribute) J3/01-315r2 010822 Maine Response to a WG5 comment (value txt attribute) J3/01-316 010814 Dedo Named Scratch Files - Proposed txt,ps,wpd Response to WG5 J3/01-316r1 010820 Dedo Named Scratch Files - Proposed txt,ps,wpd Response to WG5 J3/01-317 010814 Dedo What is an Input/Output Error? txt,ps,wpd J3/01-318 010820 Dedo JOR response to 01-259 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-318r1 010821 Dedo JOR response to 01-259 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-319 010820 Dedo JOR response to 01-271 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-320 010818 Snyder Comments concerning 01-007r2 arising ps from or after the WG5 meeting J3/01-320r1 010822 Snyder Comments concerning 01-007r2 arising ps from or after the WG5 meeting J3/01-321 010820 Dedo JOR response to 01-258 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-322 010821 Snyder Purely editorial issues from /B ps J3/01-323 010821 Dedo Response to Chapter 1 and Intro txt,ps,wpd Comments J3/01-323r1 010822 Dedo Response to Chapter 1 and Intro txt,ps,wpd Comments 17-Sep-2001 Page 20 of 26 01-347 J3/01-324 010821 Meadows BOZ constants txt J3/01-325 010821 Meadows Section 15.2.6 Edits txt J3/01-325r1 010821 Subgroup C Section 15.2.6 Edits txt J3/01-325r2 010831 Subgroup C Section 15.2.6 Edits txt J3/01-326 010821 Cohen Unresolved Issue 338 ps J3/01-327 010821 Cohen Improving present terminological ps consistency J3/01-328 010821 Maine Reorg of c13 txt J3/01-328r1 010822 Maine Reorg of c13 txt J3/01-329 010821 Maine MINLOC/MAXLOC txt J3/01-330 010822 Nagle F2k+1 slides ps J3/01-331 010822 Snyder Repair use of undefined terms in ps Sections 9 and 10 J3/01-331r1 010824 Snyder Repair use of undefined terms in ps Sections 9 and 10 J3/01-332 010822 Dedo Response to Issue 337 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-332r1 010823 Dedo Response to Issue 337 txt,ps,wpd J3/01-333 010822 Nagle Flesh Out Intro txt J3/01-333r1 010823 Nagle Flesh Out Intro txt J3/01-333r2 010823 Nagle Flesh Out Intro txt J3/01-334 010822 Nagle Database Liaison Charge txt J3/01-335 010822 Dedo Response to Chapter 5 Comments txt,ps,wpd J3/01-335r1 010823 Dedo Response to Chapter 5 Comments txt,ps,wpd J3/01-336 010822 Bleikamp Program terminology cleanup txt J3/01-336r1 010823 Bleikamp Program terminology cleanup txt J3/01-336r2 01-08-23 Bleikamp Program terminology cleanup txt J3/01-337 010822 Moene Improving present terminology txt consistency II J3/01-338 010822 Subgroup C IEEE_SUPPORT_FLAG txt 17-Sep-2001 Page 21 of 26 01-347 J3/01-338r1 010823 Subgroup C IEEE_SUPPORT_FLAG txt J3/01-339 010823 Bleikamp Writing zero in list directed and txt namelist I/O J3/01-339r1 010823 Bleikamp Writing zero in list directed and txt namelist I/O J3/01-340 010823 Snyder Request for interpretation on txt end-of-record and PAD= J3/01-341 010822 Long Command line and environment txt intrinsics J3/01-341r1 010831 Subgroup C Command line and environment txt intrinsics J3/01-342 010823 Moene Apply answer to interp F95/000005 to txt IEEE_SELECTED_REAL_KIND J3/01-343 010823 Maine Edits from editor txt J3/01-344 010823 Cohen /DATA responses to 01-260 and 01-320 ps J3/01-345 010823 Maine Interp request on OPEN txt J3/01-346 010824 North Meeting 158 Treasurer's Report txt J3/01-347 010824 Whitlock Meeting 158 Minutes txt -------------------------------------------------------------------------- 17-Sep-2001 Page 22 of 26 01-347 Appendix C: Future Meetings and Distribution Meeting Conventions: - Four meetings per year - Attempt to schedule second full week of the month - Attempt to schedule meeting contiguous with WG5 annual meeting Future meeting schedule: 159 December 3 - 7, 2001, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: November 19, 2001 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 160 February 25 - March 1, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: February 11, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 161 May 13 - 17, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: April 29, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 162 August 11 - 16, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: July 29, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic Note: Joint meeting with WG5 163 November 11 - 15, 2002, in Las Vegas, NV Mallory North, acting host Premeeting distribution deadline: October 28, 2002 Premeeting distribution: electronic Post-meeting distribution: electronic 17-Sep-2001 Page 23 of 26 01-347 Committee materials availability: Agenda and meeting notice available at the J3 web site and from the J3 ftp server. