MINUTES OF MEETING 126 X3J3 FORTRAN July 12-16, 1993 Brussels, Belgium X3J3/Meeting 126 X3J3/93-239 Table Of Contents 1 Agenda 1 2 Opening Business 2 2.1 Meeting Objectives & Chair's Report 2 2.1.2 Berchtesgaden Resolution B9 2 2.2 Adoption of the Final Agenda 2 2.3 Membership/Attendance Report 2 2.4 Approval of Meeting 125 Minutes 2 2.5 Review of the Action Items from Meeting 125 2 2.6 X3/OMC (SPARC) Report 3 2.7 ISO/WG5 Report 3 2.8 Resolution B9 Assignments 3 2.9 Meeting 126 Assignments 5 2.10 Standing Document 6 (93-006) 5 3 Committee Action Items 5 3.1 Interpretations Processing (July 13) 5 3.2 Interpretations Processing (July 14) 5 3.2.1 PROC 5 3.2.2 Not-PROC 5 3.3 Technical Subgroup Processing (July 14) 6 3.3.1 /edit 6 3.3.2 /parallel 6 3.3.3 /JOR 6 3.3.4 /OOF 6 3.3.5 Tutorial on Pointer and Derived Type Initialisation6 3.4 Miscellaneous Items (July 15) 7 3.4.1 X3T2 Knowledge Interchange Format (KIF) 7 3.4.2 Responses to the WG5 Resolutions 7 3.5 Technical Subgroup Processing (July 15) 7 3.5.1 /parallel 7 3.5.2 /OOF 7 3.5.3 /edit 8 3.5.4 /imp 8 3.5.2 /JOR 8 3.6 Interpretations Processing (July 15) 8 3.7 Response to B9 Item C7 (July 15) 9 3.8 Responses to WG5 Resolutions (July 15) 10 3.9 Interpretations Processing (July 16) 10 3.10 Membership (July 16) 10 3.11 Requirements (July 16) 10 4 Closing Business 11 4.0 Interpretations Summary 11 4.1 Membership Report 11 4.2 Future Meetings 11 4.3 Agenda of Meeting 127 11 4.4 Treasurer's Report 11 4.5 Action Items Review 11 4.6 Comments from Members 12 4.7 Adjournment 12 5 Document Lists 12 5.1 Current Standing Documents 12 5.2 1993 Document Register 12 5.3 1993 Documents By Meeting 17 5.3.1 Meeting 124 Documents 17 5.3.2 Meeting 125 Documents 17 5.3.3 Meeting 126 Documents 17 6 Committee Organization 18 6.1 Officers 18 6.2 Subgroups 18 7 Future Meetings and Distribution Assignments 18 8 Membership 20 8.1 Meeting Attendance 20 8.2 X3J3 Membership 21 1 Agenda Agenda for X3J3 Meeting 126 Monday, July 12, 1993 8:30 Opening Business J. Wagener Meeting objectives and Chair's report Adopting agenda Membership report/Introductions R. Kelble Approving Meeting 125 minutes Review Meeting 125 Action items R. Kelble X3/SPARC report J. Wagener ISO/WG5 report J.Martin, I. Philips Interpretation Processing Report Discussion of Committee Organization Comments from members 1:30 Interpretations Subgroup Meetings Tuesday, July 13, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads Interpretations Subgroup Meetings 1:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads Technical Subgroup Meetings Wednesday, July 14, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads Interpretations Subgroup Meetings 1:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads 4:00 Technical Subgroup Meetings 6:00 Implementation Subgroup Meeting Thursday, July 15, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads Review of Draft Responses to the WG5 Resolutions M. Hoffert Interpretations Subgroup Meetings Friday, July 16, 1993 8:30 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads Closing Business R. Kelble Membership Report Future Meetings Treasurer's Report Next Meeting Agenda Action Items Reviewed Comments from Members Subgroup Meetings (interpretations/technical as needed) 4:00 Subgroup Reports and Processing Subgroup heads 5:00 Adjournment 2 Opening Business 2.1 Meeting Objectives & Chair's Report 1. Continue processing interpretations 2. Respond to WG5 Berchtesgaden Resolutions 3. Plan for the 1995 revision 2.1.2 Berchtesgaden Resolution B9 note: A short discussion of this resolution took place to inform those who were not in attendance at the WG5 meeting of the intent. Schonfelder: My understanding is that the second list is expected to be requirements, i.e., WG5 would be cross if we didn't work on those unless we had good technical reasons. Weaver: Any additional requirements that we bring next year must be accompanied by rather complete proposals. Bierman: We should use a one-third positive vote to forward a requirement. Hoffert: For the next year, we need to work on those that WG5 has requested, but we also should prepare complete proposals on any additional requirements that we wish to see added to the 1995 revision. Ellis: Note that WG5 expects that we follow this list in roughly a priority order. Given that they all have been addressed, additional requirements with the appropriate analysis may be brought forward. WG5 does expect that we will subcontract some of the work as appropriate. Hendrickson: Fortran 95 should not be everything we can get done between now and 1995. 2.2 Adoption of the Final Agenda Discussion Leader: Jerry Wagener Ellis: I would like to see the agenda distributed with as part of the premeeting. Motion: (Hirchert/Lahey) Adopt the agenda as modified. Action: Motion passed by unanimous consent. 2.3 Membership/Attendance Report Discussion Leader: Rich Kelble At the end of the last meeting there were 30 members. Andrew Tait resigned between meetings leaving 29 members at the beginning of this meeting, 15 of whom are present or represented. Seven members will be in jeopardy of losing their membership if they don't attend this meeting. 2.4 Approval of Meeting 125 Minutes Discussion Leader: Rich Kelble Reference: 93-200 Weaver: Future updates of the 006 will be based on the interpretations summary (see section 4.0 of the minutes). Motion: (Kelble/Martin) Approve the minutes of meeting 125 as modified by 93-200. Action: Motion passed by unanimous consent. 2.5 Review of the Action Items from Meeting 125 Reference: Minutes of meeting 125 1. Andrew Tait: Make rules about the use of page and line numbers in 006. At meeting 124, a straw vote on whether they should appear was (21-0-3), so the rules should include the form and location of page and line numbers in 006. Status: Closed -- Page and line numbers will be enclosed in [] and may be placed anywhere within the text. 2. Jerry Wagener discuss with Andrew Tait: A subgroup field should be added to the 006 items. Status: Closed -- This has been ruled not necessary. 3. Andrew Tait:: Make a ruling on the format of standard citations in the 006. Currently, some are enclosed in quotation marks and some are indented. Status: Closed -- Citations must be distinct. If any are not, inform the editor. 2.6 X3/OMC (SPARC) Report There was nothing to report this meeting. 2.7 ISO/WG5 Report Discussion Leader: Jeanne Martin Martin: Let's take turns giving our impressions of last week's meeting. Bierman: WG5 started with many requirements and was able to work in down to a small number. Ellis: There is a new relationship between WG5 and X3J3. There is trust between the groups. Hoffert: A key indicator was the vote on item 13 from the defect index (006) as it was a sign of cooperation. Resolution B9 was another sign of renewed trust as it does not attempt to micromanage X3J3. It gives us timely additions in the 1995 revision, e.g. HPF features. Hirchert: The votes were easy. There was consensus in most cases. Kelble: The entire group worked hard and much was accomplished. Lahey: It was more enjoyable than past meetings as people were working together. Schonfelder: The Varying String Module will be complete for forwarding to SC22 in the next few weeks. Weaver: The meeting ran by consensus building which is a sign of growing trust. Philips: There was growing trust. The emphasis was on what and not how. X3J3 must get its act together regarding what our requirements are. Martin: I was surprised by WG5 accepting so much of HPF. There were only a few edits to the strategic plan. Only the edits in the defect index are being forwarded as the corrigenda. The defect index will also be forwarded to SC22. The Varying String Module will be forwarded after a 30 day WG5 letter ballot. It will be part of a multipart standard. The bindings report will also be forwarded to SC22. Hendrickson: How enthusiastic was WG5 for HPF? answer: They generally favored the rule of thumb that the majority of HPF programs should run with little or no change on a Fortran 95 processor. 