J3/03-173 Date: 1 Apr 2003 To: J3 From: Richard Maine Subject: Action on Japan's comments The following edits from Japan's comments are accepted as is: [13:32] Add the case of a scoping unit of an interface body to "all program units and subprograms" to justify the "IMPORT state- ments" in Table 2.1. [24:7+] In Table 3.1, change "Vertical bar" to "Vertical line", i.e. the name of "|" in ISO/IEC 646 and ISO/IEC 10646. [71:6+] In NOTE 5.5, line 12, change "matrix" to "humongous_matrix". [91:16+] In NOTE 5.36, line 6, change "need" to "need to". [109:4] Move the rule R632 after R626. [121:7+] In Table 7.1, change "C I,R L,L" to "C C L" for rel-ops. [253:12] Exchange this paragraph and the next. [255:9-24] Move all the R rules immediately after R1205. C1202 has a forward reference and is hard to read. [258:5] Adjust the space between "7.1.3" and "7.1.8.7". [265:9-10] The restriction that an actual argument corresponding to a polymorphic dummy argument must be polymorphic is, in our opinion, surprising, even in the case of dummy argument that is allocatable or pointer. Add a note explaining the intent. [292:9] Change "total number" to "Total number". [333:(positional)7] Add ")" after "FROM (12.7.3". [353:6-10] Exchange and renumber Subsections 13.8.1 and 13.8.2. [362:26] Change "[P,][R]" to "[P,R]". [378:] In NOTE 14.14, Change "--" to "-". [379:] In NOTE 14.15, Change "--" to "-" thrice. The following edits are modified, for the reasons stated [2:24] before "kind" insert "an intrinsic type with a". "values" -> "value". move the "(4.4)" to after "processor". {The condition is only relevant for kind type parameters of intrinsic types. We clarify that, which was probably a good thing to do anyway. Then it becomes more obvious that 4.4 is an appropriate xref.} [173:27] No edit (unless JOR suggests otherwise). {Japan suggested deleting "or a file positioning statement", noting that "This clause has been here for long, but we found it unnecessary and confusing." I am uncertain of the technical effect of this edit and thus am reluctant to do it as editor. I'll leave the technical question to JOR.} [261:13+] At beginning of Note 12.14 insert "The following code illustrates PROCEDURE statements. Note 7.42 illustrates the use of the P and BESSEL defined by this code."