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution 4 weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3) Pre- and post-meeting distribution available at the J3 ftp and web sites. Sent individually to other interested parties that specifically request to be sent the material either via surface mail or electronic mail. REQUIREMENT: Distribution of premeeting 2 weeks prior to meeting. (documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1) Meeting minutes are available at the J3 web and ftp sites. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- ftp site: ftp://ftp.j3-fortran.org/j3 J3 World Wide Web site URL: http://www.j3-fortran.org ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 17-Sep-2001 Page 24 of 26 01-347 Appendix D: Committee Organization D.1 Officers and Management Chair D. Nagle International Rep. V. Snyder Secretary S. Whitlock Treasurer M. North Librarian M. North Editor R. Maine (WG5 appointment) Maintenance S. Whitlock Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert Future Meetings M. North Membership List K. Hirchert H2 Liaison C. Dedo D.2 Subgroups JOR: Responsible for the maintenance of the Journal of Development (standing document 004) and managing the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R.1, R.2, R.8, and all MTE and B items. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, C. Dedo, D. Hendrickson, D. Nagle DATA: Responsible for language design topics related to data and data structures; manages the following Fortran 2000 requirements: R3, R5, R6, and R7. M. Cohen (head), K. Hirchert, R. Maine, J. Martin, V. Snyder INTEROP: Responsible for R9 (interoperability with C) L. Meadows (head), B. Long, R. Maine, M. van Waveren INTERP: Responsible for evaluating interpretation requests, providing responses to such requests, and maintaining standing document 006. S. Whitlock (head), R. Bleikamp, M. Cohen 17-Sep-2001 Page 25 of 26 01-347 Appendix E: Membership summary J3 Meeting Attendance (Principal Members) Meeting # 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 Location (state) UK NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV NV Date (month year) 06 08 11 02 05 09 12 03 06 08 99 99 99 00 00 00 00 01 01 01 Name Affiliation Bleikamp, Richard HP A V A** V V V A V A** V Cohen, Malcolm NAG V V V V R V V V V V (Compaq rep) Compaq A RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP A Dedo, Craig self A** V** V V V V V V V V Hendrickson, Dick self V V V V V A V A** V V Hirchert, Kurt U of IL A A** Q V V V V V Hirchert, Kurt U of KY V V Q Long, William Cray RP RP RP RP RP RP RP RP V V Martin, Jeanne self V Meadows, Larry Sun RP RP RP RP V V V V V V Nagle, Dan self P V V V V V V V V North, Mallory Rose-Hulman V V V V V V V V V V Smith, Brian U of NM A R A** R R R R A R A** Snyder, Van JPL/Caltech V V V V V V V V V V van Waveren, Matthijs Fujitsu V A** V R V A A** R** V R Whitlock, Stan Intel P A RP R RP R A V J3 Letter Ballot Participation (Principal Members) Meeting # 152a 153a 154a 155a 156a 157a Date (month year) 05 07 11 03 05 07 00 00 00 01 01 01 Name Affiliation Bleikamp, Richard HP V V V V V V Cohen, Malcolm NAG V V V R V V (Compaq rep) Compaq RP RP RP RP RP RP Dedo, Craig self V V V V V V Hendrickson, Dick self V V V V V V Hirchert, Kurt U of IL V V V V Hirchert, Kurt U of KY V V Long, William Cray RP RP RP RP V V Meadows, Larry Sun RP V V V V V Martin, Jeanne self Nagle, Dan self V V V V V V North, Mallory Rose-Hulman V V V V V V Smith, Brian U of NM R R R R A R Snyder, Van JPL/Caltech V V V V V V van Waveren, Matthijs Fujitsu V V R V V V Whitlock, Stan Intel E RP RP RP RP RP 17-Sep-2001 Page 26 of 26 01-347 V present and voting other voting attendees: R absent but represented A absent and not represented non-voting attendees: P present and not voting R Maine, alternate for M Cohen RP represented by previous member A Vaught, visitor from FSF E excused Q Resigned ** missed 2 of last 3 meetings *** lost membership Total Membership at beginning of Meeting 158 15 Majority 8 Quorum 5 Total Membership at end of Meeting 158 15 Total Members Attended or Represented at 158 13 Total Attendees at Meeting 158 15 membership changes since last meeting: Jeanne Martin joined, representing herself. She was given immediate voting status, as she was present at the previous meeting (representing Brian Smith). Stan Whitlock was named the new principal member from Intel. A new alternate for Brian Smith has not yet been named. A new principal member from Compaq has not yet been named. ********************************************************************** Appendix F: Membership Roster The Membership Roster is not reproduced here. The current Membership Roster may be found in ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/01-001.html and ftp://j3-fortran.org/j3/doc/standing/01-001.txt