2.8 Resolution B9 Assignments Discussion Leader: Jerry Wagener Reference: 93-204 Lahey: I will take item C1, CPU time. Bierman: The X3J3 manager should be a specific persons not a subgroup. Ellis: /OOF must prepare 2 papers for next meeting which may be premature as they first need to address the direction of OOF and present that to the committee. Philips: I will have a list of volunteers for subcontracting shortly. Three items don't have a required report at the next meeting. Hoffert: In some places where the names are not certain, we should assign the tasks to /JOR at least for the moment. Hirchert: I read the 3 items not specifically requiring a report to be that you just take the referenced document as a basis for a paper. Lahey: I too would like to see names instead of subgroups as the X3J3 manager. Wagener: Perhaps the subgroup should give us a name to put here. Lahey: I too feel that /OOF should present a general plan before pursuing any specific items. Schonfelder: Several of these items are not orthogonal and should be considered together by a subgroup. Weaver: Rather than having an X3J3 subgroup subcontract, Jerry should ask the head of national delegation to do some work and to submit this work to X3J3 by some given time. Martin: WG5 was adamant that with A1 that the editorial work be minimal. They don't want a rewrite of the standard. In many cases, we also need to supply a requirement as well as the proposals. There are several which do not have requirements, e.g., A2, A3, and A4. Hendrickson: The X3J3 manager column should be split in 2: the subgroup and the X3J3 champion who will read and promote the papers from any subcontractor on that issue. We can not assign an item to a subcontractor until we all agree on what we want. Schonfelder: Even when there are subcontractors, X3J3 must look at the resultant work and determine if it can be accomplished. Weaver: For each items to be subcontracted there must be a scope of work supplied by us and it should be a short document. Ellis: At WG5 it was suggested that any member body which takes on subcontracting work should be prepared to send a representative to at least the X3J3 meeting where their proposal is presented. Regarding not determining the subcontractor at this meeting, we just don't have enough time to wait until next meeting to get started. Hoffert: We need to assign these tasks to groups which represent general functional areas. Some of the assignments do that while others are in specific areas. Jerry can't manage all of these items on his own. It must be handled by others. X3J3 must take charge of this work. We are not putting another national body down by having them report to an X3J3 subgroup. Hirchert: I viewed this as working like the early Fortran 90 work, i.e., present a tutorial at one meeting and bring a proposal to the next meeting. Bierman: In subcontracting we must also remember to list what we don't want. Schonfelder: Some of these items, i.e., the edits and the HPF items, don't require any technical tutorials as the work is done. The other items will require technical tutorials first to describe the issues and alternatives and the committee should agree on a direction before the edits are done. Wagener: The X3J3 manager column will be broken into 3 columns: the X3J3 subgroup, the X3J3 contact and the external contractor. The last column will be the meeting 127 objectives. 2.9 Meeting 126 Assignments Ellis: The priority of this meeting should be development and not interpretations. Schonfelder: We should emphasize those interpretations that are likely to cause aberrant implementations. 2.10 Standing Document 6 (93-006) note: Only machine readable files in straight ASCII text will be accepted if current text is being replaced. Weaver: We should separate the items which are WG5 approved into another document. straw: Do you prefer splitting the 006 into the 006 and the 009 or the 006a and the 006b? (3-4-8) Wagener: We will use the 006a and the 006b. 3 Committee Action Items As there is no secretary at the moment, the secretarial duties were rotated as follows: Monday: Rich Kelble Tuesday: Graham Barber Wednesday: Miles Ellis Thursday: Keith Bierman Friday: Ivor Philips 3.1 Interpretations Processing (July 13) Interpretation 000139 in 006 Motion : Adopt 000139 in 006 with minor editorial changes which will be supplied by subgroup to the acting 006 editor Mover : J. Martin Second : L. Rolison After much discussion a straw vote was held : Straw Vote Yes : You like the interpretation as proposed No : You would like it fixed up by subgroup Result : 1-8-5 The motion was withdrawn and the interpretation returned to subgroup for fixing Interpretation 000007 in 006 After much discussion, the interpretation was reassigned to the PROC subgroup for future discussion with Janice Shepherd when the status of the interpretation can be straightened out. 3.2 Interpretations Processing (July 14) 3.2.1 PROC RFI #000135 (X3J3/93-208) (Hirchert/Maine) Straw vote on whether to accept the approach recommended: SV: 2/12/1 Action: Return to subgroup for reconsideration. 3.2.2 Not-PROC RFI #000097 (X3J3/93-211) (Hendrickson/Schonfelder) Passed by Unanimous Consent. RFI #000081 (X3J3/93-213) (Martin/Rolison) Passed by Unanimous Consent. Note that this interpretation assumes that interpretation 125, which was passed by 17-1 at meeting 125, is also approved by letter ballot. Both items should be balloted together. RFI #000134 (X3J3/93-215) (Barber/Rolison) A possible contradiction with interpretation 12 was identified. Action: Return to subgroup for reconsideration. RFI #000142 (X3J3/93-218) (Kelble/Rolison) Straw vote on whether to accept the approach in 93- 218 or to make a change to a constraint (which would have to be checked): SV1: 3/2/8 (Leave as in proposal/change to a constraint/undecided) Straw vote on whether to have the name change, as recommended in the answer to Question 2, or to leave the name unchanged: SV2: 4/1/9 (Different name as in proposal/same name/undecided) Action: Return to subgroup for reconsideration. RFI #000133 (X3J3/93-219) (Rolison/Hendrickson) Passed by Unanimous Consent. 3.3 Technical Subgroup Processing (July 14) 3.3.1 /edit The charter of /edit is to create/maintain S007 and S008 (the new document and the edits to create it). This is quite separate from the corrigenda. 3.3.2 /parallel Current plan is to have some papers for meeting 127, and to complete the work by meeting 129. The following short report was tabled: We interpret our "HPF" charter as follows: "The majority of HPF programs should run on a Fortran 95 conforming processor with minimal modification." This means that the parts of HPF which provide syntax or new intrinsics must be dealt with. /parallel shall find an X3J3 member to coordinate all of the work. We (/parallel) will liaise with various other groups to insure a sound proposal. Items to do: 1. FOR ALL statement 2. FOR ALL construct 3. Pure and possibly elemental functions 4. A solution to the "3 intrinsics" (a) allow user-defined functions of some sort in specification statements (b) include the "3" on some subset 5. FOR ALL and WHERE shall operate in a similar fashion. Either both nest or neither nests 6. We will NOT do anything with HPF directives or libraries 7. We will not handle EXTRINSIC 3.3.3 /JOR Bierman, Rolison and Hirchert gave brief reports on their plans for the items for which they were the X3J3 contacts (see X3J3/93-204). 3.3.4 /OOF /OOF will propose that a new standing document (S009?) be created as a repository for new proposals, etc., in connection with the 1995 revision. 3.3.5 Tutorial on Pointer and Derived Type Initialisation Discussion Leader: Schonfelder Reference: X3J3/93-207 Following the tutorial, three straw votes were taken: Straw vote on whether the preferred form of pointer initialisation was that proposed in the paper, using a special (typeless) constant, or the use of a function, e.g. NULLIFY: SV1: 7/6/1 (Function/typeless constant as in paper/undecided) Straw vote on the acceptability of the two proposed forms of pointer initialisation: SV2: 3/6/4 (Not a function/not a typeless constant/undecided) Straw vote on the preferred form of "constructor" (see section 4 of X3J3/93-207): SV3: 6/0/7 (Module/Type/undecided) 3.4 Miscellaneous Items (July 15) 3.4.1 X3T2 Knowledge Interchange Format (KIF) Wagener: If someone has an interest in this area, we could use a volunteer to review and respond to their request. 3.4.2 Responses to the WG5 Resolutions Martin: fix defect editor resolution. Ellis: note this is a draft response, not final response (that will need to occur closer to the WG5 meeting, observed the oddness of some of this years resolutions due to premature finalization). Wagener: Observation: the strategic plan is working. We should say so. Weaver: "...plan" is weak. we should have a better formulation. Ellis: "leverage is a noun" Long discussion of wording not recorded. No vote taken at this time. 3.5 Technical Subgroup Processing (July 15) 3.5.1 /parallel Report produced (see 3.3.2). No further work planned this week, other than final selection of "advocate". Ultimately Dick Hendrickson revealed himself as the Parallel Advocate. 3.5.2 /OOF /OOF vote scheduled for c7, derived type I/O. Much discussion of the Forest and its Trees. Hendrickson: Too early to remove anything from consideration. Ellis: Not too early; no way we will have enough resources. Schonfelder: "I am going to be like Janus" and agree with both of them. Hoffert: Focus on key items, defer this. Weaver: Read passage from the B* document, requested us to prepare a paper on the topic for WG5. Bierman: We ought to be honest with ourselves and with WG5. Therefore we ought to say if we *plan* to work on this, if not say so *now*. This will enable WG5 members to volunteer if they desire. Martin: were lots of old proposals. was too hard. Ellis: can write a very simple paper later. Wagener: likes Dick's idea. Please amend. Hoffert: this would be "make work". Intent of WG5 is clear. Weaver: Read B9 again. Focused on Leverage. Wants paper with details of old proposals. This would facilitate WG5 volunteering. Lahey: I learned a lot during this debate. I learned that there were old proposals. We should put this into the formal response. Hendrickson: aren't opposed. why was this put on the list? Martin: must do something. echoes of Wagener's argument. Ellis: list constructed by black art. c7 is lowest on the wish list. May be more a reflection of it not being *opposed* by anyone. Maine: 25-x-x do something; but 0 votes for 1995. Wagener: intro of Kees Ampt from Netherlands. Adams: supports removal of c7. assign a WG5 member to do the work. Ampt: this is a "road sign". Don't do anything to prevent it. Bierman: call the question 7-6 Ellis: unreasonable to assign the task to WG5, they assigned it to us. Request that the text be amended to reflect the WG5 vote (viz. do it, but not necessarily in 1995). Wording to the effect "In view of the WG5 votes, lack of J3 resource, postpone c7 until 2K revision. Lahey: too much time invested. This has already consumed a 1/2 hour of committee time + subgroup time. Vote: motion as amended: 12-1 motion PASSED. 3.5.3 /edit /edit paper 229 will appear soon, defer discussion until then. 3.5.4 /imp /imp met last night. lots of votes. a paper is in progress. 3.5.2 /JOR /ieee worked deferred until papers in hand (viz. return home). Work schedule is tentatively to have something ready for IFIP 2.5 to look at their meeting in September. /Adams will email D. Muxworthy. UK will do the work. There will be an item selected for deletion, and at least one to be made obsolescent. /Lahey CPU time paper to be produced. Will ballot on network(s). 3.6 Interpretations Processing (July 15) 212 /proc Hirchert/Hoffert Rolison: too language lawyerly Lahey: agree vote: 11-2 PASS 218 /non-proc Kelble/Rolison Ellis: reminded us of straw votes of yesterday. Massive indecision. Kelble: keep name is "right thing" vote: 13-1, motion PASS 220: /non proc deferred until later 221 /proc "The Big Edit" Hirchert/Ellis Hirchert: lots of host association problems. many edits refer to the same *words*. This will enable several outstanding interpretations to be resolved. Worked on (and presented) at the last meeting. Weaver: why not subsume several interpretations into a single one? This is not considerate. Hirchert: pointers not in this proposal will be done later. /proc will take care of doing the work. Ellis: do this first. fix the other items later. paper 185 last meeting identified related works. Weaver: 006 will not reflect all of this at the end of this meeting. Hirchert: can supply history list edits Lahey: How does this relate to last meetings tutorial? misc: this is the same paper (modulo trivial fixups and reformatting) as last meeting. Maine: refer to paper 93-185. Rolison: Data entrees of a "type *name* ..." rather than "derived type" . Mover/ seconder accepted rewording. Motion *PASSED* by unanimous consent. 223 /non proc Martin/Rolison Martin: identical to last meeting, but now with no edit. Rolison: amend "cited constraint as cited text" Deferred until later. 224, 225 /proc papers deferred 227, 228, 215r2 chaotic discussion notetaker suffered core dump. 223R Martin/Adams revised to fix discussion, minor editorial revised with help from Rolison. *PASS* unanimous consent. 234 Hirchert/Ellis 006 item 82 addendum *PASS* unanimous consent 225 "use intrinsics" Ellis/Hoffert Weaver: violent opposition. portability is seriously impacted. use statement is not a switch. Schonfelder: disagrees with Dick Maine: reads conformance section Hoffert: defines toggle. Maine: what about real*8? namely could a USE "funny_math" module be defined to switch recognition of real*8? Likes a firm demarcation. Schonfelder: interfaces - implementations using language still standard. Notes that portable and standard conforming are different. Weaver; non-standard features involve a "contract" between the vendor and the customer that is outside the standard. 7-4 motion *PASSES* Ellis: more about this on the letter ballot, no doubt. 208r1 Hirchert/Hoffert unanimous consent *PASSES* 232 Hirchert/Ellis Weaver: will /edit fix document? Martin: editorial "n" Hirchert emended unanimous consent *PASSES* 235 Hirchert/Hoffert fixed in the Big EDIT unanimous consent *PASSES* Wagener: with today's processing we have decreased the total net backlog by 2. 3.7 Response to B9 Item C7 (July 15) 231 Martin/Ellis Adams: "early" objection, the wording seems a bit arrogant. Others opined the wording was "kind". Weaver: Someone to take action item to do an email posting. Rolison: spelling employing UK or USA rules? Ellis: intent to flag soon via email Misc: wordsmithing attempts. Edited by Hoffert and accepted y mover and seconder. unanimous Consent. *PASSED* 3.8 Responses to WG5 Resolutions (July 15) 93-0005r2 Hoffert/Bierman as amended by Adams. unanimous consent *PASSED*. 3.9 Interpretations Processing (July 16) Papers: 215-r2, 227-r1, 228 Proposers: Barber/Rolison Hirchert: Change default type on 227-r1 to erratum Weaver Interpretations have no edits. Will put a note to that effect in the introduction to 006 Result: UNANIMOUS CONSENT Papers: 93-220r Proposers: Martin/Adams Weaver: Public and Private control access of names not entities. Page 44 says ...controls accessibility of entities... Martin: We will make some editorial changes. Result: MOTION WAS WITHDRAWN. Maine: There are many places in the document where "name" and "entity" are confused. Straw Vote: Generally in favor of separating an entity and its name 9-3-3 Papers: 93-236 Proposers: Rolison Maine Ellis: Change "all" to "although" Result: UNANIMOUS CONSENT 3.10 Membership (July 16) Motion: Alex Marusak membership be accepted Proposers: Kelble/Lahey Result: UNANIMOUS CONSENT 3.11 Requirements (July 16) Motion: Accept requirements material for Fortran 95 and Fortran 2000, for forwarding to WG5, based on acceptance by a majority of those voting. A two-thirds majority, or greater, of those voting will be required to remove it. Proposers: Bierman/Philips Result: UNANIMOUS CONSENT Motion: Email ballots for requirements to be forwarded to WG5 will pass if a majority of the members email yes ballots. Membership will not be affected by such voting. Proposers: Bierman/Philips Straw Vote: 4-4 FAILS Paper: 93-210 Straw Votes: #19 3-3-6 #20 8-0-3 #22 4-5-3 #30 1-1-9 #31 7-4-2 #15 Conditional compilation in language 7 Part 3 of a multipart standard 6 Neither 5 Undecided 0 #26 6-3-4 #24 2-0-10 Move something from obsolescent status to deleted status for 1995 5-5-0 Remove PAUSE in 1995 5-4-1 4 Closing Business 4.0 Interpretations Summary 93-006 Paper Minutes Item Reference Reference Mover/Seconder Disposition 12 93-227r1 3.6, 3.9 Barber/Rolison unanimous consent 32 93-234 3.6 Hirchert/Ellis unanimous consent 81 93-213 3.2.2 Martin/Rolison unanimous consent 82 93-221 3.6 Hirchert/Ellis unanimous consent 86 93-234 3.6 Hirchert/Ellis unanimous consent 90 93-234 3.6 Hirchert/Ellis unanimous consent 91 93-220r 3.6, 3.9 Martin/Adams withdrawn 97 93-211 3.2.2 Hendrickson/Philips unanimous consent 99 93-232 3.6 Hirchert/Ellis unanimous consent 114 93-228 3.6, 3.9 Barber/Rolison unanimous consent 122 93-225 3.6 Ellis/Hoffert 7-4 127 93-235 3.6 Hirchert/Hoffert unanimous consent 132 93-212 3.6 Hirchert/Hoffert 11-2 133 93-219 3.2.2 Rolison/Hendrickson unanimous consent 134 93-215r2 3.2.2, 3.6, 3.9 Barber/Rolison unanimous consent 135 93-208r1 3.2.1, 3.6 Hirchert/Hoffert unanimous consent 139 93-006.000139 3.1 Rolison/Martin withdrawn 140 93-223r1 3.6 Martin/Adams unanimous consent 142 93-218r 3.2.2, 3.6 Kelble/Rolison 13-1 144 93-236 3.9 Rolison/Maine unanimous consent 4.1 Membership Report Discussion Leader: Maureen Hoffert At this meeting 24 of our 30 members were either present of represented. 6 members are in jeopardy of losing their membership (Walt Brainerd, Alex Marusak, Geoff Millard, Linda O'Gara, Ivor Philips, and Andrew Tait). 4.2 Future Meetings See section 7 of these minutes. 4.3 Agenda of Meeting 127 Discussion: An initial discussion of the agenda was held. All further suggestions should be sent to Rich. 4.4 Treasurer's Report The Treasurer's Report will be in the papers for the next meeting. 4.5 Action Items Review 1. Miles Ellis: Distribute 92-231, X3J3 Consideration of WG5 Resolution B9 item C7, to the WG5 email list and announce the availability of 93-005, Responses and Resolutions, on the X3J3 server. Status: New. 2. Kurt Hirchert: Put 93-005, Responses and Resolutions, on the X3J3 server. Status: New. 3. Rich Kelble: Update the document processing procedures to describe email access to the X3J3 server. Status: New 4.6 Comments from Members 4.7 Adjournment 5 Document Lists 5.1 Current Standing Documents The current standing documents of this committee are 93- 000 through 93-010. 5.2 1993 Document Register Item Number Submitter/Title X3J3/93-000 Register of Documents X3J3/93-001 X3J3/93-002 X3J3/93-003 X3J3 Processes and Procedures X3J3/93-004r3 Moss/Journal of Development X3J3/93-005r2X3J3 Resolutions and Responses to WG5 Resolutions X3J3/93-006 Tait/Defect Report X3J3/93-007 Draft Revision to Fortran 90 X3J3/93-008r3ED/Editorial Considerations for 9X Draft Revision X3J3/93-009 Approved Proposals X3J3/93-010 X3J3/93-011 Shepherd/RFI: PARAMETER and SAVE statements X3J3/93-012 Wagener/Index to X3 Documents X3J3/93-013 Wagener/Interpretation Procedures X3J3/93-014 Wagener/X3J3 Organization X3J3/93-015r1 Wagener/S20 (93-006) Status Summary X3J3/93-015 Wagener/S20 (93-006) Status Summary X3J3/93-016 Wagener/Letter Ballot on S20.123 Items X3J3/93-017 Wagener/Results of S20.123 Letter Ballot X3J3/93-018 Reid/Comments on S20.123 X3J3/93-019 Moss/Report on JOD Meeting X3J3/93-020r1 Wagener/X3J3 Letter Ballot Record X3J3/93-020 Wagener/X3J3 Letter Ballot Record X3J3/93-021 Wagener/Approval of Project 966-I X3J3/93-022 Wagener/X3T2 Reply to X3J3 Review of CLID X3J3/93-023 O'Gara/How to Number Documents X3J3/93-024 O'Gara/Response to RFI #91 X3J3/93-025 Moss/RFI: Intrinsic Procedures in Modules X3J3/93-026r1 Moss/Fortran Requirements Procedures X3J3/93-026 Moss/Fortran Requirements Procedures X3J3/93-027 Shepherd/RFI: Initialization Procedures X3J3/93-028 Shepherd/RFI: Multiple USE of Modules X3J3/93-029 Shepherd/RFI: Multiple Accessible Defined Assign't X3J3/93-030r1 Shepherd/RFI: USE and Host Association X3J3/93-030 Shepherd/RFI: USE and Host Association X3J3/93-031 Hoffert/Fortran Requirements Collection Process X3J3/93-032r1 Martin/Proposed response to S20.89 X3J3/93-032 Martin/Proposed response to S20.89 X3J3/93-033 Martin/Response to Cross-Language Questionnaire X3J3/93-034 Steidel/Draft Response to S20.92 X3J3/93-035 Steidel/Draft Response to S20.100 X3J3/93-036 Tait/JIS Defects X3J3/93-037 Rolison/RFI: Is a module a global entity X3J3/93-038 Rolison/RFI: Statement execution order and expr.eval X3J3/93-050 Hirchert/X3J3/Fortran 90 Interp. Email Aliases X3J3/93-051 Wagener/Defect Management X3J3/93-052 Wagener/Letter from X3T2 re. LIA X3J3/93-053 Wagener/Note from Bruce Martin re. Paul Libassi X3J3/93-054 Wagener/Comment from Bruce martin on POSIX revision X3J3/93-055 Wagener/X3 call for candidates for X3J3 vice chair X3J3/93-056 Wagener/Letter from John Ber re. CS1 special issue on Fortran X3J3/93-057 Wagener/From Van Snyder re. suggestions for 9X X3J3/93-058 Shepherd/RFI: Generic Names X3J3/93-059 Shepherd/RFI: END Statements X3J3/93-060 Martin/Letter from Jeanne Martin on Cont. to Cross Lang. X3J3/93-061 Martin/International Activity Report to 124th Meeting X3J3/93-062 Lahey/Letter to Tom Lahey from Gary Leavens X3J3/93-063 Lahey/Fortran Implementors and the Std. Committee X3J3/93-064 Lahey/Scribe notes from Meeting 123 on X3J3 Organ. X3J3/93-065 Lahey/Article by P. Wegner on Concepts and Paradigms in OOP X3J3/93-066 Lahey/Article by G. Leavens on Intro. to Literature on OOD X3J3/93-067 Bierman/LIA: a report for X3J3 X3J3/93-068 Nebesh/Viewgraphs from OO presentation X3J3/93-069 Philips/Requirements for Future Evolution of Fortran X3J3/93-070 Steidel/RFI: Change array constructor constraint to prose X3J3/93-071 Bleikamp/CIO Ballot Item Response X3J3/93-072 Moss/Appendix F Bit Requirement X3J3/93-073 Martin/Proposed combination of 93-006, items 12 & 23 X3J3/93-074 Martin/Revised response to 93-006, item 114 X3J3/93-075 Martin/Proposed response to 93-006, item 93 X3J3/93-076 Martin/Proposed response to 93-006, item 108 X3J3/93-077 PROC/Proposed response to JIS (93-036, item 3) X3J3/93-078 PROC/Additional edit for 93-006, item 0, from JIS,93-036,1 X3J3/93-079r1 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 105 X3J3/93-079 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 105 X3J3/93-080 Martin/Revised response to 93-006, item 113 X3J3/93-081 Kelble/Additional Edits for 006.000 X3J3/93-082 PROC/Proposed change to X3J3/93-006, item 33 X3J3/93-083 EDIT/Common Block names and local names X3J3/93-084 Steidel/Response to X3J3/93-070 X3J3/93-085 Steidel/Response to X3J3/93-006, item 81 X3J3/93-086 GEN/revisions of 93-006, item 97 X3J3/93-087 PROC/response to John Reid's comment on 006, item 71 X3J3/93-088 GEN/Draft Response to X3J3/93-27, RFI: Init. expr. X3J3/93-089 LIA/Letter to X3T2 Regarding LIA X3J3/93-090 EDIT/Revision of 93-006, item 73 X3J3/93-091 PROC/Proposed 93-006, item 106 X3J3/93-092 PROC/Proposed 93-006, item 126 X3J3/93-093 O'Gara/Response to X3J3/93-006, item 111 X3J3/93-094 GEN/Response to 93-059, redefinition of 'program unit' X3J3/93-095 Steidel/Defect 006, item 125, Copy-in, copy- out of target args X3J3/93-096 Shepherd/Proposed response to 006, item 124 X3J3/93-097 Hoffert/Proposed response to 93-037, Is a module a global? X3J3/93-098 PROC/Response to 93-058, RFI Generic names, 006,item 128 X3J3/93-099 DATA/Revised response for X3J3/93-006, item 27 X3J3/93-100 DATA/Response combining 006,30 with response to X3J3/93-070 X3J3/93-101 Steidel/Revised response to X3J3/93-006, item 41 X3J3/93-102 Steidel/Revised response to X3J3/93-006, item 70 X3J3/93-103 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 90 X3J3/93-104 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 82 X3J3/93-105 PROC/Proposed response to 93-006, item 49 X3J3/93-106 Lauson/Modifications to X3J3/93-005, suggestions for hosts X3J3/93-107 PROC/Revised 93-006, item 90 X3J3/93-108 Moss/Slide on Status of Fortran Requirements (old JOD) X3J3/93-109 Wagener/Index to Selected X3 Documents X3J3/93-110 Wagener/X3J3 Annual Report: April 1992 - April 1993 X3J3/93-111 Wagener/Letter Ballot on X3J3/93-006r Items X3J3/93-112 Martin/Proposed response to X3J3/93-006, item 76 X3J3/93-113 Martin/Proposed response to X3J3/93-006, item 77 X3J3/93-114 Wagener/X3J3 Letter Ballot Record X3J3/93-115 Wagener/Status of X3J3/93-006 Items X3J3/93-116 Shepherd/Formatted Input and Kind Type Parameters (See also X3J3/93-118) X3J3/93-117 Martin/Reconsideration of 006 items based on WG5 ballot comments X3J3/93-118 Leonard/Formatted Input and Kind Type Parameters (Proposed answers to X3J3/93-116) X3J3/93-119 Lahey/BIT Data Type email(X3J3.1993-93) X3J3/93-120 Lahey/Object Oriented Fortran, OOF; Requirements with Discussion X3J3/93-121 Wagener/Proposed ANSWER section for item 000122 of X3J3/93-006r X3J3/93-122 MJHanna-Wagener/Termination of POSIX-Fortran 90 Project AKA DRAFT Final Report of the ANS/IEEE 1003.9 (Fortran Bindings) Working Group Emailed as (X3J3.1993-114) X3J3/93-123 Shepherd/Issues to reconsider about 93-006 #79 -- Emailed as (X3J3.1993-118) X3J3/93-124 Martin/Results on the WG5 Letter Ballot on 006 items approved by X3J3 X3J3/93-125 Kelble/Approval of the Minutes of Meeting 124 X3J3/93-126 Ellis /IT STANDARDIZATION have we got it wrong? X3J3/93-127 Reid-Brannon/Technical Corrigendum X3J3/93-128 Wagener/Use subsets of 006 for the four defect management dispositions X3J3/93-129 Hoffert/Implementation Subgroup X3J3/93-130 Synder-Lahey/SYSTEM_CLOCK Intrinsic X3J3/93-131 Lahey/Definition of TOKEN as used in section 3.3.1 X3J3/93-132 Weaver/Revision of Interpretation number 1 X3J3/93-133 Moss/How to Submit a Fortran Requirement X3J3/93-134 Weaver/Revision of Interpretation number 28 X3J3/93-135 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 27 X3J3/93-136 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 87 X3J3/93-137 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 91 X3J3/93-138 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 100 X3J3/93-139 J. Martin/Revised Response for Item 125 X3J3/93-140 J. Martin-Reid/Message for X3J3 re ISO Technical Corrigendum X3J3/93-141 Terpstra - Johnson/OOF - Making your favorite language object-oriented X3J3/93-142 Whitlock/JOR Processing X3J3/93-143 Weaver/Revision of interpretation 97 X3J3/93-144 Weaver/Revision of interpretation 96 X3J3/93-145 Weaver/Revision of interpretation 101 X3J3/93-146 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 124 X3J3/93-147 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 126 X3J3/93-148 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 127 X3J3/93-149 Shepherd/Proposed revision of interpretation 128 X3J3/93-150 J. Martin/Edits of 006 Items X3J3/93-151 Weaver/Automatic data objects in initialization expression interpretation 47 X3J3/93-152 Shepherd/New Edits for Interpretation 49 X3J3/93-153 Rolison/Revised response for item 111 X3J3/93-154 Lahey/Copyright permission to distribute "Concepts and Paradigms of Object-Oriented Programming" X3J3/93-155 Weaver/Parameter, Namelist, and Implicit Typing Interpretation 114 X3J3/93-156 Weaver/Intent (IN) conformance X3J3/93-157 Weaver/Scalar-structure-component of data- implied-do X3J3/93-158 Weaver/Array element in data-implied-do X3J3/93-159 Weaver/private accessibility of a module procedure X3J3/93-159r1 X3J3/93-160 Weaver/Intrinsic, External attribute questions X3J3/93-161 Maine/Obsolescence of Fixed Source Form X3J3/93-162 Phillips/IEEE 754 binding to Fortran X3J3/93-163 Lindhorst/User defined elementals X3J3/93-164 Lindhorst/Variant derived types X3J3/93-165 Kelble/New answer for 006 item 98 X3J3/93-166 Phillips/Intrinsic STRING data type X3J3/93-167 Bleikamp/Consider nested WHERE statement X3J3/93-168 Bleikamp/User defined intrinsic functions X3J3/93-169 Bleikamp/Pure User Functions and Subroutines X3J3/93-170 Bleikamp/Packaging implementor specific intrinsics in Modules X3J3/93-171 Bleikamp/Directives X3J3/93-172 Lahey/Object Oriented Features for 1995 X3J3/93-173 Shepherd/Varying String Requirement X3J3/93-174 J. Martin/Revised Response for item 81 X3J3/93-175 Lindhorst/Precedence of Host Association X3J3/93-176 Wagener/Letter to John Hill on Defect Management X3J3/93-177 Weaver/Private in a second module specifying a type definition X3J3/93-178 Maine/Sorted list of approved edits X3J3/93-179 Weaver/Precedence of Host Association X3J3/93-180 Hoffert/Extend generic intrinsic procedures X3J3/93-181 J. Martin/Response to New 006 item from email of May 7 (Yukimasa Yoshida) X3J3/93-182 Himer/Interpretation of paper 93-130 SYSTEM_CLOCK X3J3/93-183 Phillimore/Intrinsic, External attribute questions X3J3/93-184 Wagener/X3H5 Model Document and Fortran 90 Binding X3J3/93-185 Hirchert/PROC subgroup report X3J3/93-186 Shepherd/Tutorial on Host Association Edits X3J3/93-187 J. Martin/Moratorium on Interpretations X3J3/93-188 Lahey-Synder/Generic name same as specific name X3J3/93-189 Shepherd/RFI: Namelist I/O and use association X3J3/93-190 Shepherd/RFI: Use association and functions/subroutine/intrinsics X3J3/93-191 Shepherd/Response to Interpretation 135 X3J3/93-192 Shepherd/RFI: Specification expressions and implicit typing X3J3/93-193 Shepherd/RFI: Expressions in of a function statement X3J3/93-194 Lauson/Preliminary Information for Meeting 127 X3J3/93-200 Kelble/Approval of the Minutes of Meeting 125 X3J3/93-201 Wagener/Resolutions of the WG5 Meeting X3J3/93-202 Barber/Fortran-90 Interpretation Request X3J3/93-203 Barber/Fortran-90 Interpretation Requests X3J3/93-204r3 Wagener/B9 Assignments X3J3/93-205 Wagener/Agenda X3J3/93-206 Weaver/Update of 93-006 following meeting 125 X3J3/93-207 Schonfelder/Pointer and Derived Type Initialization X3J3/93-208r1 Maine/Response to Interpretation 135 X3J3/93-209 Weaver/RFI: Conformance X3J3/93-210 Wagener/X3J3 004 List X3J3/93-211 Hendrickson/Response to Interpretation 97 X3J3/93-212 Ellis/Response to Interpretation 132 X3J3/93-213 Schonfelder/Response to Interpretation 81 X3J3/93-214 X3J3/93-215r2 Barber/Response to Interpretation 134 X3J3/93-216 X3J3/93-217 X3J3/93-218r Kelble/Response to Interpretation 142 X3J3/93-219 Rolison/Response to Interpretation 133 X3J3/93-220r Martin/Response to Interpretation 91 X3J3/93-221r Hirchert/Response to Interpretation 82 X3J3/93-222 Weaver/RFI: Statement Function - Array constants in Expressions, "composed" X3J3/93-223r Martin/Response to Interpretation 140 X3J3/93-224 Ellis/Response to Interpretation 122 X3J3/93-225 Ellis/Alternate Response to Interpretation 122 X3J3/93-226 Lahey/Process Time from System Clock X3J3/93-227r1 Weaver/Response to Interpretation 12 X3J3/93-228 Weaver/Response to Interpretation 114 X3J3/93-229 Maine/Edit Subcommittee Procedures X3J3/93-230 Wagener/Fortran 95 Implementation Process X3J3/93-231r1 Wagener/X3J3 Consideration of B9 item C7 X3J3/93-232r Hirchert/Response to Interpretation 99 X3J3/93-233 Lahey/Implementation Subgroup Initial Meeting X3J3/93-234 Hirchert/Additional History for 006 item 82 X3J3/93-235 Hirchert/Response to Interpretation 127 X3J3/93-236r Rolison/Response to Interpretation 144 X3J3/93-237 Hirchert/OOF Subgroup Report from Meeting 126 X3J3/93-238 Walter/Proposal for Accurate Floating-Point Vector Arithmetic X3J3/93-239 Minutes of Meeting 126 X3J3/93-240 Adams/Invitation to UK on Obsolescent Features From B9 X3J3/93-241 Minutes of Meeting 124 X3J3/93-242 Minutes of Meeting 125 Other Papers Distributed: WG5/N871 WG5 DRAFT of the repository of requirements (WG5 SD-5) WG5/N870 Martin/Proposed Form for the Repository of Requirements WG5/N904 Repository of Requirements WG5/N917 Straw Votes of Repository Items WG5/N931 Allow Allocatable derived-type components WG5/N932 Requirement for Initialization of Pointers and Derived-Type Objects X3J11.1/92-065 Extending 'C' for Numerical Computing X3J3/92-241rHoffert/Proposal for an Implementation Subgroup X3J3/92-252 Reproduced copy of John Reid's remarks on S20.029 X3H5/SD-2 Leasure/Revision I Model Document - Parallel Processing Model for High Level Programming Languages X3T2/93-048 John Sharp/Request for Review and Comment on "Knowledge Interchange Format (KIF)" Document (X3T2/93-041) X3T2/93-059 (excerpt from X3T2/89-62)/Base Requirements Document for ANSI X3 Project Number 689-D Conceptual Schema Specification for Data Interchange X3T2/88-118 /SD-3 for Project 689-D X3T2/93-041 /Knowledge Interchange Format Version 3.0 Reference Manual June 1992 5.3 1993 Documents By Meeting 5.3.1 Meeting 124 Documents The documents for meeting 124 are X3J3/93-000 through X3J3/93-108, WG5/N870, X3J3/93-241, WG5/N871, X3J11.1/92-065, and X3J3/92-252. 5.3.2 Meeting 125 Documents The documents for meeting 125 are X3J3/93-004r, X3J3/93- 008r3, X3J3/93-109 through X3J3/93-186, X3J3/93-242, and X3H5/SD-2. 5.3.3 Meeting 126 Documents The documents for meeting 126 are X3J3/92-241r, X3J3/93- 005r2, X3J3/93-187 through X3J3/93-239, WG5/N904, WG5/N917, WG5/N931, WG5/N932, X3T2/93-048, X3T2/93-059, X3T2/88-118, and X3T2/93-041. 6 Committee Organization 6.1 Officers Chair J. Wagener Vice Chair R. Kelble International Rep I. Philips Secretary Librarian D. Mattoon Editor W. Brainerd Maintenance J. Shepherd Vocabulary Rep. K. Hirchert 6.2 Subgroups X3J3/F90maint -- F90 defect management, responsible for document 006 A. Tait -- coordinator and editor of document 006 GEN (chap 1-3,7,17) DATA (chap 4-6) CIO (chap 8-10) PROC (chap 11-13) R. Hendrickson (head) H. Katz R. Bleikamp (head) K. Bierman T. Lahey J. Martin R. Kelble M. Ellis A. Marusak L. O'Gara (head) W. Leonard J. Himer T. Terpstra L. Rolison (Steidel) J. Oglesby K. Hirchert (head) R. Weaver G. Steele (Phillimore) M. Hoffert J. Shepherd X3J3/JOR -- Journal of Requirements for 1995, responsible for document 004 D. Mattoon, G. Millard, L. Moss(head), I. Philips, S. Whitlock X3J3/editorial -- prepare the draft standard, responsible for documents 007 and 008 W. Brainerd(head), R. Maine, H. Lauson, M. North X3J3/parallel - parallel computing, responsible for coordinating with X3H5 and HPFF K. Bierman, J. Himer, L. O'Gara, G. Steele(D. Phillimore), J. Steidel(head) X3J3/posix -- Posix coordination, especially on the Fortran 90 Posix binding J. Brixius, B. Martin, R. Weaver(head) X3J3/OOF -- Object-Oriented Fortran M. Ellis, M. Hoffert, H. Katz, R. Kelble, T. Lahey(head), B. Leonard, J. Martin, R. Weaver 7 Future Meetings and Distribution Assignments Four Meeting Schedule for 1993: Meeting conventions: - 4 meetings per year - attempt to schedule second full week of month - attempt to schedule meetings back to back with WG5 meetings 127 Nov. 8-12, 1993 - Albuquerque, NM (Lauson, host) pre-meeting distribution deadline: October 4, 1993 pre-meeting distribution: Mattoon, Railroad post-meeting distribution: Ted Terpstra, DECUS 128 Feb. 7-11, 1994 - Palmdale, CA (Richard Maine, host) pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Philips, Boeing post-meeting distribution: Bleikamp, Convex 129 May 2-6, 1994 - Lake Tahoe (Lahey, host) pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Hirchert, UIUC post-meeting distribution: Kelble, Unisys 130 August 15-19, 1994 - Edinburgh, Scotland (EPC) pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Levine, HP post-meeting distribution: Moss, SLAC 131 Nov. 7-11, 1994 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: North, Rose-Hulman post-meeting distribution: Oglesby, Microsoft 132 Feb., 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Rolison, Cray post-meeting distribution: Weaver, IBM 133 May, 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Whitlock, DEC post-meeting distribution: Marusak, Los Alamos 134 July, 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: Bierman, SUN post-meeting distribution: Maine, NASA 135 Nov., 1995 - pre-meeting distribution deadline: pre-meeting distribution: post-meeting distribution: Martin: Distributes WG5 Documents Ellis, Hendrickson, Millard: European Based Excused: Himer, Lauson List for Distribution Recipients: pre and post meeting distribution sent to: principals FEW additional others: alternates who attend the meetings regularly active participants in email, such as former members REQUIREMENT: DISTRIBUTION of Pre-Meeting 2 Weeks before meeting (documents for action - two week rule: SD-2 4.3.4:1) minutes sent to (required by X3) principals alternates observers, consultants, liaisons REQUIREMENT: DISTRIBUTION 4 Weeks Following Meeting Adjournment (SD-2 4.2.5, 4.3.6) agenda and meeting notice sent to: general mailing list consisting of: principals alternates observers, consultants, liaisons WG5/ISO members general (names of contacts, former members) REQUIREMENT: DISTRIBUTION 4 Weeks prior to meeting (SD-2 4.3.3) 8 Membership 8.1 Meeting Attendance X3J3 Meeting Attendance X3J3 Principal Members Meeting # 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Location TX NV OX NM MN NH CA IN WA CT FL IL BE Date 01 04 08 12 04 08 11 05 08 11 02 05 07 90 90 90 90 91 91 91 92 92 92 93 93 93 Name Affiliation Bierman, Keith Sun I I I I I V V V V V V V V Bleikamp, Rich CONVEX I V I A R R A R V V V V A Brainerd, Walt Unicomp V V P V V V A A** R** Ellis, Miles Oxford V V V A V V V A V V A V V Hendrickson, Dick ACSET V V V V V A A** V** V V V V V Himer, Jim Esso Canada P V A A V** V A V A** V A** Hirchert, Kurt Univ. Illinois V V A A V V V V V V V V V Hoffert, Maureen HP V V V V V V V V V V V V V Katz, Henry DoD V V A A V V V V V V V V A Kelble, Rich Unisys I I I A I V V A V A** V V V Lahey, Tom Lahey V V V A V V V V V V V V V Lauson, Herrick V V V V A V A** Leonard, Bill Harris V V A A V R A R V A V V A Martin, Jeanne Livermore V V V V V V V V V V V V V Marusak, Alex Los Alamos V V V V V V A V V A A** R** A** Mattoon, David Assoc. Railroads P V A A V V A V V V V V A Maine, Richard NASA P V V V A V V Millard, Geoff Edinburgh R V R A A V V A V R A A** R** Moss, Len SLAC V V A A V V V A V V V A A** North, Mallory Rose-Hulman Inst V V A V A V V V V V V V A O'Gara, Linda Supercomputer Sys V V V V V V V A V V A A** A*** Oglesby, Jose Microsoft I I A A I V R R V A R R A Philips, Ivor Boeing V V V V V A V V V A A** V** V Rolison, Larry Cray* I I I I I I R R R R R V V Steele, Guy Thinking Mach.* A A R R A A R** R R R A R A** Terpstra, Ted DECUS* I I I I I I I A I R V V A Wagener, Jerry Amoco V V V V V V V V V V V V V Weaver, Dick IBM* V V V V V A R V V V V V V Whitlock, Stan DEC A V V V V V V V A V V V A V present and voting represented R absent but P present but not represented voting A absent and not I institution represen * institutional member ** missed 2 of last 3 meetings *** LOST membership Total Membership at beginning of Meeting: 29 One over Half: 15 Total Membership at end of Meeting: 28 Total Members Attended or Represented: 15 Total Attendees: 17 Changes since Meeting 125: Andrew Tait resigned as a member Lost Linda O'Gara as a member New Members: NONE Alternates Representing principals at meeting: Jeanne Adams, Unicomp Graham Barber, EPC Visitors at Meeting: Lawrie Schonfelder, WG5 Kees Ampt, WG5 8.2 X3J3 Membership -------------- Walter S. PRINCIPAL Brainerd Richard A. MEMBERS Unicomp Inc. Hendrickson 1123 Marigold ACSET ---------------- Drive Ave. Albert -------------- Albuquerque NM Einstein 4 B-1348-Louvain- Keith H. Bierman phone: (505) 275- la-Neuve SMI 0800 Brussels 1532 Norman Ave. email: BELGIUM San Jose CA walt@netcom.com 95125 fax: (505) 275- phone: 011 32 10 0800 470 833 phone: (415) 336- email: 2648 alternate: hendrick@acset.b email: Jeanne Adams e keith.bierman@en Charles Ritz fax: 011 32 10 g.sun.com 470 899 fax: (415) 968- ---------------- 6396 -------------- alternate: Karen Spackman alternate: T. Miles R. Michael Ellis ---------------- Ingrassia Computing -------------- Teaching Centre ---------------- Oxford James T. Himer -------------- University Esso Resources 59 George Street Division/Exxon Richard Oxford OX1 339 Woodside Bay Bleikamp 2BH S.W. CONVEX Computer ENGLAND Calgary Alberta Corporation T2W 3K9 3000 Waterview phone: 011 44 CANADA Parkway 865 278800 P. O. Box 833851 email: internet phone: (403) 237- Richardson TX MEllis@vax.ox.ac 4215 75083-3851 .uk email: email: janet jthimer@iras.uca phone: (214) 497- MEllis@uk.ac.ox. lgary.ca 4133 vax fax: (403) 237- email: fax: 011 44 865 2907 (room 16) bleikamp@convex. 278834 fax: (403) 232- com 5730 fax: (214) 497- alternate: John 4500 D. Wilson ---------------- BSI Fortran -------------- alternate: Panel Presley Smith BCS Fortran Kurt W. Hirchert Specialist Gr University of ---------------- Illinois -------------- ---------------- 152 Computing Applications fax: (410) 455- 87110-4803 Bldg. 3969 605 East phone: (505) 298- Springfield ---------------- 2769 Avenue -------------- email: Champaign IL lauson@unmvax.cs 61820 Richard P. .unm.edu Kelble phone: (217) 333- Unisys alternate: Brian 8093 Corporation Smith email: 2476 Swedesford hirchert@ncsa.ui Road ---------------- uc.edu P. O. Box 203 -------------- fax: (217) 244- Paoli PA 19301 2909 William Leonard phone: (215) 648- Harris Computer alternate: 4009 Systems Division Murray F. email: 2101 W. Cypress Freeman kelble@tredysvr. Creek Road tredydev.unisys. Ft. Lauderdale ---------------- com FL 33309 -------------- fax: (215) 648- 4624 phone: (305) 973- Maureen Hoffert 5130 Hewlett-Packard alternate: Allie email: Company Murphy bill@ssd.csd.har 3404 E. Harmony ris.com Road ---------------- fax: (305) 977- Fort Collins CO -------------- 5580 80525-9599 Tom Lahey alternate: Doug phone: (303) 229- Lahey Computer Scofield 2774 Systems Inc. email: 865 Tahoe Blvd ---------------- mbsh@fc.hp.com Suite 204 -------------- fax: (303) 229- P. O. Box 6091 6409 Incline Village Richard Maine NV 89450-6091 NASA Dryden alternate: David M/S D-1021 Levine phone: (702) 831- P.O. Box 273 2500 Edwards CA ---------------- email: uucp 93523 -------------- uunet!lahey!tom1 fax: (702) 831- phone: (805) 258- Henry Katz 8323 3316 8250 Brattle email: Road ---------------- maine@altair.dfr Baltimore MD -------------- f.nasa.gov 21208 fax: (805) 258- Herrick S. 3567 phone: (410) 859- Lauson 6324 7711 Euclid Ave. alternate: Bruce email: bitnet N.E. Martin katz@umbc2 Albuquerque NM ---------------- 3140 South fax: (415) 926- -------------- Federal Street 3329 Chicago IL Jeanne T. Martin 60616 alternate: Lawrence Sylvia Sund Livermore Natl. phone: (312) 808- Lab. 5868 ---------------- 7000 East Avenue email: -------------- P. O. Box 808 David_Mattoon_at L-300 _CTC@relay.prote C. Mallory North Livermore CA on.com Rose-Hulman 94550 fax: (312) 808- Institute of 5425 Tech. phone: (510) 422- 5500 Wabash Ave. 3753 ---------------- Campus Box 145 email: -------------- Terre Haute IN jtm@llnl.gov 47803 fax: (510) 423- G. E. Millard 6961 E.P.C.L. phone: (812) 877- 17 Alva Street 8216 alternate: John Edinburgh EH2 email: bitnet T. Engle 4PH north @ rhit convenor of SCOTLAND fax: (812) 877- ISO/IEC 3198 JTC1/SC22/WG5 phone: 011 44 31 225 6262 alternate: Jerry ---------------- email: Fine -------------- geoff@epc.ed.ac. uk ---------------- Alex Marusak fax: 011 44 31 -------------- Los Alamos 225 6644 National Lab Jose Oglesby Group IT-1 alternate: c/o Microsoft MS/B228 Graham Barber One Microsoft Los Alamos NM David T. Way 87545 Muxworthy Redmond WA 98052 phone: (505) 667- ---------------- 6922 -------------- phone: (206) 882- email: internet 8080 alm @ lanl.gov Leonard J. Moss email: SLAC uunet!microsoft! alternate: Tony 2575 Sand Hill joseogl Warnock Rd. fax: (206) 883- DOE Language Menlo Park CA 8101 Working Group 94025 alternate: Greg ---------------- phone: (415) 926- Lindhorst -------------- 3370 Lauren Feaux email: David Mattoon ljm@slacvm.slac. ---------------- Assoc. of stanford.edu -------------- American email: bitnet: Railroads ljm @ slacvm Ivor R. Philips Boeing Computer 1000 Services email: internet alternate: Rex P. O. Box 24346 gls @ think.com L. Page MS 7L-21 X3J3 chair Seattle WA alternate: David X3H3 (Graphics) 98124-3046 Phillimore institutional ---------------- phone: (206) 865- member (Thinking -------------- 3522 Machines) email: internet Richard Weaver philips @ ---------------- IBM M77/E365 atc.boeing.com -------------- P.O. Box 49023 fax: (206) 865- San Jose CA 2966 Ted Terpstra 95161 (DECUS) alternate: Alvin Princepton phone: (408) 463- C. Mong Plasma Physics 2956/3088 Laboratory email: ---------------- Princeton weaver@vnet.ibm. -------------- University com P. O. Box 451 fax: (408) 463- Lawrence R. Princeton NJ 3114 Rolison 08543 Cray Research alternate: Inc. phone: (609) 243- Janice Shepherd 655F Lone Oak 2823 institutional Dr. email: member (IBM) Eagan MN 55121 TERPSTRA@USC.PPL .GOV ---------------- phone: (612) 683- -------------- 5807 alternate: Joel email: Rose Stan Whitlock lrr@cray.com instititutional Digital fax: (612) 683- member (DECUS) Equipment Corp. 5307 ZK02-3/N30 ---------------- 110 Spit Brook alternate: Jon -------------- Rd. Steidel Nashua NH Joanne Brixius Jerrold L. 03062 institutional Wagener member (Cray Amoco Production phone: (603) 881- Research) Research 2011 4502 East 41st email: internet ---------------- Street whitlock@tle.ene -------------- P. O. Box 3385 t.dec.com Tulsa OK 74102 fax: (603) 881- Guy L. Steele 0120 Thinking phone: (918) 660- Machines Corp 3978 alternate: Keith 245 First Street email: Kimball Cambridge MA jwagener@trc.amo 02142 co.com ---------------- fax: (918) 660- -------------- phone: (617) 234- 4165 ALTERNATE 47803 fax: (612) 683- ---------------- 5307 phone: (812) 877- -------------- 1511 alternate: email: bitnet Jeanne C. Adams Lawrence R. fine @ rhit NCAR Rolison fax: (812) 877- Scientific institutional 3198 Computing member (Cray Division Research) alternate: C. M. P.O. Box 3000 North Boulder CO ---------------- 80307 -------------- ---------------- -------------- phone: (303) 497- John T. Engle 1275 Lawrence Murray F. email: internet Livermore Natl. Freeman jeanne Lab. Bell @ncar.ucar.edu P. O. Box 808 Communication fax: (303) 497- L-300 Research 1137 Livermore CA RRC 4B-721 94559 444 Hoes Lane alternate: Piscataway NJ Walter S. alternate: 08854-4182 Brainerd Jeanne T. Martin phone: (201) 699- ---------------- ---------------- 2272 -------------- -------------- alternate: Kurt Graham Barber Lauren Feaux W. Hirchert E.P.C.L. c/o Microsoft 17 Alva Street One Microsoft ---------------- Edinburgh Way -------------- SCOTLAND Redmond WA 98052 Michael phone: 44 31 225 Ingrassia 6262 fax: (206) 883- SunPro email: janet 8101 2550 Garcia gra@epc.ed.ac.uk UMTV 12-40 fax: 44 31 225 alternate: Jose Mountain View 6644 Oglesby CA 94043 alternate: G. E. ---------------- phone: (415) 336- Millard -------------- 1024 email: ---------------- Jerry Fine michael.ingrassi -------------- Rose-Hulman a@eng.sun.com Institute of Joanne Brixius Tech. ---------------- Cray Research Dept. of -------------- Inc. Mechanical 655F Lone Oak Engineering Keith Kimball Dr. 550 Wabash Ave. Digital Eagan MN 55121 Terre Haute IN Equipment Corp. ZK02-3/N30 Oglesby P. O. Box 203 110 Spit Brook Paoli PA 19301 Road ---------------- Nashua NH -------------- ---------------- 03062 -------------- Bruce A. Martin phone: (603) 881- Relativistic David T. .... Heavy Ion Muxworthy email: Collider EUCS kimball%tle.dec@ Build 911-C University decwrl.enet.dec. Brookhaven Library com National George Square fax: (603) 881- Laboratory Edinburgh EH8 0120 Upton NY 11973 9LJ SCOTLAND alternate: Stan phone: (516) 282- Whitlock 5647 phone: 011 44 31 email: 650 3305 ---------------- bam@bnl.gov email: janet -------------- email: d.t.muxworthy @ bam@bnlux1.bnl.g edinburgh.ac.uk David R. Levine ov fax: 011 44 31 Hewlett-Packard 662 4809 Company alternate: MS CHD02CS Richard Maine alternate: G. E. Massachusetts Millard Language Lab. ---------------- 300 Apollo Drive -------------- ---------------- Chelmsford MA -------------- 01824 Alvin C. Mong Boeing Computer Rex L. Page phone: (508) 256- Services Amoco Production 6600 P. O. Box 24346 Research email: MS 7L-21 P. O. Box 3385 drlevine@apollo. Seattle WA Tulsa OK 74102 hp.com 98124-0346 phone: (918) 660- alternate: phone: (206) 865- 3935 Maureen Hoffert 3531 email: alternate: ---------------- mong@espresso.bo Jerrold L. -------------- eing.com Wagener Greg Lindhorst alternate: Ivor ---------------- c/o Microsoft R. Philips -------------- One Microsoft Way ---------------- David Redmond WA -------------- Phillimore 98052 Thinking Allie Murphy Machines Inc. fax: (206) 883- Unisys 245 First Street 8101 Corporation Cambridge MA 2476 Swedesford 02142 alternate: Jose Road phone: (617) 234- FL 33309 fax: (505) 277- 1000 0813 email: internet phone: (305) 973- dphillim @ 5120 alternate: think.com email: Herrick Lauson doug@ssd.csd.har ACM/SigNum alternate: Guy ris.com Parallel Steele Computing Forum alternate: ---------------- William Leonard ---------------- -------------- -------------- ---------------- Charles Ritz -------------- Presley Smith Fortran Journal CONVEX Computer P.O. Box 4201 Janice Shepherd Corporation Fullerton CA IBM Canada Ltd. 3000 Waterview 92634 31/123/844/TOR Parkway 844 Don Mills P. O. Box 833851 phone: (714) 441- Road Richardson TX 2022 North York 75083-3851 fax: (714) 441- Ontario M3C1V7 2022 CANADA phone: (214) 497- 4545 ---------------- phone: (416) 448- email: -------------- 3101 psmith@convex.co email: m Joel S. Rose janshep@torolab2 fax: (214) 497- Computing Center .vnet.ibm.com 4500 University at fax: (416) 448- Buffalo 6057 alternate: Rich Buffalo NY Bleikamp 14260 alternate: X3H2 (Database) Richard Weaver phone: (716) 645- ---------------- 3566 ---------------- -------------- email: -------------- acuser@ubvms Jon Steidel fax: (716) 645- Brian T. Smith Cray Research 3734 University of Inc. New Mexico 655F Lone Oak alternate: Ted Computer Science Dr. Terpstra Dept. Eagan MN 55121 339 Farris ---------------- Engineering phone: (612) 683- -------------- Center 5734 Albuquerque NM email: jls @ Doug Scofield 87131 cray.com Harris Corporation phone: (505) 277- alternate: Larry Computer Systems 5500 Rolison Div. email: phonenet 2101 W. Cypress smith @ ---------------- Creek Rd. unmvax.cs.unm.ed -------------- Ft. Lauderdale u Sylvia Sund -------------- Cedex 07 SLAC F-92080 Paris La Bin 60 OBSERVER Defense P.O. Box 4349 FRANCE Stanford CA ---------------- AFNOR 94309 -------------- ---------------- phone: (415) 926- Stephen -------------- 2277 Adamczyk email: bitnet Edison Design Brian Brode sunnie @ slacvm Group Pacific Sierra 4 Norman Road Research Corp. alternate: Upper Montclair 12340 Santa Leonard J. Moss NJ 07043 Monica Blvd. Los Angeles CA ---------------- phone: (201) 744- 90025 -------------- 2620 ---------------- Tony Warnock ---------------- -------------- Los Alamos -------------- National Lab. Thomas W. Bucken MS B296 Thomas Aird Kendall Square C-10 IMSL Inc. Research P.O. Box 1663 2500 Parkwest 170 Tracer Lane Los Alamos NM Tower One Waltham MA 87545 2500 Citywest 02154 Blvd. phone: (505) 667- Houston TX phone: (617) 895- 7158 77042 9490 email: alternate: Alex phone: (713) 782- tbucken@koas.ksr Marusak 6060 .com fax: (617) 890- ---------------- ---------------- 0996 -------------- -------------- ---------------- John D. Wilson B. Banes -------------- Computer Centre Rolls Royce Ltd University of Eng Comp Thomas Gordon Leicester P.O. Box 3 Butler Leicester LE1 Filton Bristol Texaco Inc. 7RH BS12 7QE 4800 Fournace ENGLAND ENGLAND Place Bellaire TX phone: 011 44 ---------------- 77401 533 522235 -------------- email: ---------------- jdw@leicester.ac C. Bourstin -------------- .uk AFNOR Div. Bor Chan alternate: T. Informatique- NERSC Miles R. Ellis Secteur Lawrence Tertiaire Livermore ---------------- Tour Europe - National Lab. University of 435 South Street 4194 Bedburg-Hau- California Morristown NJ Hasselt P.O. Box 5509 07960 GERMANY L-560 Livermore CA ---------------- phone: (70) 94550 -------------- 930160 WG5/Netherlands ---------------- Lloyd Fosdick -------------- Dept. of ---------------- Computer Science -------------- Ingemar University of Dahlstrand Colorado John Hill DNA/LTH Campus Box 430 Unisys Corp. Box 118 Boulder CO M/S E8-130 S-22100 Lund 80309 P.O. Box 500 SWEDEN Blue Bell PA ---------------- 19424 email: internet -------------- ingo @ phone: (215) 986- dna.lth.se Michael J. 4565 WG5/Sweeden Frisch Academic ---------------- ---------------- Computing -------------- -------------- Services & Sys. University of Paul Hurtley L. M. Delves Minnesota P.G.R. Computing Dept. of 128 Lind Hall Dorchester House Computer Science 207 Church Station Road and Statistics Street Southeast Letchworth University of Minneapolis MN Herts SG6 3AW Liverpool 55455 ENGLAND Liverpool ENGLAND ---------------- phone: 44 462 -------------- 480-648 ---------------- -------------- Peter Galloway ---------------- International -------------- Charles Dickman Computers Ltd. General Electric Arndale House Kalman Janko Information Sys. Arndale Centre CSENGERY 59 - 11 401 North Manchester M4 117 Washington 3AR Budapest 1067 Street ENGLAND HUNGARY Rockville MD 20850 email: ---------------- P.Galloway@qmw.a -------------- ---------------- c.uk -------------- E. Andrew ---------------- Johnson Stuart I. -------------- Open Software Feldman Foundation Bell L G J ter Haar 11 Cambridge Communications Am Alten Center Research Sportplatz 20 Cambridge MA 02 -------------- William La phone: (617) 621- Plante Neldon H. 8794 Box 2130 Marshall email: Arlington VA EG&G Idaho Inc. andyj@osf.org 22202 1580 Sawtelle fax: (617) 225- Street 2782 phone: (301) 763- M/S 2408 3905 P. O. Box 1625 ---------------- Idaho Falls ID -------------- ---------------- 83415 -------------- William Kahan phone: (208) 526- EE & Computer Rochelle Lauer 9342 Science Dept. Director email: internet University of Yale University nhm @ inel.gov California High Energy fax: (208) 526- 573 Evans Computing 9591 Berkeley CA Facility 94720 512 Gibbs ---------------- Physics -------------- ---------------- Laboratory -------------- 260 Whitney C. J. Mas Avenue IBM France Joseph King P. O. Box 6666 Dept. 2729 Genetics New Haven CT Tour Descartes Computer Group 06511-8167 Cedex 50 Inc Paris La Defense 575 Science Dr phone: (203) 432- FRANCE Suite B 3366 WG5/France Madison WI email: bitnet 53711 lauer @ yalehep ---------------- fax: (203) 432- -------------- phone: (608) 231- 3824 5200 Hiroshi Matsuo email: alternate: Jeol Software Works jking@gcg.com Rose Hitachi Ltd. fax: (608) 231- instititutional 5030 Totsuka-cho 5202 member (DECUS) Totsuka-ku Yokohama-shi ---------------- ---------------- 244 -------------- -------------- JAPAN Judy Bruce Leasure phone: 011 81 45 Kochanowski Kuck and 824-2311 Intel Corp. Associates fax: 011 81 45 M/S HF2-80 1906 Fox Drive 824-9092 5200 Elam Young Champaigne IL WG5/Japan Parkway 61820 Hillsboro OR ---------------- 97124 phone: (217) 356- -------------- 2288 ---------------- Keith McConnell -------------- ---------------- 106 Apple Street Tinton Falls NJ 305 Talbot Lab M. Rannou 07724 Urbana IL AFNOR 61801 Tour Europe - phone: (201) 758- CEDEX 07 7000 ---------------- F-92080 Paris La -------------- Defense ---------------- FRANCE -------------- George Paul IBM Research phone: (617) 895- Michael Metcalf Division 9490 DD T.J. Watson email: Cern Research Center tbucken@koas.ksr 1211 Geneva 23 P. O. Box 704 .com SWITZERLAND Yorktown Heights fax: (617) 890- NY 10598 0996 phone: 011 41 22 767 4427 phone: (914) 789- ---------------- email: bitnet 7750 -------------- metcalf @ email: bitnet: cernvm.cern.ch GP1 @ yktvmh John K. Reid fax: 011 41 22 email: csnet: Atlas Centre 767 7155 GP1 @ ibm.com Rutherford Appleton ---------------- ---------------- Laboratory -------------- -------------- Oxon OX11 0QX ENGLAND Meinolf Aurelio Munchhausen Pollicini phone: 011 44 D ST SP314 CEC JRC Ispra 235 44 6493 Seimens Ag I-21020 Ispra email: D-8000 Munchen ITALY jkr@ib.rl.ac.uk 83 WG5/Italy fax: 011 44 235 GERMANY 44 5808 EWICS ---------------- -------------- ---------------- ---------------- -------------- -------------- Richard R. Ragan Control Data William C. Linda O'Gara Corp. Rinehuls c/o Microsoft 5101 Patrick Chairman One Microsoft Henry Dr. OMC Way Santa Clara CA 8457 Rushing Redmond WA 95054 Creek Court 98052 Springfield VA phone: (408) 496- 22153 ---------------- 4340 OMC -------------- email: rrr@svl.cdc.com ---------------- David Padua fax: (408) 496- -------------- Center for 4106 Supercomputer Keith D. Roberts Research ---------------- British University of -------------- Petroleum Res. Illinois Ctr. Chertsey Road P.O. Box 147 Sunbury-on- Liverpool L69 phone: (617) 245- Thames 3BX 9540 Middlesex ENGLAND email: TW16 7LN stpierrre@tle.en ENGLAND phone: 011 44 et.dec.com (51) 794-3716 email: ---------------- email: janet stpierre@compass -------------- jls@liverpool.ac .com .uk fax: (617) 246- Mike Ross 1078 Metaware Inc. ---------------- 2161 Delaware -------------- ---------------- Ave. -------------- Santa Cruz CA Jurgen Schonhut 95060 c/o FhG-AGD Richard C. Swift Wilhelminenstr.7 MASPAR Inc. ---------------- D-6100 Darmstadt 749 North Mary -------------- GERMANY Avenue Sunnyvale CA K. H. Rotthauser ---------------- 94086 GMD -------------- Schloss phone: (408) 736- Birlinghoven Ward Sly 3300 D-5205 St. 4308 Edinbrook email: Augustin 1 Ter. argosy!swift@dec GERMANY Minneapolis MN wrl.dec.com WG5/Germany 55443 ---------------- ---------------- ---------------- -------------- -------------- -------------- Andrew D. Tait Lindsey Savage Madeleine R. Amdahl University of Sparks Corporation Manchester X3H3.4 Chair 1250 East Arques Manchester UNISYS Corp. Ave. Computer Centre 4000 S. Memorial M/S 276 Oxford Road Parkway PO Box 3470 Computer Huntsville AL Sunnyvale CA Building 35802 94088-3470 Manchester M13 9PL phone: (205) 880- phone: (408) 746- UNITED KINGDOM 5544 7370 fax: (205) 880- email: ---------------- 5680 adt10@uts.amdahl -------------- .com ---------------- fax: (408) 992- J. L. -------------- 2209 Schonfelder Director Paul St. Pierre ---------------- Computer 110 Spit Brook -------------- Laboratory Road ZKO2-3/N30 University of Nashua NH Hideo Wada Liverpool 03062 Software Division Qing-bao Wu -------------- Fujitsu Limited P. O. Box 619 140 Miyamoto Beijing B. Buckley Numazu-shi P.R.O.C. Computing Shizuoka 410- CHINA Science 03 WG5/China Department JAPAN Dalhousie ---------------- University phone: (0559) 23- -------------- Halifax Nova 2222 Scotia B3L 3C4 email: CANADA wada@lp.nm.fujit OMC Secretary su.co.jp CBEMA ---------------- Suite 200 -------------- ---------------- 1250 Eye Street -------------- NW Jeremy du Croz Washington D.C. NAG Central Wolfgang V. 20005 Office Walter Numerical Inst.f.Angewandt phone: (202) 737 Algorithms Group e Mathematik 8888 Ltd. Universitat fax: (202) 638 Wilkinson House Karlsruhe 4922 Jordan Hill Road Postfach 69 80 fax: (202) 628 2 Oxford OX2 D-76128 7DE Karlsruhe ---------------- ENGLAND GERMANY -------------- ---------------- phone: 011 49 ISO/WG5 -------------- (721) 377936 email: ---------------- Dale Ellis wwalter@iamk4508 -------------- DRE A .rz.uni- P. O. Box 1012 karlsruhe.de Cornelis G. F. Dartmough N.S. fax: 011 49 Ampt B2Y 3Z7 (721) 385979 Krokus Laan 10 CANADA B-1981 ---------------- Tervuren-Vossem ---------------- -------------- BELGIUM -------------- Graham Warren ---------------- Ingolf Grieger Dept. -------------- Dept. of 31/123/844/TOR Aerospace IBM Canada Akio Aoyama Engineering 844 Don Mills Hitachi Universitat Road 549-6 Shinano- Stuttgart Don Mills cho Pfaffenwaldring Ontario M3C 1W3 Totsuka-ku 27 CANADA Yokohama-shi D 7000 Stuttgart WG5/Canada Kanagawa-ken 80 244 GERMANY ---------------- JAPAN -------------- ---------------- ---------------- -------------- Society of Japan Sven Hammarling The Kilai- NAG Central Shiukokai Bldg. Office 1-Shiba-Koen Numerical Minato-ku Tokyo Algorithms Group JAPAN Ltd. Mayfield House ---------------- 256 Banbury Road -------------- Oxford OX2 70E Rainer Zimmer ENGLAND Seimens AG K D St SP email: janet Otto-Hahn - Ring nagsven%vax.oxfo 6 rd.ac.uk @ 800 Munchen 83 nss.cs.u GERMANY fax: 011 44 865 310139 ---------------- -------------- ---------------- -------------- Tadayoshi Kan Department of Physics Faculty of Science Gakushuin University 1-5-1 Mejiro Toshima-ku Tokyo 171 JAPAN ---------------- -------------- H. Sobiesiak Kern Forschungs Zentrum Karlsruhe Iak Postfach 3640 D 7500 Karlsruhe GERMANY ---------------- -------------- Eiji Tokunaga c/o Information Processing